Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Place Names of Upper Deeside
The Place Names of Upper Deeside'', now cleaned-up, expanded and sourced. The nomination is deeply flawed, it does not even find the correct author, Adam Watson (scientist), where the book already had {{em|its own}} section! This AFD is a textbook example of lack of |due dilligence. There's simply no way to miss the search results with a string like {{mono|The Place Names of Upper Deeside}} if one {{em|does}} any searching. As for ''The Cairngorms'' that had an incoming link from Adam Watson (scientist) at the Special:PermaLink/893735956|time of nomination, I do not have the time to source it now, but the title is a perfectly valid {{tl|R from book}}, so for now that's a '''Redirect''' to Adam Watson (scientist
— User:Sam, 15:35, 11 May 2019 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BEFORE (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion)