Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1/0 (web comic) (3rd nomination)
You can find AFDs in years past where the award was considered notable and ones where it was not.  No reason to be cherrypicking.  The award is notable.  Web Cartoonists' Choice Award   It gets coverage, even once in the New York Times column on webcomics.  As mentioned the first time this nominator sent it to AFD, it meets , having won a notable award, and having been nominated for that award three times.  ''Being nominated for such an award in multiple years may also be considered an indicator of notability
— User:Dream, 11:09, 17 May 2012 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:WEB (Wikipedia:Notability)