Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krista White
on "where are they now" articles that feature Krista White'' (like those linked above, from https://www.buzzfeed.com/bricesander/wanna-be-on-top-top-top-top ''BuzzFeed'', the https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/12/04/fashion/americas-next-top-model-finale-where-are-the-winners-now.html ''New York Times'', http://www.intouchweekly.com/posts/america-s-next-top-model-where-are-they-now-124647/photos/krista-white-antm-2017-230359 ''In Touch Weekly'', http://www.eonline.com/photos/17666/ranking-every-america-s-next-top-model-winner-who-s-on-top/537423 ''E! Online'', https://www.popsugar.com/beauty/photo-gallery/3120661/image/13473756/Krista-White ''PopSugar'', and http://ew.com/gallery/americas-next-top-model-where-are-they-now/americas-next-top-model-then-and-now ''Entertainment Weekly''): the significance of these articles is quite opposite to what {{u|Cthomas3}} attributes to them. "Where are they now" articles exist on a variety of competitions, and they do ''not'' automatically feature capsule biographies of ''all'' the winners, as these on America's Next Top Model|''ANTM'' do. (The one from https://www.popsugar.com/beauty/photo-gallery/3120661/image/13473756/Krista-White ''PopSugar'' even gives individual capsule biographies for all 204 ''contestants!'') For comparison, I searched for "where are they now" articles on the Scripps National Spelling Bee, introduced above by {{u|Cthomas3}} as a term of comparison. I found a couple of "where are they now" articles from http://www.slate.com/articles/life/explainer/2012/06/scripps_national_spelling_bee_what_happens_to_the_winners_later_in_life_.html ''Slate'' and https://www.inverse.com/article/32544-where-are-they-now-scripps-spelling-bee-champions ''Inverse Culture'', but their structure was very different from the America's Next Top Model|''ANTM'' articles. There was no attempt at capsule biographies of all winners, or even of all recent winners for some definition of "recent". Instead, they gave broad generalizations about the winners as a class, with more detailed information about a very few winners selected as examples. This kind of article supports the notability of the competition itself and of the specific winners given detailed coverage (Rebecca Sealfon in particular clearly needs her own article, not just a redirect as she has at present!), but it does not present the competition as conferring notability on all its winners. By contrast, six different publications giving capsule biographies of ''all'' America's Next Top Model|''ANTM'' winners for the competition's entire history are making a very strong statement that ''all'' America's Next Top Model|''ANTM'' winners are worthy of coverage (and thus notable!) as individuals ''simply because they won a cycle of'' America's Next Top Model|''ANTM''. (https://www.popsugar.com/beauty/photo-gallery/3120661/image/13473756/Krista-White ''PopSugar'' even votes to extend that to all ''contestants'', but it appears to be alone in that.) Note that  within  specifically states that the topic "does not need to be the main topic of the source material". So these articles not only support the notability under  of America's Next Top Model|''ANTM'' itself, and of every one of the individual winners they cover, including Krista White—they also support the status of winning America's Next Top Model|''ANTM'' as a "well-known and significant award or honor", conferring notability via  even on winners in cycles after their publication
— NONE, NONE
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:SIGCOV||WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO (Wikipedia:Notability)