Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isis Nile (2nd nomination)
per |DEL8 for lack of notability under any of the applicable guidelines.The available coverage falls far short of the significant, independent, and reliable coverage required by |GNG and |BASIC. Of the |BIO additional criteria, |ENT and |PORNBIO points 1 and 2 are clearly inapplicable. The third PORNBIO criterion—multiple appearances in notable mainstream media—deserves analysis. Setting aside sourcing issues, Ms. Nile's supposed role as an unnamed dancer on ''Soul Train'' could be understood as her being "featured multiple times in notable mainstream media," thus satisfying PORNBIO. However, read in context with the rest of the BIO guideline, and appreciating the significance indicated by the word "featured," I do not believe such a permissive interpretation is correct. Instead, I read the criterion to require that the pornographic performer have appeared in and been covered personally and significantly ("featured") by multiple mainstream shows: this aligns with the intent of BIO and |the purpose of the notability requirement.Furthermore, even if PORNBIO were met here, PORNBIO, as with the other BIO additional criteria, is to be used in mine run cases where notability is plausible; it is not to be used to find notability where notability is obviously lacking. ''See'' #Additonal_criteria|BIO § Additional criteria ("Meeting one or more additional criteria does '''not''' guarantee that a subject should be included."); ''cf.'' |WHYN. Ultimately, the notability requirement isn't about whether or not someone deserves to be included; it's about whether or not it's possible to write a balanced (|NPOV), reliable (|RS), useful article based on secondary sources (|OR, |SYNTH
— User:Rebbing, 03:02, 11 December 2016 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:DEL8||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:BIO||WP:ENT||WP:PORNBIO||WP:WHYN||WP:BIO||WP:WHYN||WP:NPOV||WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:SYNTH (Wikipedia:Deletion policy)