Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert J. Schwalb
I think there are several issues here which some people don't appear to be addressing. Firstly, in order to confer notability, the Ennies need to be considered major awards. Simply being one of the main awards within a narrow industry sector is not sufficient. If they are major awards, why do they get so little coverage? Secondly, it seems to be stretching things to say that a game winning an award means that anyone who worked on that game won the award. Some of the awards listed are for specific aspects, and anyone not directly involved in those aspects cannot be considered to have won the award. Thirdly, we need reliable sources to verify both that those games won those awards and that the subject of this article played a significant part in the work that was recognised by those awards.  is a requirement for articles, and particularly for BLPs, and the reliable sources do not appear to exist to form the basis of an article here
— User:Michig, 15:18, 8 May 2011 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:V (Wikipedia:Verifiability)