Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pennsylvania Punch Bowl
I think we should be cautious about deleting a magazine that has been published for more than '''100 years'''.  The Ezra Pound reference is impressive.  The article itself is not great and no doubt can be improved but only 3 of 7 sources are self published.  I have to admit that the notability guidelines for magazines are not too clear.  There's little at .  But a quick Google News search found several New York Times and Philadelphia Inquirer articles about the magazine.  And Google Books shows many, many quotes.  I also noticed that there are about 30 college humor magazines on WP.  If this one is deleted, to be consistent we'd probably have to delete most of the others as well
— User:Logical, 06:39, 8 January 2011 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BK (Wikipedia:Notability)