gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Emu,SYSTEM,Falcon,Narwhal,Hamster&&E,X,5,4
Falcon: hey guys! i originally checked both the E and 4 cards but I think the only true card we can test is the E
Hamster: ans please?
Narwhal: I think the 4 tests the same claim
Falcon: I think the answer is just the E card
Emu: Im thinking 5 and 4
Falcon: 'It''s the only vowel'
Falcon: We need to turn the vowel card over to see if there is an even number
Hamster: E&4
Narwhal: 'i think that''s right'
Falcon: But there is no point in turning the 4, becuase not ALL even numbers have to have a vowel
Falcon: So I am saying just E
Narwhal: 'it doesn''t matter if other cards have even numbers'
Narwhal: on the other side
Falcon: Right, just the E
Narwhal: yes I agree
Falcon: oh
Falcon: BUT
Emu: But it says all carde with even # have a vowel
Narwhal: 'it doesn''t say only'
Falcon: emu, not all even numbers have vowels, just all vowels have even numbers
Falcon: 'i''m actually thinking we need to turn the 5'
Falcon: because if there is a vowel on the other side, then the rule is wrong
Hamster: final ans tell me
Falcon: 'I''m going E & 5'
Narwhal: yeah, e and 5 sound good
Hamster: E,5
Falcon: E & 5 it is
Emu: lets go for it
Narwhal: thank you!
Falcon: any other ideas before final submission?
Falcon: they want us to chat for at least 5 minutes
Narwhal: ok
Narwhal: 'let''s go over the case for each card'
Falcon: hamster, 4 will not prove anything
Emu: yesnarwhal idea
Narwhal: flipping E will test the claim directly: "All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other."
Falcon: correct
Narwhal: flipping X is meaningless
Falcon: 'x will not prove anything, because it''s allowed to have either even or odd'
Falcon: 5 will also test the rule directly, if flipping 5 reveals a vowel, we know the rule is wrong
Narwhal: flipping 5 will test if there is a vowel on the other side, which would disprove it
Hamster: all are final ans tell me once
Falcon: and flipping 4 would prove nothing
Falcon: SO
Narwhal: 4 could have any letter on it, which is allowable by: "All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other."
Falcon: that leaves E & 5
Narwhal: very strong case for E & 5
Emu: I checked 5 but it doesnt flip
Falcon: well its not going to flip
Falcon: we have to click final decision and submit hit
Falcon: 'do you think we''ve chatted enough to receive credit at this point?'
Hamster: i think E&4
Falcon: 'i feel pretty good about where we''ve arrived'
Falcon: 'hamster you can go e& 4 but I''m 95% sure it''s E & 5'
Narwhal: E,5
Falcon: I think narwhal agrees with me
Falcon: 'I''m going to go ahead and submit'
Falcon: good luck you guys
Emu: I have e and five