Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed Carfrey
Appears to satisfy  as a professional baseball player with a 15-plus year career.  I'm finding quite a lot of information on Carfrey.  He did not just play one game.  He had a career in professional baseball that appears to have run from 1882 through at least 1897.  He also played in an 1891 game that attempted, unsuccessfully, to introduce the sport of indoor, winter baseball.  Most of his career was in the minor leagues, but he does seem to have received a good deal of coverage over the years.  Of course, on-line information is quite limited for 19th Century baseball players, but I'm adding some of what I've found
— User:Cbl62, 03:42, 26 June 2012 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:GNG (Wikipedia:Notability)