Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conflict (Sy Smith album)
I try to stick to the |"assume good faith" standard, but the nominator's comments display an unfamiliarity with some relevant WP policies including , , and . The AfD process is not the forum for drawing attention to an article that needs clean-up or expansion. An editor who is capable of initiating the AfD process can use those same fingers to improve the article in question. Also, it has never been necessary for an album to chart and win awards to be considered notable in Wikipedia. Those are things that help establish notability, but being reviewed in reliable sources, as is the case with this album, also bestows enough notability for at least a stub article. The Billboard links added by the last voter are brief but valid, and I also found this much more substantial review: https://www.soultracks.com/review-sy_smith_conflict
— User:doomsdayer520, 13:00, 12 October 2018 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:AGF||WP:BEFORE||WP:NEXIST||WP:UGLY (Wikipedia:Assume good faith)