Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Hatch
After thinking about it for a day, I still don't see that this person is notable. It appears to me that the consensus of those commenting or voting is that he is notable only because he meets, in the most technical sense, the additional criteria for athletes. The essence of  is that you do not slavishly follow the rules to reach a result that you know is absurd, and we shouldn't do it here. I understand that there is precedent to the contrary, but in this case that amounts to . The most notable thing that can be said about Mr. Hatch is that he was a member of a highly ranked football team, played in part of one game and threw 2 passes. That shouldn't put you into Wikipedia
— User:Xymmax, 13:53, 29 November 2007 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:IAR||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS (Wikipedia:Ignore all rules)