Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Talk:Mark Boguski
procedurally, as a severely malformatted nomination. The nominator apparently does not know how to properly list an article for an AfD. At the moment, neither the article nor its talk page are tagged with an AfD tag. There is still a PROD tag, placed by the nominator, at the article itself. If the nominator wishes to list the article (rather than its talk page) for an AfD, this needs to be re-done from sctratch by following the instructions at . If the nominator only wishes to have the talk page of the article deleted, the appropriate nomination needs to be listed at . Regarding the article itself. There is a disclosure note at the talk page by the article's creator confirming that the article is indeed a product of paid editing. However, the subject is certainly notable per . The lead paragraph mentions that he is an elected member of the U.S. National Academy of Medicine. Although no reference is provided, this fact easily checks outhttps://nam.edu/member/?member_id=SHOmcgJRrkgrumYXqQqF7Q%3D%3D. That alone already makes the subject pass #C3. The article is very underlinked and in general poorly written in terms of complying with our sourcing and notability requirements. The sources cited do not provide publication details (so that it is unclear which ones are published by the subject and which ones are third-party references). No references are given for the National Academy of Medicine membersip, and there are no mentions of awards, journal editorships etc (which the subject does have, according to his CVhttp://markboguski.net/docs/Boguski-cv-2013-12-23.pdf). The CV also mentions that he is a former editor-in-chief of Genomics (journal), which would make him qualify under #C8. GoogleScholar shows h-index above 60. Whomever let this article through at AfC in its current form did a pretty sloppy job, and the paid editor apparently does not really know what they are doing either. The article needs substantial clean-up, not deletion
— User:Nsk92, 13:44, 26 August 2019 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:AFD||WP:MFD||WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion)