Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David W. Allan
Thanks and kudos to {{u|Johnpacklambert|John Pack Lambert}} for a careful and balanced nomination. I'm not entirely sure about this either, but when I {{diff|David W. Allan|prev|653950733|removed the copyvio}} (i.e., essentially the whole article/eulogy written by his son) in 2015, I was persuaded by the cites and the IEEE award that he passed the bar and so did not request deletion as G12. It may be worth noting that our page on the Rabi Award was written by the same |COI editor. {{u|Claude J}}, is this a significant or notable award, can you tell us? If not, perhaps that page should be nominated too
— User:Justlettersandnumbers, 13:04, 24 November 2016 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:COI (Wikipedia:Conflict of interest)