Nicotinamide in Friedreich's ataxia: useful or not? (2014)

Friedreich's ataxia is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder caused by mutations in the frataxin gene (FXN), leading to progressive ataxia, cardiomyopathy, scoliosis, and various other clinical features.1Pandolfo M Friedreich ataxia: the clinical picture.J Neurol. 2009; 256: 3-8Crossref PubMed Scopus (304) Google Scholar Most patients have GAA repeat expansions in intron 1 of FXN, leading to decreased concentrations of frataxin protein and downstream mitochondrial dysfunction. The GAA repeats lead to gene silencing through heterochromatin formation, and decreased transcription of FXN mRNA. The coding region of the mRNA and the aminoacid sequence of the protein are normal, but the amount of protein produced is reduced; as a result, reversal of the epigenetic changes (such as histone deacetylation) represents a potential therapeutic strategy in Friedreich's ataxia. Inhibitors of histone deacetylase (HDAC) have been reported to increase frataxin concentrations in cell culture and in animal models of Friedreich's ataxia.2Gottesfeld JM Rusche JR Pandolfo M Increasing frataxin gene expression with histone deacetylase inhibitors as a therapeutic approach for Friedreich's ataxia.J Neurochem. 2013; 126: 147-154Crossref PubMed Scopus (47) Google Scholar, 3Chan PK Torres R Yandim C et al.Heterochromatinization induced by GAA-repeat hyperexpansion in Friedreich's ataxia can be reduced upon HDAC inhibition by vitamin B3.Hum Mol Genet. 2013; 22: 2662-2675Crossref PubMed Scopus (64) Google Scholar In an open-label, dose-escalation study reported in The Lancet, Vincenzo Libri and colleagues4Libri V Yandim C Athanasopoulos S et al.Epigenetic and neurological effects and safety of high-dose nicotinamide in patients with Friedreich's ataxia: an exploratory, open-label, dose-escalation study.Lancet. 2014; (published online May 1.)http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60382-2PubMed Google Scholar note an increase in FXN mRNA expression and frataxin protein concentration in peripheral blood mononuclear cells in patients given nicotinamide, a drug that has HDAC inhibitor activity when given at high concentrations. Ten adult patients with Friedreich's ataxia from the UK were given single doses (phase 1) and repeated daily doses of 2–8 g oral nicotinamide for 5 days (phase 2) and 8 weeks (phase 3). In phase 1, a single dose of up to 8 g (about 200 times higher than the typical recommended daily allowance for nicotinamide as a vitamin [B3]5US National Library of MedicineMedlinePlus—niacin and niacinamide (vitamin B3).http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/druginfo/natural/924.htmlGoogle Scholar) led to an increase in frataxin concentration in peripheral blood mononuclear cells, and this effect increased with increasing dose (p=0·0004). In phases 2 and 3, repeated daily dosing at 3·5–6 g resulted in a sustained and significant (p<0·0001) upregulation of frataxin expression, which was associated with changes in chromatin structure (a significant reduction methylation at aminoacid position 9 of the histone H3 tail and a non-significant increase in H3 acetylation at the FXN locus). The investigators did not report any significant improvements in neurological measures, as assessed by the scale for the assessment and rating of ataxia and the spinocerebellar ataxia functional index. These results are of interest for several reasons. First, although nicotinamide has several potential mechanisms of action, these data match the effects of nicotinamide and other HDAC inhibitors seen in model systems, both in the increase in frataxin concentration over the course of several hours, and in the estimated induction of frataxin expression by 1·5 to 2·0 times (corresponding to nicotinamide doses of 3·8–7·5 g).2Gottesfeld JM Rusche JR Pandolfo M Increasing frataxin gene expression with histone deacetylase inhibitors as a therapeutic approach for Friedreich's ataxia.J Neurochem. 2013; 126: 147-154Crossref PubMed Scopus (47) Google Scholar, 3Chan PK Torres R Yandim C et al.Heterochromatinization induced by GAA-repeat hyperexpansion in Friedreich's ataxia can be reduced upon HDAC inhibition by vitamin B3.Hum Mol Genet. 2013; 22: 2662-2675Crossref PubMed Scopus (64) Google Scholar Libri and colleagues' findings substantiate the existence of epigenetic mechanisms in patients with Friedreich's ataxia like those seen in model systems, as well as raising the possibility of therapeutic interventions based on the manipulation of such mechanisms. The increase in FXN mRNA expression was fairly small, but within a range that could affect clinical outcome in Friedreich's ataxia on the basis of an association between frataxin concentrations and disease severity.6Deutsch EC Santani AB Perlman SL et al.A rapid, noninvasive immunoassay for frataxin: utility in assessment of Friedreich ataxia.Mol Genet Metab. 2010; 101: 238-245Crossref PubMed Scopus (72) Google Scholar Thus, the estimated increase in frataxin mRNA and protein reported with nicotinamide could be clinically meaningful if the drug is provided at the right time, for a sufficient duration, and to the appropriate tissues. Nevertheless, the evidence for nicotinamide in Friedreich's ataxia is incomplete. Although even a small increase in frataxin concentration might be clinically meaningful, how long the effect of nicotinamide on frataxin expression could be maintained is unclear. The biological effect lasted for 2 months in Libri and colleagues' study—a short time in the life of a patient with Friedreich's ataxia. Additionally, the effects on frataxin noted by the investigators were assessed in peripheral blood mononuclear cells, which are not functionally affected in Friedreich's ataxia. Although nicotinamide crosses the blood–brain barrier, Libri and colleagues' study does not address whether nicotinamide increases the amount of frataxin in the nervous system and other affected tissues; it would have been useful to have measured drug concentrations and biological effects in disease-relevant tissues such as the dorsal root ganglia and heart. Finally, restoration of frataxin concentrations must occur while the nervous system is still responsive to increases in frataxin. No effects on ataxia were noted in the study; whether this finding was caused by an inability of patients to respond or by the short duration of the study is not yet known. Longer studies will be needed to answer this question. Although nicotinamide was used at doses that are much higher than the recommended daily allowance for vitamin B3, it was still reasonably well tolerated, with minor to moderate side-effects such as nausea (100% during phases 2 and 3 combined) and vomiting (50%). These adverse effects could be limiting for long-term treatment. Thus, in view of the fairly small changes in FXN expression and frataxin concentration, the absence of a demonstrated clinical effect, and the unknown risks of long-term use, we need to look for a clinically meaningful benefit in randomised controlled studies of longer duration to determine whether nicotinamide is effective for Friedreich's ataxia. Unlike other targeted drugs currently under development for Friedreich's ataxia,7Lynch DR Willi SM Wilson RB et al.A0001 in Friedreich ataxia: biochemical characterization and effects in a clinical trial.Mov Disord. 2012; 27: 1026-1033Crossref PubMed Scopus (64) Google Scholar, 8Soragni E Xu C Plasterer HL Jacques V Rusche JR Gottesfeld JM Rationale for the development of 2-aminobenzamide histone deacetylase inhibitors as therapeutics for Friedreich ataxia.J Child Neurol. 2012; 27: 1164-1173Crossref PubMed Scopus (29) Google Scholar nicotinamide is widely available, and patients and carers might be tempted to start using it for treatment. Although the data from Libri and colleagues' study4Libri V Yandim C Athanasopoulos S et al.Epigenetic and neurological effects and safety of high-dose nicotinamide in patients with Friedreich's ataxia: an exploratory, open-label, dose-escalation study.Lancet. 2014; (published online May 1.)http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60382-2PubMed Google Scholar show the potential for epigenetic-based treatments in Friedreich's ataxia, such approaches are not yet ready for widespread application in this disorder. This online publication has been corrected. The corrected version first appeared at thelancet.com on May 29, 2014 This online publication has been corrected. The corrected version first appeared at thelancet.com on May 29, 2014 DRL has received grant funding from Santhera, Edison, Penwest, and Viropharma, and has acted as a paid consultant for Apopharma and Retrotope. KHF has served as an unpaid advisor to Biogen Idec, Prosensa, and Summit Corporation, and has a patent pending with Novartis (unrelated to the topic of this Comment). Epigenetic and neurological effects and safety of high-dose nicotinamide in patients with Friedreich's ataxia: an exploratory, open-label, dose-escalation studyNicotinamide was associated with a sustained improvement in frataxin concentrations towards those seen in asymptomatic carriers during 8 weeks of daily dosing. Further investigation of the long-term clinical benefits of nicotinamide and its ability to ameliorate frataxin deficiency in Friedreich's ataxia is warranted. Full-Text PDF Open AccessDepartment of ErrorLynch DR, Fischbeck KH. Nicotinamide in Friedreich's ataxia: useful or not? Lancet 2014; 384: 474–75—This Comment should have been published under a Creative Commons CC BY open-access licence. The correction has been made to the online version as of May 29, 2014, and to the printed Comment. Full-Text PDF