gkaradzhov/DeliData huggingface dataset:
SYSTEM: Raven,SYSTEM,Tiger,Llama&&3,2,J,U
Llama: 'It''s 3 and U because if you turn the 3 and it''s a vowel, then you know odd numbers become vowels and vice versa.'
Llama: 2*
Llama: 'Crap, I read it wrong, it''s evens.'
Tiger: 'hi - I''ve marked only U - if there is an even number on the other side it proves the rule'
Llama: 'Mark 2 as well. If there''s a vowel on the other side, it also proves the rule.'
Raven: 'I chose U only because the rule says all card with vowels which means the other cards don''t matter -- they don''t have to follow the rule.'
Tiger: I agree with Raven
Llama: 'It''s asking you to test the rule. Would it not prove that the rule is tested if the 2 turns up a vowel?'
Tiger: the test is all cards with a vowel
Raven: 'Couldn''t the 2 just as easily have turned up a consonant? In which case, the 2 is not necessary to prove the rule?'
Llama: Good point.
Tiger: again - Raven - I agree
Llama: U
Llama: But would it not strengthen the correlation if we did find a vowel?
Tiger: if U has an even number on the other side the rule is proven
Llama: I pose a question here.
Llama: Would turning over the 3 not be useful for testing?
Raven: 'It might help, but if we didn''t find a vowel it would hurt the rule.'
Llama: It would, but it does seem like that would be necessary for a proper test.
Llama: 3,U
Raven: The question in the task implies that you only need one card to prove the rule.
Llama: While it does, it says most players get it wrong. The assumption then would be that the task is more complex than that.
Tiger: if you want to turn a second card - turn 2 - if 2 has a vowel on the other side the rule is also proven
Tiger: you turn ONLY the cards needed
Raven: 'Agree with Tiger. You don''t "need" to turn over the 2 to prove the rule.'
Llama: Does U coming up even really prove it if other cards could show something different?
Tiger: ONLY is key
Tiger: 'no it''s a logical exclusion'
Tiger: so what do we agree to?
Raven: I vote "U" only.
Llama: I guess what you do if it must be done, but the timer ran out, can it even be submitted?
Tiger: I vote U only
Tiger: U
Raven: U