Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Silich
This is just another one of countless plastic surgeons, who is not notable just because his practice is located in Manhattan, as that island does not transfer notability to its inhabitants. The ''New York Times'' reference is not significant biographical coverage of Silich as a surgeon or as a person, but rather a passing mention and a quotation by him. ''New You'' is a beauty, fashion, entertainment, lifestyle magazine which I do not consider a reliable source for determining the notability of a surgeon or academic. As an assistant professor, he does not meet . A Google search brings up coverage of a murderer with the same surname, but not much else
— User:Cullen328, 08:06, 24 July 2016 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:ACADEMIC (Wikipedia:Notability)