Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Vinatea (3rd nomination)
The Keep proponents in the previous AfDs ''solely'' based their stance on the fact that being an engineer for prominent musicians means that the subject somehow passes  and is notable.  Errr, excuse me?  Do we also cite the artist who did the album cover art, or the musician's agent, both of whom likewise materially contribute to a musician's success?  Of course not, because ''|notability is not inherited.'' Beyond that, this unwarranted stretching of the notability criteria misses the fundamental premise of notability criteria: that you can claim notability for (say) a popular artist because someone with a song at the top of the Billboard charts can be presumed to be featured in multiple citations in reliable sources, and so pass the GNG.  No such presumption can be made about a sound engineer, be the musicians for whom he works ever so notable.  So ... show me the sources.  Period
— User:Ravenswing, 15:49, 9 December 2010 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:MUSIC||WP:INHERITED (Wikipedia:Notability)