Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controversies related to prevalence of Jews in leadership roles in Hollywood
As the nominator of this article, I feel some need to speak up a bit about the reasons why it was nominated.  As I said in the original nomination, it appeared to have some significant sourcing issues as the article at that time mainly consisted of excerpts from other WP articles, and had the appearance of making significant claims of anti-semitism without properly sourcing or criticizing them.  Of the sources listed, both the Haaertz and the Joel Stein columns appear to be somewhat satirical, and not as factual as other sources might be.  Nowhere did I ever list  as a reason for this AfD, and I don't believe that it applies here.  As for Noleander's second question, I don't know.  It should be noted that this AfD stemmed from an Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard/Incidents#user:Noleander_and_antisemitism-related_articles|ANI entry where an accusation of anti-semitism was brought against a user and I brought the conversation over here so that the conversation would focus on the article instead of the user
— User:Frmatt, 18:19, 20 October 2009 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:COATRACK (Wikipedia:Coatrack articles)