Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of 2004 Songs
per Northamerica1000 as satisfying  and . Contra the nomination, NOTDIR itself notes that Wikipedia keeps "indexes or directories of its own content." And it is standard practice to limit lists of X, where not every X that exists is notable, only to the Xs that are notable. "Notable" means "has or should have an article" per , nothing more. So the nominator and Richhoncho's fear about this including all the 2004 songs that exist or were produced is unfounded. When the list is expanded with valid article entries to the point where it gets too big for one page, it can be split into sublists
— User:Postdlf, 17:15, 3 August 2017 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:LISTPURP||WP:NOTDUP||WP:N (Wikipedia:Manual of Style)