Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gérard Gertoux (3rd nomination)
Despite strenuous efforts at demonstrating otherwise, all of the claimed qualifications and cited sources are not indicative of an article subject that passes .  None of the eight criteria are satisfied by either the article or the discussion above.  Many of the claimed accomplishments are either meaningless (e.g., his books have been indexed in libraries) or very dubious (e.g., publishing a book through a publisher accused of "dealing in bulk"). A large portion of the article attempts to "borrow" notability through mentioning other academics but notability is  and the mentions by others are extremely disputable in legitimacy. The only route towards notability, therefore, is through the . The only independent, reliable sourcing that makes significant mention of Gertoux is in relation to a subject that the current article avoids entirely: his lack of qualification for a PhD and claims of religious discrimination.  Even that, however, founders on .  There is nothing worth salvaging through  so the only option left is Delete
— User:Eggishorn, 18:22, 30 March 2020 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:NACADEMICS||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG||WP:ONEEVENT||WP:ATD (Wikipedia:Notability)