Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Peshawar
There is a disconnect between the stated |film notability guidelines and the way that the guidelines are applied.  As written, unreleased films, and this one was unreleased when it was nominated, are only notable if principal photography itself has been notable.  As applied, films are considered notable, at least by some editors including AFD !voters, if principal photography has begun.  This has the side effect of encouraging the creation of promotional articles on films in principal photography, although removing the promotional material would leave a stub or sub-stub.  One remedy would be to change the guidelines to state that films are notable when they are in principal photography, even without any coverage, but that would just encourage promotional use.  Another remedy would be to apply the guideline as written.  Another approach would be to ignore the disconnect, which is what we do.  I am willing to change my !vote to '''Neutral'''.  I won't change my !vote to Keep
— User:Robert, 03:54, 19 September 2017 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NFILM (Wikipedia:Notability)