Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erica Muhl
per #C2 -- the AAAL award is a lifetime achievement award which, while low money, is mainly won by composers in the upper echelon of composition (consider the level of the other winners that year).  Her position is full professor at a top music school, which is substantially above the Average Professor Test.  The commission by the Orchestra of Saint Luke's is also a high honor (the other commissions don't individually pass the  test, but cumulatively they do).  Saying "Non-notable" isn't, to me, an argument in itself for deletion -- it's a conclusion to be reached based on evidence of lack of notability -- the website of the AAAL is a reliable source for who their winners are and the websites of the orchestras are reliable sources of who their commissioned composers are. I agree with AllyD that trimming the article of 2/3 of its content (including a notice about a commission of hers that appeared in the New York Times!) just before nominating for deletion is bad form
— User:Mscuthbert, 00:43, 29 November 2012 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:PROF (Wikipedia:Notability)