Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruzwana Bashir (4th nomination)
I just don't see much of a claim to notability here. She was president of the Oxford Union for one term (the Union elects a different president for each of the three terms each year), but being President of the Oxford Union is not enough to merit an article. We have articles about some past presidents, but that's because they went on to prominence in other fields, not just because they were presidents of the Union. We don't have articles about any of the other presidents from the last 17 years. The Oxford Union is, after all, just a student organization at a single university. She was the first British-born Asian female president of the Union, but there had been an Asian female president of the Union before Bashir herself was born. (That was Benazir Bhutto, who has a Wikipedia article, but because she was Prime Minister of Pakistan, not because she was president of the Union.) Adding the "British-born" qualification doesn't make this a breakthrough, because British-born students are not going to be at a disadvantage in running for president of a student organization at a British university. And reportedly she has dated an actor, but |notability is not inherited and she has received little press coverage in regard to that
— User:Metropolitan90, 04:58, 18 November 2009 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:NOTINHERITED (Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions)