Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jewish Nobel laureates
It serves no purpose (and only creates  issues) because the Nobel Prize committee explicitly states its prize is awarded without consideration to ethnicity, religion, or even nationality. |Ethnicity, by itself, is not notable and the |policy on lists states that a good way of judging whether something is CRUFT|listcruft is by seeing if an article can be written about its contents. List of Freemasons exists because of Freemasonry... but List of Jewish Nobel Prize winners doesn't have a Jews & The Nobel Prize article to substantiate it, and will never have such an article because there's nothing to say except "A good number of Nobel Prize winners had a Jewish parent." Furthermore having members of a distinct ethnic group win the prize ''often'' is also not a list-worthy characteristic. Nobody feels the need to make List of ethnic German Nobel Prize laureates, though if it were created on the same criteria as the Jewish list (having a recent ancestor of German ethnicity), there'd be just as many self-identifying candidates. Also I get the feeling that if  List of ethnic German Nobel Prize laureates did exist, it'd be |trolled into oblivion for being "racist." Furthermore, despite what's being said here, about 1/3rd of the list maintains various other ethnic ancestries in addition to Jewish, and many more have never outright stated they identify as being "Jewish." (e.g., It's never mentioned that Otto Wallach -- who is frequently listed as only ''Jewish'' -- is only approximately 1/4th Jewish by ethnic descent -- his Jewish grandfather having converted to Protestantism and the remainder of his ancestors being ethnic Germans
— [[User talk:Bulldog123|Bulldog123]], 21:27, 25 November 2010 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:BATTLEGROUND||WP:EIN||WP:LIST||WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:TROLL (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)