Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melbourne best and fairest (AFL Women's)
I'm very mixed on this as to whether it constitutes its own article or whether it should be redirected to Melbourne Football Club. Although I do feel this article may be a bit , in saying that, while the Melbourne best and fairest hasn't received a whole lot of independent coverage (probably due to who the winner has been and her multiple other achievements), other club B&Fs have https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/teams/adelaide/cocaptain-chelsea-randall-was-the-clear-club-champion-at-the-adelaide-crows-awards-night/news-story/070a7aa0771ab902a743ec57e014340e, http://thewomensgame.com/news/randall-named-club-champion-at-crows-awards-night-487523, https://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/aflw/emily-bates-makes-brisbane-lions-history-by-winning-the-clubs-inaugural-aflw-best-and-fairest/news-story/0ba585c3fa8022223e0614899c6f62d9, https://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/aflw/katie-loynes-and-breeann-moody-crowed-joint-carlton-aflw-bestandfairest-winners/news-story/b006e753f869b25491f1238e2b44932f as an example and I don't think we can have one club B&F deemed notable and others not. In addition, although this discussion focuses primarily on players (Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Australian rules football/Archive 7#RFC on sports notability), editors within  tend to edit in the way and believe Australian Football League|AFL and AFL Women's|AFLW are treated equally, i.e. all men's articles have B&FS and probably the reason for the creation of this page. Also in response to this being awarded to a "small group of people decided by an even smaller group of people from the same club", there was a real crackdown a few years ago in the project regarding non-notable club awards. This award, in my opinion, does not fall into that group as it is the most elite level women can play Australian rules football at and the preeminent award within each women's team
— User:Flickerd, 07:07, 24 June 2018 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:TOOSOON||WP:AFL (Wikipedia:Too soon)