Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tottenham Hotspur F.C. 3–4 Manchester City F.C. (2004)
I won't go into how I believe that this is notable and is not  because as the article creator I feel it should be obvious that I believe it's suitable for inclusion. What I would like to ask those who have voted, however, is what criteria they are using to judge this article? Or to put it another way, when no-one has ever really agreed and put down in writing Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Notability|what is notable in an article then can this AfD be seen as a fair trial, or is it not something of a scattergun approach with everyone voting according to gut feeling and personal bias? Would a better test of public opinion not be to establish a consensus first and then come back to judge individual articles afterwards, especially since I would suspect that the majority of people who patrol the AfD debates would likely consider themselves meta:Deletionism|Deletionists and therefore this AfD is likely to produce something of an inherent bias anyway
— User:Falastur2, 22:47, 19 February 2018 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOTNEWS (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)