Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sven Bärtschi
I'll explain my stance so we don't end up relisting this a third time.  Remember that Nail Yakupov was brought here, an article I wrote for someone who was a sure lock for the ROY award in the OHL.  Problem?  I wrote it early.  It was brought up for deletion by someone claiming no notability.  It was deleted.  Less than three weeks later, he won ROY.  It went to Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2011 April 9|deletion review.  After a discussion that appeared in consensus to keep, it remained deleted.  Puzzled and confused, I had an exchange on the closing admin's page.  Eventually, it was reconsidered and kept after all.  So...with that out of the way, I have not checked this player's stats, but based on the prior AfD, that's not enough; Yakupov is the top rookie scorer for the Sarnia Sting, and that wasn't enough either.  Since we can't use a |crystal ball to predict ROY, we must look at whether he meets .  If he does, it's a definite keep.  If not, it's delete.  Even so, my weak keep also votes to incubate and end this discussion for the time being; if he does not win ROY, then off to deletion review to delete after May 4 if he's not otherwise notable under 
— User:CycloneGU, 04:39, 23 April 2011 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG||WP:GNG (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)