Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 Texas vs. Oklahoma State football game
I agree with the nominator's rationale except insofar as he asserts that all the sources are . My delete vote is based on the long-standing practice in the college football and American football projects to (a) include game summaries in articles covering each team's season (''see'' 2007 Texas Longhorns football team#Oklahoma State) and (b) limit stand-alone articles about individual games to bowl games, championship games, or, in rare cases, regular season games that have truly historic or enduring importance. In this case, Texas played poorly for three quarters against a mediocre, unranked opponent and then launched a truly impressive comeback in the fourth quarter. I just don't see anything truly historic or extraordinary about the game to warrant a departure from the general practice. For me, it's not so much a question of notability, as most Power Five conferences|Power Five games get enough significant, non- coverage to pass . Instead, it's an issue of editorial judgment in how we present content about individual college football games, and I think the existing practice of relying on team season articles is sound. For further detail on the established practice, see '''(1)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2005 Texas vs. Texas A&M football game (2nd nomination)|2005 Texas v. Texas A&M; '''(2)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1996 UCLA at Tennessee football game|1996 UCLA vs. Tennessee; '''(3)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 Michigan vs. Notre Dame football game|2011 Michigan vs Notre Dame; '''(4)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 Oregon vs. Oregon State football game|2008 Oregon vs. Oregon State; '''(16)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 Missouri vs. Kansas football game|2007 Missouri vs. Kansas; '''(5)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2001 Tennessee vs. Florida football game|2001 Tennessee vs. Florida; '''(6)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Alabama vs. Texas A&M football game|2013 Alabama vs. Texas A&M; '''(7)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1996 Texas Tech vs. Kansas State football game|1996 Texas Tech vs. Kansas State; '''(8)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2006 USC vs. UCLA football game|2006 USC vs. UCLA; '''(9)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Florida State vs. Georgia Tech football game|2015 Florida State vs. Georgia Tech; '''(10)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 Pittsburgh vs. West Virginia football game|2007 Pitt vs. West Virginia; and '''(11)''' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2006 Texas vs. Ohio State football game|2006 Texas vs. Ohio State
— User:Cbl62, 16:18, 6 April 2017 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG (Wikipedia:Notability)