Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. P. Calderon
As noted, this is the third time in a month that this article has been AFDed. The first Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.P. Calderon|closed with no consensus and the second, opened just minutes after the first one closed, was Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.P. Calderon (2nd nomination)|closed with a '''KEEP'''. There is absolutely no justification for nominating and renominating and renominating this article. The subject ''clearly'' passes . "The article isn't relevant" is ''not'' a valid criterion for deletion. "This isn't well known," in other words , is ''not'' a valid criterion for deletion. "Nor was he great on Survivor: Cook Islands" is ''not'' a valid criterion for deletion. The nomination does not cite any guideline or policy that the article violates and while I am doing my best to assume good faith, the constant attacks on this article are absolutely ridiculous. The matter of Scorpion's continuing hostility to this article and his extremely poor conduct regarding it are not relevant to this discussion, as much as he would like to make this about me and him
— User:Otto4711, 03:51, 24 February 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BIO||WP:IDONTKNOWIT (Wikipedia:Notability)