gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: SYSTEM,Hedgehog,Guinea pig,Duck&&X,9,U,2
Guinea pig: Hi! My thoughts on the cards were that you have to flip over 9 and U to verify the rule. Anyone come up with something different?
Hedgehog: hi i chose x
Duck: I got U and 2
Hedgehog: 'but thinking now i''m probably wrong'
Guinea pig: 'I don''t think you''d need to flip over X. X is a consonant, and the rule doesn''t say anything about what consonants can have on the other side.'
Duck: The rule only mentions vowel cards
Hedgehog: probably the 9
Hedgehog: X
Guinea pig: 'You wouldn''t need to flip over 2, because the rule says vowels have even numbers, but it doesn''t say that even numbers must have vowels.'
Duck: 9 would show either vowel (correct) or consonant (false)
Guinea pig: And U would show an even number (true) or an odd number (false)
Duck: 2 would show vowel (correct) or not
Guinea pig: 'No, it doesn''t matter what 2 has on it'
Guinea pig: The rule says vowels have even numbers, but it never states that the inverse is true
Guinea pig: 'Even numbers don''t have to have vowels on the other side'
Duck: Which card(s) means we can choose more than one
Guinea pig: Think of it like the rule that "all dogs are four legged animals"
Guinea pig: 'The rule doesn''t mean all four-legged animals are thus dogs'
Guinea pig: So it goes vowel > even number, but not necessarily even number > vowel
Guinea pig: 'So you don''t have to flip over 2 to test the rule'
Duck: Sounds sound
Guinea pig: So all you need is 9 and U
Guinea pig: 'Unless I''m missing something?'
Duck: I like 9 and U, I am going to revise my solution
Guinea pig: 'I''m going to stick with 9 and U too'
Guinea pig: Thanks for the discussion :)
Duck: What do you think Hedgehog?
Duck: See you later Guinea pig