Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clone Manga
I'm doing a bit of a search on the Joe Shuster Award and I'm not seeing where this is so tremendously notable that winning one would keep the article on that merit alone. It does somewhat extend notability but I'm not seeing where it's tremendously notable. As far as webcomic creators go, Fred Gallagher is pretty notable in the webcomic world and is one of the very, very few people I'd consider to be notable enough to have a blog count towards notability. I'll see what I can do for the article, but offhand this needs pretty much an almost complete rewrite in many sections. It reads like a fan page rather than an encyclopedic entry. It's pretty |puffy in places
— User:Tokyogirl79, 03:35, 4 September 2012 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:PUFFERY (Wikipedia:Wikipuffery)