Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Tipping
Doesn't meet notability criteria.  Only claim to fame seems to be getting nominated for a Gemini Award for editing, but that doesn't establish notability (see  etc).  Having worked on shows that have been nominated in other categories is definitely not evidence of anything.  By comparison, all recent nominees for the Academy Award for Best Film Editing have articles but a lot of those are very thin and poorly sourced, e.g. Andrew Weisblum, and I wouldn't be upset seeing some of them deleted either
— User:Colapeninsula, 17:30, 28 February 2012 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:FILMMAKER (Wikipedia:Notability)