Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tall men
The most common reason for deletion I'm seeing is that any inclusion criterion for the article would be "arbitrary".  However, all you really mean by that is that there are a great many alternatives.  '''So what?!?!'''  In that sense, every WP policy and guideline is ''arbitrary'', as there are many possible alternatives to them.  For example, instead of not allowing |original research, WP could allow it.  There is nothing wrong with an arbitrary criterion for inclusion, as long as it is reached by '''consensus''' on the article's talk page.  So far, such a discussion (to establish consensus) has not taken place.  Also, my original vote/comment is about 10-12 votes above
— User:Black, 17:08, 23 January 2007 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NOR (Wikipedia:No original research)