Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Magic: The Gathering keywords
This article easily passes #GUIDE, as it contains more that just a rote listing of game mechanics.  The article covers not only the keywords themselves but the history of the keyword, set in which the keyword was introduced, and in some cases the effects the introduction of a new keyword had on existing cards.  I believe this falls well under the "analysis and critical commentary" criteria.  Additionally, the mere listing of game rules does not make an article a "game guide"; the article is about the keywords present in the Magic: the Gathering card game, so it would make little sense to mention the terms without defining them.  The article does not go into any great detail explaining the terms and does not provide any sort of "how-tos" or examples; if it had, ''that'' would be a game guide.  As it is the article glosses over certain details anyway and does not even provide enough information to be used as an instruction manual, much less a game guide. -- |Y'''&#124
— User:Yukichigai, 05:53, 10 July 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOT||WP:IKNOWBEST (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)