Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightsaber combat (4th nomination)
As an additional aside...a more appropriate check for notability guidelines on this subject is .  Somehow, I don't think anyone will argue that Star Wars is a work of fiction.  As to whether or not lightsaber combat is considered a major or minor concept within Star Wars...well, the vast majority of SW fiction certainly contains instances of lightsaber combat, particularly the prequel era works and the post-movie works.  Within the genre, I would say that it has distinctly established notability.  The OR argument has been debunked so many times in this AfD that I suspect people are simply not even trying to look at the references section of the article.  Ironically, I feel Moreschi has the best take on this-chunks of the article do need cleaned up, because Wikipedia isn't a how-to guide; the article on Karate doesn't go into detail on how to perform its art; neither should this article try to do the same.  Those segments of the article should be removed
— User:Gjd001, 14:05, 12 March 2007 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:FICT (Wikipedia:Notability)