Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Baseer (cricketer)
As one of the authors of the Wikipedia:Village_pump_(policy)#The_criteria_of_WP:NSPORT_here_are_too_inclusive|RfC that is partially referenced in the nomination, I might make a couple of points: 1) The close also states: "As with the RfC on secondary school notability, this should not be an invitation to flood AfD with indiscriminate or excessive nominations."  The nomination here does little more than reference that RfC and then throw this article into discussion.  If the nominator wanted to make a single-article test case, then they probably should have made that clear.  2) The discussion there reached no conclusions about the exclusivity of any particluar guidelines, and certainly not on .  3) The discussion there reached a clear conclusion that WP:NSPORTS and  do not override WP:GNG.  While discussions within projects have historically tried to advocate that their subject-specific guidelines (SSG's) do override the GNG, this third point is not new to that discussion and in fact re-iterates long-standing project-wide consensus.  Discussions of this sort on the |Village Pump are often preferred since they have such project-wide visibility. There is currently more discussion about this guideline relationship at Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(sports)#Proposal re GNG/SSC relationship and much of the discussion above is about points and arguments probably better-placed there.  Thank you
— User:Eggishorn, 17:09, 12 June 2017 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NCRIC||WP:VP (Wikipedia:Notability)