gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: SYSTEM,Chipmunk,Beaver,Giraffe&&5,8,V,A
Giraffe: Hello
Beaver: I think the answer is every card other than V
Giraffe: Why is that?
Chipmunk: 'It''s only A and 5'
Beaver: All cards with vowels have an even number
Beaver: So V is already out
Giraffe: I went with A and 5 as well.
Beaver: What happens if 8 has a vowel on the other side?
Chipmunk: 'Yes.  It doesn''t matter what''s on the other side of the 8 or the V.'
Beaver: 'It does matter what''s on the other side of 8'
Beaver: We are testing the rule
Chipmunk: 'It doesn''t say that all even numbers have a vowel on the other side'
Chipmunk: 'Same with the V.  Flipping it wouldn''t prove anything'
Beaver: I agree with V
Beaver: What if there is a vowel on the other side of 8
Giraffe: I thought we should only test the vowels since it was a condition mentioned.
Chipmunk: 'It doesn''t matter'
Beaver: That would disprove what we are testing, correct?
Chipmunk: 'If 8 is not a vowel, it wouldn''t matter.'
Chipmunk: The rule is that all vowels have an even number on the other side.
Beaver: And we are supposed to test that rule
Chipmunk: 'If V had an even number, it also wouldn''t matter'
Beaver: I agree on V
Beaver: But we need to flip 8
Chipmunk: The only two cards necessary are the A and the 5.
Chipmunk: If the A is an odd number, it would disprove the rule.
Beaver: Sure
Chipmunk: If the 5 is a vowel, it would also disprove the rule.
Giraffe: I agree we only need to test the rules mentioned.
Chipmunk: The other two would do nothing.
Chipmunk: 'It doesn''t matter what''s on the other side of the 8 or the V.'
Beaver: It absolutely matters what is on the 8
Chipmunk: How?
Giraffe: Why?
Beaver: 'Because if it''s a vowel, it disproves the rule that we are supposed to be testing'
Beaver: 'The V is irrelevant because we already know it''s not a vowel so it''s not part of the rule'
Chipmunk: All vowels have an even number on the other side.
Beaver: We are supposed to test the rule
Chipmunk: 8 is an even number.
Chipmunk: 'If it''s a vowel, it confirms the rule.  If ot'
Chipmunk: 'If it''s not a vowel, it means nothing.'
Beaver: 'If it''s not a vowel, then the rule is disproven'
Chipmunk: No.
Beaver: Lol
Chipmunk: 'The rule doesn''t apply to non-vowels.'
Giraffe: We already know 8 is a vowel though.
Chipmunk: 'It says simply if it''s a vowel.'
Beaver: 'We don''t know that 8 is a vowel'
Beaver: Because the rule is being tested
Beaver: 'You are taking it as a point of fact and that''s not the purpose of this exercise'
Chipmunk: 'Suppose we flip the V and it''s an even number.  Would that matter?'
Beaver: 'Flipping V wouldn''t matter at all'
Beaver: Nothing has been mentioned about non-vowels
Chipmunk: 'If it''s even or odd, it wouldn''t matter.  Same with the 8.  Whatever the letter is, it doesn''t matter.'
Beaver: 'Ok I''m submitting my hit. Best of luck.'
Chipmunk: Same here.
Beaver: 5,8,A
Giraffe: 5,A
Chipmunk: 5,A