Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Taylor (second baseman)
Does not meet , but does appear to meet .  He was a first-team All-American for Baseball America, what appears to be one of only two recognized sources for that year (see 1989 College Baseball All-America Team).  Admittedly, college baseball is well below football or basketball, but he was a first-team selection.  Obviously would be nice if he were a unanimous selection, but since he made one of only two teams we could say he is a consensus selection, so I would say he meets the standard to presume notability.  Considering the fact that they player's prime was 25-30 years ago, I think finding sources will be a challenge.  In view of that, I give the presumption its due, presume sources are out there, and say keep
— User:RonSigPi, 22:49, 10 April 2017 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NBASE||WP:NCOLLATH (Wikipedia:Notability)