Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of recordings with a prominent flanging effect
as original deprodder despite the concerns I raised on the talkpage, and my general dislike of lists. This is a sourced (partially, but the remainder could be sourced by a dedicated editor with a copy of ''The Rough Guide to Music''), interesting and useful list. (Before anyone starts quoting |ATA at me, can I remind them that that's a ''personal essay'' not a policy.) As TTH says, this kind of list is one of the reasons Wikipedia shines while the wannabes fall by the wayside; something that will never be included in Britannica or even Knol, but is potentially very valuable to someone researching the subject. I'm baffled by the use of  as a nomination reason - quite aside from the fact that LC is, again, a personal essay, this is the type of list specifically ''not'' considered as "listcruft" in that essay; Flanging|a parent article exists, and the list would be disproportionately long as part of the parent article
— User:Iridescent, 22:28, 3 January 2008 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:ATA||WP:LISTCRUFT (Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions)