Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christmas Tree (Lady GaGa song)
merge strongly preferred.  Extremely strong do-not-delete edit history.  While song is totally not notable it is by a Grammy-nominated artist whose album hit the top-10 in charts in several countries.  In my book, this qualifies under the "all works by this very notable artists get a free pass"  exception.   recommends redirects for non-notable songs, so I'm kind of surprised this went to AFD instead of a  proposal or even a  redirect and merge.  I do not think a merge would be controversial at this time.  It would be a shame to lose the edit history and have some editor later spend time rewriting the article should this song ever become notable in its own right
— User:davidwr, 18:33, 19 December 2008 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:IAR||WP:SONGS||WP:MERGE||WP:BOLD (Wikipedia:Ignore all rules)