gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Emu,Unicorn,Kiwi,Dolphin,SYSTEM,Beaver,Duck&&3,4,A,D
Unicorn: Hello! So what are everyones thoughts here?
Dolphin: A,4
Emu: Hello
Kiwi: Hello
Beaver: which cards did you guys select
Kiwi: I chose the vowel card
Emu: I chose 4 and A
Dolphin: I choose 4 and A
Unicorn: I chose A and 3
Duck: Hey. My assumption is to only turn over the even and vowels as those are the only cards in questions.
Unicorn: 'But we''re also trying to prove the statement isn''t false'
Kiwi: and the 4 card
Emu: 'That was my assumption but I see Unicorn''s point'
Unicorn: A and 4 would only confirm that answer, not disprove it
Kiwi: makes sense
Dolphin: I thought same way as Duck did
Beaver: I chose 3 cards just to verify with the third one
Duck: 'Yes A and 4 can prove that. Turning over anything else doesn''t prove or disprove the statement'
Emu: I do think that Unicorn has a point that we need to disprove as well
Unicorn: 'That''s wrong, Duck'
Kiwi: 3 sounds good too
Dolphin: If you need to disapprove too then wouldnt we have to check all 4 then
Unicorn: No, we would only need one
Beaver: good point Dolphin
Unicorn: 'D isn''t a vowel so we wouldn''t care about it'
Emu: I see how A and 3 make sense
Duck: It says l cards with a vowel on oneside have an even number on the other.
Kiwi: hmm A and three makes the most sense to me
Duck: 'We don''t care what odd numbers or consonants have'
Dolphin: starting lean 4, a, 3
Duck: We only care about even numbers and vowels
Unicorn: No, we are trying to test the rule
Emu: Do we need to choose the three cards or just the A and 3
Unicorn: 'How do we know 3 doesn''t have a vowel on the other side?'
Beaver: 3,A,4
Duck: We omly need 2
Emu: I think A and 3 fit best to test the rule
Unicorn: I think so too
Duck: 'Turning over anything with a consonant or an odd number doesn''t test the rule'
Unicorn: But it does
Duck: 'It doesn''t state anything else can''t have an odd number of consonant'
Duck: There is no inverse statement
Unicorn: 'So how do you know 3 isn''t a vowel on the inverse, thus invalidating the rule?'
Dolphin: We need to turn 4 though to make sure a vowel is on the other side
Emu: 'I agree you have to verify that 3 doesn''t have a vowel on it.'
Unicorn: 'If you only look at A and 4, you can''t confirm the rule is correct'
Duck: 'Verifying 3 doesn''t have a vowel doesn''t prove the statement'
Unicorn: It could disprove the statement
Emu: It could prove that the statement is wrong
Kiwi: 'wait, to test rule you have to choose A, and then 4.If 4 doesn''t have a vowel on the other side...'
Unicorn: 'We are testing that by flipping A to see if it''s even'
Kiwi: 'we don''t care about D or 3'
Duck: 'According to the statement consoants can have either even or odd. We don''t care'
Duck: Vowels must have even
Unicorn: 'And how do you know that if you don''t flip 3'
Emu: I am going with what Unicorn said A and 3.  I think that A would verify and then 3 could prove that it is wrong.
Duck: 'The 3 isn''t even'
Unicorn: Exactly
Duck: So it proves nothing
Unicorn: 'So if you flip it and it''s a vowel'
Unicorn: The rule is wrong
Emu: 3,A
Kiwi: if you flip 4 and A and there are not an even number or a vowel, rule is wrong.
Duck: I agree that A and 4 are the only ones needed
Dolphin: The rule just mention even and vowels as well
Unicorn: 'But the rule doesn''t say that'
Unicorn: 'The rule says if there is a vowel on one side, there''s an even number on the other'
Unicorn: 'It doesn''t say evens have to be vowels'
Duck: 'You''re not proving everything else wrong. You are proving tgis statement right'
Unicorn: It says all vowels are even, but NOT that all evens are vowels
Unicorn: Flipping the 4 proves nothing
Unicorn: 'It''s irrelevant'
Unicorn: A and 3
Duck: 3 is irrelevant. Then just the A to compromise
Unicorn: No, it is not
Unicorn: If you flip 3 and it is a vowel, the rule is broken
Unicorn: Because all vowels are even per the rule
Duck: But why do you have to prove the inverse
Unicorn: You are proving that all vowels are even
Unicorn: 'If 3 is a vowel, the rule isn''t true'
Kiwi: 4 A
Unicorn: 4 is irrelevant
Duck: 'Doesn''t sound like there is a consensus'
Unicorn: 'Let''s explain this simply'
Unicorn: The rule is: All vowels are even
Kiwi: do we have to come to a consensus?
Unicorn: Obviously we need to flip A
Unicorn: Flipping 4 does nothing to the rule
Unicorn: 'If we flip 3 and it''s a vowel, the rule is wrong'
Kiwi: we need to verify that even 4 has a vowel
Duck: And if 3 is a consonant what does it prove
Unicorn: 'No we don''t'
Unicorn: It proves that the rule still stands
Unicorn: 'Until you flip it, you can''t say with certainty that all vowels are even'
Kiwi: A,4
Duck: 'I don''t agree that just because you don''t tyrn over everything to disprove something doesn''t mean it isn''t true'
Unicorn: 'You can''t definitively say it''s true'
Unicorn: 'Because you don''t know if the 3 is a vowel or consonant'
Duck: Even if both follow the rule you cannot say its true
Unicorn: Yes you can
Unicorn: Based on the sample
Duck: You just know these 2 followed the rule
Unicorn: 'That''s all that matters'
Kiwi: 'I don''t believe we have to have the same answers. We just have to discuss for at least five minutes. I am going with A 4 and submitting mine now.'
Unicorn: A 3 is correct
Unicorn: Just FYI