Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Middle-earth cosmology
Article does not appear to be "original research", but rather is a reindexing of verifiable information, apparently including good referencing.   does not seem to apply, as it is neither a personal essay or an original analysis of the material by the article's author.   is likewise met, as everything appears to be verified and sourced, and the article is not intended to introduce new, original ideas, or do any of the other things listed under the bullet points of "What is Excluded". Indexing collections of referenced information is normally acceptable
— User:Dugwiki, 18:52, 23 January 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOT||WP:OR (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)