Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of professional wrestling matches rated 5 or more stars by Dave Meltzer
There's a lot of commentary here that isn't based on WP policy. It doesn't matter that these are just his opinions (so is every award for something subjective - like the Oscars). It doesn't matter that he's arbitrary (so, again, are the Oscars). It doesn't matter whether this list |is/is not useful or |interesting. What matters is , , and . That's all that matters really in this particular AFD. Based on these sources (https://www.inquisitr.com/5607224/wwe-news-pete-dunne-criticizes-this-years-pwi-500-list-and-dave-meltzers-star-rating-system/ 1 https://www.si.com/wrestling/2018/08/15/dave-meltzer-observer-star-ratings-wwe-njpw 2 http://whatculture.com/wwe/10-wrestling-observer-newsletter-star-ratings-dave-meltzer-got-wrong 3) I can see that they probably are since Meltzer's ratings for matches are discussed as a group in what appear to be reliable (at least passes for ), independent sources
— User:FOARP, 11:26, 6 September 2019 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:USEFUL||WP:INTERESTING||WP:NLIST||WP:NOT||WP:V||WP:NEWSORG (Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions)