Source: EURLEX
Language: en
Format: md

JUDGMENT OF THE GENERAL COURT (Third Chamber)

2 July 2025 ([\*](#Footnote*))

( EU trade mark – Opposition proceedings – International registration designating the European Union – Figurative mark C&M – Earlier EU word mark C&A – Relative ground for refusal – Likelihood of confusion – Visual and phonetic similarity – Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 )

In Case T‑380/24,

**Camilla and Marc Operations Pty Ltd,**  established in Waterloo (Australia), represented by J. van Manen and A. Heemskerk, lawyers,

applicant,

v

**European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO),** represented by M. Eberl, acting as Agent,

defendant,

the other party to the proceedings before the Board of Appeal of EUIPO, intervener before the General Court, being

**C&A AG,** established in Baar (Switzerland), represented by K. Guridi Sedlak, lawyer,

THE GENERAL COURT (Third Chamber),

composed of P. Škvařilová‑Pelzl, President, I. Nõmm and R. Meyer (Rapporteur), Judges,

Registrar: V. Di Bucci,

having regard to the written part of the procedure,

having regard to the fact that no request for a hearing was submitted by the parties within three weeks after service of notification of the close of the written part of the procedure, and having decided to rule on the action without an oral part of the procedure, pursuant to Article 106(3) of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court,

gives the following

**Judgment**

1        By its action under Article 263 TFEU, the applicant, Camilla and Marc Operations Pty Ltd, seeks the annulment of the decision of the Second Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) of 21 May 2024 (Case R 1667/2023-2) (‘the contested decision’).

**Background to the dispute**

2        On 1 October 2020, the applicant designated the European Union in its international registration of the following figurative sign:

![Image not found](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)

3        The goods in respect of which protection of the international registration was sought are in Classes 18 and 25 of the Nice Agreement Concerning the International Classification of Goods and Services for the Purposes of the Registration of Marks of 15 June 1957, as revised and amended, and correspond, for Class 25, to the following description: ‘Clothing, footwear, headgear, belts (clothing)’.

4        On 24 February 2021, the intervener, C&A AG, filed a notice of opposition pursuant to Article 46 of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 on the European Union trade mark (OJ 2017 L 154, p. 1) to registration of the sign applied for.

5        The opposition was based on the following earlier rights:

–        the EU word mark C&A, registered on 24 November 2003 under No 2 840 940;

–        the EU word mark C&A, registered on 17 May 1999 under No 105 882, for goods in Classes 18 and 25 corresponding, for each of those classes, to the following description:

–        Class 18: ‘Leather and imitation leather; goods made from these materials, not included in other classes; trunks and travelling bags; umbrellas, parasols and walking sticks’;

–        Class 25: ‘Clothing, footwear, headgear’.

6        The grounds relied on in support of the opposition were those set out in Article 8(1)(b) and (5) of Regulation 2017/1001.

7        Following the applicant’s request, EUIPO invited the opponent to furnish proof of genuine use of the marks relied on in support of the opposition.

8        By decision of 8 June 2023, the Opposition Division found that only the EU word mark C&A, registered under No 105 882 (‘the earlier mark’), had been put to genuine use and only in respect of ‘clothing’. It rejected the opposition in its entirety.

9        On 3 August 2023, the intervener filed a notice of appeal with EUIPO against that decision of the Opposition Division.

10      By the contested decision, after stating that the scope of the appeal was limited to the assessment of the likelihood of confusion referred to in Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, the Board of Appeal found that there was a likelihood of confusion in respect of the goods in Class 25 covered by the contested mark. Consequently, it upheld that appeal in part and annulled the decision of the Opposition Division in so far as it had rejected the opposition as regards the goods in Class 25.

**Forms of order sought**

11      The applicant claims, in essence, that the Court should:

–        annul the contested decision in part in so far as it concluded that there was a likelihood of confusion as regards the goods found to be identical with, or similar to, the clothing in Class 25;

–        order EUIPO to pay the costs.

12      EUIPO contends that the Court should:

–        dismiss the action;

–        order the applicant to pay the costs incurred in the event that an oral hearing is convened.

13      The intervener contends, in essence, that the Court should:

–        dismiss the action;

–        order the applicant to pay the costs.

**Law**

14      In support of the action, the applicant relies on a single plea in law, alleging infringement of Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001. It complains, in essence, that the Board of Appeal failed to take into consideration all the relevant factors and characteristics specific to the case in order to assess whether there was a likelihood of confusion between the two signs at issue. It thus disputes that there is a visual and phonetic similarity between those two signs and criticises the Board of Appeal for finding that there was a likelihood of confusion as regards the goods found to be identical with, or similar to, the clothing in Class 25 without taking into account practices in the fashion industry. It also submits that the contested decision is tantamount to granting the intervener a de facto monopoly over the sign ‘C&’.

15      Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001 provides that, upon opposition by the proprietor of an earlier trade mark, the trade mark applied for must not be registered if because of its identity with, or similarity to, the earlier trade mark and the identity or similarity of the goods or services covered by the trade marks, there exists a likelihood of confusion on the part of the public in the territory in which the earlier trade mark is protected. The likelihood of confusion includes the likelihood of association with the earlier trade mark.

16      The risk that the public may believe that the goods or services in question come from the same undertaking or from economically linked undertakings constitutes a likelihood of confusion. The likelihood of confusion must be assessed globally, according to the relevant public’s perception of the signs and goods or services in question and taking into account all factors relevant to the circumstances of the case, in particular the interdependence between the similarity of the signs and that of the goods or services covered (see judgment of 9 July 2003, *Laboratorios RTB* v *OHIM – Giorgio Beverly Hills (GIORGIO BEVERLY HILLS)*, T‑162/01, EU:T:2003:199, paragraphs 30 to 33 and the case-law cited).

17      For the purposes of applying Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, a likelihood of confusion presupposes both that the marks at issue are identical or similar and that the goods or services which they cover are identical or similar. Those conditions are cumulative (see judgment of 22 January 2009, *Commercy* v *OHIM – easyGroup IP Licensing (easyHotel)*, T‑316/07, EU:T:2009:14, paragraph 42 and the case-law cited).

18      It is in the light of those considerations that it must be examined whether, as the applicant submits, the Board of Appeal infringed Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, by finding that there could be a likelihood of confusion in the present case as regards the goods found to be identical with, or similar to, the clothing in Class 25.

19      It should be noted as a preliminary point that it is not disputed in the present action, first, that use for the services in Class 35 (retail services for various goods) of EU trade mark No 2 840 940 has not been sufficiently established, or, second, that genuine use of EU trade mark No 105 882 has been proved for ‘clothing’, namely the clothing, headgear, footwear and belts in Class 25.

***The relevant public***

20      The Board of Appeal found, first of all, that, since the opposition was based on an earlier EU trade mark, the relevant territory for the purpose of assessing the likelihood of confusion is that of the European Union.

21      It then took the view that the goods in question were aimed at the general public, since they were ordinary consumer goods.

22      Lastly, the Board of Appeal stated that the level of attention of the relevant public was average.

23      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal, which are not, moreover, disputed by the applicant, must be upheld.

***The c****omparison of the goods** **in question***

24      The Board of Appeal took the view that, first, the ‘clothing’ and the ‘belts (clothing)’ and, second, the ‘footwear’ and the ‘headgear’ covered by the mark applied for were, respectively, identical with and similar to, the ‘clothing’ covered by the earlier mark.

25      The Board of Appeal also found that there was a difference between the goods ‘leather and imitations of leather; trunks and travelling bags; suitcases, umbrellas’ in Class 18 covered by the mark applied for and the ‘clothing’ in Class 25 covered by the earlier mark.

26      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal, which are not, moreover, disputed by the applicant, must be upheld.

***The comparison of the signs** **at issue***

27      Two marks are similar when, from the point of view of the relevant public, they are at least partially identical as regards one or more relevant aspects, namely the visual, phonetic and conceptual aspects (judgment of 14 November 2018, *Foodterapia* v *EUIPO – Sperlari (DIETOX)*, T‑486/17, not published, EU:T:2018:778, paragraph 36).

28      In order to assess the degree of similarity between the marks concerned, it is therefore necessary to determine the degree of visual, phonetic and conceptual similarity between them (order of 27 April 2006, *L’Oréal* v *OHIM*, C‑235/05 P, not published, EU:C:2006:271, paragraph 40).

29      Furthermore, the global assessment of the likelihood of confusion must, so far as concerns the visual, phonetic or conceptual similarity of the signs at issue, be based on the overall impression given by the signs, bearing in mind, in particular, their distinctive and dominant elements. The perception of the marks by the average consumer of the goods or services in question plays a decisive role in the global assessment of that likelihood of confusion. In that regard, the average consumer normally perceives a mark as a whole and does not engage in an analysis of its various details (see judgment of 12 June 2007, *OHIM* v *Shaker*, C‑334/05 P, EU:C:2007:333, paragraph 35 and the case-law cited).

30      In the present case, the marks to be compared are the following:

|  |  |
| --- | --- |
| C&A | Image not found |
| Earlier mark | Contested sign |

*The dominant and distinctive elements of the signs at issue*

31      The Board of Appeal found that the two marks at issue consisted of the combination of two letters, linked by an ampersand, which did not convey any clearly perceptible meaning. It deduced that the word elements of the two signs at issue had an average degree of distinctiveness.

32      The Board of Appeal also found that the stylisation of the figurative elements of the contested sign consisted solely of the use of a standard bold typeface which, therefore, did not influence the overall impression created by the sign.

33      It concluded that the signs at issue did not contain any element which could be regarded as more dominant than others.

34      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal, which are not, moreover, disputed by the applicant, must be upheld.

*The similarity of the signs at issue*

–       *The visual similarity of the signs at issue*

35      As a preliminary point, in so far as the mark applied for is a figurative mark and the earlier mark is a word mark, it should be borne in mind that, as regards the visual comparison, there is nothing to prevent a determination as to whether there is any visual similarity between a word mark and a figurative mark, since the two types of mark have graphic form capable of creating a visual impression (see judgment of 4 May 2005, *Chum* v *OHIM – Star TV (STAR TV)*, T‑359/02, EU:T:2005:156, paragraph 43 and the case-law cited).

36      In the present case, the Board of Appeal found, in paragraph 50 of the contested decision, a finding which the applicant does not dispute, that the signs coincided in their first two characters, but differed in their third character.

37      The Board of Appeal first of all stated, in paragraph 51 of the contested decision, that the initial part of a mark normally has a greater impact than the final part, including in the case of short marks. It then found, in paragraph 52 of that decision, that, in the present case, although the signs are rather short, first, the similarities between those signs accounted for two thirds of their length and, second, the structure of the signs was identical. Lastly, it concluded that the difference in a single letter did not constitute a significant difference and did not give rise to a different overall visual impression, with the result that the signs were, at the very least, visually similar to an average degree.

38      The applicant criticises paragraph 51 of the contested decision and submits that the rule that consumers tend to focus on the beginning of a sign does not apply when faced with a short sign. In such a case, the consumer would have no difficulty in perceiving the sign as a whole. According to the applicant, that is all the more true where the middle character is an ampersand, which indicates that the two letters are of equal importance.

39      The applicant adds that the length of a sign influences the effect of similarity or dissimilarity between the signs. Accordingly, when faced with short signs, the relevant public is likely to perceive more clearly what differentiates them.

40      EUIPO and the intervener dispute the applicant’s arguments.

41      It must be borne in mind that the rule that greater attention is paid to the beginning of signs cannot apply in all cases and cannot call into question the general principle that the assessment of the similarity of marks must take account of the overall impression produced by those marks, since the average consumer normally perceives a mark as a whole and does not proceed to analyse its various details. The Court must not take as its starting point the premiss that the consumer pays greater attention to the beginning of a word sign rather than to its end. It may hold that the end of signs which are the subject of opposition proceedings is more distinctive or dominant than the beginning of those signs or even that one of the elements in those signs is not more distinctive or dominant than the other (see judgment of 24 April 2024, *Adeva* v *EUIPO – Sideme (MAISON CAVIST.)*, T‑313/23, not published, EU:T:2024:270, paragraph 69 and the case-law cited).

42      It is true that the Board of Appeal stated, in paragraph 51 of the contested decision, that the initial part of a mark normally has a greater impact than the final part. However, that general statement is followed, in paragraph 52 of that decision, by a specific assessment of the visual similarity of the signs at issue, from which it follows that those signs are similar in two thirds of their length and that their structure is identical. The Board of Appeal concluded that the difference in a single letter did not constitute a significant difference and did not give rise to a different overall visual impression, with the result that the signs were, at the very least, visually similar to an average degree.

43      Consequently, the Board of Appeal’s conclusion as regards the visual similarity of the signs at issue is not based solely on the fact that that similarity concerns the beginning of those signs, but on an overall assessment of the signs.

44      First, it follows that the applicant’s argument is based on an incomplete reading of the contested decision. Second, the applicant does not dispute, as such, either the specific assessment of the visual similarity of the signs at issue or the Board of Appeal’s conclusion, which are set out in paragraph 52 of the contested decision. Therefore, that argument must be rejected as ineffective.

45      In addition, as is stated by EUIPO, it is only where the differences between those signs can lead to different overall impressions that the similarity between them is appreciably reduced. That is not the case as regards the signs at issue, which are similar in two thirds of their length, the overall structure of which is identical and the standard stylisation of which does not influence the overall impression. Furthermore, even in the case of short signs, the presence, in each of the signs, of several letters in the same order is important in the overall assessment of their similarity (see, to that effect, judgment of 7 February 2024, *Darila* v *EUIPO – Original Buff (Buffet)*, T‑101/23, not published, EU:T:2024:65, paragraphs 40 and 42 and the case-law cited).

46      The Board of Appeal was therefore entitled to find that the difference in a single letter did not constitute a significant difference and did not give rise to a different overall visual impression, with the result that the signs at issue were, at the very least, visually similar to an average degree.

–       *The phonetic similarity of the signs at issue*

47      The Board of Appeal found, in paragraph 53 of the contested decision, that two thirds of each of the signs were pronounced identically, which the applicant does not dispute.

48      It also stated, in paragraph 54 of that decision, that the phonetic similarity between the signs lay in the beginning of those signs, to which the relevant public generally pays more attention. It concludes that the similarity between the beginning of the signs had a significant impact on the overall phonetic impression, with the result that the signs at issue were, at the very least, phonetically similar to an average degree.

49      The applicant’s arguments with regard to paragraph 54 of the contested decision are identical to those put forward against paragraph 51 of that decision and reference should therefore be made, in that regard, to paragraphs 38 and 39 of the present judgment.

50      EUIPO and the intervener dispute the applicant’s arguments.

51      As has been observed in paragraph 41 of the present judgment, the rule that greater attention is paid to the beginning of signs cannot apply in all cases and cannot call into question the general principle that the assessment of the similarity of marks must take account of the overall impression produced by those marks, since the average consumer normally perceives a mark as a whole and does not proceed to analyse its various details.

52      However, in the present case, it is not disputed that the signs at issue are similar in two thirds of their length. Furthermore, they have an identical structure consisting of three syllables, which results in a similarity of intonation and rhythm in the overall impression they produce.

53      In addition, even in the case of short signs, the presence, in each of the signs, of several letters in the same order is important in the overall assessment of their similarity (see, by analogy, judgment of 7 February 2024, *Buffet*, T‑101/23, not published, EU:T:2024:65, paragraph 42 and the case-law cited).

54      The Board of Appeal was therefore entitled to find that the signs at issue were, at the very least, phonetically similar to an average degree.

–       *The conceptual similarity of the signs at issue*

55      Taking the view that the two signs at issue have no meaning for the relevant public, the Board of Appeal found, in paragraph 55 of the contested decision, that the conceptual comparison did not influence the assessment of the similarity of those signs.

56      Those assessments of the Board of Appeal, which are not, moreover, disputed by the applicant, must be upheld.

*The distinctive character of the earlier mark*

57      It should be noted that, in paragraphs 58 to 60 of the contested decision, the Board of Appeal confirmed the Opposition Division’s analysis, which is not disputed by the parties, that the earlier mark had acquired a high degree of distinctiveness through its use on the market, in respect of the clothing in Class 25.

58      The Board of Appeal concluded, in paragraphs 60 and 63 of the contested decision, that the earlier mark had a high degree of distinctiveness on account of a high degree of intensive use and reputation in the European Union as regards the clothing in Class 25. That assessment, which is not, moreover, disputed by the applicant, must be upheld.

*The global assessment of the likelihood of confusion*

59      As a preliminary point, it must be borne in mind that a global assessment of the likelihood of confusion implies some interdependence between the factors taken into account and, in particular, between the similarity of the trade marks and that of the goods covered. Accordingly, a low degree of similarity between those goods may be offset by a high degree of similarity between the marks, and vice versa (judgment of 29 September 1998, *Canon*, C‑39/97, EU:C:1998:442, paragraph 17).

60      Furthermore, it must also be borne in mind that the more distinctive the earlier mark, the greater will be the likelihood of confusion. Marks with a highly distinctive character enjoy broader protection than marks with a less distinctive character (judgments of 11 November 1997, *SABEL*, C‑251/95, EU:C:1997:528, paragraph 24; of 29 September 1998, *Canon*, C‑39/97, EU:C:1998:442, paragraph 18; and of 15 July 2020, *Itinerant Show Room* v *EUIPO – Save the Duck (FAKE DUCK)*, T‑371/19, not published, EU:T:2020:339, paragraph 67).

61      In the present case, it is apparent from the foregoing that the relevant public consists of the general public with an average level of attention, that the goods covered by the marks at issue are in part identical and in part similar, that the signs at issue are visually and phonetically similar to an average degree and that the conceptual aspect does not influence the assessment of their similarity.

62      In addition, as stated by the Board of Appeal in paragraph 64 of the contested decision, the figurative elements of the contested sign are not capable of altering the overall impression of similarity between the signs, since those elements consist merely of a standard and, thus, non-distinctive typeface.

63      Therefore, it must be concluded, as the Board of Appeal did, that, in the global assessment of the likelihood of confusion, the similarities between the signs at issue outweigh the existing differences, with the result that there is a likelihood of confusion on the part of the relevant public as regards the goods which have been found to be identical with, or similar to, the clothing in Class 25 covered by the earlier mark.

64      That conclusion cannot be called into question by the arguments put forward by the applicant.

65      In the first place, the applicant complains, in essence, that the Board of Appeal found, in paragraph 64 of the contested decision, that particular weight had to be given to the fact that two thirds of the signs were visually and phonetically similar and that that similarity existed in the beginning of the signs.

66      It should be noted that that line of argument is no different from that put forward in relation to the visual and phonetic similarity of the signs at issue. In those circumstances, and in so far as that line of argument was rejected in the examination of the visual and phonetic similarity of the signs at issue, it must also be rejected as regards the global assessment of the likelihood of confusion.

67      In the second place, first, the applicant submits that the use of two letters, which are the initials of two names, linked by an ampersand, is a well-established practice in the field of trade marks, particularly in the fashion industry. Therefore, since the letter following the ampersand is phonetically and visually different, consumers would understand that the signs at issue relate to different names, which would create a different overall impression.

68      The applicant’s argument is based on the premiss that the consumer has a particular knowledge of the customs of the fashion industry as regards the name of trade marks. However, it does not dispute that the relevant public consists of the general public or that the level of attention of that public is average. The applicant cannot therefore rely on a use specific to the fashion industry which the relevant public would be used to and aware of.

69      Moreover, as stated by EUIPO, the applicant has not substantiated its claims with evidence showing that the relevant public will necessarily associate two letters linked by an ampersand with the initials of the names of the founders of the mark or the designers of the clothing in question. The applicant merely produced a list of clothing trade marks composed of two letters linked by an ampersand, associated with the names corresponding to those initials, without it being possible to draw any inference from that list in respect of the present case.

70      Second, the applicant submits that EUIPO took the view that no economic link between the two marks would be established by the relevant public, which the intervener did not dispute before the Board of Appeal. It infers from that fact, which must be regarded as established before the Court, that there is no likelihood of confusion, particularly as regards the goods ‘bags of all kinds; leather straps, wallets, purses, card cases and key cases’ in Class 18 in respect of which no proof of use has been furnished by C&A.

71      As noted by EUIPO, the intervener’s appeal as regards the goods in Class 18 was dismissed, with the result that those goods are not relevant for the purposes of the present proceedings.

72      Accordingly, that argument must be rejected as unfounded.

73      In the third place, the applicant submits that the Board of Appeal’s reasoning is tantamount to granting, for all the goods concerned, a de facto monopoly over the element ‘C&’, especially since, in the fashion industry, it is common to use such sign structures.

74      In paragraph 66 of the contested decision, the Board of Appeal clarified, in essence, that it was important to take due account of the high degree of distinctiveness enjoyed by the earlier mark in respect of the clothing in Class 25, that is to say, in respect of the goods found to be identical with, or similar to, the goods covered by the contested mark. It thus rightly highlighted the limited scope of protection conferred on the earlier mark.

75      The Board of Appeal also added that it is for those very specific aspects of the present case that, contrary to what the applicant claims, the contested decision is not likely to grant the intervener an unfair monopoly over the element ‘C&’ of its mark. The Board of Appeal was therefore right in stating that the scope of the contested decision is limited to the likelihood of confusion between the marks ‘C&A’ and ‘C&M’ in relation to certain types of goods and that it is not tantamount to conferring de facto any right on the intervener in respect of the elements ‘C&’. The finding that there is a likelihood of confusion leads to the protection of only a certain combination of elements assessed in each specific case (see, to that effect, order of 22 October 2014, *Repsol YPF* v *OHIM*, C‑466/13 P, not published, EU:C:2014:2331, paragraph 84).

76      Furthermore, as has been stated in paragraph 60 of the present judgment, the high degree of distinctiveness of the earlier mark, which is not disputed by the applicant, justifies enhanced protection of that mark against a likelihood of confusion.

77      The Board of Appeal was therefore right to find that the contested decision was not likely to grant the intervener an unfair monopoly over the element ‘C&’.

78      It follows that the applicant’s argument must be rejected as unfounded.

79      In the fourth place, the applicant disputes, in essence, the application by analogy, in paragraph 68 of the contested decision, of an earlier decision of the Board of Appeal.

80      In that regard, it must be observed that, in paragraph 68 of that decision, the Board of Appeal ‘note[d], *en passant*’ that its finding was in line with the decision of the Fourth Board of Appeal of 19 December 2018 (Case R 1252/2018 –4 concerning the signs C&J and C&A).

81      It must be stated that, by proceeding in that way, the Board of Appeal complied with the obligation that, in the light of the principle of equal treatment and the principle of sound administration, EUIPO must, when examining an application for registration of an EU trade mark, take into account the decisions already taken in respect of similar applications and consider with especial care whether it should decide in the same way or not (judgment of 10 March 2011, *Agencja Wydawnicza Technopol* v *OHIM*, C‑51/10 P, EU:C:2011:139, paragraphs 73 and 74).

82      Moreover, in so far as the applicant disputes the relevance of the decision to which the Board of Appeal referred, it is sufficient to note that it is apparent from the very wording of paragraph 68 of the contested decision that that ground is included for the sake of completeness. This is also borne out by the structure of the contested decision, since that paragraph follows the concluding paragraph by which the Board of Appeal found that there was a likelihood of confusion and took the view that the appeal was in part well founded and that the Opposition Division’s decision had to be in part annulled.

83      Even if a ground proves to be erroneous, that cannot justify the annulment of the measure in which it is set out if it is superfluous and if other grounds exist which are sufficient to justify the measure, with the result that complaints directed against such grounds are ineffective (see judgment of 5 June 2024, *Hofstede Insights* v *EUIPO – Geert Hofstede (HOFSTEDE INSIGHTS)*, T‑429/23, not published, EU:T:2024:349, paragraph 23 and the case-law cited).

84      That argument of the applicant must therefore be rejected as ineffective.

85      It follows that the applicant’s single plea in law, alleging infringement of Article 8(1)(b) of Regulation 2017/1001, must be rejected as unfounded and, consequently, the action must be dismissed.

**Costs**

86      Under Article 134(1) of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for in the successful party’s pleadings.

87      Since the applicant has been unsuccessful, it must be ordered to bear its own costs and to pay those incurred by the intervener, in accordance with the form of order sought by the intervener.

88      Since no hearing has taken place, EUIPO must bear its own costs, in accordance with the form of order sought by it.

On those grounds,

THE GENERAL COURT (Third Chamber)

hereby:

1.      **Dismisses the action;**

2.      **Orders Camilla and Marc Operations Pty Ltd to bear its own costs and to pay those incurred by C&A AG;**

3.      **Orders the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) to bear its own costs.**

|  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Škvařilová-Pelzl | Nõmm | Meyer |

Delivered in open court in Luxembourg on 2 July 2025.

|  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- |
| V. Di Bucci |  | M. van der Woude |

|  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Registrar |  | President |

---

[\*](#Footref*)      Language of the case: English.

[Top](#document1)