Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Fragile Intellect (2nd nomination)
I think this has been a good discussion that has made a lot of good points about the handling of scientific papers in the popular press. I agree with those points and mostly with the policy reasons for downgrading the article. Basically I am OK with merging it to Gerald Crabtree. But my concern (per {{u|Green Cardamom|GreenC}}) is that bringing over enough of it would overwhelm that article in terms of his overall career. Was it really that important in the course of his career? It seems like there would be problems with  and . In terms of , I think it might be better add a sentence or two about this paper to his article and just leave this article as is, as what it is – a media event, a kind of footnote to a long-standing cultural debate. –&nbsp
— User:Margin1522, 22:33, 10 January 2015 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:DUE||WP:ARTICLESIZE (Wikipedia:Neutral point of view)