Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canoeing at the 2010 Summer Youth Olympics – Girls' K1 slalom
for now, until a broader consensus can be determined for the notability or not of the Youth Olympics.  This AfD is not the place to determine that consensus; deleting a ''single'' article out of :Category:2010 Summer Youth Olympics events is not a good result.  Either they all stay, or all go.  Yes, I know about OTHERSTUFF etc. but I think that these articles are essentially a summary-style treatment of main YOG articles, so a consistent treatment must be applied.  I reject any statement that previous consensus for the "regular" Olympic Games should apply here.  The YOG are clearly a new event with an entirely different criteria for competition, and a vastly different amount of media attention–and therefore, secondary sources.  I have yet to see any significant secondary coverage at the ''event'' level, so my own opinion is that the set of per-sport articles in :Category:2010 Summer Youth Olympics should be used, but the per-event articles should be deleted.  (I am also unconvinced that the complete set of per-nation articles in :Category:Nations at the 2010 Summer Youth Olympics should exist.)  In other words, the summary-style treatment of YOG is still necessary, just not to the same level of detail that we have for the summary-style treatment of the main Games.  I make these comments even as a long-time ikiProject Olympics member and a staunch supporter of per-event and per-nation articles for the main Games.  I propose that a RfC be used to attain a broader YOG consensus before any action is taken here
— User:Andrwsc, 17:54, 28 August 2010 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:W (Help:Watchlist)