Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sino Japanese Wars and Conflicts
The wiki on "Indo-Pakistani wars and conflicts" is about armed clashes and wars that have happened since 1947 between two clearly identified modern states whose relationship has been mainly characterized by conflict. In this wiki, however, "China" and "Japan" refer to a large number of different polities whose relations did not become mainly conflictual until the very late 19th century. Apart from the two Sino-Japanese Wars of 1894-1895 and 1937-1945, we have: a seventh-century battle that did not even mainly oppose "China" and "Japan"; Wokou piracy (certainly not a conflict between China and Japan, since no Japanese state was involved, and because the Wokou also counted Chinese and Koreans among their ranks); the Mongol invasions of Japan (why the Mongol Empire should represent "China" is not explained); the Japanese invasions of Korea in 1592 and 1598 (a real war); and a boat collision incident that took place in 2010. I know of no |reliable source that could conceivably discuss all these together. Even if we got rid of the atrocious English, removed the main editor's personal analysis ("China was like one of the superpowers on Earth in early times"; "the causes of many wars become Korea and Taiwan"), and added meaningful and well-referenced information on each event, we would only end up with a , that is, an "excessive focus on one aspect of the subject" of Sino-Japanese relations. Excessive focus on conflict in Sino-Japanese relations would violate , and the miscellaneous nature of the events discussed would constitute either  or . A page which, even in the best case scenario, would still violate two of Wikipedia's three content policies ( and ) should clearly be deleted
— User:Madalibi, 10:11, 18 September 2011 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:COATRACK||WP:NPOV||WP:SYNTHESIS||WP:NPOV||WP:NOR||WP:original research (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)