Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of hip hop albums considered to be influential
By its very construction, this list is pure . There are places on the internet where constructing a list in this way would be appropriate, but Wikipedia is not one of them. I think {{u|JesseRafe}}'s comparison with List of films considered the best is a bit misguided, because that list is constructed in an entirely different way—the inclusion criteria there is that each film must have been voted ''the best'' in a notable poll. Using polls rather than lists and only counting the top entry from each rather than all entries makes a lot of difference (though I personally think that list should have a slightly higher threshold for inclusion). That being said, I'm not exactly unbiased since I have been quite heavily involved in editing the film list and discussing the entries and inclusion criteria on its talk page. Maybe it would be possible and appropriate to construct a hip hop list in the same way as the film list, but that would be a fundamentally different list than the one under discussion and would need to be constructed from scratch
— User:TompaDompa, 00:54, 29 August 2021 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:SYNTH (Wikipedia:No original research)