Contamination of a Recombinant Hepatitis B Virus Nucleocapsid Preparation with a Human B-Cell Activator (2006)

The hepatitis B virus nucleocapsid is a very immunogenic structure (7) that activates mouse B cells in a T-cell-independent manner (3). We reported a similar observation with human B cells: nucleocapsids induced capsid-binding immunoglobulin M molecules when purified B cells of unprimed humans were transferred into the spleens of NOD/Scid mice (2). However, recent results which we report in this letter suggest that an immunostimulatory contaminant in the HBcAg preparation rather than the nucleocapsids themselves were likely responsible for the observed T-cell-independent B-cell activation. This emerged when four different nucleocapsid preparations were used to study the stimulatory potential of nucleocapsids for purified human B cells. HBcAg-c1 (Diasorin), HBcAg-c2 (Biodesign), and HBcAg-c3 (Biodesign) were produced in Escherichia coli. HBcAg-y was produced in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals, Belgium). HBcAg-c1 nucleocapsids lack the first 2 amino acids and contain 11 foreign amino acids, 8 of which are derived from β-galactosidase (4). HBcAg-c1, HBcAg-y, and HBcAg-c2 contain encapsidated RNA, while HBcAg-c3 nucleocapsids do not, as these lack amino acids 145 to 183. The lipopolysaccharide (LPS) contents of HBcAg-c1, -y, -c2, and -c3 were 136, 0.422, 9.48, and 0.17 endotoxin units LPS/μg nucleocapsid, respectively.

We first investigated whether nucleocapsids induced or enhanced the proliferation of purified B cells. Neither HBcAg-c1, HBcAg-y, nor HBcAg-c2 induced thymidine (TdR) incorporation (Fig. ​(Fig.1A).1A). The addition of HBcAg-c1 to B cells stimulated with interleukin-4 (IL-4), anti-CD40 plus IL-2, and anti-CD40 plus IL-4 had a clear synergistic effect on incorporation of TdR. This was not observed with HBcAg-y and HBcAg-c2. Next, we observed that HBcAg-c1 caused a clear up-regulation of CD86 and CD80 (Fig. ​(Fig.1B).1B). This was never observed with HBcAg-y, HBcAg-c2, and HBcAg-c3 (data not shown). A goat anti-human Fab-specific F(ab)2 fragment induced only the expression of CD86, indicating that the intracellular pathways triggered by HBcAg-c1 and the anti-Fab were different. Because only HBcAg-c1 stimulated B cells, we concluded that a contaminant was present. Total purified human circulating B cells do not respond to different toll-like receptor 2 (TLR2), TLR4, TLR2/TLR6, and TLR7/8 ligands (1), suggesting that HBcAg-c1-encapsidated RNA and contaminating LPS and TLR2 ligands (5, 6) were not responsible for the activation of B cells. The capacity of HBcAg-c1 to induce CD80 and CD86 was not destroyed by boiling for 30 min (data not shown), demonstrating indeed that HBcAg-c1 nucleocapsids themselves were not responsible for the stimulation of B cells. Unluckily, the use of HBcAg-c1 in our experiments suggested that nucleocapsids behaved as T-cell-independent B-cell antigens (2). We suggested previously that the stimulatory capacities of nucleocapsids for monocytes and dendritic cells might be attributed to contaminating TLR4 and TLR2 ligands (5, 6). Our data again highlight that caution is needed when studying the stimulatory capacities of nucleocapsids, especially when produced in a bacterium. Proteins produced in E. coli inherently contain products like LPS, bacterial DNA, porins, lipid A-associated proteins, fimbrial proteins, protein A, and lipoproteins. All these can activate cells (8).



FIG. 1.

(A) HBcAg-c1 enhances B-cell proliferation induced by IL-4 and anti-CD40 plus IL-2 or IL-4. Purified B cells were incubated for 3 days with 1 μg/ml of HBcAg-c1 (black), HBcAg-y (dark gray), or HBcAg-c2 (light gray) or without nucleocapsids (white), ...