Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madelaine Neumann
leaning towards '''delete'''.  I was going to close this debate, instead I offer a couple of opinions.  My observations:  Faith Healing is ''not'' an appropriate merge location/redirect location, as it is not the same concept (at least according to our article) as what these parents were doing with their own child.  Spiritual Healing redirects to Faith Healing.  '''Prayer healing''' redirects to Prayer.  Prayer healing is what these parents were doing.  I also don't believe this would be an adequate place for a merge.  This particular biography, while yes, getting news coverage, falls squarely under our |one event guideline.  I don't believe this particular (and rather tragic) case merits a standalone article, and I also don't believe either merge/redirect proposal is appropriate.  I therefore recommend deletion.  The most promising suggestion is by Casliber: create a new list of articles, with citations, about deaths that happened whilst involved in faith or prayer healing, although that would be tough to maintain as POV.   (By the way, I specifically am ''not'' saying Death by Faith Healing for POV reasons; diabetes killed this girl, not faith healing, any more than it would be appropriate to have a title called "Death by Dialysis".  Faith Healing is an illfounded, but also in some circles well meaning, attempt at recovery or repair, it is ''not'' the cause of death
— User:Keeper76, 16:12, 14 April 2008 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:BIO1E (Wikipedia:Notability)