Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of critics of Islam
The nominator's argument for deletion is essentially "oh no, there could be a content dispute about inclusion", which is unpersuasive. This is one of the few lists that could be a valuable encyclopedic resource. But the article as it stands - just a list of names without comment - is very unhelpful and reeks of . I'd support deleting it in a later AfD unless all entries are individually referenced and sourced, e.g. "Joe Schmoevich - Bozarkian Member of Parliament who sponsored a bill in 1985 to outlaw the sale of the Koran, source: Bozarkian Chronicle of 12 June 1985
— User:Sandstein, 17:16, 4 September 2006 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:OR (Wikipedia:No original research)