Source: EURLEX
Language: en
Format: md

JUDGMENT OF THE GENERAL COURT (Sixth Chamber)

2 July 2025 ([\*](#Footnote*))

( EU trade mark – Opposition proceedings – Application for EU figurative mark JOLi – Earlier national word mark JOLIFE – Relative ground for refusal – No likelihood of confusion – Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 )

In Case T‑473/24,

**Villafrut Srl,** established in Oppeano (Italy), represented by A. Rizzoli, lawyer,

applicant,

v

**European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO),** represented by C. Bovar and D. Stoyanova-Valchanova, acting as Agents,

defendant,

the other party to the proceedings before the Board of Appeal of EUIPO being

**Venture Fruit Global Ltd,** established in Auckland (New Zealand),

THE GENERAL COURT (Sixth Chamber),

composed of M.J. Costeira, President, M. Kancheva and U. Öberg (Rapporteur), Judges,

Registrar: V. Di Bucci,

having regard to the written part of the procedure,

having regard to the fact that no request for a hearing was submitted by the parties within three weeks after service of notification of the close of the written part of the procedure, and having decided to rule on the action without an oral part of the procedure, pursuant to Article 106(3) of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court,

gives the following

**Judgment**

1        By its action under Article 263 TFEU, the applicant, Villafrut Srl, seeks annulment and alteration of the decision of the Fifth Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) of 23 July 2024 (Case R 2468/2023-5) (‘the contested decision’).

**Background to the dispute**

2        On 22 July 2021, Venture Fruit Global Ltd filed an application with EUIPO to register the following figurative sign as an EU trade mark:

![Image not found](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)

3        The trade mark applied for designated goods falling, after the limitation entered into on 14 December 2021, in the course of the proceedings before EUIPO, in Class 31 within the meaning of the Nice Agreement Concerning the International Classification of Goods and Services for the Purposes of the Registration of Marks of 15 June 1957, as revised and amended, and corresponding, in particular, to the following description: ‘Agricultural and horticultural products; fresh fruits and vegetables including pip-fruit’.

4        On 16 November 2021, the applicant filed an opposition to the registration of the mark applied for in respect of the goods referred to in paragraph 3 above.

5        The opposition was based, inter alia, on the earlier Italian word mark JOLIFE, registered on 22 April 2003 under No 889 342, designating goods in, inter alia, Class 31 and corresponding to the following description: ‘Fresh fruit and vegetables’.

6        The ground relied on in support of the opposition was the existence of a likelihood of confusion within the meaning of Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 on the European Union trade mark (OJ 2017 L 154, p. 1).

7        Following the request made by Venture Fruit Global, EUIPO invited the applicant to provide evidence of genuine use of the earlier mark cited in opposition. The applicant complied with the request within the prescribed period. The Opposition Division found that genuine use of the earlier mark had been proved only in respect of ‘fresh fruit and vegetables’ in Class 31.

8        On 6 November 2023, the Opposition Division partially upheld the opposition and consequently rejected the application for registration in respect of part of the goods designated by the mark applied for, namely the goods referred to in paragraph 3 above, on the ground that there was a likelihood of confusion with the goods in respect of which genuine use of the earlier mark had been proved, namely ‘fresh fruit and vegetables’ in Class 31.

9        On 14 December 2023, Venture Fruit Global filed a notice of appeal with EUIPO against the decision of the Opposition Division.

10      By the contested decision, the Board of Appeal upheld the appeal on the ground that there was no likelihood of confusion between the marks at issue in the mind of the relevant public, within the meaning of Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, and partially annulled the decision of the Opposition Division.

**Forms of order sought**

11      The applicant claims that the Court should:

–        annul the contested decision;

–        uphold the opposition in respect of all the goods designated by the trade mark applied for and dismiss the trade mark application in its entirety;

–        order EUIPO to pay the costs, including those relating to the earlier proceedings before EUIPO.

12      EUIPO contends that the Court should:

–        dismiss the action;

–        order the applicant to pay the costs, in the event a hearing is convened.

**Law**

13      In support of its action, the applicant relies on a single plea in law alleging infringement of Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001.

14      The applicant claims that the Board of Appeal wrongly concluded that there was no likelihood of confusion. First, the applicant submits that the finding of the Board of Appeal that the level of attention of the public varied from low to average for the goods at issue is erroneous. Secondly, the applicant contests the visual and phonetic comparison of the signs at issue, in that the Board of Appeal considered that those signs were short and had a low degree of visual similarity and ‘at most’ an average degree of phonetic similarity. Thirdly, the applicant submits that the overall assessment of the likelihood of confusion is wrong, since the differences between the signs at issue cannot outweigh their similarities.

15      EUIPO disputes the applicant’s arguments.

16      Under Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, upon opposition by the proprietor of an earlier trade mark, the trade mark applied for is to be refused registration where, because of its identity with or similarity to an earlier trade mark and because of the identity or similarity of the goods or services which the two trade marks designate, there is a likelihood of confusion on the part of the public in the territory in which the earlier trade mark is protected. The likelihood of confusion includes the likelihood of association with the earlier mark.

17      According to the case-law, a likelihood of confusion is the likelihood that the public might believe that the goods or services at issue come from the same undertaking or, where appropriate, from economically linked undertakings. The likelihood of confusion must be assessed globally, according to the perception that the relevant public has of the signs and the goods or services at issue, and taking into account all factors relevant to the circumstances of the case, in particular the interdependence of the similarity between the signs and the similarity between the goods or services covered (judgment of 4 July 2019, *FTI Touristik* v *EUIPO*, C‑99/18 P, EU:C:2019:565, paragraph 20).

18      For the purposes of applying Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, a likelihood of confusion presupposes both that the marks at issue are identical or similar and that the goods or services which they cover are identical or similar. Those conditions are cumulative (see judgment of 22 January 2009, *Commercy* v *OHIM – easyGroup IP Licensing (easyHotel)*, T‑316/07, EU:T:2009:14, paragraph 42 and the case-law cited).

***The relevant public***

19      The Board of Appeal took the view that the goods concerned were aimed at both the general public and professionals and that it was appropriate to take into account the degree of attention of consumers belonging to the general public. In its view, the degree of attention of the latter varied from low, in the case of low-priced products intended for mass consumption, to average, in the case of higher-priced foodstuffs and beverages.

20      The Board of Appeal then considered that, in view of the earlier national trade mark on which the opposition was based, the relevant territory was that of Italy.

21      The applicant claims, in essence, that, when assessing the level of attention of the relevant public, the Board of Appeal erroneously included products which were not at issue in the present case and, consequently, wrongly overestimated that public’s level of attention as being average. It claims that the reference in the contested decision to foodstuffs is very broad and imprecise because, in particular, the price and frequency of purchase of foodstuffs can vary the level of attention of the relevant public, which is not the case with ‘fruit and vegetables’ in Class 31. In addition, the reference to beverages is erroneous, as they are not covered by the marks at issue. Consequently, as regards the goods at issue, namely ‘fresh fruit and vegetables’, the applicant considers that the level of attention of the relevant public is low.

22      EUIPO disputes the applicant’s arguments.

23      According to settled case-law, for the purposes of the overall assessment of the likelihood of confusion, the average consumer of the category of goods concerned is deemed to be reasonably well informed and reasonably observant and circumspect. In that regard, it should also be borne in mind that the average consumer’s level of attention is likely to vary according to the category of goods or services in question (see judgment of 22 June 1999, *Lloyd Schuhfabrik Meyer*, C‑342/97, EU:C:1999:323, paragraph 26 and the case-law cited).

24      In the present case, it should be noted, first, that the reference to foodstuffs is relevant, given that fruit and vegetables form part of that generic category and, secondly, that beverages were mentioned only by way of example. As EUIPO points out, that reference is part of a general reasoning and, in any event, only ‘fresh fruit and vegetables’, expressly referred to in paragraph 68 of the contested decision, were taken into account in the overall assessment of the likelihood of confusion.

25      It should also be noted, as EUIPO points out, that, for ‘fresh fruit and vegetables’, the level of attention of the relevant public varies, in the case-law, from low (see, to that effect, judgment of 15 October 2018, *Apple and Pear Australia and Star Fruits Diffusion* v *EUIPO – Pink Lady America (WILD PINK)*, T‑164/17, not published, EU:T:2018:678, paragraph 51) to average (see, to that effect, judgment of 13 November 2024, *Chiquita Brands* v *EUIPO – Compagnie financière de participation (Representation of a blue and yellow oval)*, T‑426/23, not published, EU:T:2024:807, paragraph 24).

26      It follows that the Board of Appeal did not make an error of assessment in considering that the level of attention of the relevant public varied from low to average.

***The c****omparison of the goods at issue***

27      The Board of Appeal found that the goods designated by the mark applied for, included in Class 31, were identical to the goods in the same class covered by the earlier mark, since the general category of ‘fresh fruit and vegetables’ covered by the earlier mark either included the goods of the mark applied for or was included in them.

28      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal are not contested by the applicant and there is nothing in the case file to call them into question.

***The comp****arison of the** **signs** **at issue***

29      As regards the mark applied for, the Board of Appeal found, in paragraph 38 of the contested decision, that it consisted of the word element ‘joli’, written in stylised black bold type, and a purely decorative curve, placed below that word element. The Board of Appeal then found, in paragraph 39 of the contested decision, that the word element ‘joli’ was devoid of meaning for a significant proportion of the Italian-speaking public, with a below-average level of attention, who did not recognise the French word ‘joli’.

30      With regard to the earlier mark, the Board of Appeal first held, in paragraph 40 of the contested decision, that that mark consisted of a single six-letter word element, the element ‘jolife’. The Board of Appeal then noted, in paragraphs 41 to 45 of the contested decision, that the earlier mark would not be broken down by the relevant public. In its view, the letters ‘jo’ had no meaning for the targeted consumer and, since the letter ‘j’ was not part of the Italian alphabet, the sign as a whole would be perceived as a foreign word by a significant part of the relevant public in Italy. The Board of Appeal concluded that, irrespective of whether the Italian-speaking public recognised the English word ‘life’, it would perceive the earlier mark as a whole. Finally, in paragraph 46 of the contested decision, the Board of Appeal added that there was no visual indication enabling the relevant consumer to break down the earlier mark into two terms, ‘jo’ and ‘life’ or ‘joli’ and ‘fe’.

31      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal are not contested by the applicant and there is nothing in the case file to call them into question. By contrast, the applicant contests the findings of the Board of Appeal relating to the visual and phonetic comparison of the marks at issue.

32      The overall assessment of the likelihood of confusion must, as regards the visual, phonetic or conceptual similarity of the signs at issue, be based on the overall impression produced by them, taking into account, in particular, their distinctive and dominant elements. The perception of the marks by the average consumer of the goods or services in question plays a decisive role in the global assessment of that likelihood of confusion. In that regard, the average consumer normally perceives a mark as a whole and does not engage in an analysis of its various details (see judgments of 12 June 2007, *OHIM* v *Shaker*, C‑334/05 P, EU:C:2007:333, paragraph 35 and the case-law cited, and of 4 March 2020, *EUIPO* v *Equivalenza Manufactory*, C‑328/18 P, EU:C:2020:156, paragraph 58 and the case-law cited).

*The visual comparison*

33      The Board of Appeal found that the marks at issue coincided as regards the sequence of the letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’ and differed as regards their ending and the stylisation and figurative element of the mark applied for. According to the Board of Appeal, as the signs at issue were relatively short, the difference linked to the additional syllable ‘fe’, placed at the end of the earlier mark, would be clearly perceptible to the relevant public. The Board of Appeal considered that, for that type of sign, the ending was as important as the beginning. It therefore concluded that the marks at issue had a low degree of visual similarity.

34      The applicant contests that analysis, arguing that the signs at issue cannot be regarded as short signs and that, even if they were, the difference between their final parts would have only a limited visual impact. According to the applicant, consumers pay more attention to the beginning of a trade mark than to its end. That is why the four identical letters in the same position at the beginning of the signs attract consumers’ attention more than the last syllable ‘fe’ of the earlier mark. Furthermore, the applicant submits that the Board of Appeal erred in considering that the last two letters of the earlier mark, ‘fe’, constituted 50% of the word element of the mark applied for. Finally, the applicant points out, citing the Court’s case-law, that the figurative element of the sign concerned plays a secondary role in relation to its word element. Accordingly, in the applicant’s view, the Board of Appeal should have found that there was at least an average degree of visual similarity.

35      EUIPO disputes the applicant’s arguments.

36      In that regard, it should be noted that the marks at issue both contain the sequence of the letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’, and that ‘joli’ constitutes the sole word element of the mark applied for, as well as the first four letters of the earlier mark JOLIFE, which implies a certain degree of similarity between those marks.

37      Thereby, it should also be noted that the signs at issue have a number of visual differences.

38      In the first place, although the sequence of letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’ is certainly common to the signs at issue, it must be said that its specific graphic representation in the sign applied for attracts the public’s attention in some way, having regard to its particular typeface. In addition, the marks at issue are visually distinguished by the curve below the word element of the mark applied for and by the unusual use of upper-case letters for the ‘JOL’ element and a lower-case letter for the ‘i’.

39      It is true that, where a trade mark is composed of word and figurative elements, the former are, in principle, more distinctive than the latter, because the average consumer will more easily refer to the goods in question by quoting the name of that trade mark than by describing its figurative element (judgment of 14 July 2005, *Wassen International* v *OHIM – Stroschein Gesundkost (SELENIUM-ACE)*, T‑312/03, EU:T:2005:289, paragraph 37). Nevertheless, a figurative mark, by definition, contains a particular figurative element which, unless it is wholly insignificant, must, even if it is dominated by a word element, as in the present case, be taken into account in the overall assessment of the similarity of the signs at issue (see judgment of 11 December 2024, *López-Ibor Aliño* v *EUIPO – Dimensión Estratégica Quality Research (LOPEZ-IBOR ABOGADOS)*, T‑672/22, not published, EU:T:2024:892, paragraph 60 and the case-law cited). Thus, it is apparent from an analysis of the mark applied for that, although they are not co-dominant, the figurative elements of that mark, consisting essentially of letters with a slight stylisation, the existence of a curve under the word element thereof and the unconventional use of lower-case and upper-case letters, are not, as the Board of Appeal recognised in the present case, negligible.

40      In the second place, the earlier mark contains two final letters in addition to those of the mark applied for, namely the letters ‘fe’.

41      In that regard, it should be noted, as does EUIPO, that the Board of Appeal did not describe the signs at issue as short signs, but as ‘quite short’ or ‘relatively short’ signs. Nor did it apply the case-law on short signs, according to which the relevant public is likely to perceive more clearly the differences between two signs of that kind (see, to that effect, judgment of 3 December 2014, *Max Mara Fashion Group* v *OHIM – Mackays Stores (M & Co.)*, T‑272/13, not published, EU:T:2014:1020, paragraph 47 and the case-law cited), but considered, in the present case, that the elements at the end of the signs at issue were just as important as their elements at the beginning and their central elements.

42      The Court has recognised that, although the relevant public generally pays greater attention to the beginning of a trade mark than to the end (judgment of 25 March 2009, *L’Oréal* v *OHIM – Spa Monopole (SPA THERAPY)*, T‑109/07, EU:T:2009:81, paragraph 30), in respect of word marks which are relatively short, such as those in the present case, the elements at the beginning and end of the sign were as important as the central elements (see, to that effect, judgments of 20 April 2005, *Krüger* v *OHIM – Calpis (CALPICO)*, T‑273/02, EU:T:2005:134, paragraph 39; of 15 March 2012, *Cadila Healthcare* v *OHIM – Novartis (ZYDUS)*, T‑288/08, not published, EU:T:2012:124, paragraph 52; and of 28 April 2021, *FCA Italy* v *EUIPO – Bettag (Pandem)*, T‑191/20, not published, EU:T:2021:226, paragraph 39).

43      In the present case, it is true that the first four letters of the marks at issue are identical and make up the entire word element of the mark applied for. However, in accordance with the case-law, it cannot be ruled out that signs may be considered to be visually similar to a low degree, even though they contain a sequence of identical letters (see, to that effect, judgments of 11 December 2013, *Eckes-Granini* v *OHIM – Panini (PANINI)*, T‑487/12, not published, EU:T:2013:637, paragraph 42; of 27 February 2019, *Aytekin* v *EUIPO – Dienne Salotti (Dienne)*, T‑107/18, not published, EU:T:2019:114, paragraph 48; and of 11 October 2023, *Pascoe pharmazeutische Präparate* v *EUIPO – Novartis Pharma (PASCELMO)*, T‑435/22, not published, EU:T:2023:610, paragraphs 50 to 54).

44      Consequently, the Board of Appeal was right to consider that the group of letters ‘fe’ had a significant impact on the perception of the signs at issue, since that final element of dissimilarity is as important as the elements at the beginning, so that it contributes to mitigating, in the context of an overall impression, the similarity produced by the initial letters ‘joli’.

45      Therefore, contrary to the applicant’s assertion, in the present case the beginning of the signs at issue will not necessarily have a greater effect on consumer perception than the ending of the earlier mark, and the latter will be perceptible by the relevant public.

46      As regards the applicant’s argument that the last two letters of the earlier mark do not constitute 50% of the word element of the mark applied for, it must be noted that that mark consists of four letters and that two letters represent half of four. The assessment of the Board of Appeal that the last two letters of the earlier mark constitute 50% of the four letters of the mark applied for must therefore be confirmed.

47      Consequently, the visual similarity of the signs at issue is limited solely to the presence of the common letter sequence ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’.

48      The assessment of the similarity between two trade marks cannot, in principle, be limited to taking into consideration only one component of a complex trade mark consisting of a sequence of common letters and comparing it with another trade mark. It is only in circumstances where the overall impression conveyed to the relevant public by a complex trade mark is dominated by one or more of its components and all the other components of that mark are negligible that the assessment of similarity may, by way of exception, be made solely on the basis of the dominant element (see, to that effect, judgment of 12 June 2007, *OHIM* v *Shaker*, C‑334/05 P, EU:C:2007:333, paragraphs 35 and 41 and the case-law cited).

49      When comparing the marks at issue, account must also be taken of the figurative elements of the trade mark applied for, which, as is apparent from paragraph 39 above, are not insignificant (see, to that effect, judgment of 11 December 2024, *LOPEZ-IBOR ABOGADOS*, T‑672/22, not published, EU:T:2024:892, paragraphs 87 and 88).

50      Accordingly, the differences between the signs at issue, due to the figurative elements of the mark applied for and the presence of additional letters in the earlier mark, namely those making up the syllable ‘fe’, contribute, to a not inconsiderable extent, to visually distinguishing the signs at issue.

51      In the light of the foregoing considerations, the Board of Appeal’s conclusion that the signs at issue, taken as a whole, show little visual similarity must be upheld.

*The phonetic comparison*

52      The Board of Appeal found that the marks at issue coincided as regards the sound of the sequence of letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’ and differed in the number of syllables and the rhythm of pronunciation. According to the Board of Appeal, as the signs at issue are relatively short, the difference in ending linked to the additional syllable ‘fe’ in the earlier mark would be clearly perceptible. Accordingly, the Board of Appeal concluded that the marks at issue were phonetically similar to at most an average degree.

53      The applicant disputes that analysis and submits that the difference in the final part ‘fe’ of the earlier mark is not such as to compensate for the identical sound of the first four letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’ of the signs at issue. Furthermore, the marks are devoid of conceptual meaning and are pronounced with the same rhythm and intonation, according to the Italian rules of pronunciation, which produces a similar overall phonetic impression. According to the applicant, the Board of Appeal should therefore have found that there was at least an average degree of phonetic similarity.

54      EUIPO disputes the applicant’s arguments.

55      In that regard, it should first be noted that the earlier mark will be pronounced in three syllables, namely ‘jo’, ‘li’ and ‘fe’, whereas the mark applied for will be pronounced in two syllables, namely ‘jo’ and ‘li’, so that they differ in length.

56      While it is true that there is a partial phonetic identity between the signs at issue resulting from the presence of the sequence of common letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’, the Board of Appeal was right to conclude that there is at most an average degree of phonetic similarity between the signs at issue, taking into account the additional syllable in the earlier mark.

57      That conclusion is not called into question by the applicant’s argument that the Board of Appeal should have recognised a degree of phonetic similarity which was at least average, and not at most average. In that regard, it must be noted, as does EUIPO, that the applicant does not substantiate its argument. Moreover, as EUIPO also points out, the applicant acknowledges, as did the Board of Appeal, that the degree of phonetic similarity between the signs at issue to be taken into account in assessing the likelihood of confusion is average.

*The conceptual comparison*

58      The Board of Appeal found that none of the signs at issue had any meaning for the relevant public. It therefore concluded that the conceptual comparison was neutral. By contrast, for the section of the public that understood the French word ‘joli’, it considered that the signs were conceptually different.

59      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal are not contested by the applicant and there is nothing in the case file to call them into question.

***The intrinsic distinctiveness of the earlier mark***

60      In paragraph 58 of the contested decision, the Board of Appeal concluded that the earlier mark had normal distinctive character.

61      That assessment by the Board of Appeal is not contested by the applicant and there is nothing in the case file to call it into question.

***The overall assessment** **of the likelihood of confusion***

62      The Board of Appeal considered, after taking into account the degree of attention of the relevant public, the identity of the goods concerned, the absence of any possibility of decomposing the earlier mark, the low degree of visual similarity of the signs at issue, their at most average degree of phonetic similarity, their neutral conceptual comparison or their lack of conceptual similarity, that the overall impression of the signs at issue was clearly different. Accordingly, there was no likelihood of confusion.

63      The applicant contests that assessment, in that it is based on erroneous premises, according to which the signs at issue are short, visually similar to a low degree and phonetically similar to at most an average degree.

64      In that regard, the applicant reiterates its arguments concerning the visual and phonetic comparison of the signs at issue, arguing that the differences in the ending of the earlier mark and in the figurative element of the sign applied for cannot outweigh the similarities between the signs at issue. In addition, it stated that, even if the relevant public displayed an average level of attention, a likelihood of confusion could not be ruled out, owing to the principle of imperfect memory retained by consumers. Finally, the Board of Appeal erred in considering that the earlier mark was ‘not recognisable’ within the mark applied for, because this would mean that there would never be a likelihood of confusion where an earlier mark was longer than the mark applied for or where the marks did not consist of identical letters.

65      EUIPO disputes the applicant’s arguments.

66      It should be borne in mind that, according to the Court of Justice’s settled case-law, a likelihood of confusion on the part of the public must be assessed globally, taking into account all factors relevant to the circumstances of the case (see judgment of 4 March 2020, *EUIPO* v *Equivalenza Manufactory*, C‑328/18 P, EU:C:2020:156, paragraph 57 and the case-law cited).

67      The overall assessment of the likelihood of confusion involves a degree of interdependence between the factors taken into account and, in particular, between the similarity of the marks at issue and that of the goods or services designated by them. Thus, a low degree of similarity between the goods or services designated by the trade marks may be offset by a high degree of similarity between those trade marks, and vice versa (judgments of 29 September 1998, *Canon*, C‑39/97, EU:C:1998:442, paragraph 17, and of 14 December 2006, *Mast-Jägermeister* v *OHIM – Licorera Zacapaneca (VENADO with frame and others)*, T‑81/03, T‑82/03 and T‑103/03, EU:T:2006:397, paragraph 74).

68      In the present case, it follows from the foregoing considerations that the relevant public consists of the general public and professional consumers, with a low to average level of attention, and that the signs at issue are visually similar to a low degree and phonetically similar to at most an average degree, while the conceptual comparison remains neutral for the predominant part of the relevant public and results in a difference for the part of that public which understands the French word ‘joli’. The similarities between the signs are not particularly significant in the present case. Despite the presence of the sequence of identical letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’ at the beginning of the signs at issue, the overall impression produced by the mark applied for is distinct from that produced by the earlier mark, owing to the presence of the figurative elements of the mark applied for and the two additional letters of the earlier mark.

69      The circumstances of the present case are therefore such that the relevant public will clearly distinguish the signs at issue, even if they have a certain degree of similarity, due to the presence of the sequence of common letters ‘j’, ‘o’, ‘l’ and ‘i’, and even if the goods at issue are identical and the earlier mark has an average degree of distinctiveness.

70      In the present case, therefore, the Board of Appeal was right to hold that there was no likelihood of confusion.

71      That conclusion cannot be called into question by the applicant’s reliance on the principle of imperfect recollection in order to establish that a likelihood of confusion cannot be excluded. It is true that the average consumer only rarely has the chance to make a direct comparison between the different marks but must place his or her trust in his or her imperfect recollection of them (judgment of 22 June 1999, *Lloyd Schuhfabrik Meyer*, C‑342/97, EU:C:1999:323, paragraph 26) and that that principle is applicable even to a public displaying an average level of attention (see, to that effect, judgment of 14 February 2019, *Torro Entertainment* v *EUIPO – Grupo Osborne (TORRO Grande MEAT IN STYLE)*, T‑63/18, not published, EU:T:2019:89, paragraph 66).

72      Nevertheless, in the present case, the visual and phonetic differences between the signs at issue, such as those based on the ending of the earlier mark and the pronunciation of its last syllable, will not go unnoticed. Consequently, the relevant public, with a low to average level of attention, will perceive those differences, even if it only retains an imperfect image of those signs, which have a different overall impression.

73      Finally, as regards the applicant’s argument that the Board of Appeal considered that there was no likelihood of confusion because the earlier mark was ‘not recognisable’ within the mark applied for, it should be noted that the Board of Appeal took into account all the relevant factors and their interdependence in analysing the likelihood of confusion, and not only the fact that the earlier mark was not contained within the mark applied for. It follows that, contrary to the applicant’s claim, the Board of Appeal did not consider that there was no likelihood of confusion where the earlier mark was longer than the mark applied for or where those marks were not composed of the same letters. The Board of Appeal simply noted that, as the earlier mark could not be broken down into two words, ‘joli’ and ‘fe’, and was regarded as an indivisible whole, the relevant public would have a different overall impression of the marks at issue.

74      Furthermore, the examples drawn from the General Court’s case-law and EUIPO’s decision-making practice, relied on by the applicant, relating to the recognition of the existence of a likelihood of confusion in cases where the earlier mark is longer than the mark applied for or is not composed of the same letters, placed in the same order, as the latter, are not relevant to the present case.

75      First, as EUIPO submits, with regard to the judgments of 29 March 2023, *Machková* v *EUIPO – Aceites Almenara (ALMARA SOAP)* (T‑436/22, not published, EU:T:2023:167), of 12 July 2023, *Nurel* v *EUIPO – FKuR Property (Terylene)* (T‑325/22, not published, EU:T:2023:397), and of 28 February 2024, *Drinks Prod* v *EUIPO – Wolff and Illg (IGISAN)* (T‑164/23, not published, EU:T:2024:132), the circumstances are different from the present case, in that the signs were not considered to be relatively short and share the same beginning and ending.

76      Secondly, as regards the judgment of 29 November 2023, *Claro* v *EUIPO – Claranet Europe (Claro)* (T‑661/22, not published, EU:T:2023:762), the earlier mark was broken down into two terms, ‘clara’ and ‘net’, and the Court recognised that the term ‘clara’ was the more distinctive. Therefore, unlike in the present case, that term and the term constituting the contested sign in the case giving rise to that judgment were of the same length and differed only in their last letter. The same is true of the decision of the Second Board of Appeal of 23 October 2023, *DEVO* v *devonfw* (Case R 336/2023-2), where the earlier mark had been broken down into ‘devon’ and ‘fw’, which is not the case here. Moreover, it should be borne in mind that the legality of EUIPO decisions must be assessed solely on the basis of Regulation 2017/1001, as interpreted by the EU judicature, and not on the basis of decision-making practice prior to those decisions (see, to that effect, judgment of 26 April 2007, *Alcon* v *OHIM*, C‑412/05 P, EU:C:2007:252, paragraph 65).

77      Thirdly, with regard to the judgment of 30 March 2022, *Copal Tree Brands* v *EUIPO – Sumol + Compal Marcas (COPALLI)* (T‑445/21, not published, EU:T:2022:198), the case concerned Article 8(5) of Regulation 2017/1001, namely the question of whether there was a likelihood of the mark applied for taking unfair advantage of the repute of the earlier mark ‘COMPAL’, and not the assessment of the likelihood of confusion within the meaning of Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001.

78      In the light of all the foregoing considerations, the action must be dismissed in its entirety.

**Costs**

79      Under Article 134(1) of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for in the successful party’s pleadings.

80      Even though the applicant has been unsuccessful, EUIPO contended that it should be ordered to pay the costs only in the event that a hearing is convened. Since no hearing was held, each party must be ordered to bear its own costs.

On those grounds,

THE GENERAL COURT (Sixth Chamber)

hereby:

1.      **Dismisses the action;**

2.      **Orders Villafrut Srl and the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) each to bear their own costs.**

|  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Costeira | Kancheva | Öberg |

Delivered in open court in Luxembourg on 2 July 2025.

|  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- |
| V. Di Bucci |  | M. van der Woude |

|  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Registrar |  | President |

---

[\*](#Footref*)      Language of the case: English.

[Top](#document1)