gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Butterfly,Falcon,Lion,SYSTEM,Giraffe&&3,2,J,A
Giraffe: Hi what did everyone submit?
Falcon: 'I think all but the J card? but I''m not so great at these logic problems'
Giraffe: J,A
Lion: the 2 card and the A card
Falcon: Just curious, why not the 3? what if there is a vowel on the other side?
Butterfly: I submitted the 2 and A cards because the question asked which cards test the rule "All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other."
Butterfly: 2 is an even number and A is the vowel
Giraffe: I chose the 2 and A at first but now I am question
Lion: Not the 3 because its odd and the test failed
Giraffe: yes, not 3
Falcon: Right, but 3 could have, say, an E on the back?
Lion: does not matter
Butterfly: I can understand that if you are wanting to test the theory that 3 may have a vowel which would debunk that rule
Butterfly: That makes sense
Lion: has to have even number and a vowel on the other side
Falcon: the rule is violated if 3 has a vowel though.
Lion: All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other.
Giraffe: oh thats true falcon
Falcon: 'right, that''s a rule we are testing, not that it is exactly true?'
Butterfly: But it says to test that rule which means it could be wrong
Falcon: it could be an incorrect rule
Giraffe: 3,2,J,A
Butterfly: 3,2,J,A
Giraffe: if thats the case, then we need to choose all
Lion: we need to test the cards that are even numbered and have a vowel
Lion: the J and the 3 already failed
Falcon: 'I don'' think J matters. it can have any number on the back'
Giraffe: 3,2,A
Falcon: '3 hasn''t failed yet unless it has a vowel on the other side.'
Butterfly: I agree with Giraffe because J could have an even number on the other side too
Giraffe: I think they are saing the rule has to include a vowel
Lion: no 3 has failed
Falcon: 'but the rule is all cards with vowels have an even number. J isn''t a vowel so it can have an odd or even'
Butterfly: And it would bust that rule
Falcon: 'wait. we don''t have to test 2'
Butterfly: The key word is to TEST the rule
Falcon: 'doesn''t matter what is on the other side'
Giraffe: I think all but J because 3 could have a vowel on the other side
Lion: im going with testing the 2 and the A
Falcon: ok, so here is my new thought...old brain kicking in.
Lion: the J and 3 failed
Falcon: '2 doesn''t matter'
Falcon: 'J doesn''t matter'
Falcon: only the odd number and the vowel matter
Falcon: they are the only two who could violate the rule
Butterfly: I see what you are saying, Falcon.
Falcon: 'I''m talking too much, lol'
Butterfly: But I still think that it could be any of them. I chose all
Lion: but the rule says "All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other."
Falcon: Right, so we only concern ourselves with the ones that could violate the rule
Falcon: which is 3 and A
Butterfly: But we have to test that rule and the only way to do that is to turn them all over, no?
Falcon: it does NOT say all cards with even numbers have a vowel
Lion: and conversely all even numbers have vowels
Lion: on the other side
Falcon: 'nope, that''s not the rule'
Falcon: even numbers can have consonents
Falcon: consonants?
Falcon: 'i can''t spell goodly'
Lion: it doesnt say it but it has to be true
Falcon: the rule is only concerning vowels
Giraffe: I think you still should test 2,3 and A
Lion: its a card
Falcon: why does it have to be true?
Falcon: a 2 could have X on the back and the rule is still true
Lion: flip it back
Giraffe: i see what you are saing
Lion: the card still has a two on it
Lion: and an x
Lion: that violates the rule
Falcon: 'right but the rule isn''t that all even numbers have a vowel'
Lion: if you flip it back
Falcon: 'it''s all vowels have even numbers'
Falcon: 'so if there''s no vowel (x) then it can be any number, odd or even'
Lion: ok .. im going with 2 and A
Falcon: and the rule still stands
Giraffe: yeah not the all evens have vowels
Falcon: 'I''ll go with 3 and A. 3 to make sure there''s no vowel there, A to make sure there''s an even number'
Lion: no .. i see what you are saying but i dont agree
Lion: why the three?
Giraffe: to see if there is a vowel
Falcon: what giraffe said
Lion: good luck
Falcon: Ok, I think we can submit now?
Giraffe: Ok, i am 3 and A