Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert McIntosh Walp, Jr.
It appears that you're citing just his service record. That's not enough to meet Wikipedia |notability guidelines. And unless you can cite a source that shows that he was specifically chosen for assignment to the Skate for the express purpose of being the youngest crewperson aboard for this one deployment, then you can really only owe it to chance that he was there at the time. When I had the chance to pick sea assignments, all I had to go on was the type of ship and where they were homeported. I just picked from a list based on my standing in the class I was in
— User:DarkAudit, 00:58, 29 May 2007 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:BIO (Wikipedia:Notability)