Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Fragile Intellect (2nd nomination)
to Gerald Crabtree. I came here from the ping to editors who commented in the previous AfD. Looking at the page as it has come to be now, the "reception" section is entirely about negative receptions in the scientific community, and the "cultural trope" section is basically about this work echoing cultural ideas that preceded it, rather than exerting influence of its own. I agree with Qwertyus that this AfD should evaluate the page as a news event more than as a scientific concept. I do think the topic is interesting and encyclopedic in the context of Crabtree's work, and it seems to me that the biographical page is currently incomplete without it, so a merge would improve that biographical page. But I think that  points against keeping this standalone page
— User:Tryptofish, 15:54, 4 January 2015 (UTC)
Stance: merge
Cited policy: WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE (Wikipedia:Notability)