Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judson Laipply
1.''' As someone who seems to be "up" on Wikipedia rules, you should know better than to make an edit (even a small one) to someone else's comments in a discussion thread. I'm sure you wouldn't appreciate it if I started doing it to your comments. Please don't do it to mine. If you think I took something out of context, then YOU can put it into context entirely in YOUR comment. '''2.''' I agree that I took criteria from "notable actors and television personalities" ''because'' there is no criteria for internet video personalities and yes, I could have made that clearer. '''3.''' The subject still passes the alternative  "Google Test" (gets lots of distinguishable hits on Google or another well known search mechanism) by a country mile - 65,800 hits on Google for "Judson Laipply" and 634,000 for "Evolution of Dance". That alone gets ''my'' '''keep''' vote. '''4.''' I've already agreed that independent citations are needed for a couple statements made on the page. I've fixed some and requested one more. I'm sure it can be found. If not, it only means the deletion of one sentence - not the entire page. In my personal opinion, there is ''no way'' this page should be deleted
— User:CindyLooWho, 05:51, 24 August 2006 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:BIO (Wikipedia:Notability)