gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Lion,Raven,SYSTEM,Narwhal&&3,4,F,E
Narwhal: 'Hey, guys. I think you definitely need to turn over the 3 to make sure there''s not a vowel on the back'
Lion: 'i think the best choice would be to select the vowel and even number cards. the word ''always'' in the task description leads me to think that if either of these cards prove incorrect then there goes the rule right there.'
Raven: 'I just chose E; since that''s a vowel. This means it should only need to be tested with one card?'
Raven: ah, yeah.
Narwhal: No, because vowels OR consanants can have an even number on the other side
Lion: 'the rule doesn''t say that cards with odd numbers can;t have a vowel on the other side either, though.'
Raven: oh, right.
Narwhal: 'We''re trying to disprove the rule to prove it'
Lion: but we are not trying to rule out that a card with an od number could have a vowel on the otherr side.
Narwhal: 'If we turn over the 3 and there''s a vowel, we''ve proven it wrong right away'
Narwhal: 'Or if there''s an odd number behind the E'
Raven: But is that alone enough to prove it?
Narwhal: So both of those two
Lion: 'the rule diesn''t state that a card with an odd number-3 in this case-can''t have an ebven number, though.'
Lion: it only states that a vowel has an even number.
Narwhal: Are you saying there could be a number on both sides?
Lion: we need to limit it to the 2 cards that fit this rule, the vowel (e) and even number card (4).
Lion: 'i am saying that the rule doesn''t say that an odd number card might also have a vowel on the other side. so the f and the 3 are irerelevant to the task we are assigned to.'
Raven: With understanding the rule; "All" should imply every single one, right?
Narwhal: No, if there is a vowel on the other side of the 3, the rule is invalid
Narwhal: ALL CARDS with vowels MUST have an even number on the other side
Lion: it says nothing about odd numbers. we are not trying to prove that this could be a possible rule as well.
Narwhal: 'The 4 is irrelevant, because it could have a vowel or consanant and it wouldn''t prove anything'
Raven: That also seems to make sense...
Lion: the rule specifically mentions vowels and even numbers. those are the only cards we need to investigate to prove the theory or debunk it.
Narwhal: 'I''m sorry, but you are incorrect.'
Lion: 'i disagree but that is fine. we don''t have to agree do we?'
Narwhal: 'No, but we also can''t both be right'
Raven: 'I think I''m going with just E. Thanks y''all.'
Narwhal: 'It doesn''t matter what''s on the other side of the 4'
Lion: 'i certaintly don''t want to be pushy or discredit anuone else. i weill just go with my choice.'
Lion: if the 4 has a vowel on the other side we know it is true
Narwhal: 'NO. That is only one card. The 4 could also have a consanant on the other side, and that would prove nothing because we don''t have a rule for consanants'
Narwhal: We only need to know where the vowels are
Narwhal: Even numbers CAN be on either, but they MUST be on vowels
Narwhal: 'You need to see if there''s a vowel on the other side of the 3. It''s imperative.'