Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/British and Irish Historic House books recently published
The PROD rationale was "|Wikipedia is not a directory. Listing ''all'' books published on this topic in 2008 or later, regardless of their significance, appears to be indiscriminate information. There's no clear reason for making 2008 the cut-off, and in future years 2008 will no longer be "recent" (in other words, even if the article remains, there are obvious reasons why the title should be changed, but changing the title won't solve the essential problems with the topic)". I declined the PROD on a procedural basis, since we're at AFD now
— User:Ultraexactzz, 16:08, 22 February 2010 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NOT (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)