gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Butterfly,Ox,Dolphin,Lobster,SYSTEM&&E,2,9,D
Lobster: Hi.
Butterfly: hi!
Butterfly: how do we know if we all got the same solution?
Dolphin: I went with the 9 and E cards. My logic was, that we need to make sure a vowel isnt on 9 and confirm that an even number is on the opposite of E.
Lobster: We need to test the 9 because if there is a vowel on the other side, the rule fails. We also need to test E.
Butterfly: I picked 2 and E, because 2 already had an even number and is already a vowel.
Ox: i pick 2 and E for the same reason as butterfly
Butterfly: 'in theory as long as we''ve tested 2 or E, we will be fine, right?'
Dolphin: 'It doesn''t really matter if 2 is a vowel or not. If it is, it follows the rule, if it isnt it still doesnt break the rule necc'
Lobster: '2 doesn''t help because it does not validate the rule regardless of what is on the other side.'
Ox: if the other side of 9 is not vowel?
Butterfly: 'wouldn''t it though? like if it isn''t a vowel doesn''t that disprove the rule?'
Butterfly: E,2,9
Dolphin: A vowel on 9 and an odd on E are the only two ways to break the rule. So those are the two to check the way I see it
Lobster: Definitely need to test 9 because if there is a vowel it disproves the rule. Test E as well.
Dolphin: Perhaps we have diff rules. Mine is "vowels have even"
Butterfly: ok, can we only test two cards or can we test three?
Butterfly: yeah mine is vowels have even too
Dolphin: can test as many as you want. But the question is what are the "only" ones you need to
Ox: the other side of 2 is not necessary vowel?
Lobster: You have to try to find what disproves the rule.
Dolphin: It doesnt matter if it is or not. It cant break the rule
Dolphin: The rule doesnt say that consonants cant have even, just that vowels must
Lobster: 'You don''t need to prove the rule. That doesn''t help,'
Butterfly: 'I think in the end as long as we test one of the cards that''s either even or a vowel we have our answer.'
Butterfly: 'so for example, if 2 doesn''t have a vowel on the other side, the rule is incorrect'
Butterfly: 2
Dolphin: 'No, read my last message. It doesn''t say even must be vowel, just vowel must be even'
Butterfly: 'but wouldn''t the reverse also be true?'
Butterfly: 'but the same card that has a vowel on one side or whatever is the same card that would have the inverse -- if it was flipped over to a different side than the one we can see, it''s still the same card'
Ox: 'It doesn''t say even must be vowel, just vowel must be even'