Update on Mechanisms of Ischemic Acute Kidney Injury (2006)

Acute renal failure (ARF), classically defined as an abrupt decrease in kidney function that leads to accumulation of nitrogenous wastes such as blood urea nitrogen and creatinine, is a common clinical problem with increasing incidence, serious consequences, unsatisfactory therapeutic options, and an enormous financial burden to society (1–5). ARF may be classified as prerenal (functional response of structurally normal kidneys to hypoperfusion), intrinsic renal (involving structural damage to the renal parenchyma), and postrenal (urinary tract obstruction). This review focuses on intrinsic ARF, which has emerged as the most common and serious subtype in hospitalized patients and can be associated pathologically with acute tubular necrosis (ATN). Consequently, it still is common clinical practice to use the terms intrinsic ARF and ATN interchangeably. Despite decades of pioneering basic research and important technical advances in clinical care, the prognosis for patients with intrinsic ARF remains poor, with a mortality rate of 40 to 80% in the intensive care setting. Two major problems have plagued the field and hindered progress. First, well over 20 definitions for ARF have been used in published studies, ranging from dialysis requirement to subtle increases in serum creatinine (6). In an attempt to standardize the definition and reflect the entire spectrum of the condition, the term acute kidney injury (AKI) has been proposed (4). AKI refers to a complex disorder that comprises multiple causative factors and occurs in a variety of settings with varied clinical manifestations that range from a minimal but sustained elevation in serum creatinine to anuric renal failure. Prerenal azotemia and other fully reversible causes of acute renal insufficiency are specifically excluded from the spectrum of AKI. An inherent shortcoming of this term is the continued reliance on serum creatinine measurements, and the definition of AKI undoubtedly will undergo enhancements as novel early biomarkers for the identification of ARF before the rise in serum creatinine come to light (7). This review avoids the term ATN and uses the expressions AKI and intrinsic ARF transposably. The second problem is an incomplete understanding of the cellular and molecular mechanisms that underlie AKI. This review updates the reader on current advances in basic and translational research that hold promise in human ischemic AKI. Classic concepts are mentioned briefly as founding principles but expanded on only if contemporary findings substantiate or refute them. The reader is referred to recent publications that address the mechanisms that underlie other causes of intrinsic AKI, such as sepsis (8) and nephrotoxins (9). However, from the clinical viewpoint, it is acknowledged that AKI is frequently multifactorial, with concomitant ischemic, nephrotoxic, and septic components and with overlapping pathogenetic mechanisms. Alterations in Morphology If function depends on form, then it follows that mechanisms that are invoked to elucidate kidney dysfunction in AKI also must explain the morphologic alterations. In this regard, the term ATN is a misnomer, because frank tubule cell necrosis is rarely encountered in human ARF. This fact has once again been driven home by careful examination of protocol kidney biopsies that are obtained soon after deceased-donor transplantation (10), which represents a predictable model for ischemic AKI (11). Prominent morphologic features of ischemic AKI in humans include effacement and loss of proximal tubule brush border, patchy loss of tubule cells, focal areas of proximal tubular dilation and distal tubular casts, and areas of cellular regeneration (12). Necrosis is inconspicuous and restricted to the highly susceptible outer medullary regions. The glomeruli are usually unimpressive, unless a primary glomerular disease had caused the ARF. This apparent disparity between the severe impairment of renal function and the relatively subtle histologic changes in AKI traditionally has been bothersome. More recently, however, reconciliation has been forthcoming from a consistent finding of apoptotic cell death in both distal and proximal tubules in both ischemic and nephrotoxic forms of human AKI (9,10). In addition, a great deal of attention has been directed toward the peritubular capillaries, which display a striking vascular congestion, endothelial damage, and leukocyte accumulation (13–15). The mechanisms that underlie these newly emphasized morphologic findings and their implications for the ensuing profound renal dysfunction are detailed herein. Alterations in Hemodynamics An intense and persistent renal vasoconstriction that reduces overall kidney blood flow to approximately 50% of normal has long been considered a hallmark of intrinsic ARF, prompting the previous designation of “vasomotor nephropathy” (1). As if to add insult to injury, the postischemic kidney also displays peculiar regional alterations in blood flow patterns. Notably, there is marked congestion and hypoperfusion of the outer medulla that persist even though cortical blood flow improves during reperfusion after an ischemic insult (13–15). Even under normal conditions, the medullary region subsists on a hypoxic precipice as a result of low blood flow and countercurrent exchange of oxygen, although paradoxically housing nephron segments with very high energy requirements (e.g., the S3 segment of the proximal tubule and the medullary thick ascending limb of Henle’s loop). The characteristic postischemic congestion worsens the relative hypoxia, leading to prolonged cellular injury and cell death in these predisposed tubule segments. Sophisticated imaging techniques have documented these changes in regional renal blood flow in animals and validated them in human AKI (16). Mechanisms that underlie these hemodynamic alterations have begun to surface, and they relate primarily to endothelial cell injury (13–17). This results in a local imbalance of vasoactive substances, with enhanced release of vasoconstrictors such as endothelin and decreased abundance of vasodilators such as endothelium-derived nitric oxide (NO) (2). Endothelin receptor antagonists ameliorate ischemic AKI in animals (18), but human data are lacking. Similarly, both carbon monoxide and carbon monoxide–releasing compounds are protective in animal models of ischemic AKI (19,20), and of medullary blood but have been in these fully for the profound loss of renal and human of vasodilators such as have to in in ARF of renal blood flow However, alterations are to a major as Alterations in in tubule include and of The consistent histologic findings of proximal tubular dilation and distal tubular in human biopsies that to tubular flow occurs in ischemic AKI. The for which is by the thick ascending limb as a an is enhanced by the that is encountered in the distal tubule in AKI This an for with tubule and brush However, it is that can for the intense because human that used with or have an on the and renal rate of patients with ARF. Similarly, although of the glomerular the has been to this for only a very of the decrease in in human ARF (2). a for of has been proposed on the of human The of to the as a result of cellular in the ischemic proximal tubule be to receptor and decrease However, recent have that a of the in a of ischemic renal injury, and of protective after ischemic injury may a that of and to the proximal the for of in human AKI remains to be Alterations in profound in occurs early after ischemic renal injury, which in a of in tubule are detailed and their is in Alterations in leads to a of to and prolonged is to and to accumulation to of by mechanisms of cells, and their of during However, although of or can ischemic AKI in animal this has results in human ARF Alterations in leads to the as well as of the in the rise in after AKI. include of and and However, the such as and which an important in the cell during from AKI in animal models of this a recent that may from renal injury in the but for their in other forms of human AKI is lacking. of is for the of in the of AKI. the of to by from as a result of or as a result of of and In the of forms the highly in tubule cells, and the that is with to which results in cell damage injury as well as renal tubule cell injury by of of damage to and of recent documented a in in humans with ARF, as by of and in only a and on the of and on of (e.g., ischemic AKI in but human have been in the field is the protective of a of and of the of reperfusion in a model of ischemic AKI has been for human use in the of and results of use in human AKI are with that is from or other is as of the most factors in the of and the injury in animal However, the associated clinical use in human AKI Two major advances have come to light in the of The is the of human an that renal injury in animals by renal has been used for the of in patients have cell transplantation The second is the of a major to as of the most highly and in the kidney after ischemic injury The of in AKI is detailed of structural and in animal models The use of both of these and in human AKI is under Alterations in techniques have novel the cell of the proximal tubule in ischemic AKI. The structural response of the tubule cell to ischemic injury is and loss of cell and brush cell of cells, and of a normal as in The mechanisms that underlie this morphologic of are complex and Alterations in the leads to a of the and of from the and the The ensuing alterations in to of or that are or the tubular components that are the to and and that and also as have been in the in animal as well as human AKI The of in the is under is a that is in the by In renal tubule cells, leads to with and of to the and the and the to and which in leads to well for of such as and of also can by which may to of of may a but in AKI. of the by also results in loss of and and of a of that the and have been documented after ischemic injury in cell animal and human The loss of function can the of glomerular that is by Alterations in the results in the early of and The is to the the the In cell animal and human studies, leads to a reversible accumulation of and in The remains to but is of mechanisms that to loss of include of with loss of and of by of such as of the loss of is an impairment in proximal tubular and a in of which are of intrinsic ARF. The are to the they injury leads to a of to the with of from the is for between these the tubular by an between and the of of compounds tubular and renal impairment in animal and the recent of antagonists promise for human AKI recent animal has that the of also is for of tubule of that the in of renal and of and of the response The protective a therapeutic for human AKI, but the for is an Alterations in and human that tubule can of after ischemic AKI. The of that they injury or are only and undergo of tubule display patchy cell death that results from mechanisms. Necrosis is an that is by loss of and cellular is a that is by and and of the cell apoptotic that are by forms of cell death can and are considered of a ischemic renal injury, the of cell death depends primarily on the of the insult and the of the cell Necrosis usually occurs after severe injury and in the susceptible nephron after severe injury and in the distal nephron segments. can be by if the apoptotic are The used for and between and morphologic are for the and of and and and that is the major of early tubule cell death in contemporary clinical ARF recent animal models of ischemic AKI and the of apoptotic tubule a variety of this has been by in human models of AKI still the of to the of ARF. First, most the of only approximately to of tubule after ischemic injury, which is to explain the profound renal In response to this is that the of is because it is a that is to and in is encountered in the distal loss of occurs in proximal segments. of this is by the of both necrosis and in the proximal these may a is as a that and may be to the and the The to this is that after ischemic AKI is a that occurs in in animal The is to of the approximately and This tubule cells, to the ensuing The second apparent approximately and cells, and may a in the of the is in of as a pathogenetic attention has been directed toward the molecular of the intrinsic and and and and to be by ischemic AKI, as in leading for the of the in animal by of of these in apoptotic tubule after and the that is by that the However, human data are because the of the that in of human kidney in publications However, there is an imbalance between the and and and of the in both animal and human the the has been to be the and and of by by of and of However, is an for therapeutic in humans because of will of or in other of hold promise in ischemic AKI is by and the common in also has been and have for have been only in only and are most before the However, these as a to apoptotic damage during of deceased-donor kidneys before as has been in animal models In this regard, an and to be in injury after and transplantation in animals is in clinical for injury in human other ameliorate and AKI in with structural and of and of the However, of by of in a of ischemic AKI, by of factors of function receptor receptor of and have from ischemic AKI with of and but the mechanisms have been fully of these are and used in other human conditions, and results of their use in AKI be for the clinical use of in AKI include the of the of the and of the The mechanisms the of tubule cell death and or after ischemic AKI under have as of this of is of a highly cellular response that is and after ischemic AKI. cell by and of renal tubule also the of normal cellular function by as molecular that in the of as well as of there is for the of in the of and after ischemic AKI in animal models In tubule cells, of the response by techniques profound impairment of cellular and and of the loss of after these findings that that the response have in human AKI but that of from to has been However, that this also may cellular such as to from the the Mechanisms of renal tubule a to and after ischemic AKI is by the of that a for The of these remains is but they most tubule that have In the the that for a variety of such as and and undergo marked In the factors such as cell and and undergo the normal fully is during from renal tubule and that are very to during normal kidney of that to the of of by include and of these only are to early kidney but also are in the kidney after ischemic injury, they to a in the regeneration and the molecular mechanisms of may toward from ARF. has been documented to be and in animal models of AKI, by and However, the use of in humans has been in by the of the of serious with of display kidney and disease of the in the proximal tubule the from ischemic AKI, with enhanced tubule cell and decreased of to the human proximal however, remains a In the of for has been by of and in the kidney after in animals and clinical with human have to be in has been by the recent of a that increases serum and the kidney from ischemic injury by endothelial function and in animals of the of that are in the regeneration and may have important therapeutic implications and has been a of intense contemporary for an from of in the kidney after transplantation or from ischemic AKI in but First, the of that in the postischemic kidney is very and their has been with technical results the of these in the and in nephron for of renal after AKI the overall of is in of the that of the tubule after ischemic AKI occurs of renal with have been in the kidney their to the is and the tubule to the primary the of by may be to but to and mechanisms that are are this therapeutic promise in human AKI. Alterations in the In recent the of the vascular as an that is both a of and a for injury has and the of endothelial alterations in the and of AKI has increasing attention (13–17). of the and to in tubule cells, has been documented in endothelial in AKI endothelial cell and of and endothelial have been in humans with septic of endothelial may be to prolonged and has and even of blood flow in peritubular during reperfusion or of fully endothelial postischemic kidneys in a that endothelial ischemic injury leads to a marked of a that of endothelial these findings a for the use of that can the or of endothelial cells, such as vascular endothelial and AKI also leads to endothelial of a variety of that include and of the and with to ischemic AKI, human with after AKI in Similarly, and have a for and However, have that it is endothelial that is the leading to AKI mechanisms include of to the with leukocyte and of to with and in peritubular with other in the such as alterations in and in the kidney may for the that are in the renal after ischemic Alterations in the of that the response a major in ischemic AKI. that are by endothelial dysfunction can be by the of a of by the ischemic proximal which is to a include (e.g., and (e.g., human that the of the and in the mortality in patients with AKI and the of in the AKI after kidney transplantation to the clinical of these mechanisms. receptor may a major of this response tubular of is enhanced ischemic AKI, and by and renal tubule and of and also is in postischemic tubules and ischemic AKI by the of and in proximal tubule leukocyte have been to in peritubular capillaries, and even tubules after ischemic AKI and their relative under are the to in the postischemic However, or of function in but animal are a of ischemic AKI in the clinical of are the to in animal models in response to of in tubule and of receptor on ischemic AKI, but the of injury by to the of and However, have been in animal as well as human models of ischemic AKI and cell is protective in AKI are from ischemic AKI and of the this protective However, and recent data that the of in ischemic AKI may be with the identification of both protective and of animals that are in both and are from ischemic AKI and of to from ischemic AKI The of in ischemic AKI is with are from structural and ischemic renal injury, and cell serum but cell to ischemic AKI, a serum as a by which cell renal of the in ischemic AKI, with a of the response in the has attention in recent injury in most the in animals and humans have a for the in ischemic AKI However, this remains because other have a for the as well in after animal and human ischemic AKI is the identification of the to the of a complex recent have this and have a for in ischemic AKI is a that such as and The kidney is of the in which the receptor is in proximal tubule as well as receptor in tubule is after injury and sepsis of renal dysfunction that by and and in models with receptor antagonists the histologic and impairment that by ischemic AKI in animal models antagonists for receptor are a clinical in and for the or of ischemic AKI. that the response also may in human AKI, and have been in is a that has been to ischemic AKI by by of a the structural and of ischemic AKI, decreased and a novel from ischemic AKI in a kidney model by of and and of and In to in used that may be in ischemic AKI, profound of and of endothelial have structural and from ischemic AKI by with Similarly, used in humans for also has and and has been used for of ischemic AKI in animals an ischemic AKI by the of that and renal injury the of remains even after the renal and also the injury that occurs after ischemic AKI The clinical with of these and their overall them highly for the and of ischemic AKI. Alterations in the molecular of the that are by complex such as ischemic AKI have been by recent advances in and have used these techniques in human and animal models of ischemic AKI to of of with these have novel with that are and even and biomarkers in AKI. of the to be in the postischemic kidney kidney injury to be in postischemic animal and human kidney on the of proximal tubule cells, it may a in renal regeneration An is the a of ischemic human AKI recent is of the most highly in the early postischemic kidney is in kidney tubules very early after ischemic AKI in animals and humans and is in the it represents a early of ischemic AKI In the postischemic kidney in a that with is highly in tubule that are a protective or after AKI. for this from the by in kidney during of kidney and tubules of in models or even after ischemic injury the and structural with an of and striking of of tubule In this by a for and may a of to regeneration and also a protective in AKI that by of such as and carbon and the cell of protective has emerged as a therapeutic in ischemic AKI. that is very early after ischemic injury is a that is in the of a of is during kidney and is in the postischemic tubule cells, with major of and the apoptotic response to in have a that may a in the early tubule cell death that ischemic renal in models has a and in as early after ischemic AKI The is in the postischemic proximal tubule cells, it with from ischemic injury, with striking structural of kidney results have apoptotic that is in proximal tubule early after ischemic AKI. is an fact that after an from an of clinical ARF, a of patients persistent or in renal is that the postischemic kidney is fully to and animal models display a in renal tubular and and persistent in the has been used to in the kidney during an after from ischemic AKI but before the of or changes that novel to the ARF field and light on the of these and other in the of ischemic AKI. of and Alterations The clinical of ischemic AKI has been classically and this the of an after the has been primarily to reflect advances in the of ischemic AKI to between the clinical and the cellular alterations detailed in this The is the during which to the ischemic insult kidney function to and injury is but fully is injury to the tubule and endothelial of is and of mechanisms protective such as of in tubule cells, also are to during the If the injury is this then and is the of by reperfusion in the flow to the and tubules undergo cell death but also the regeneration In medullary blood flow remains in tubule cell and endothelial and the and the endothelial the intense The to This represents the most of for early and therapeutic the the injury is and the is even though renal blood flow to cell injury and regeneration and the and of this may be by the between cell and of both and endothelial to be to overall to the regeneration may be during this The is by in and structurally by of tubule with fully and However, the may be and both and tubular has been in animal and to the a with a and of to and if of the other then in the a finding the the under a and the ischemic AKI, is a with multiple mechanisms that with and to the a to has been to the to in AKI AKI also will a finding the an early and a therapeutic that is on a understanding of the The in basic and translational AKI research that has been this in is in this The cellular and molecular of have the of and injury, endothelial regeneration and and the response in the of ischemic AKI. that have emerged from these recent findings hold promise for the of human AKI and are under intense Alterations in tubule cell after ischemic acute kidney injury The is by profound which the cell by a of and cell death mechanisms. the prolonged by reperfusion these to primarily in and of these may novel therapeutic as with and by Alterations in tubule cell after ischemic AKI. The leads to injury, with loss of brush and of cell and the If the injury is this then If then the injury the with cell and an response in of and this may a therapeutic The is by a between tubule cell death and occurs as a result of of tubule cells, although and also may a to the may by apoptotic in human ischemic AKI. The of with in of The intrinsic of to the for the release of and of between these is by also is by is in normal by and and which the morphologic of of these therapeutic promise in human acute renal failure. that have been in animal models in human are by Alterations in the and in ischemic AKI. the endothelial injury leads to intense and congestion with a of and that tubule cell In addition, tubule a response by and that the that the response may in ischemic AKI. by for AKI on the of recent that are in this review and in the by from the of of and and and a from the and a from The is to for and which have only this but also the entire