Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Nokia products (2nd nomination)
1. ''non-notable products'' () - to argue this, I think you would have to argue against the existence of the linked articles about each phone and series. If they exist, this list is useful, and much better than a Category. 2. ''not a directory'' - None of #DIR apply (1 - these topics are clearly not loosely associated; 2 - not genealogical or phonebook; 3/4 are aimed at avoiding promotional material, whereas this is archival). Similarly 3 - It is hardly ''indiscriminate'' (#INFO). Personally, I have just this week found this article a very useful resource after starting work at phone-related company - finding information and comparisons on non-current models is not as easy as it might be. (You may take that as a declaration of interest if you wish, but I've also found it useful before) That said, I agree with comment here and in the previous AfD (and in Talk:List_of_Nokia_products|Talk) that the page needs cleaning up. (Aside: the revision history suggests that you proposed this ''before'' reading the previous AfD debate, and I don't feel that this AfD adds anything new
— User:Royan, 10:02, 28 August 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NN||WP:NOT||WP:NOT (Wikipedia:Notability)