Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cinhil Haldane
An element from a fictional series spanning a score of books and running for nearly 50 years. Even a cursory review of ISFDB listings would show a significant quantity of reviews and criticism of the series. There's even running, right now at tor.com, an extensive analysis of the series and its characters (more than a year of weekly installments, and not even half done!) by the notable writer/academic Judith Tarr, which itself cites commentary on the series by Ursula LeGuin. Since the nominator has admitted their practice of noncompliance with , their opinion should be given little or no weight
— User:Hullaballoo, 00:36, 16 January 2017 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BEFORE (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion)