Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elf Sternberg (2nd nomination)
Elf's notability in Usenet was unquestioned at the time, and is well documented (in some cases by |reliable sources, in some cases not).  There seems to be no genuine disagreement that the sources are accurate - the claim seems to be that not enough of them are reliable by WP standards.  If there were serious BLP concerns, one could challenge info on that basis, but this is a deletion debate, in which the notability of the subject and accuracy of the article are the primary concerns.  There seems to be no legitimate claim that the article's inaccurate, or that Elf wasn't notable.  Asking for more reliable sources when there's a plethora of evidence that he was is a shrubbery.  Keep
— User:Georgewilliamherbert, 00:56, 24 September 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:RS (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)