Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guillotine (character)
though a little weak).  Keep because GNG is satisfied, but weak because she's pretty minor.  I remember trying to sort out what came first, the game or the comic since that was the initial reasoning for having an article by {{re|Arnabdas}}. Doesn't seem like {{u|Arnabdas}} is active recently to chime in, but regardless, I think there's enough out there outside of the game (even if not in the article) to say that reception for the character does .  For example:ComicsVerse https://comicsverse.com/contest-of-champions-1-are-you-not-entertained/ was intrigued to see more of her, and found her fascinating with the way she was weaved into history.http://web.archive.org/web/20170729004055/https://www.geekedoutnation.com/comic-book-review-contest-of-champions-1/ Another review was interested to know where the author would take the character after the setup and unique story.https://www.adventuresinpoortaste.com/2015/10/07/contest-of-champions-1-review/ AIPT praised the art/design of the character (and artwork is half of comics), as did https://www.newsarama.com/26311-best-shots-reviews-amazing-spider-man-1-batman-robin-eternal-1-axcend-1-more.html Newsarama who especially praised the coloring.  AIPT also found her story "efficient and interesting" given only a few pages, while Newsarama was more critical of her story, though criticism is still GNG material.  Bottom line, my vote is not to delete. I don't think a merge/redirect is unreasonable, but I don't know where, that discussion can be handled on the talk page by the appropriate project(s) outside AfD
— User:2pou, 20:47, 3 December 2019 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NEXIST (Wikipedia:Notability)