gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Leopard,SYSTEM,Bat,Duck,Hamster&&R,U,7,4
Duck: Hello everyone
Hamster: Hello Duck
Hamster: Hey
Duck: Okay based on these cards we see and the objective
Bat: Okay the only card with a vowel is U so I picked this to see if it has an even number as the rule suggests
Leopard: 'Guess it''s 4 and U'
Duck: I think we should flip the U and 7
Hamster: I also picked 4 and U
Hamster: Even number and vowel to check
Hamster: Why 7?
Duck: understood
Bat: I think 4 and U
Duck: 7 because by the same logic you would check 4, you would also check 7 for that
Duck: right?
Bat: @ Hamster why 7
Hamster: '7 isn''t an even number'
Hamster: But I guess you could check it to see if the rule is a lie
Duck: there could be a vowel under it which would also test the rule yep
Duck: so we could do both?
Hamster: May as well cover all the bases, yeah
Bat: 'However, the rule is if it has a vowel it has an even number therefore having an even number doesn''t mean it has a vowel'
Leopard: i mean in that sense you could flip all of them
Bat: I think if we go by the rule we should just pick U
Hamster: It says to ONLY flip which ones are needed to verify the rule
Hamster: Definitely need to check at least 4 and U
Duck: that doesnt follow through logically, R has no basis on this whatsoever.
Bat: Yes, so U is the only vowel
Leopard: okay, then 4 and U
Duck: okay look, to test the rule
Duck: i say we flip all 3 of those
Duck: R is irrelevant
Bat: But do we need to do 4 as it might have a consant on the other side
Duck: its not a vowel
Hamster: 4, 7, and U? Agreed
Duck: 7 might have a vowel
Duck: 4 might have
Duck: and U is vowel.
Bat: No we should just flip U
Duck: R is irrelevant.
Bat: Agree R is irrelevant
Hamster: 'All cards with vowels have an even number, but this doesn''t mean all cards with odd numbers don''t have a vowel'
Duck: flipping it and seeing it follows the rule does not prove the rule in every case
Duck: think about that also.
Leopard: R and 7 are equally irrelevant
Duck: as odd even is 50%
Duck: No
Duck: 7 is an odd number and could have a vowel
Bat: 4 could have a consant
Duck: under no circumstance do you need to check R
Bat: It says all cards with vowels have even numbers
Leopard: if they want us to only flip cards that need to VERIFY the rule, then the only ones that visibly already adhere to the rules are 4 and U
Bat: 'It doesn''t mention anything about non vowel letters'
Hamster: They are supposed to, but if we are VERIFYING the rule, the rule could also be false/a lie, which we need to confirm
Duck: aye
Duck: but
Hamster: 'That''s a good point'
Duck: just because the one vowel has an even number
Leopard: right, and in that sense you would flip all of them to get a greater confidence
Duck: 'doesn''t mean all do'
Bat: 'Let''s vote'
Duck: R is not
Duck: relevant
Duck: its not a vowel, the rule says only for vowels.........
Bat: I guess I would check 4 and U
Hamster: Absolutely 4 and U, possibly 7 also to cover all bases
Duck: i say we check 4, U, 7 bc that odds of getting an even number is 50%
Hamster: Sounds good to me
Duck: that maximizes how sure you can be
Bat: There is not limit to how many we can check?
Duck: no mention of that
Bat: Okay so 4 U and 7
Duck: see the 7 is necessary bc it could also invalidate the rule
Hamster: No, but it suggests only, which means it is less likely we should check all 4
Leopard: so could the R
Hamster: 'It implies you don''t want to check too many/ones that are irrelvant'
Bat: I got the those three ticked off
Duck: doesnt say that
Leopard: 'It says we''re out of time?'
Duck: 4 u 7
Bat: U,7,4
Duck: submit it
Hamster: NB: Select ONLY the card(s) required to verify the rule.
Leopard: 'I''m submitting 4 and U'
Duck: SUBMIT 4 U 7
Duck: U,7,4