Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightsaber combat (4th nomination)
I agree that much of the content of this article appears to be culled from inappropriate sources and hence this article has sigificant  problems. However, I also agree that enough sources and content would be left if the unreliable material were culled out to make topic |notable and justifying a reasonable article. AfD covers whether the topic itself is encyclopedic, not whether the current article complies with standards in all respects. The topic supports an encyclopedic article, and that is enough
— User:Shirahadasha, 05:48, 16 March 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:OR||WP:N (Wikipedia:No original research)