Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doreen McAndrew DiDomenico
all. Refactoring comment as I misunderstood: DeGise was never the mayor of Jersey City, he just ran and lost. But being county executive is ''not'' an automatic notability boost, over and above anybody else on the freeholder board, in the ''absence'' of enough |reliable source coverage about him to clear , and neither is having been a ''city councillor'' in Jersey City — but the sourcing for him isn't notably better than it is for any of the others (it's actually ''weaker'' than some of them.) The only evidence I see of "nationalized" coverage here is a single article from ''The New York Times'' — but that article isn't about DeGise, but rather merely namechecks his existence in coverage ''about'' the guy DeGise ''lost'' to in the mayoral race. And in the context of ''Jersey City'', it represents ''local'' coverage within the NYT's ''local'' coverage area — but when a person's notability claim falls under one of those subject areas where we require nationalized rather than purely local coverage, such as city councillors and county executives, then they do ''not'' get a free notability boost ''just'' because they happen live in the NYC Metro and so their local coverage happens to be in ''The New York Times'' instead of ''The Palookaville Herald''. It still represents ''local'' coverage, not wider coverage that inherently makes them ''more'' notable than other people who hold the same job, and get the same amount of local coverage, further away from New York City. And none of the others have any strong or well-sourced claim of notability at all either. To get over , an officeholder at the ''county'' level of office has to show the substance and sourcing to support a credible claim that they're ''more'' notable than most other people at the same level — and that still holds true ''regardless'' of whether they were just a regular freeholder or an executive
— User:Bearcat, 16:21, 26 February 2018 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NPOL (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)