Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cult films (2nd nomination)
Looks like my point was unclear. I'm not nominating because of large size, and certainly not solely because of large size. I'm only pointing at the size as the symptom of the article's inherent and unfixable problem - there's no way to define what is and is not "cult". Frankly, we may as well write List of films that people unexpectedly liked and watch it grow indefinitely - it feels like this list is exactly that.I think the designation of cult film should be done solely on the film's own article, and perhaps also in a category. This list, however, feels |INDISCRIMINATE and I can't say otherwise until each film on the list has a non-empty column called "Notes". If an |ENCYCLOPEDIA are to list cult-films and not a thoughtless free-for-all index, we need to elaborate each and every entry
— User:Gaioa, 18:33, 11 March 2018 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:5P1 (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)