Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everyonesacritic.net
Articles like this one are why i'm not a deletionist anymore. Yes, this site doesn't meet the Alexa test, yes this site is questionable on  (the news piece is a blurb at best, and the award probably isn't notable), yes  was broken, which often makes articles a target for deletion (hell, Jimbo Wales breaks  all the time), but ultimately to me, deleting this smacks of . Dave Seidner here has a website that's on the border of notability, he wrote a decent length article about it that's following , ("Words of Hope" was some event, albeit, an also non-notable event) and he gets rewarded with an afd right off the bat, several sockpuppets coming to his aid here making things worse, and a few people who are slightly newer than Dave here smacking the "rules"(half the rules around here are broken anyway)in his face with his |misplaced good faith contributions on his website here. Just leave the damn thing alone
— User:Karmafist, 15:25, 19 February 2006 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:WEB||WP:AUTO||WP:AUTO||WP:BITE||WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:AGF (Wikipedia:Notability)