Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Roth (baseball)
the question is whether any of the national coverage is more than routine game summaries or statistical summaries. Note that  requires that "Significant coverage is more than a trivial mention". This is the type of article that I personally would like to see kept but that fails . There is no consensus on WP that being an All-American confers permanent notability for college baseball players. There was a time when this article would have until the end of the season the following his final collegiate year to meet either ATHLETE or GNG. I am leaning toward saying that this article has sufficient depth to meet GNG at this time. However, the biographical sketch is thin. The benefit to wikipedia is retention of encyclopedic detail. If the article result is deletion, maybe we could agree to hold this in the article incubator until the end of September 2012 out of respect for the old policy
— User:TonyTheTiger, 15:09, 3 April 2012 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE (Wikipedia:Notability)