Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bullshido.net (4th nomination)
I think it might be useful to quote the definition of "trivial coverage" from , in order to prevent ad-hoc definitions from being used:Trivial coverage, such as (1) newspaper articles that simply report the Internet address, (2) newspaper articles that simply report the times at which such content is updated or made available, (3) a brief summary of the nature of the content or the publication of Internet addresses and site or (4) content descriptions in Internet directories or Electronic commerce|online stores.Note what this ''doesn't'' say.  It doesn't require that the subject of the Wikipedia article be the primary subject of the source of the mention.  It doesn't require that the website be described in intimate detail.  It is designed to avoid references to the URL only, to brief general statements of the nature of the site, or to automatic aggregators.The ''Real Fighter'' article does not fall under this definition because it references specific activities undertaken by Bullshido that were relevant, indeed central, to the subject of the article.  The TV spot doesn't fall under it either.  Certainly the ''Kung Fu Magazine'' article exceeds this criterion.Any vote to delete which does not address these points directly and in detail, with reference to the details of Wikipedia policy rather than just blurbs, is not adding anything informative to the discussion
— User:Cy, 00:36, 27 May 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:WEB (Wikipedia:Notability)