gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Puffin,SYSTEM,Beaver,Hamster,Alpaca&&7,T,A,4
Puffin: hello
Beaver: Hey everyone
Puffin: i chose all cards except the last one (T)
Beaver: I selected A and 4
Hamster: i selected A and 4 as well
Puffin: 7 should be selected, because if it has a vowel on the other side, it would invalidate the rule
Alpaca: Hi, nice to meet you. I think we need to test the hypothesis by checking the vowel (A card) and the even number card (number 4 card)
Hamster: I think that is the answer because neither T nor 7 are even numbers or vowels so who cars
Hamster: cares
Alpaca: great! We seem to agree pretty well
Beaver: Yes
Puffin: i think 7 should be selected as well
Alpaca: why 7? Are you testing for false results?
Puffin: yeah. if there is a vowel on the other side of 7, then the rule could be false
Hamster: i dont think you need the 7 card
Puffin: it would be a card with a vowel and an odd number
Alpaca: I can see a lot of merit in that. But we are supposed to minimize the cards we turn over
Alpaca: so I would still recommend the A and 4 cards alone I guess
Hamster: if you pick 7 you may as well pick T too
Alpaca: We succeed by submitting as few cards as possible to verify the rule
Puffin: 'i don''t think so - there is no vowel on the T card'
Beaver: I think T might be a good one to turn as well
Hamster: but there could be a even number on the other side of it invalidating the rule
Puffin: no because the rule only applies to vowels
Hamster: but I think A and 4 are enough to figure it out
Alpaca: A would test the vowel portion and 4 would test the even number portion
Puffin: All cards with vowels on one side - so we can exclude T. but the rest of the cards need to be checked to make sure the rule holds true for all of them
Beaver: The rule applies to vowels not consonants
Puffin: because there could be a vowel on the other side of 7
Alpaca: Turning over A would solve the vowel issue
Puffin: for that specific card - not all of them
Beaver: Exactly. I think we should flip 7, A, and 4
Alpaca: I see what you mean now
Beaver: Those would all have to match the rule
Puffin: if there is a vowel on the other side of the 7, then the rule "All cards with vowels on one side" is FALSE
Puffin: meaning we have to flip the 7
Beaver: 7,A,4
Puffin: on one side have an even number**
Hamster: I am going with A and 4 good bye
Alpaca: okay, A and 4 for me, too
Hamster: A,4
Beaver: Wait in this case does 4 even need to be turned??
Alpaca: Not sure. I was wondering the same thing
Puffin: 'oh you''re right'
Puffin: 'it doesn''t'
Alpaca: 4 must be turned to check the even number part
Puffin: 'because if it''s a vowel, it confirms. if it''s not a vowel, then it''s irrelevant'
Alpaca: right
Beaver: If it is a vowel then we already know its a 4 if it is a consonant it doesnt matter what the number is
Puffin: so only 7 and A
Alpaca: no, 4 and A I think
Beaver: I think it is 7 and A
Alpaca: why 7,that is an odd number?
Beaver: If it is a vowel on the other side then the rule is FALSE
Puffin: because if there is a vowel on the other side of the 7, it invalidates the rule
Puffin: so we must flip to check
Alpaca: only we would still need to turn 4 to validate it also?
Puffin: 'no because we can assume it''s a vowel. if it''s a consonant, it is irrelevant'
Beaver: exactly
Puffin: 'it can either confirm the rule or be irrelevant. but it can''t refute the rule so we gain no knowledge from flipping it'
Alpaca: 'oh, so you''re arguing for A and 7?'
Puffin: yeah, A and 7 looks to be right
Beaver: Well put, Puffin
Beaver: Yup I think its A and & too
Beaver: *7
Puffin: 'i''m going to submit'
Beaver: Same
Alpaca: 'I see your point, except we don''t know if 4 has a vowel without checking'
Beaver: 'We don''t need to know if it is a vowel or not'
Alpaca: why
Alpaca: because of the A?
Beaver: Say we flip it and it is a consonant. It tells us nothing because the rule does not apply to consonants. if we flip it and it is a vowel then it confirms the rule
Beaver: But we would already be confirming the rule with the other 2 cards
Alpaca: so which ones do you recommend?
Beaver: I will be submitting 7 and A
Alpaca: True and false checks then?
Alpaca: T,A,4
Alpaca: sounds good me too