Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul John Dykes
perhaps .  Claim to notability is based on 2 books about Scottish football.  The first is said to have inspired a documentary, but the documentary does not appear to have come out yet.  There appear to have been no published reviews of either book.  The first book did attract a small amount of attention when it was announced that it would become a documentary film.  Finally, both books were included in The Scotsman's  lists of the 20 or so ''Top Sports Books'' of the year.  Not at the top of the lists, and I am tempted to suspect that The Scotsman included them because of the local angle - and editorial need to include a local book, at least, inclusion on such a list would be more persuasive if it was in a newspaper published in Dublin or Sydney.  In addition, I have some suspicion that this article may be intended to assist with promotion of that documentary, if it is actually going to come out.  If that is the case, one of the editors active on the page or in this discussion might want to offer to move this article to userspace, and bring it back when/if the film or a more notable book makes this writer notable
— User:E, 20:42, 20 February 2017 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:TOOSOON (Wikipedia:Too soon)