Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Letter of British Jews on 60th anniversary of Israel
on deletion but if kept, '''move''' to We're Not Celebrating Israel's Anniversary, the title under which the letter was published. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/apr/30/israelandthepalestinians Epson has already responded to SelfEvidentTruths' points but I have an additional comment on point 2. The idea that "the letter is surprising and newsworthy in that it runs contrary to the official Israeli line that the State of Israel somehow represents all Jews worldwide, and that all Jews are proud (or should be proud) of what it's doing today and what it did in the past" makes it seem that Jews who are critical of Israel are normally unheard of and thus the open letter is something nobody would have expected. This is hard to believe given that :Category:Jewish anti-occupation groups has 22 entries (including this article). As to point 3, "it's signed by more than 100 prominent, well-known Jews who have achieved significant accompolishments and are public personalities" is belied by the fact that so many of the signatories are not actually that prominent or well-known. In fact, for some of them, a large number of their Google hits seem to come from their association with this letter. Finally, the article may purport to be "balanced and neutral" but the article seems to give |undue weight to the letter by quoting from it, then reprinting the entire letter, then reprinting the entire list of signatories
— User:Metropolitan90, 04:14, 28 May 2008 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:UNDUE (Wikipedia:Neutral point of view)