Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carson Cooman
He sounds a talented man with many achievements; I have tried to be convinced, but the article doesn't establish it as my opinion that he is notable per .  The article says he has composed 600 works - a reference to a review of one of them by a reviewer in a national journal independently opining that it is a notable composition would convince me.  I notice that one of the hundreds of works the article says he has premiered is by Peter Maxwell Davies, although the piece was not written for him; however, although this appears to be his most notable first performance, it does not of itself convince me, either; I was somewhat surprised that it is not mentioned in the article.  His activities as journal editor, music reviewer, and collaborator with authors would be good article content if he were otherwise notable.  Notable teachers (and Bernard Rands and Gillian Weir ''certainly'' are notable) do not confer notability on the pupil.  The references cited are his own website and Musikfabrik, neither qualifies as |independent
— User:RobertG, 14:50, 27 September 2006 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:MUSIC||WP:RS (Wikipedia:Notability)