Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional swords (2nd nomination)
per Protonk's reasoning. Having looked over the article, I believe that for it to be properly split into separate articles on encyclopedic topics (ie. Swords in Norse mythology) rather than being a largely indiscriminate list (the attempt to make it discriminate via the lead sentence is weak and entirely ignored), a vast majority of the content would have to be scrapped and rewritten from scratch. Should there be articles about the use of swords in fiction? Absolutely. Should there be independent articles about notable fictional swords? Of course. Should there be an article which attempts to list every sword ever used in fiction? No, that is |indiscriminate
— User:IllaZilla, 23:46, 11 December 2008 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:IINFO (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)