Rock Melt Borehole Sealing System, Final Technical Report for SBIR Phase I Grant No. DE-SC0011888 (2015)

Purpose of Research Deep borehole disposal is one option that has received attention in recent years as a possible strategy for long-term disposal of the tens of thousands of tons of spent nuclear fuel. The feasibility of the deep borehole option relies upon designing and constructing an effective seal within the borehole to ensure that the waste package does not communicate with the shallow subsurface biosphere through the borehole itself. Some of the uncertainty associated with the long-term suitability of the deep borehole option is related to (1) the degradation of traditional sealing materials over time and (2) the inability of traditional sealing methods to adequately seal a Disturbed Rock Zone surrounding the borehole. One possible system to address these concerns consists of encapsulating the waste in a melt generated from either the waste itself or a plug above the waste. This current project expanded on previous work to further advance the deep borehole disposal concept. Research Objectives & Findings The overarching objective of the study was to evaluate the feasibility of constructing a downhole heater that is capable of meeting the technical and logistical requirements to melt rock. This ultimate objective was accomplished by two primary approaches. The first approach was to define the heater requirements and conceptually design a system that is capable of melting rock. The second approach was to determine the feasibility of conducting an in situ, field-scale melting experiment to validate the suitability of the rock melt seal concept. The evaluation and conceptual design of the heater system resulted in the following primary findings: • Borehole wall temperatures capable of producing a partial melt are achievable under most expected thermal conductivities with a 12-kilowatt heater. • Commercially available components have been identified that meet the requirements of the heater system, including resistive elements that are capable of providing the required heat generation, container materials that can withstand the anticipated temperatures, and a system capable of providing power to the heater. Evaluating the feasibility of performing field-scale experiments resulted in the following major findings: • The Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) has been identified as a host site for field testing of prototype heaters. The technical and logistical requirements for performing the rock melt tests can be met by using or expanding the existing infrastructure at SURF with on-site personnel and contractors. • In situ hydraulic conductivity test using packers can test the effectiveness of the rock melt seal, while a mine back performed from a lower level can further evaluate the recrystallized melt. • Preliminary costing indicates that a field-scale melting experiment at SURF is feasible within a Phase II Small Business Innovation Research budget while allowing sufficient budget for refining the heater design, coordinating the test program, and interpreting the results. Application of Research The rock melt sealing concept has the potential to reduce uncertainty associated with the long-term storage of nuclear waste. Preliminary efforts of this study defined the requirements of a downhole heater system capable of melting rock and indicated that developing such a system is feasible using available technology. The next logical step is designing and manufacturing prototype heaters. Concurrent with prototype development is coordinating robust field-scale experiments that are capable of validating the design for marketing to potential users.