Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bush Derangement Syndrome (6th nomination)
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bush_Derangement_Syndrome&oldid=543545866 This is what the article looked like when I came across it for this AfD and http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bush_Derangement_Syndrome&diff=543035114&oldid=542829605 this is what it looked like when the AfD nomination was posted. As for the delete positions, Wikipedia widely uses newspaper articles as papers to source information about topics discuss in Wikipedia articles. See Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources. There are plenty of sources betwen 2003 and 2013 that are (1) independent of Charles Krauthammer (who provided a primary written source for the term) and independent of the primary source events that surround the Bush Derangement Syndrome topic and (2) provide information about the topic beyond mere use of the term, including:{{Citation |page= A12 |publication-date= September 14, 2006|title=Bush Derangement Syndrome isn't new |work= Lexington Herald-Leader }}, * {{Citation |page= A18 |publication-date= August 6, 2007 |title= FISA and Bush Derangement Syndrome |url=http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2007/aug/6/fisa-and-bush-derangement-syndrome/ |work= Washington Times }}, * {{Citation |page= A21 |author=Tony Blankley |publication-date=September 26, 2007 |title=Swooning over Ahmadinejad \. A bad case of Bush derangement syndrome |url=http://www.questia.com/library/1G1-169138057/swooning-over-ahmadinejad-a-bad-case-of-bush-derangement|work= Washington Times }}, * {{Citation |page=B9 |author= Leonard Pitts Jr.|publication-date= December 9, 2010|title=From Bush Derangement Syndrome then to Obama Dementia now |work= St. Paul Pioneer Press }}, * {{Citation |publication-date=December 9, 2010 |title=Obama Dementia supplants Bush Derangement Syndrome |work= Charlotte Observer }}, * {{Citation |page=A15 |author=Barbara Kay |publication-date=February 9, 2011 |title=Is George W. Bush a war criminal?; Another symptom of Bush Derangement Syndrome  |url= |work= National Post }}. A secondary source provides an author's own thinking based on primary sources, generally at least one step removed from an event. See |No original research. These newspaper articles have Bush Derangement Syndrome in their article title (making Bush Derangement Syndrome the main topic of the newspaper article). Primary sources for Bush Derangement Syndrome are the events (mostly political events) that surround Bush Derangement Syndrome and the above cited secondary sources are at least one step removed from those political events and they provide an author's own thinking based on the events that surround Bush Derangement Syndrome and provide independent information about the topic. The deletes appear to be requiring secondary sources that analyze Krauthammer's 2003 primary source column for the term. They are mistake in that the Wikipedia article is not about Krauthammer's 2003 primary source column. Rather, the article is about the Bush Derangement Syndrome topic. In addition to papers such as newspapers, http://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&q=%22Bush+Derangement+Syndrome%22 Google books also provides plenty of source material for the topic that are about the events surrounding the topic as does http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Bush+Derangement+Syndrome%22 Google scholar papers. There are more than enough reliable sources that provide information about the Bush Derangement Syndrome topic and that provide an author's own thinking based on the events that surround Bush Derangement Syndrome provide source material for the article to support this topic as its own article
— User:Jreferee, 12:52, 13 March 2013 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:PSTS (Wikipedia:No original research)