Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of celebrity and notable guest appearances in Doctor Who (3rd nomination)
I think my !vote from the second AFD still is as valid as it was back then. Most of the reasons listed for deletion are reasons for cleanup and we all know that AFD is not cleanup, per Peregrine Fisher above. Furthermore,  does not apply in this case. The policy is against indiscriminate lists of loosely or non-connected topics. This is a list with a clear focus that just is in bad need of cleanup and maybe a rename. We have others such lists, like List of guest stars on The Simpsons, which are perfectly acceptable and as such, even arguing a bit of  is allowed here. This is a nomination that indicates a certain dissatisfaction by the cleanup that was not done after the last AFD (that being |somebody else's problem in many !voters' eyes) but nevertheless, the reasons put forward are not reasons that allow deletion, nor should they. The nominator should be advised to use their time instead in trying to rectify those problems - per . Regards
— User:SoWhy, 11:56, 13 August 2009 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:OSE||WP:SEP||WP:BEFORE (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)