Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scarlet Fade
I don't pay attention to music much, but to reply to "the article is notable" — Have the song and the CD been issued on any of these major labels?  If not, it fails that criterion, regardless of whether the separate song is considered a separate album.  Just like |politicians — although national and regional significance can make the music group and the elected official notable, simply local significance (whether being played on local stations or holding local elected office) doesn't make the subject notable.  Finally, as to the city: I would guess that this refers to really large cities, probably larger than Bristol; if it meant ANY city, then a four-person band from Ruso, North Dakota would obviously be the most prominent representative of that city's cultural scene, but that wouldn't mean much.  Ultimately, to be notable under the  criteria to which you refer, it must '''fully''' pass one or more of the notability criteria; passing them partially isn't enough
— User:Nyttend, 04:08, 12 October 2008 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:POLITICIAN||WP:MUSIC (Wikipedia:Notability)