Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 404 podcast
I, and other editors here, disagree. This is clearly a CNET production.  The shows email address is @cnet.com , the podcast is listed in iTunes under artist "CNET.com".  Previous comments on this article identified it as a CNET production.  That was when it was used as an argument to show its notability. Now its being argued not to be a CNET production in hopes of fitting it into 's criteria.  This isn't a game of save the article, we cant have it both ways.  Also, please don't accuse editors of bad faith and let's focus on discussing the merits of this article.  This isn't an us vs. them contest.  This discussion is quickly becoming very polarized.  Disagreement doesn't equate to bad faith.  Also, while the podcast's tactics are not a disqualifier for a Wikipedia article, they need to be taken into account by the closing admin in determining if creation protection should be applied should the outcome here be delete
— User:RadioFan, 19:17, 26 July 2009 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:WEB (Wikipedia:Notability)