gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Hedgehog,Leopard,Unicorn,SYSTEM,Raven&&W,8,E,9
Leopard: is it the 8
Hedgehog: I think that the E and the 9 should be selected
Raven: I went with the 8 and E
Unicorn: its the E and the 8
Leopard: W,9
Leopard: E,8
Unicorn: a vowel and and an even number
Raven: My reasoning was it only wants even numbers and vowels that excludes the W and the 9 automatically
Hedgehog: 'The 8 doesn''t need to be selected because there''s no requirement that if there''s a consonant on one side that there CAN''T be an even number on the other'
Raven: 'Yea but we''re trying to prove out the rule, so we need to verify the cards that we think are part of it'
Leopard: 8 has a vowel on the other side
Hedgehog: 'The 9 needs to be selected because if there''s a vowel on the other side then it disproves the rule'
Raven: right now we think the 8 has a vowel, and the E has an even number
Leopard: e has an even number on the other side
Raven: hrm Hedgehog is right.  We might need to do all 4 cards then
Unicorn: 9 might be right also for the reason stated by Hedgehog
Hedgehog: No, you need to prove the rule by confirming that cards neither violate the rule or are consistent with it
Raven: 'we''re not just proving cards that follow the rule, we''re ensuring the rule itself is being followed'
Leopard: 9 and w we dont know whats on the other side
Hedgehog: 9 and E are the answers
Leopard: 8 and e we do
Hedgehog: Not 8.
Raven: what if the 8 has a non-vowel letter
Unicorn: nothing states the 8 wont have a consonant instead of a vowel
Hedgehog: 'All cards with vowels on one side..... This says nothing of consonants.  Who cares what''s on the other side of the 8?'
Leopard: but if all cards with vowels have an even number on the other side
Raven: yea.  All 4 cards are part of it
Leopard: then we know the 8 has a vowel on the other side
Hedgehog: 9 and E are the answers.
Leopard: or else it wouldnt have an 8 showing
Hedgehog: 'We don''t KNOW what''s on the other side of any card'
Unicorn: all vowels have an even number, that doesnt mean all even numbers have vowels.
Hedgehog: 'That''s what we''re trying to test, Leopard'
Raven: 'We don''t, so we need to verify all 4 cards.'
Hedgehog: 9 and E are the answer>  Nothing else.
Unicorn: I agree with that
Hedgehog: 'We don''t need to verify all cards if cards can''t violate the rule.  W and 8 can''t violate the rule'
Hedgehog: 9 and E are the answer.
Raven: So if you turn the W card and you get a 4 the rule is broken
Hedgehog: No
Unicorn: Yeah I think so as well, because w and 8 wont give us any information we need.
Hedgehog: Yes Unicorn.  No Raven
Hedgehog: E and 9. Trust me or be wrong.
Raven: 'Oh okay.  Now I see what you''re saying.'
Unicorn: The w could have any number it wouldnt matter, it wouldnt break the rule
Raven: 'Go with Hedgehog''s answer.'
Raven: E,9