Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Self creation cosmology
I have been aware of this for some time and have expressed concern about the "conflict of interest" inherent in Garth writing about his own research.  I haven't mustered interest/time/energy to get hold of original sources and study them so I can form my own opinion about whether his description violates , but I do have the superficial impression that he has been well-behaved (e.g. not spamming other articles) and don't recall noticing anything which suggested to me that he is editing in bad faith or anything like that.  Still, I'd be a lot happier of someone was willing to take the time to look more carefully than I have into this.  I also wish I had the sense that Garth is going to declare the article complete at some point.  FWIW, I think the outcome should of this AfD should probably be reported as ''inconclusive'', reserving the right to nominate it again without prejudice if problems should develop (which I hope won't happen since we have enough trouble from other quarters in the physics/cosmology categories
— User:Hillman, 09:52, 26 June 2006 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NPOV (Wikipedia:Neutral point of view)