Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Miok
despite being a well written and well sourced article, the subject fails  as the biography of a person famous for a non-notable event, who is not otherwise notable.  As the OP said, don't take this review as harsh or insensitive, my personal view is that Mr. Miok and all of the others that have been killed in action are heroes. However, a soldier killed in a military conflict is not notable, and the ongoing roadside bombings in Afghanistan are not ''independently'' notable.  The sheer number of ghits is irrelevant: #NEWS|we are not reporting the news here, and he has not done anything that we would consider |notable other than being killed alongside the first Canadian reporter to be killed in this conflict, and that does not make him notable beyond .  While I applaud the work of the editors on this article, and recognize the sensitivity of the subject matter, Wikipedia is WEBHOST|not a web host and |not an indiscriminate collection of information. As other commenters here have suggested, I also suggest that this article should be moved to an appropriate web server as a memorial (which these soldiers rightfully deserve
— User:Ivanvector, 06:42, 15 January 2010 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:GNG||WP:NOT||WP:N||WP:BIO1E||WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:IINFO (Wikipedia:Notability)