Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Nokia products (2nd nomination)
While I wonder if we really need an article on every cellphone in existence, this is no more a directory than List of Google products, List of IBM products, Amiga models and variants, List of Intel microprocessors, or List of Microsoft Windows versions. And if by "directory" you mean "repository of information", then every article fails #DIR. Wikipedia:Deletion_policy/Brand_name_products says "Minor products from a company should be merged into a 'list of minor products from this company' which is kept in the company article, unless it becomes too large as above." This list appears too large for the Nokia article. I'm wary of Wikipedia being used for marketing, but I don't think this article reads like an advertisement. Words like "ground-breaking" and "pedestrian" are highly opinionated though. If there are many articles on this list, it may even be wise to merge that information into this list instead of having a separate article on each and every cellphone
— User:Pixelface, 04:25, 30 August 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOT (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)