Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim and Mary McCartney (2nd nomination)
per , as well as being well sourced, and having already survived one AfD nomination with good arguments that should be taken into consideration for this nomination. I agree there is an abundance of trivial/fan cruft, but feel the solution is paring down content (indeed, there is lots of junk here) rather than outright deletion. Yeah, I get the WP:INHERIT arguments, but consider the intrinsic value of wikipedia by providing articles that assuage a wider public curiosity that comes with one of the most famous persons in the world. Including deep detail on family lineage and parents in the McCartney article would make it unwieldily, so this spin off is appropriate. It’s kind of the same reason we have a separate article on Abraham Lincoln’s mother, who was equally unremarkable on her own
— User:ShelbyMarion, 17:20, 18 March 2019 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:SPINOFF (Wikipedia:Content forking)