Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of defensive gun use incidents
Nothing indiscriminate about it-- lists three sorts of indiscriminate info, and "news stories on one topic" isn't one of them.  The nom is also clearly wrong in that there is a specific criteria for list inclusion: defensive use of firearms reported in reliable sources.  The other Delete !voters are unconvincing, although I don't disagree with Ubelowme's rename suggestion.  The notion that "Defensive" or "incident" are sufficiently ill-defined that deletion is the preferred outcome is uncompelling.  The GNG is met, the sources appear clearly adequate, and no delete !voter has put forth any policy-based reason that this list article is unsuitable or couldn't be fixed by regular editing per 
— User:Jclemens, 03:50, 31 July 2012 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:IINFO||WP:ATD (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)