Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History Matters
to &nbsp;Appalachian_State_University#Publications. The remark from the IP  user above seems just opinion, and doesn't cite policy, so can be ignored, and the earlier comment does come from the article creator. I must admit to wanting to retain this article (my personal bias), but I can find  few grounds to  do so. Summary text by the journal has been repeated on other university websites and has then been cited here. These don't count, but at least shows its worthy of being included in another organisations useful links. It would be helpful if the article creator could find evidence that helps meets  - although the link they've provided above shows its opinion and advice has indeed been sought by others, but these don't quite do enough to prove notability or that it influential in its field. As it's unlikely  ever to be expanded much, a redirect seems appropriate with perhaps a brief merge/expansion of the entry in the Appalachian State University article, at least until such evidence is forthcoming. I think justifies inclusion as a link in List of history journals.  Regards from the UK
— User:Nick, 23:59, 5 January 2018 (UTC)
Stance: merge
Cited policy: WP:JOURNALCRIT (Wikipedia:Notability)