Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradon Godfrey
College football is tough, because it's unquestionably more notable than the college equivalents of the other three major North American sports (only basketball comes close), but yet it's still not necessarily satisfactory of . Yet it's also the sport where it's most possible to be a major star in college and not even make the pro league at all. If Gino Torretta or Ron Dayne had flopped to the point where they never even made the NFL, would they be notable? Maybe. Hard to say. Godfrey seems to have been a star college player per the links given by Cbl62 (though obviously not a Heisman winner like Torretta and Dayne), but I'm not entirely convinced that's enough. Deletion per failure of ATHLETE wouldn't bother me at all
— User:Nosleep, 00:22, 16 September 2009 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:ATHLETE (Wikipedia:Notability)