Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olaf Karthaus
I am confused as to why you consider http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Olaf_Karthaus&diff=113996392&oldid=112543807 DGG's edit a non-material edit.  More broadly, a lack of people caring to edit an article has no weight on the notability of its subject.  As regards , please reread the full text of point 3.  A "textbook" is only one of the examples given, and the other is this: ''if it is widely cited by other authors in the academic literature''.  This is how those 5 works meet point 3.  I agree that the format in which the article is written is substandard, but for that there is {{tl|wikify}}.  I will attempt to address some of the points you've raised, but I will not read the 365 works that cite these 5 articles to determine the extent to which they are about these works.  The fact of having written something that is widely cited in a literature is itself a factor
— User:Black, 01:16, 15 March 2007 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:PROF (Wikipedia:Notability)