Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur S. Herman
or '''Merge to Franklin & Marshall College''' The subject fails  by lacking significant coverage in secondary sources.  Significant "means that sources address the subject directly in detail", not that there are a large number of trivial sources. The two ''New York Times'' references and the ''Reading Eagle'' references are  game coverage that listed Herman in the starting lineup or mentions that he scored in a single sentence as part of routine game coverage. This does not establish notability. The following sentences serve to establish his school's notability, but not Herman's: {{quotation|In 1914, the Franklin & Marshall football team, with Herman playing halfback, compiled a 6–2 record and defeated Penn, at the time considered one of the "Big Four" of college football,n 1 by a score of 10–0.67 In 1915, the team again compiled a 6–2 record and outscored opponents by cumulative score of 188 to 43.8 With Herman playing fullback, Franklin & Marshall lost to Penn by a score of 10–6 in 1915, but the Boston Globe praised the effort of the Franklin & Marshall squad: "The University of Pennsylvania football team in its third game of the season beat Franklin and Marshall today, 10 to 6, in one of the best battles seen here in years. Much praise is due the visitors from Lancaster, for during the entire game they fought with a snap and vim that at times had the Red and Blue eleven bewildered."9
— NONE, NONE
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE (Wikipedia:Notability)