MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 34.16 1.60 Hi,welcomeeverybody. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 35.84 7.68 ThisisCommunityMediaCenterofMarinTV,CMCMTV,andmynameisCraigSlater. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 43.52 5.12 I'mheretodaywithLarryBragman,currentMayorofFairfax,andJoryPrum. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 48.88 9.36 AndwearegoingtobetalkingaboutMeasureD,ahalfcentsalestaxforFairfaxwhichisontheballotNovember8. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 58.88 1.68 Here'sJoryfirst. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 61.68 18.56 MynameisJoryPrum,IamwiththeCommiteetoOpposeMeasureD.AndwhiletheproponentsoftheMeasureDsalestaxaremakingalotofclaimsastowhyit'snecessaryandwhatthey'vedonetoavoidit,we'vefoundthatwhenlookingattheseclaimscritically,thattheyactuallydon'tholdup. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 80.32 3.44 Theyclaimthatsalestaxandpropertytaxrevenueshavedecreased. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 83.92 4.00 Theyclaimthatthestategrabbedmoneyfromlocalgovernments. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 88.08 8.88 Theyclaimedthatthefloodwasverycostly,whichitwas,butyouknow,whetheritcontributedtothetown'sfinancialsituationisawholedifferentstory. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 97.04 6.24 Theyclaimthatthey'vecutalldepartmentalspendingby4%,andwefindthatnoneoftheseactuallyholdup. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 103.68 6.32 Whenstudyingthetown'saudits,weactuallyfindthattheytellaverydifferentstory,so. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 111.60 14.64 WellFairfax,likemosttownsinCalifornia,isfacingafinancialcrisisbecauseofthefinancial,thehousingbubblepoppinginCalifornia,andthroughoutthecountry. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 126.24 6.64 Andasaresultofthatfact,propertytaxeshaveactuallygonedowninFairfax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 133.04 4.56 Innormaltimes,propertytaxesgoupabout21/2percent. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 137.84 13.92 Forthelastthreeyears,unfortunatelyforFairfax,ourassessedvaluationhasgonedownwhiletheoperatingcostsofoperatingthetownofFairfaxhavegoneup. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 152.48 8.80 We'veconcludedaftermanydiscussionsthatthefairestwaytohandlethisisamodestsalestaxproposalofhalfacent. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 161.76 8.08 Soinresponsetothetown'sassertionsthatpropertytaxesandsalestaxesaredown,wedon'tdisagreethattheyhavefallenoverthelastthreeyears. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 169.84 7.44 However,ifyoutakealargerview,you'llactuallyseethattherewasabubble,andthebubblehascorrecteditself. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 177.60 8.88 IfyoulookatoverallrevenuesofthetownofFairfaxfrom2005to2010,you'llfindthatrevenueshaveactuallyincreasedover13%. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 186.48 6.40 Ifyouadjustthatforinflation,itactuallycomesoutthatthetownisupby4.2%inoverallrevenues. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 193.28 9.36 Thestatemoneygrabsisanotheroneoftheirargumentsexceptthatwhiletheyhappened,thestatewasrequiredtogiveallthefundsbackaccordingtothe2010audit. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 203.12 2.80 Theflooddidhappen,ofcoursethatwasverycostly. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 206.00 9.76 ButithasbeenpaidforbyFEMA,OES,andinsuranceandthetownisstillnegotiatingtogetsomeofthosefundsback,sothat's,it'snotafinalsay. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 215.92 7.68 Butadditionally,thosefundscomefromadifferentaccountalsoknownastheStormCapitalFund. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 223.68 4.56 Andsothosedon'tactuallyeffectthegeneralfundsspending. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 228.48 15.12 Whilethetownclaimstohavespent4%lessinalldepartments,itactually,whenyoulookattheoverallinformationpresentedbythetown'sofficialaudits,youfindoutthatactually,spendingisup241/2percentinalldepartments. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 244.32 24.56 Mostrecently,Iwastoldbytownofficialsthatthatwasasaresultoffloodspending,anddespitetheargumentaboutFEMA,OES,andinsurance,ifwetakethatargumentatfacevalue,itdoesn'texplainwhygeneralgovernmentspendingusup75%,butpublicworks,thefolkswhoactuallydotherepairsaroundtownareonlyup1.68%overall. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 269.12 12.88 Thetownalsoclaimsthatthey'veleftunfilledpositionsvacant,kindofinsinuatingthat,inferringthatthey'renothiring,butthenagain,thisyear,theycreatedawholenewposition. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 282.08 5.12 Sowedon'tfeelthatthey'reactuallydoingquiteeverythingtheycan,orthatthewholestoryisbeingtold. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 287.60 4.96 TownofFairfaxhashadafrozenpolicepositionforthelastfouryears. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 292.88 6.72 Wefrozeinthemanagementpositionofplanningdirectorforthelastyear,that'sbeinghandledbythemanager. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 299.68 6.96 Andhe'sbeingbackedupbysomebodywebroughtinasaparttimertohandlespecialchores. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 307.12 5.68 AllemployeegroupsinFairfaxhaveagreedtoacontinuingwagefreeze. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 312.96 10.96 WageshavebeenfrozeninFairfaxforthelasttwoyears,andunderthenewcollectivebargainingagreementsweenteredintothisyear,they'llcontinuetobefrozenfortwomoreyears. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 324.16 9.28 Inadditiontothat,allemployeegroupshaveagreedtoa5%payreductionbecausethey'regonnabepickingup5%oftheirpensions. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 333.84 4.64 SomyquestiontoJoryis,areallthesegroupswrong? MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 338.56 2.80 Areallthesebargainingunitswrong? MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 341.44 4.48 ThathavelookedatthebudgetandmadetheseconcessionsforFairfax? MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 346.16 5.68 Arethesacrificesbeingmadebytheseemployeessimplyinvainorfornoreason? MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 352.32 7.20 Thefactofthematteris,isthatpropertytaxesthroughoutMarinCountyhavebeendecliningfortwoyears. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 359.68 6.72 Lastyear,theassessorreducedpropertyassessmentson21%ofthepropertieshereinMarin. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 366.64 6.32 Thisyear,hereducedassessmentsfor27%ofthepropertieshereinMarinCounty. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 373.20 7.92 Thishasadevastatingeffectonlocalgovernmentbecausewedependonpropertyassessmentsforpropertytaxes. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 381.52 13.36 Propertytaxespayformostofourgeneralfund,andthefactofthematteris,isthatsince2009,ourpropertytaxeshavedeclinedbyover$200,000. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 395.04 8.64 That'sjustafact,youcanlookitupatthecountyassessorsofficeifyoudon'tbelievethenumbersthatwe'repostinginFairfax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 403.68 8.80 ButImightadd,allthenumbersthatwepostinFairfaxhavebeenauditedandapprovedbyindependent,outsideauditors. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 414.72 3.12 ThetownofFairfax,theydohaveanaudit. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 417.84 4.08 It'sageneralaudit,itdoesnotcovertheactualbudget,itdoesnotcoverpayroll. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 421.92 7.44 Itonlycoverstheauditsofexpendituresandrevenues,andweagreethatthatgenerallyistrueandcorrect. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 429.44 5.44 Andweareusingthenumbersthatcomefromthoseaudits,thoseofficialdocumentsfromthetownofFairfax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 435.12 10.08 Whatwefindwhenweanalyzethoseauditsisthatfrom2005to2010,thetownofFairfaxbroughtin$2.7millionmorerevenuethantheyexpected. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 445.36 12.88 Thatonaverage,thetownofFairfaxearnsanadditional$459,000peryearthantheyexpect,infact,ifyouchartitoutyouwillnoticethateverysingleyear,thetownhasbroughtinmorerevenuethantheyexpected. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 458.80 2.48 Theyalsospendmoremoneythantheyexpected. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 461.36 6.08 From2005to2010,thetownspent$909,000morethantheyexpectedtospend. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 467.52 7.20 Andevenwiththat$2.7millionbudgetsurplus,thetownmanagedtospendthe$2.3milliondeficit. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 475.20 10.88 Wedon'tdisagreethatoverthelasttwoyearsthatthetaxrevenuesaredecreasingoverall,butoverthelastfiveyears,theyareincreasedcompletely. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 486.24 1.92 4.2%overall. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 488.32 12.08 Sowedon'tsaythatthefirefightersandtownemployeesarewrong,whatwe'resayingisthattheinformationthat'sbeingpresentedtothemisnottransparent,it'snotnecessarilyaccurate. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 500.56 12.72 Andwhenyoulookattheinformationinalargerscope,ratherthansayingjustthelastcoupleofyears,youfindthattheinformationbeingprovidedisvery,veryeasytoquestionandeasytofindholeswith. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 513.60 18.24 WehopethattheFairfaxvoterswilldosomeresearchforthemselves,they'lllookattheinformationwe'veprovidedwhichallcitedandsourced,andnoonehassofarbeenabletotellusthat,withanyactualproofthatthenumberswearecitingareactuallyincorrect. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 531.92 0.72 Thankyou. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 533.60 7.04 Jory,I'dliketociteanumberthatyou'veputinyourwebsitethat'sabsolutelyincorrect. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 540.72 0.72 Goforit. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 541.44 15.84 Okay,inthe"NoonD"website,itclaimsthatFairfaxobtainedinpropertytaxfortheyear2009,approximately$4.6million. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 557.52 12.80 Nowifyoulookattheactualauditfor2009,you'llseethatFairfaxactuallyreceivedabout$3.453millioninpropertytax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 570.56 5.04 Soinotherwords,the"NoonD"websiteisoffaboutamilliondollars. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 575.76 5.44 Nowlet'sgobacktoyourfigureabout$2.7millionbeingunaccountedfor. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 581.52 12.40 ThetownhasstatedrepeatedlythatwhenwefirstreceivedFEMAfundsbackin2006,thosefundswerereportedaspartofthegeneralfund. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 594.16 8.72 Thatwasactuallynotedinthetownmanager'sbudgetstatementfortheyear2006,atpagethreeofherbudgetstatement. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 603.36 8.64 Now,thosefundsplusthemilliondollarsthatyou'vemisstatedonyourwebsitemightaccountforthat$2.7million. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 612.16 1.04 Idon'treallyknow. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 613.28 11.28 Butit'sadisservicetothetruthtotellpeoplethatFairfaxisnotfacingreducedgeneralfundsfromareductioninitspropertytaxbase. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 626.24 4.32 It'sjustadenialofthecrisisthatwe'rein. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 630.72 5.92 Andwe'renotgonnabeabletodealwithitunlesswefirstrecognizethefacts. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 637.04 2.48 Thetownadministrationhasdonethat. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 639.68 3.68 We'vefrozensalaries,we'vefrozenbudgets. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 643.60 6.88 Townemployeeshavedonethatbytakingasalaryfreezeandareductiononpensions. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 650.80 10.72 Ithinktogether,ifthevotersagree,wecanandwillgetthroughthiscrisisbutnotunlessweallunderstandwhat'shappeningaroundus. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 661.84 3.84 Okay,wellIthoughtIwassummarizingbefore,soI'lljustcontinueon. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 666.00 4.96 Larry,I'mlookingatthe2009fiscalyearbudget,andit's,oraudit,sorry. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 671.04 4.00 Anditsays,generalrevenues,propertytaxes,$4.6million. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 675.20 8.80 Idon'tknowwhereyou'regettingyournumbersfrom,butifIcanlookitupintheaudit,Iwouldimaginethatanybodycan,andfinditonthetown'swebsite. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 684.08 6.96 Ifyougotothefairfaxsaysno.comwebsiteyou'llfindthatallthefiguresareavailabledirectlyonthewebsite. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 691.12 3.44 Wehavecharteditoutsopeoplecanseeit,we'renotskewingthenumbers. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 695.36 1.84 Wehavenotdistortedanyofthenumbers. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 697.28 3.28 Weciteexactlywherethosenumberscomefromusingfootnotes. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 700.72 3.68 Andyoucanlookallthosenumbersupforyourself,andwehopethatyouwill. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 704.56 20.80 Becausewelovethistown,weappreciatethatpeoplearetakingthetime,achancetoactuallyfindoutmoreaboutthisissue,appreciatethattheMediaCenteriscoveringthisissueinsuchdepth,andwehopethatyouwilldosomeresearchandlearnmoreaboutityourselfbeforeyougotothepolls. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 726.96 10.40 I'mgonnashowyou,Idon'tknowifyoucanfocusonthis,butthisisthe"NoonD"websitethatshowsthis$4.6millionfigure,okay? MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 737.84 7.52 NowI'mgonnaholduptheactualaudit,whichshowspropertytaxrevenueof$3.43million. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 746.32 4.56 Sohere'sthetruthinnumbers,here'sthetruthinnumbers. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 752.24 1.12 Samedocument. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 754.48 4.00 We'reinafinancialcrisis. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 758.56 6.08 AndMeasureDisamodestproposaltogetusthroughitasatown. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 766.32 4.32 Wecangetthroughthecrisisifweworktogether. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 772.00 8.64 IfweworktogethertopassMeasureD.Fairfaxwillnotonlysurvive,itwillthrive. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 780.96 2.48 Andthat'smyvisionforFairfax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 784.16 5.60 It'sathriving,resilienttownanditgoestoitsownbeat. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 790.48 3.20 AndIknowMeasureDispartofthat. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 794.16 11.04 I'mseeingnow,propertytaxrevenue,thatdifferenceispreciselycausedbythepensiontaxoverridewhichispropertytaxbased. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 805.36 2.32 He'scountingone,we'recountingtheother. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 807.76 2.16 Pickandchoosenumbers,fine,goahead. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 810.00 5.92 Thepointofitis,thetown'sbudgethasbeenunderestimatedbyover$2.7million. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 816.24 6.88 Thetown'sexpenseshavebeenmorethan$900,000overbudget. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 823.92 5.76 Thefloodhasnothingtodowiththis,it'saccountedforinatotallyseparatefund. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 830.00 10.80 Wecanshowitandwecanshow,ifyougotothewebsite,youcanseethetown'sactualwordsexplainingthetownfloodfund. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 840.88 1.12 CraigSlateragain. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 842.00 3.84 I'mgonnareadsomethingfromtheNocamp. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 846.08 17.36 "Thattheargumentsofthetownsoundbelievableonthesurfacebutwhenlookedatwithacriticaleye,it'sobviousthejustificationsarenotonlyfalse,they'rebasedonacompletelackoffiscalresponsibilityoraccuratefinancialreportingfromtownstaff,andourelectedrepresentatives". MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 863.52 11.28 Sothat'stheclaimmadebytheNogroup,andobviously,theYesonDcamphasaverydifferentviewofthemanagementofthetown. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 874.88 5.92 Soit'supforusascitizenstolookatwhatisreallygoingonhere. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 880.80 15.68 There'sclearlyadisagreementintheperceptionofthenumbers,andIthinkitreallygetsdowntoeachofusdoingourjobasvoters,andfindingoutabouttheissues,talktopeoplewhoareopponents,talktopeoplewhoareproponents. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 896.56 6.00 Andfindouthowthismighteffectyouandthenhowtovote. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 902.72 9.12 Hi,myname'sMattHartwell-Herrera,I'mthecampaignmanagerforYesforMeasureD.Andthereasonwe'resupportingthisisbecausewehaveasimplechallengewithinFairfax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 911.84 7.92 Propertytaxesaredownoverthelastcoupleyears,andexpenseshavecontinuedtorise,drivenbyspiralinghealthcarecostsandpensioncosts. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 919.92 16.00 Thetownhastakenlotsofstepsinordertomakethoseothercoststhatwecancontaingolower,butwehavenotbeenabletobridgethegapandwesimplymustlivewithinourmeans,andthetownchoseahalfcentsalestaxbecauseitwasthefairestwaytobalancethatbudget. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 936.00 12.24 ItallowsvisitorsfromoutsideFairfaxtocontribute,itdoesn'tapplytogroceries,it'sasmall,halfcentthatreplacesaonecenttaxthatwasretiredbyCalifornia,soourtaxeswillstillbelower. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 948.32 4.72 ThisiswhyMeasureDisagoodcompromiseandwillbegoodforFairfax. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 953.20 14.56 It'sjusttocalloutthefolkswhohaveendorsedMeasureD.WehavetheunanimousTownCounselofFairfax,thetownfinancedirector,thetowntreasurer,supervisorHoweBrownfromtheMarinBoardofSupervisors. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 967.92 6.64 WehavetheFairfaxPolice,wehavetheFairfaxFirefighters,wehavetheFairfaxChamberofCommerce. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 974.80 10.48 ThemajorityofbusinesseswithinFairfaxaswellasmanyindividualfolkswithinthecommunity,MarkSquire,GaryGrahamandothers. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 985.28 12.00 Sothereisatremendousamountofsupportwithinthecommunity,andthefolksthatthecitizenscountontorepresentthem,whohavebeenelectedandarehiredinordertoanalyze. MeasureD-cmcm_h264 1 997.44 28.48 Thankyou.