gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Zebra,Lobster,SYSTEM,Cat,Chipmunk&&E,7,6,Z
Chipmunk: Hello all
Zebra: hello.
Cat: Hi everyone!
Zebra: pretty straightforward, right?
Cat: I think so!
Lobster: Feels like it
Chipmunk: 6 is the answer correct?
Zebra: no. it would be E
Cat: I think E and 6 actually
Cat: It says you can select more than one answer
Zebra: 6 is incorrect. it does not state that it is reciprocal
Chipmunk: I think Cat is correct
Zebra: have vowel/have even. not have even/have vowel
Lobster: It does feel like E would be the choice
Chipmunk: E,6
Lobster: 'Because it''s only stating "all cards with vowels"'
Zebra: yes, E.
Cat: 'But wouldn''t you want to see if there was a vowel on the other side of 6?'
Chipmunk: All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other.
Cat: OK
Zebra: 'it doesn''t matter. it doesn''t say all evven numbers have a vowel on the other side.'
Chipmunk: Vowel even/Even vowel
Lobster: In real life, yes but this is just making a definitive statement about cards with vowels
Lobster: in this scenario
Cat: Ok, I can see your point
Chipmunk: Even number cards have a vowel as the letter on the other side of the card
Zebra: it doesn not say that
Cat: Right, but his point is that it actually only specifies what is on the other side of a vowel card
Cat: An even number card might have different rules
Chipmunk: Cards with the a Vowel letter have a even number
Lobster: 'That makes sense, but I think that''s the point of this exercise is to get us talking about his specifically'
Lobster: *this
Cat: It only tells us what the rule is for vowels.
Chipmunk: Only one rule....vowels on one side have an even number on the other
Chipmunk: and to test the theory you have to turn both E and 6
Zebra: 'no you don''t. only E'
Zebra: it does NOT say even number cards have only vowels on the other side
Cat: 'That was my initial thought too, but I can see Zebra''s point that the only thing we know for sure is vowel cards have an even number'
Cat: 'We don''t know the rule for even numbers'
Zebra: 'it''s a classic logic game'
Chipmunk: If you only do E how do you know if all even number cards have vowels?
Cat: Even numbers might have a rule that says it will be either vowels OR consonants
Zebra: 'all number cards don''t HAVE to have vowels'
Cat: 'You don''t, that''s the point. It doesn''t tell us that in the rule'
Chipmunk: So no matter how many rules you would still need to turn both cards to test the theory
Zebra: 'no. you don''t'
Cat: That having been said, I think an argument could be made to flip them both. But to test the actual rule, we only NEED to flip E.
Chipmunk: I can go with that
Zebra: okay, all choose E and get that sweet bonus?
Cat: 'Let''s do it!'
Chipmunk: Agreed
Chipmunk: Have a good day everyone