Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Carroll
What is considered the highest level of competition in hurling? I have no knowledge of hurling at all, and to me this question is very important for determining the notability of this person. If one or both of the leagues he played in were top-level and fully professional, the page would likely meet |athlete notability standards. If not, I don't think sufficient notability is established by the sources, though I do note that the first is apparently to an official organization, which may not establish notability but is not necessarily unreliable. Again, my lack of knowledge of the sport precludes me from being sure in that regard
— User:Giants2008, 23:19, 9 June 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:ATHLETE (Wikipedia:Notability)