Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janet Brumby
Firstly, not every person who won some award at some point in their lives is notable under .  Individuals notable under that part of the guideline are typically notable in other parts as well, and that assumes that this is even the correct guideline here, which I'm not convinced it is.  Plenty of people win awards, within academia and without.  What matters in the application of  is not just that the individual ''won some award'', but that the award is significant evidence that the subject has made a notable impact on scholarship.  Given the lack of other supporting evidence of notability under that guideline, I think it is not unreasonable to conclude that this particular award does not convey the kind of scholastic notability that  demands
— User:Slawekb, 17:19, 5 May 2016 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:ACADEMIC||WP:ACADEMIC||WP:ACADEMIC (Wikipedia:Notability)