Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of HIV-positive people
on the basis that names should only be appearing on the list where they are notable ''for being'' HIV positive (eg Ryan White and Rebekka Armstrong), per , rather than merely being notable ''and'' being verifiably HIV positive.  There would be nothing wrong with a list formed on this basis.  I realise that  takes a different approach, allowing for the creation of lists of notable people sharing a verifiable but unnotable characteristic, but I believe that  is the practice more recently followed by the community at AfD (see the recent debates on race/profession interesections).  In the event that I am wrong about this approach to list selection criteria, and that a list of notable people sharing an unnotable characteristic is theoretically a valid list, I would change my vote to delete based upon the list having no encyclopaedic value
— User:DustFormsWords, 05:10, 5 January 2011 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:LSC||WP:NLIST||WP:LSC (Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists)