Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Manuel Rodriguez (writer)
Yes, Rodriguez has published several books and articles. But noone has produced reliable sources that they have won significant critical attention or has made a significant impact per  or , apart, that is from this one controversy. Possibly reviews have been published, (in Spanish language sources?), but this needs to be demonstrated before claiming notability for anything other than the Man of Ashes incident.   Unless other sources are found, we are basically dealing with a | BLP article about a person notable only for one event; the policy specifically points out the dangers of an unbalanced, POV biography where we have very little evidence '''about''' Rodriguez  with which to write balanced article. Unless other independent sources (reviews etc) appear about the notability of his books, scholarship or the author himself, the appropriate action is to delete the article, especially given that the creator argues for this. Maybe the article could be renamed the Man of Ashes controversy, but given that all the information cited is already in the Salomon Isacovici, it does not seem particularly necessary
— User:Slp1, 19:29, 3 January 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF||WP:ONEEVENT (Wikipedia:Notability)