gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Bee,SYSTEM,Cat,Raven,Narwhal&&5,2,F,E
Cat: hello
Narwhal: 'Hi all. I selected 3, the 5, E, and 2. What did y''all pick?'
Narwhal: hi all
Bee: Hi - not sure where to start so picked the odd and even number
Cat: I picked 5 and E
Raven: I picked just 5 and E
Narwhal: I also picked "E" because you have to check if the other side is even
Narwhal: 'And I also picked 2 because you don''t know what''s on the other side'
Raven: seems like you could pick any two
Narwhal: If you want you can pick all 4
Bee: can it be done with just 1 card?
Raven: or just one and see if it contradicts the rule
Raven: yeah
Narwhal: The questions is we have to pick "ONLY" the card(s) required to verify the rule.
Narwhal: But you need to flip "2" to confirm it is a vowel or not
Cat: Remember, the rule is that cards with a vowel on one side have an even on the other side
Bee: would it then be either the 5 & 2 or the F &E
Raven: there could be three that abide by the rule and only that contradicts it
Raven: only one*
Cat: ie. if vowel, then even. We do not need to check the other way (that an even card has a vowel on the other side)
Narwhal: 'actually we don''t need to flip "5" because it is an odd number. So maybe we don''t need it?'
Raven: it could have a vowel, tho
Bee: so by the rule, consonants can have either a odd or even, so would have to be the vowel to prove it..
Narwhal: So the answer should be 5 and E?
Cat: i think so
Narwhal: Ok I think I see the logic in that
Raven: 'that''s what I went with, but I think it''s a trick question'
Narwhal: Trick in what way?
Bee: why not just E
Raven: 'that either there''s multiple answers or no answer'
Raven: well, flip them all
Bee: a vowel can only be even, but a consonant can technically be anything, correct?
Narwhal: Because you need to confirm if "5" has a vowel. If it is then the theory is wrong
Narwhal: 'F you don''t care because it is a consonant'
Narwhal: so the question is either the other 3 or just 5 and E.
Narwhal: You saw the argument against the 2 above
Raven: ok. all cards with vowels. narrows it down to E
Narwhal: And 5
Raven: 'but it''s not a vowel'
Narwhal: You have to flip it over to confirm the rule.
Raven: 'so it doesn''t matter.'
Raven: only card that is a vowel is E
Narwhal: 'No, you have to prove the rule. You don''t know what is on the other side of 5. If it is a vowel it disproves the rule.'
Bee: 'because the rule needs to be proven, need to flip two cards, i''m okay with E & 5'
Cat: I agree with Bee. Those two cards should prove the rule
Raven: 5,E
Narwhal: I revised my answer to just E and 5 as well