Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disenchantment: The Guardian and Israel
It must be pointed out that The Guardian commissioned the book "to justify itself", so any review (e.g. #9) coming in anyway from the The Guardian is worthless. Five other refs are not possible to verify without a subscription. Ref #1 is more a discussion about The Guardian than the book it commissioned. Ref #2 appears to be about the fact that The Guardian commissioned the book about itself. #5 is about The Guardian which uses the book commissioned by The Guardian as a discussion point. One subscription item does state that it is a review of the book, so assuming that one of the other subscription refs is a review, the book passes . However, I'm not going to assume that
— User:VMS, 08:28, 14 May 2015 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NBOOK (Wikipedia:Notability)