gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Llama,SYSTEM,Bat,Falcon,Cat&&2,7,V,A
Falcon: 'I selected only the A, since that''s the only vowel we see.'
Bat: flipping the A will show us if vowels have an even number and flipping the 7 should show us a consonant since it is an odd number
Cat: A is only vowel
Llama: I had A and 2
Falcon: 'We don''t have a rule that all odd numbers have consonants on the other side, though.'
Falcon: 'And we don''t know that every even number goes with a vowel (just vice versa).'
Bat: even number and vowel? no.
Bat: All cards with vowels have an even number
Falcon: 'But it''s possible that some consonants also have evens, right?'
Cat: All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other.  to test this i feel selecting the card with A is appropriate
Falcon: I agree with @Cat
Bat: 'yes A has to be one but that only proves vowels and odd numbers it doesn''t tell us that evens have consonants. I don''t think we can know for certain only flipping one card'
Falcon: 'It doesn''t say we have to figure out all the rules, though, just prove the one rule we were given... Hm...'
Bat: 'yes but just flipping the A only proves that the A card has an even number. the task says ALL cards with vowels have an even number so we''d probably need to flip the 2 card as well'
Falcon: 'If we flipped the 2 and it had a consonant on the other side, that wouldn''t disprove the rule we received, as far as I can tell. Consonants might have odds OR evens, but that doesn''t affect the separate rule that vowels MUST have evens.  Right?'
Bat: 'otherwise by flipping only the A we only know about the A we don''t know that ALL cards with a vowel have an even number. all we know is A we don''t know E I O U'
Falcon: 'I see what you''re saying, Bat.  Hm... I guess if we looked at it your way we''d need to flip A, 2, and 7 (to make sure 7 didn''t have a vowel?).'
Llama: So are we going with A and 2?
Bat: 'yeah it''s not easy since we have 5 vowels reaching 100% certainty is difficult'
Bat: I think A 2 or A 7 is the bare minimum
Bat: 'I don''t think flipping only 1 card really tells us much'
Bat: 'it can tell us about that one card but it won''t result in being able to eliminate any other options'
Falcon: 'Now I''m thinking A, 2 & 7 if you wanted to be 100% sure.  Because if you flipped A & 2 and it proved the rule, 7 could still have a vowel lurking behind it.'
Bat: 'I think you''re on to something with that Falcon'
Bat: 'this way we''ve nailed down the vowels with the A and 2 and the consonants with the 7'
Falcon: 'I''m going with that.'
Llama: Ok sounds good
Falcon: 'Do we need to reach an anonymous decision? I don''t think so...?'
Falcon: 2,7,A
Bat: 2,7,A
Llama: 2,7,A
Bat: 'unanimous? no I don''t think so'
Bat: I think the only requirement was to click on submit game if your choices changed from the initial choice to your choice during this discussion
Bat: 'then when we''ve come to a conclusion make sure you have your proper cards selected and hit the final decision'