Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jewish American entertainers
Comment: Not that I disagree with this nomination but... aren't we cherry-picking here? These pages are not ''unlike'' the Nobel Prize list at all. You can probably find more external reading about Jewish American entertainers than Jewish Nobel Prize laureates by a mile. I don't understand why you're using it as an example of a "good list" when '''all''' these lists have the same inherent problem -- they |synthesize relationships where there are none. It's passive |original research. Unless everybody on this list is somehow related to Yiddish theatre or Jewish comedy... their Judaism has no bearing on their careers as entertainers (though conspiracy theorists will have us believe otherwise). Simply because "Look Who's Jewish!" cites somebody as a Jew, doesn't mean we are encyclopedically BOUND to report that, and that applies equally to the Nobel Prize list
— [[User talk:Bulldog123|Bulldog123]], 02:29, 26 November 2010 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:SYNTH||WP:OR (Wikipedia:No original research)