Sealing Behaviour of Container Closure Systems under Frozen Storage Conditions: Nonlinear Finite Element Simulation of Serum Rubber Stoppers (2018)

There has been a growing interest in recent years in the assessment of suitable vial/stopper combinations for storage and shipment of frozen drug products. Considering that the glass transition temperature (T<sub>g</sub>) of butyl rubber stoppers used in container closure systems (CCSs) is between -55 °C to -65 °C, a storage or shipment temperature of a frozen product below the T<sub>g</sub> of the rubber stopper may require special attention because below the T<sub>g</sub> the rubber becomes more plastic like and loses its elastic (sealing) characteristics. Thus, they risk not maintaining container closure integrity (CCI). Given that the rubber regains its elastic properties and reseals after rewarming to ambient temperature, leaks during frozen temperature storage and transportation are transient and the CCI methods used at room temperature conditions are unable to confirm CCI in the frozen state. Hence, several experimental methods have been developed in recent years in order to evaluate CCI at low temperatures. Finite element (FE) simulations were applied in order to investigate the sealing behaviour of rubber stoppers for the drug product CCS under frozen storage conditions. FE analysis can help in reducing the experimental design space and thus the number of measurements needed, as they can be used as an add-on to experimental testing. Several scenarios have been simulated including the effect of thermal history, rubber type, storage time, worst-case CCS geometric tolerances, and capping pressure. The results of these calculations have been validated with experimental data derived from laboratory experiments (CCI at low temperatures), and a concept for tightness has been developed. It has been concluded that FE simulations have the potential to become a powerful predictive tool toward a better understanding of the influence of cold storage on the rubber sealing properties (and hence on CCI) when dealing with frozen drug products.<i>LAY ABSTRACT:</i> The growing interest in the assessment of suitable vial/stopper combinations for storage and shipment of frozen drug products has led to the development of a number of experimental methods to evaluate container closure integrity at low temperatures. The application of finite element simulations could aid in the investigation of the sealing behaviour of rubber stoppers for drug product container closure systems under frozen storage conditions by simplifying the experimental design space and the number of experimental measurements needed. In this work several scenarios have been simulated including the effect of thermal history, rubber type, storage time, worst-case container closure system geometric tolerances, and capping pressure. The results have been further validated with experimental data derived from laboratory experiments and a concept for tightness was developed. In conclusion, finite element simulations have shown the potential to become a powerful predictive tool toward a better understanding of the influence of cold storage on the rubber sealing properties (and hence on container closure integrity) when dealing with frozen drug products.