gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Ox,Hamster,Lion,Lobster,SYSTEM,Guinea pig&&3,U,8,J
Ox: U
Guinea pig: hello
Lion: hey
Ox: U,J
Lobster: Hi all. So U is a vowel and 8 is an even number so either of those cards should work.
Guinea pig: yep
Lion: 'no it''s either 3 or J'
Lion: 'since if you do U or 8 and you get an even number or vowel, respectively, you don''t discover anything new'
Lion: 'you''re looking to disprove the rule'
Hamster: The way they worded the task confuses me
Lobster: Yeah so if you want to disprove the rule J should have an odd number on the other side
Lion: 'I think it''s 3, J wouldn''t tell you anything since the rule doesn''t mention consonants'
Lion: 'whether J ends up being an even or odd number won''t tell you anything about the rule'
Hamster: What do they mean by test the rule?
Lion: 'see if it''s true or not'
Lobster: 'But also it says we''re testing the rule so don''t we want to find card that validates our claim not necessarily disproves it'
Lobster: What does everyone else think?
Lion: 'we want to see if it holds true in all cases and if we find one card where it''s false, that disproves the rule'
Guinea pig: 'i''m on u or 8'
Lion: 'assuming U and 8 follow the rule, we still don''t know whether it''s ever false or not'
Lion: 'it could be that it''s false but just not in those cases'
Lion: so we need to try to disprove it and the only way to do that is with 3
Guinea pig: why not all 3
Hamster: 'Wouldn''t we just remove the U to prove it false?'
Guinea pig: if we pick 3 only then we need a vowel behidn it to disprove it right
Guinea pig: and if its not a vowel
Guinea pig: then we dont know anything again
Guinea pig: we have a vowel, odd, and an even number
Hamster: 3
Guinea pig: those all can play into the rule
Guinea pig: i dunno about the J
Lion: 'ok why don''t we do all 3 then'
Lobster: that works for me
Lion: 3,U,8
Guinea pig: 3,U,8