Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharon Raydor
I must admit I am disappointed that it seems that no editors have engaged with the sources I referred to. Perhaps no one who has !voted since has access to them, and I know I should , but it does seem as if the responses are to the existing article, rather than to the secondary sources which . I do agree that, as written, the current article is totally in-universe. The secondary sources I found from 2012, when the series was about to start, discuss the series creator's decisions in choosing to start a new, spin-off series, rather than have this character be promoted within the old series; the difference between the lead characters in the two series; that the old series was regarded by fans as a one-woman show whereas, before it launched, the creator saw the new series as more of a group view of the justice system with a captain who insists on her detectives following the rules, unlike in the old series, and so on. One of the 2012 articles makes the point that the new captain is good at making deals with suspects, avoiding the cost of trials.  This article goes into quite a bit of details about her making deals, but doesn't mention critics' perception that this was to save money. As I said above, in my opinion, there is enough secondary coverage of this character (from subsequent years too) for her to meet , but if no one else agrees, I don't want to waste time editing a fictional character's article when there are so many articles about real people that need improving
— User:RebeccaGreen, 13:20, 17 December 2019 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:AGF||WP:NEXIST||WP:GNG (Wikipedia:Assume good faith)