Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of defensive gun use incidents (2nd nomination)
It seems to me that it would be very desirable to have some sources that address the topic of listing past defensive gun use ''as a whole'', rather than compiling a list of one-off news reports.  As it currently stands, I think the article is verging on , and that is an issue that needs addressing.  I do not think the "criteria" section below is an adequate remedy, since it suggests that Wikipedia editors will be judging which news reports to include based on criteria studies of defensive gun use in various&mdash;well, that's practically the definition of synthesis.  (What would we say: "This incident would be considered a defensive use based on the criteria in ''blah'', but not ''blah''"?!)  If we can find reliable secondary sources that list defensive uses of guns in the past, then we can cite those ''and'' reference the primary source literature (news reports).  If we can't, then the article should probably be deleted
— User:Sławomir, 13:54, 20 December 2012 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:SYN (Wikipedia:No original research)