Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broad homeland hypothesis
This article is about a theory, based on one book by Kilian, which has not acquired any support from the academic community. The article itself seems to be |synthesis and |original research. It confuses Kilian's proposal with that of Hausler, who argues in favour of an easten european homeland, although they are quite different. Part of this confusion also results in false claims about the the general acceptance of Kilian's theory. There has been little academic take-up of Kilian's theory; in the only review I could find, Renfrew dismissed it as too far from mainstream theories. The term broad homeland does not seem to be currently used in mainstream literature. The fact that the article has existed for a long time is irrelevant; it is pushing a fringe point of view as if it were an accepted piece of mainstream academic research
— User:Mathsci, 23:46, 17 July 2008 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:SYN||WP:OR (Wikipedia:No original research)