Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ilsa Paulson
Are people arguing under the GNG or under ? I don't quite follow the above arguments. If under the GNG, there doesn't appear to be SIGCOV. If under , nobody that's !voted appears to have read the guideline. As far as I can tell, she doesn't meet any of the 10 criteria; particularly: she hasn't finished top-8 "in a competition at the highest level outside of the Olympic Games and world championships" (e.g. the guideline specifically lists the 6 World Major Marathons as instances of this requirement) nor has she competed in the IAAF World Half Marathon Championships (again listed in the guideline). The USA Marathon Championships are not on the aforementioned, while her other non-top-8 results are not in any of the previously mentioned categories (nor are they top-8!). Yes, they're all amazing feats, but they don't make her inherently notable per the guideline cited, and when it comes to coverage that would support inclusion per general notability, there is nothing substantial either, unless someone can provide several quality sources. Can anyone please elucidate which notability criteria she satisfies, and how? Best
— User:PK650, 23:22, 2 February 2020 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NATH (Wikipedia:Notability)