Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louisa Thiers
DHanson317, your contributions to six AFDs each argue based on an implied belief in "inherent notability" for the individual criteria you state. While further consensus is still sought at the discussion link in the nom, I believe it established that there is no consensus for biography-level notability inhering in single-source cases on such broad criteria: the few cases truly inherently notable also turn out to be |generally notable. Consensus indicates instead that these individuals have only line-item notability, i.e., one reliable source would permit the individual to be (only) a line-item in one or more list articles: and in your six cases, the individual is in an average of ''seven WP lists already'', which is still excessive
— User:John, 20:55, 6 December 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:GNG (Wikipedia:Notability)