Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of atheist Nobel laureates (3rd nomination)
While the sourcing improvements are positive, they do not address the confused scope ("atheist, agnostic, nonbeliever or secular spiritual"). These are not at all the same thing (a person may be a nonbeliever in the dominant religion of his/her milieu while still having religious beliefs), and several people on the list (like Einstein) indeed had their own religious beliefs (often some form of Pantheism). Secular spirituality in particular seems to overlap with Buddhism. Furthermore, although the lede restricts membership to "self-identified" atheists, the sources in many cases simply reflect labelling by somebody else. A fundamental difficulty is that gaining a religion generally involves joining an organisation, while many atheists take no overt self-identifying action. This makes the list inherently  in nature. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.74.183|202.124.74.183
— [[User talk:202.124.74.183|talk]]), 02:40, 1 April 2012 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:SYNTH (Wikipedia:No original research)