Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ty Russell (2nd nomination)
As George Ho points out,  is indeed disputed. It is unstable and chaotic, and is the subject of a recent ongoing Wikipedia talk:Notability (people)#RFC for more feedback|RfC. Criteria #1 relating to "Has won a well-known award such as an AVN Award" (in essentially the same form) has been in the guideline since it's inception in 2006 (when it was a separate guideline). Excluding scene and ensemble awards is an extremely recent and unstable addition and there is no community wide consensus to make these and other changes, as evidenced by the the DISPUTE tag, the edit war in the guideline, and the RfC. The stable criteria that has been in force since 2006 is the only valid version that can be applied in this AfD. Otherwise we are in the untenable position of attempting to apply a guideline that is in chaos to what is supposed to be a rational and deliberative process. It's like changing the applicable law in the middle of a jury trial. If and when the the dust settles from the PORNBIO dispute and RfC, then we will have a new guideline. Or not
— User:Becksguy, 08:17, 22 May 2012 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:PORNBIO (Wikipedia:Notability)