Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiyo Miyako
The rationale for this deletion debate is flawed because it relies on the argument that the article is "unencyclopedic", whatever that means. According to |Arguments to avoid in deletion debates, a widely respected essay, "the terms 'unencyclopedic', and its flip-side 'encyclopedic', are too general to be useful in deletion discussions". We do not delete articles based on the vague and general personal opinions of the nominator. I also object to the use of the term "fancruft" by the nominator in this debate. According to our essay on |fancruft, "The term 'fancruft' is most commonly applied to fictional works and pop culture." Chiyo Miyako was a real human being and not the subject of popular culture. Describing her biography as "fancruft" is disrespectful and inappropriate
— User:Cullen328, 00:46, 31 July 2018 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP: UNENCYCLOPEDIC||WP:FANCRUFT (Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions)