Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carnival Glory (2nd nomination)
I would dispute the assertion that "cruise ships and ocean liners are inherently notable" in the absence of a community consensus to the contrary. We don't have articles for every Airbus A380 or for every train the runs the Northeast Corridor line or for every tram at Disneyworld. These articles reek of |indiscriminate information. Note that I did ''not'' say a ship has to be record-breaking to be &mdash;that's just one potential indicator of notability. The ships you cite are notable because they are historically significant and legitimately famous. Carnival has a fleet of dozens of undistinguished ships of no historical significance whatsoever
— User:Clconway, 21:02, 19 March 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:NOTABLE (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)