Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fan translation
I agree with what Kitsune Sniper said. Just because there are problems with the article does not mean that it's not a valid topic for Wikipedia. Characterising editors who contribute to this article as "ultra-anal geeks" probably is a violation of , even if their contributions do not meet with Wikipedia standards. I admit that  is somewhat of a problem, since a lot of facts about this topic are only to be found in community forums or blogs. That still doesn't mean that this is not an encyclopedic topic, it just means there are difficulties to work around. Above all, there is no reason to merge this article into fansub, although the opposite merge might be valid. This article is not about subtitling anime
— User:Soluzar, 18:01, 12 July 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:CIVIL||WP:V (Wikipedia:Civility)