Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Baker (shogi)
We shouldn't nominate articles for deletion on valid noteworthy topics simply due to weaknesses in the article's current state.  I agree that someone who is an expert Shogi player, who merely happens to be a professor, is unlikely to be notable.  But I am concerned that Alan Baker may be a notable academic, and I would feel a lot more comfortable if nominator had shown they had complied with .  Would the NYTimes have used questions from one of his exams in their pop quiz column if he was a nobody
— User:Geo, 03:06, 29 March 2014 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:BEFORE (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion)