Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shabbos App
The most interesting question to me in this fD is what |"promotion" means. Does anyone think a Rabbinical authority is likely to be influenced by a Wikipedia article to declare this app halachically acceptable? These are ''religious'' questions. The last I looked Wikipedia was a secular project. There are religious questions that only an authority conversant in halacha can address. We cannot "promote" the acceptability of this Mobile app. It is impossible. Can someone tell me what else we might be trying to promote by hosting this article on our project? Sources are abundant. This is an interesting question. Is it possible to make cellphone-use halachically-compliant for Jewish-Sabbath use? This is an article on that. There are no shortage of good quality sources weighing in on this. Most or all are doubtful that there is any way of getting around the several reasons that cellphone use would be prohibited for observant Jews on the Sabbath. But the discussion is taking place in many reliable sources. Wouldn't that give us the green light to proceed with an article on the subject
— User:Bus, 12:29, 13 October 2014 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:A||WP:SPIP (Wikipedia:Attribution)