Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Amazing Race trivia (4th nomination)
I realize that this might not be up to good standards, but I am currently working on the page List of The Amazing Race statistics and trivia, to kind of mirror or parallel, if you will, List of Survivor statistics and trivia. The current trivia page has indeed been a mess of random information seemingly placed anywhere at random, and I was thinking maybe we could clean it up to resemble the aforementioned Survivor page, which apparently has been deemed acceptable. If neither Amazing Race page is accepted, then is the Survivor page not keep-worthy too? And while we're on that topic, I don't understand how pages like List of American Idol contestants, which is nothing but names, can be kept while Trivia pages, which actually provide information that many would find useful, say, if one were writing a book or needed statistics, are the constant subjects of deletion. While I understand that Wikipedia is not a collection of "indiscriminate information" (which, on the |What Wikipedia is Not page, doesn't explicitly state collections of statistics and the like), that very same page also lists that #Wikipedia is not a paper encyclopedia|Wikipedia is not paper, and being nitpicky over what is "important", which is one's own opinion, I believe violates that last link
— User:HansTAR, 18:49, 25 November 2006 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NOT||WP:NOT (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)