gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Raven,SYSTEM,Hedgehog,Puffin&&E,7,M,4
Raven: I picked the card with the E
Hedgehog: Hi everyone!
Raven: 'Hey what''s up?'
Raven: Which card did you decide to turn?
Puffin: 4 E 7
Hedgehog: I picked the 4 card and the E.
Hedgehog: Since 4 is even and E is a vowel.
Puffin: '7 we don''t know if a vowel is on the other side, if there is it would prove the rule was false.'
Raven: Well the rule is All cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other.
Raven: But not necessarily
Raven: All cards with an even number have a vowel on the other side.
Raven: Right?
Puffin: We need to test the rule, so we have to check for proof of the opposite as well
Raven: But the opposite is not a rule
Puffin: M is irrelevent since we know it has no vowel.
Raven: That I agree with.
Puffin: 'You can''t test the rule if you only test for it to be true.'
Puffin: You also have to test if it is false.
Puffin: If there is a vowel opposite seven, it shows the rule is not correct and fails the test.
Hedgehog: @Puffin, if that were the case, the M would be relevant as a test for it being false
Puffin: M is not relevent as the rule applies only to vowels. M is not a vowel.
Hedgehog: Because there could be an even number on the other side
Puffin: The gives no relationship to consonants and numbers.
Puffin: E,7,4
Raven: The question is, do we think
Raven: All cards with even numbers on one side have vowels on the other
Raven: Is a rule
Raven: I do not as it is not stated as a rule
Hedgehog: '@Raven, it''s stated as being a rule'
Hedgehog: to test the rule
Hedgehog: 'so to me, that tells me that it''s certain that all cards with vowels on one side have an even number on the other.'
Raven: 'OK, I''ll buy that.'
Hedgehog: hmm wait a second. maybe puffin is onto something
Hedgehog: 'okay so let''s say the rule is absolute, that would mean that it''s for certain that 4 and E are definitely in with the rule right?'
Hedgehog: 'so Puffin''s idea about disproving, would essentially prove the correctness of the statement.'
Raven: So we need the even number and the vowel.
Raven: Is the only way to falsify the rule.
Hedgehog: 'So let''s say that the 7 card has an A behind it, that would falsify the rule'
Puffin: Correct.
Raven: E,4
Hedgehog: And what about M?
Hedgehog: Because that could have a 2 or something behind it
Puffin: M is not in play, because it has now vowel.
Puffin: The rule is not
Hedgehog: 'ah that''s right. goodness.'
Hedgehog: brain slip. sorry about that lol
Puffin: THe rule is not that every even number has a vowel
Puffin: consonants having an even number does not break the rule
Raven: I am gonna go with E and 7. Good luck to you all.
Raven: E,7
Hedgehog: yes, I know i was focused on thinking about even numbers
Hedgehog: in that moment
Hedgehog: E,7,4
Hedgehog: I agree with 4, E, 7
Puffin: One sec
Puffin: lets consider 4.
Puffin: If it has a consonants it proves nothing...
Puffin: If it has a vowel, does it prove anything?
Puffin: I think not.
Puffin: I am going E 7
Hedgehog: hmmm
Hedgehog: well based on the statement, it basically verifies that 4 is correct, and the same with e
Hedgehog: according to the rule, we would already know that 4 has a vowel on the other side, and E has an even number on the other side
Puffin: 'But we are ''testing'' the rule to see if it is true.'
Hedgehog: 'now I''m not so sure about the 7. here''s why.'
Hedgehog: so the rule is that the cards have to have a vowel on one side and an even number on the other, right?
Hedgehog: the directions say to "verify" the "rule"
Hedgehog: 'it doesn''t say to disprove it, it says to verify it'
Puffin: 'mine says ''test the rule''.'
Hedgehog: 'so if we already know that 4 would/should have a vowel on the other side, and E would/should have an even number on the other, I''m thinking that those would be the two needed to verify it'
Hedgehog: It does? right above the cards?
Puffin: 'I think we interpret the instructions differently. I say we go ahead and submit as we interpret them. We don''t have to submit the same.'
Hedgehog: @Raven, what does yours say?
Hedgehog: 'I wonder if that''s part of this though. That one single word, since mine says "verify" and yours said "test." To me, that means two different things.'
Puffin: 'We are 20 minutes in, let''s just go with what we each think'
Hedgehog: Okay, nice chatting with you!
Puffin: hopefully it tells us the correct answer when we submit :)
Hedgehog: I hope so!
Puffin: E,7
Hedgehog: Have a good day!