Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John W. Goode
I'm not impressed with the sourcing and Richard Arthur Norton would do well to read them. The ''Alcalde'' mention is in a deceased alumni section and Goode doesn't get an actual obit, just a mention. It's a fine citation to source his education but GNG requires that there is sufficient coverage to confer notability. The other sources are also problematic. The University of Texas|U-T link talks about an archive of pictures from ''San Antonio Express-News'' where Goode is pictured. That Goode had his picture in the paper isn't notable nor is the fact the University has said pictures. It's fine to use the website as a source but again, people are trying to hang general notability on this stuff. There's an old issue of ''The Historian (journal)|The Historian'' listing my name as a member of Phi Alpha Theta and that's fine to source my membership but you can't call me generally notable if you pile up a half-dozen such mentions. In all, I think Goode ought to be the subject of some good secondary-source academic writing in the future and that would suffice for notability. Right now, I'm guessing Goode fails our notability criteria although I'm not going to vote for deletion because I'm not a deletionist and I think there will be enough coverage for us to presume notability. Let's also remember Goode also fails 
— User:Chris, 15:05, 18 May 2016 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:MILPEOPLE (Wikipedia:Notability)