Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jo Matumoto
I dont see the need for the |personal attack on Alex.  The person's notability was not readily apparent until he nominated the article for AfD.  So this directly improved the quality of the article and WP, which I can only see as productive.  Personally, I'm more disappointed with the article creator for not keeping the article in their |user page until there was minimum evidence in the article as to why a minor league player should be considered notable so an AfD would never be in question
— User:Bagumba, 19:48, 20 July 2011 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NPA||WP:UP (Wikipedia:No personal attacks)