gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Lion,Lobster,SYSTEM,Bat,Cat&&E,2,5,J
Lion: Hi, did everyone turn the last 2 cards?
Bat: The rule is: all cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other, so the only card that needs to be checked is the one vowel card.
Lobster: I think that only the cards with the 2 and the E are relevant to test the rule.
Lion: Right, the first 2 cards are applicable
Bat: 'The 2 does not need to be turned. The rule doesn''t say that even numbers have a vowel on the other side.'
Lobster: If we turn the 2, we can see if it has a vowel, which would further test the rule
Bat: It only says vowels have even numbers. Even numbers could possibly have consonants on the other side.
Cat: This is true, if you want to test the actual rule, you have to flip the first two
Bat: 'No it wouldn''t. It doesn''t say, even numbers only have vowels, it says vowels have even numbers.'
Lobster: And vice versa. Both apply to the rule.
Lion: 'That''s why I flipped the last 2 cards, for the first 2 cards to follow the rule'
Bat: If we needed to turn over the 2, it would say even nyumbers only have vowels.
Lobster: It does say vowels have an even number. That would also mean even numbers would have vowels.
Cat: The problem is that it could
Bat: 'We don''t need to turn the five because it is odd and that would not tell us anything about a vowel card.'
Lobster: 'We can''t be certain the rule is always true either way, but only the first two cards matter in this case.'
Bat: The only card that matters is E.
Lion: The first 2 cards matter
Bat: 'If the first card mattered, it would say only even numv=bers have vowels on the other side but it doesn''t.'
Cat: All vowel cards have an even number on them, so the opposite also applies
Lobster: If the first card has a vowel, that would be a test of the rule.
Lion: Which cards have you turned?
Lobster: Has anyone revised their rule?
Lobster: I have the first two checked.
Lion: Same, first two checked, and I turned the last 2
Cat: First two checked
Lion: If you checked the first two, then we only see 5 and J
Lion: 'I''ve checked the last 2, so I only see 2 and E to follow the rule'
Lion: 5,J
Lobster: 'I think checking means those are the ones you want to see. That''s how they are selected.'
Cat: I also thought that