Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hide the Decline
Where is the significant depth of coverage required by ? Is it in one source that treats the subject in depth or is it a large number of brief mentions that together show depth of coverage, or something in between? For an article subject that attacks someone (who falls well above marginal notability himself, but isn't famous), the sourcing should be airtight. Wikipedia has a number of articles that have very negative information on people who are notable but not very famous. It might be a good idea to change BLP policy to disallow articles like this, about subjects that may be marginally notable attacks (in this case suggesting, with a laugh, that a notable scientist is a liar). We should expect a lot more of these in the future. For now, I'm undecided on keep/delete
— User:JohnWBarber, 12:45, 27 June 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:N (Wikipedia:Notability)