Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elf Only Inn (5th nomination)
this is the fifth deletion discussion and still nobody has been able to identify any significant coverage in |reliable, third party sources, the primary requirement of the |general notability guideline. The nomination comes down to whether winning a single Web Cartoonists' Choice Award is enough to be the basis of an encyclopaedia article or meet the provision in |specific notability guideline for web content which states "''The website or content has won a well-known and independent award from either a publication or organization''". Personally I do not think that one award of this type is enough when no |reliable sources cover the fact that the award has been won. Effectively it means all the information in the article is sourced to primary sources - the information on the comic from the comic's website, the information on the award from the award's website. As a side note it has been four years since the last |AfD (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elf Only Inn (4th nomination)|which ended in no consensus). Many things have changed on Wikipedia in that time, the |consensus about this article could be one of them - I don't think the nominator deserves to be accused of any wrong doing for asking for the community's opinion on the matter
— User:Guest9999, 15:19, 13 June 2010 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:NN||WP:WEB||WP:RS||WP:AFD||WP:CONSENSUS (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)