Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Octavio Carranza Torres
The article is very badly written and formatted, badly sourced, and suffers somewhat from |crystal ball-ism: it has too much about what Carranza is going to do when it should only be about what he has done. And some of the article text is copied and pasted from http://octavioacarranzatorres.com/ Carranza's web page (or vice versa, I suppose). Despite all that I was prepared to look through the article and try to find some notability in it. The only thing I see, really, that could save the article is the subject's award, the 2005 Premio Nacional de Logística. But, though I found a few web pages that mention it, in Google News I could find only http://www.universia.cl/portada/actualidad/noticia_actualidad.jsp?noticia=89210 two http://www.universia.cl/portada/actualidad/noticia_actualidad.jsp?noticia=91754 articles from a Chilean university that mention him only briefly in connection with a seminar that he visited. I have to conclude that, with no Spanish-language press on the award, it is not an especially notable one. Without that, and without other evidence of passing , I don't see why we should keep the article
— User:David, 04:25, 3 November 2009 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:CRYSTAL||WP:PROF (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)