Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journal of Forensic Accounting
The fact that the article is well-sourced (in the sense that every claim in the article is verified, rather than that the references themselves are ideal, which they are not) largely overrides any |COI concerns for me. That leaves the question of Wikipedia:Notability|notability. Unfortunately, the main notability criterion of 'significant coverage in independent, reliable sources' is not really suited to academic journals. For instance, even a prominent journal such as the ''Journal of Peace Research''–one of the top five journals in fields of political science and peace and conflict studies–would have some trouble meeting that criterion. The field of forensic accounting is significantly narrower than political science, so I think that the article is worth keeping in this case, per Bilby's analysis (the journal is peer-reviewed, relatively widely-cited, and relatively well-regarded
— User:Black, 15:36, 27 May 2008 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:COI (Wikipedia:Conflict of interest)