Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of surviving veterans of World War I
to List of last surviving World War I veterans by country. I'm rather suprised by this nomination, it smacks of frivolousness to nominate a list for deletion because of a disagreement over one entry (even if that entry makes up a third of the list). I'll also respond to the the only policy-based argument for deletion, which was KoshVorlon's claim that this list violates , which makes me question: which clause? It doesn't qualify as a violation of #OR (the dispute not withstanding), MEMORIAL (how can it memorialize a person who still lives?), DIR (not a directory), nor  (a very clear and specific scope that is not a trivial intersection). However, it does seem rather redundant to List of last surviving World War I veterans by country, and will eventually have to be redirected there once the last of the survivors die (which is likely to be soon, given thier advanced ages). Most of the information that is unique to the current article can be easily moved, and the edit history preserved with a redirect. I alo not with suprise and mournful regret to see that Frank Buckles passed yesterday, perhaps the impetus behind this motivation
— User:Bahamut0013, 21:12, 1 March 2011 (UTC)
Stance: merge
Cited policy: WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:NOTDIR||WP:INDISCRIMINATE (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)