Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ji Yoon
Disagree with the statement 'Yoon has only been member of one notable ensemble' as I'm seeing several, unless being a session musician doesn't count as being a ''real'' member of a band, which I think is a pretty  assertion. Even failing that, a redirect to 4minute would fail to appease criteria 10, since it doesn't either a) recognise the party as legitimately worthy of their own page or b) provide a meaningful redirect the appropriate article, but a completely different one instead! It seems clear in my mind the intent of that additional clause on p10 was to protect against it being used for someone with no other notes of point, which is not the case here. I make that assertion on the grounds the suggested remedy (redirect to the page of the TV show, in this instance) is clearly out of touch with this scenario
— User:Rushyo, 23:48, 3 December 2011 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:bold (Wikipedia:Be bold)