Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Desbiens (2nd nomination)
The notability standard for music video directors needs to be, and is, that they're the ''subject'' of enough |reliable source coverage to properly support the article. It is not enough that directories and unreliable sources and glancing namechecks of his existence in coverage of the musicians he worked with nominally |verify that he did the claimed work; the requirement is that media coverage exists ''about him''. And even for a musician, a Juno Award nomination would still depend on their being the ''subject'' of reliable source coverage — it would ''not'' make a musician notable enough to be kept if they were so unsourceable otherwise that nominal verification of the Juno nomination in the Juno Awards' own |self-published database of its own nominees was the ''strongest'' source that was actually present anywhere in the entire article. But this isn't based on reliable sources; it's based almost entirely on unreliable and namecheck sources, not reliable source coverage ''about'' Jonathan Desbiens. No prejudice against recreation in the future ''if'' someone can do ''better'' than this, but this as written and sourced still ain't good enough
— User:Bearcat, 20:08, 8 October 2017 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:V||WP:SELFPUB (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)