Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed O'Loughlin 2nd attempt
fails notability test as noted repeatedly above. Is a pet hate subject for a handful of pro-Israeli groups. Interestingly is a pet hate subject for pro-Palestine groups as well. But despite all of that, he is just a journalist working for a newspaper, like tens of thousands of others. As regards #Basic criteria, the secondary source material does not appear to meet the requirement to be "intellectually independent" as it is all published by groups with stated pro-Israeli (or pro-Palestine) agendas. He has won no major awards, he has never been newsworthy in his own right and is no more entitled to a WP article than I am
— User:Manning, 00:04, 18 January 2008 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:BIO (Wikipedia:Notability)