Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seven day roguelike (2nd nomination)
In the reasoning for reopening the AfD, it was claimed the article failed to provide the  that was promised in the previous AfD.  Not having witnessed the previous AfD and only having the logs to go by, I don't see any such promise.  Indeed, users such as Lankybugger quite clearly state the only  are roguebasin/rgrd.  Despite this, the consensus was keep.  So what new information is prompting yet another round of bickering?   (One reason for my Merge request is that I see even a Keep consensus as being pointless as it will just be another 6 months before it gets AfDed once more, wasting everyone's time that could be better spent writing roguelikes (or, heaven forbid, improving Wikipedia articles rather than defending/deleting them
— User:JeffLait, 23:45, 14 July 2007 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:N||WP:V (Wikipedia:Notability)