Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chelsea Vowel (2nd nomination)
I'd still like to see a couple more media sources if possible — the QWF award nomination, in particular, should be sourced to a media article rather than to the QWF's own press release of its shortlist — but CBC News, the Winnipeg Free Press, Kirkus Reviews and Eastern Door are all perfectly acceptable sources. Book reviews in reliable and well-established publications ''do'' count toward a writer's notability — amateur book reviews on |blogs and GoodReads and Amazon wouldn't assist, but if |reliable sources are publishing ''professional'' critical reviews of her work then notability ''is'' demonstrated by those reviews. Note, for the record, that I was the ''nominator'' of the  and entirely |primary sourced first version — and ''I'm'' satisfied that this version has properly ''addressed'' the reasons why I listed the original iteration for AFD
— User:Bearcat, 15:48, 25 March 2017 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BLOGS||WP:RS||WP:TOOSOON||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES (Wikipedia:Verifiability)