GENERATION AND CHARACTERISATION OF WEAR DEBRIS FROM SILICON NITRIDE COATINGS AIMED AT INCREASING THE LONGEVITY OF JOINT REPLACEMENTS (2014)

Summary Statement The chemistry, amount, morphology, and size distribution of wear debris from silicon nitride coatings generated in the bearing surface can potentially reduce the negative biological response and increase the longevity compared to conventional materials in joint replacements. Introduction Total hip implants have a high success rate at 15 years of implantation, but few survive over 25 years. At present, revisions are mostly due to aseptic loosening, believed to mainly be caused by the biological response to wear debris generated in the joint bearing. For the polymer liners the size of the wear debris determines the biological response, while for metal bearing surfaces a limitation is the metal ion release. When ceramics are used, the wear debris is in general small and mechanical factors may be the main cause for failure. A more recent, experimental alternative is to let the well-known metallic substrate serve as the soft, tough bulk, and additionally apply a hard and smooth ceramic coating. In this way a lower wear rate and reduced metal ion release could be obtained. Furthermore, the chosen composition, silicon nitride (SixNy), contains no detrimental ions, and silicon nitride debris has been shown to slowly dissolve in aqueous medium. Altogether, it can potentially increase the longevity of the implant. However, the debris from SixNy coatings has not yet been characterised. In this study, a wear model test was performed to generate wear debris from SixNy coatings. The debris was characterised using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) in combination with computational calculations. Methods Silicon nitride coatings deposited on flat cobalt chromium alloy (ASTM F75) were worn in a reciprocating ball on disc setup in a 25% serum solution at 37°C against an alumina ball with a load of 1.5 N. Wear debris was separated using serum digestion with hydrochloric acid (ISO 17853:2011) and examined in SEM in combination with EDS. As reference polyethylene (PE) was used to verify that relevant particles sizes were achieved. The SEM images were processed using a modified MATLAB-script originating from Cervera Gontard et al. [1], identifying the particles and calculating their size. Results Particles generated from SixNy coatings (n=62) a size distribution D50 [D10-D90] of 0.29 µm [0.16–0.69] and were round to oval in shape. The PE particles (n=70) had a size distribution of 0.29 µm [0.13–1.3], shaped similar to the SixNy particles or with a more elongated shape. Discussion and conclusions PE wear debris has been reported to lie in the size range of nm up to several μm in vivo, with a large proportion within the critical size for macrophage activation (0.2 to 0.8 μm). The model test reports relevant sizes and shape of PE debris, confirming the validity of the method. Particles generated from the SixNy coatings showed a smaller size range than PE, however most particles were within the critical size range for biological activation. In conclusion, this model test could be used to generate what we believe are relevant sizes and shapes of PE and SixNy wear debris and to learn more at an early stage of prediction of wear debris. Further dissolution studies as well as studies on the in vitro and in vivo cell response to these types of particles will be performed. The authors thank the Swedish Foundation for Strategic Research (SSF) through MS2E and FP7 NMP project LifeLongJoints for financial support, as well as Linkoping University for the coating facilities and expertise.