Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NeoGAF (4th nomination)
Like the 1UP article says, the userbase isn't merely "fanatical" but actually includes industry insiders. And while Alexa ratings aren't really part of , in this case the relatively low rating can be explained by the fact that the board being so industry focused. The larger gaming sites the nominator is comparing neogaf to are aimed at a general public interested in the games themselves, while the neogaf discussions often revolve around the industry behind the games, a more narrow field of interest
— User:Titney, 19:21, 8 December 2008 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:WEB (Wikipedia:Notability)