Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa McGhee
I see everyone's point, but I would contend that being a finalist on American Idol (note:this does not mean all or even most reality shows. AI is the exception, not the rule.) is enough to drag the subject across the threshold of . I would find this to be more of a candidate for having a tag requesting sources or expansion, not deletion. If deleted, I would urge the admin to note in the deletion logs something about deletion due to  so that a future article on the topic that does address these concerns is not knee-jerk deleted via CSD G4. I would also make urge said admin to create a redirect to the season of the show in which she performed. (note: this is a cut 'n paste of my comment on Nadia Turner's AfD. Same arguement applies
— User:Youngamerican, 21:03, 1 March 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BIO||WP:V (Wikipedia:Notability)