Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinnyx
per , , , , and . Without getting into |the weeds of whether a particular source is significant or reliable, I want to address the big picture. Wikipedians have long had a consensus that producers are ordinary and run of the mill, because their job - while important to the industry and them - does not actually entail creating anything by themselves (they collaborate with and direct musicians). They are not otherwise notable for doing anything at all but their jobs; using a mult box does not require a college degree or a great deal of talent. Actually notable producers tend to own their own studios, are members of an academy such as the Grammys, have long careers, help create innovative or ''avant garde'' work, bring together artists from different genres, have been interviewed by the media for their work, and win awards for their work. I don't see any of that here. SIGCOV creates a ''presumption'' that someone is notable, but many red links direct you to deleted articles about people who've had significant coverage in reliable sources. (I don't want to embarrass anybody, but if you insist, I have the receipts.) I also note that NMUSIC applies to specific issues that musicians and bands deal with; they are notable not for what they write on the bus, but rather for performing in public, even as small as a house concert. For that reason, studio musicians are rarely considered notable. In 2020, everybody knows that Wikipedia is a private charity; thus nobody has a right to have anything |hosted by us. There's certainly no legal right; see https://www.reuters.com/article/us-google-lawsuit-censorship/google-defeats-conservative-nonprofits-youtube-censorship-appeal-idUSKCN20K33L recent https://www.cnet.com/news/federal-court-tosses-out-tulsi-gabbards-google-lawsuit/ caselaw. You certainly wouldn't demand that the Girl Scouts donate a share of their cookies to your charity, or demand an Episcopal church to host your denomination's rites, or a youth hostel to let you crash there without being a member. The same goes here. To save your article, you still have the burden to find details about a public figure's life (school, relationships, charitable work, etc.), and much more on his song-writing and Platinum certifications. I encourage sysops to give the proponent(s) a week's time to fix this article
— User:Bearian, 20:41, 6 March 2020 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:MILL||WP:NBAND||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG||WP:WIKILAWYER||WP:NOTWEBHOST (Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill)