Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Astrid Besser
If we are compelled to go strictly by  then this player is notable, I would say, but common sense surely says otherwise, and that the policy, therefore, needs to be replaced with sport-specific criteria for notability.   For baseball, appearing in at least one major league or Olympics/World Classic tourney team roster (or making one such level appearance?) should be the minimum while for tennis, for singles, maybe then its one appearance in a main draw of a tier I WTA event or ATP 250 or higher, etc., etc.  I don t want to see WP watered down with 20 000 to 100 000 bios for each sport (such complete 'blanketing' should occur for sport-specific wikis, not WP
— User:Mayumashu, 23:33, 17 August 2009 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:ATHLETE (Wikipedia:Notability)