Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana Pharaoh Francis
for the moment but learning delete. I looked in Gbooks, in Highbeam, in Worldcat and in JSTOR for published reviews of her word and am coming up with precisely bupkis. Using EBSCO seems to require being behind some sort of a paywall. So far the only published review of the subject's work that I see is the one mentioned above (but still not included in the article),  a http://publishersweekly.com/978-1-4165-9814-5 Publishers Weekly Review. I also tried some plain Google searching to try to find other reviews, but am only getting a ton of commercial mirrors, fan-sites and various blogs. So if there in fact do exist bona fide multiple published reviews of the subject's work in sources passing , I'd like to see the actual evidence (and I'd really want to see more than just 2-3 of such reviews). Regarding library holdings argument raised by DGG: I would have been willing to consider this argument if we were talking about academic notability and scholarly books. But these books are just commercial fiction books. Here we should not use  considerations, and just go with  standards
— User:Nsk92, 22:52, 4 June 2016 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:PROF||WP:CREATIVE (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)