Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On the Strength of All Convinced
The AllMusic review ''is'' both a reliable source and good coverage. While AllMusic is a database, if a reviewer had to write something up, we accept that as a reliable source. We do not accept entries that have only a rating without a review. We do not accept user-submitted reviewers either. We do not accept the genre clouds that are machine-generated. We only accept the prose as reliable, but with that said, we need more than one reliable source, and the https://www.punknews.org/review/4198/daphne-loves-derby-on-the-strength-of-all-convinced PunkNews staff review would be enough. My concern is that the article may not ever be more than a track listing. The article should incorporate elements of all three reviews. I suggest that the nominator should improve the article for not adequately doing , but I have no way of enforcing that and since BEFORE was ignored I suspect that this suggestion will be as well
— User:Walter, 20:20, 3 May 2019 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: :WP:BEFORE (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion)