Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana DeCilio
I believe Citizenkane7 may be misinterpreting the  criterion. DeCilio did not win an award from the Marbella International Film Festival, as far as I can tell. Rather, a documentary she edited was ''nominated'' for Best Documentary there, but did not win. Had it won, the award would have gone to the director, not to her as editor. Similarly, the Producers Guild of America gives its awards, as the name implies, to producers. I can't find any evidence that DeCilio herself was honored by having a project she edited nominated for a PGA award. The kind of award or nomination that could help establish DeCilio as notable would be an Oscar or Emmy for Best Editing, or the American Cinema Editors' Eddie Award. Furthermore, most of the sources cited in the article discuss projects she has worked on but without mentioning her or her work as an editor; thus, they don't help establish her notability. If DeCilio personally (as opposed to a production she worked on) receives a nomination for a significant award, or starts to receive media attention for her editing work on such productions, she can be considered for a Wikipedia article at that time
— User:Metropolitan90, 05:30, 13 October 2009 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:BIO (Wikipedia:Notability)