Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shalom Reimer
Appreciate the neutral notification to revisit this AfD, given my delete !vote above. Thank you for your clear argument and digging up those sources, as well.  isn't a guarantee, or a presumption, of notability, rather a suggestion that "coverage probably exists, go find it!" imo. Indeed, it states as much on the page. We do very frequently delete things that appear to 'meet' the additional criteria in  (there's a ongoing WT discussion regarding SNGs, tangential to this area, which may be of interest btw). I don't think a bunch of regional sources which are a couple of paragraphs at most which practically just state "Reimer won Miss Teen BC this year!" is significant coverage. It's pretty much un-of-the-mill; we don't give articles to every other pageant contest winner, year after year, especially when nothing else is likely to come of it. / applies as overriding exclusionary criteria. The vast majority of such individuals tend to not go further into pageantry. This individual is notable for one event in 2016, nothing since, and it's unlikely she will. She doesn't have the substantial coverage required for her own article. Hence I continue to support deletion, as we've done with previous individuals of this genre, and I believe she should be listed in the table at Miss Teen BC
— User:ProcrastinatingReader, 20:55, 9 July 2020 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:ANYBIO||WP:NBIO||WP:R||WP:BIO1E||WP:BLP1E (Wikipedia:Notability)