Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A-Girl (2nd nomination)
Notable author, yes, but not so overwhelmingly notable that automatically everything she writes is notable. Notable publisher is irrelevant, as notability is not inherited in that way. Length of serialization is not a clause of  and proposals to add it have always lacked anything close to consensus. If the anime were a television series, then it would be an automatic notable, but it's an OVA, which means it has to demonstrate notability with, for ex, reviews. So, no, not ironclad. That said, there is one very strong indication of notability, which User:Starblind doesn't mention, which is that it was republished in a new edition -- that doesn't happen unless there's strong continuing interest. It's not on its own enough to ''demonstrate'' notability, but it means the work should not be dismissed out of hand without a good hard look for reviews and the like. Withholding my !vote for now till I have a chance to do said searching
— User:Quasirandom, 14:11, 4 June 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:BK (Wikipedia:Notability)