Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about weather
all. It would be a better use of editors' time to establish a consensus guideline that clearly addressed the issue of "List of songs about topics."  There is some residue from previous discussions that suggests that work should be started up again.  Regarding these specific nominees, I'm here because of List of songs about the environment.  I came across that list a few weeks ago and found it interesting but clearly incomplete (and incapable of being "complete").  I added Little Boxes, which clearly fits any criteria that could be devised for a list with this name.  I spent some time looking for other ommissions and for songs that didn't belong there, and I planned to do more.  While I now know that this effort was to some, both sickening and laughable, I do not know what Policy clearly demands the erasure of this work.  What the list of environmental songs needs is a link to an appropriate article or section on Songs about the environment or Environmental protest songs, or even Protest songs, where such a list would be needed and would be a useful research tool.  I do not agree that most of these lists are .  Their problem is , for the songs that do not already have articles (especially those that never will), and ongoing article maintenance.  Most of these lists need cleanup and editing help, which should have been begun, or at least proposed, prior to initiating AfD.  I realize that this multiple-list nomination is an efficient way for regular AfD participants to handle a bunch of stuff they don't like, but since this one nomination could eliminate thousands of edits by hundreds of editors, based on the particpation of a few dozen (mostly) flippant members and one administrator, it seems to me to be wholly inappropriate
— User:Hjal, 23:45, 12 June 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOT||WP:V (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)