Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Irrational Atheist
While I'm not sure that they'll check back in, if they do, I'd like to request the keep people who are saying "it's notable enough for an encyclopedia" to please explain how it meets either of the relevant notability guidelines-- or .  To simply assert that it is notable is not enough.  As a side note, that it's in 118 libraries is also insufficient, as that's not one of our criteria (and, to be honest, I'd argue that only 118 libraries actually practically proves a lack of notability, as that is a tiny number in my opinion--and the very fact that we disagree shows why that's not enough to verify notability
— User:Qwyrxian, 23:18, 6 October 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:GNG||WP:BK (Wikipedia:Notability)