Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Ulrich
You make it sound like I did a ''Bad Thing'' ... I deleted what I believe most editors will agree is a http://www.saudibritishsociety.org.uk/pictures/Dunes.pdf spam link to a PDF order form for a book titled ''Beyond the Dunes'', with the edit summary, ''replaced  with {{cn}} -- a link to the order form for a book is not a  citation for a claim of "only novel ..."'' If it had been under '''External links''', then I might have left it alone, but it was being used as a citation/reference for the very first sentence of the article: '''''Saudi Match Point''''' is the only novel originally written in English and set entirely in modern-day Saudi Arabia or its immediate neighbors on the Arabian peninsula.1A claim ''that'' grandiose requires a , and the ''order form'' for a 552 page book that allegedly contains erification of that claim just isn't a , IMHO, although a proper {{tl|cite book}} with a page number is ... after I confirmed {{ISBN|1850439729}} on Amazon.com, I noticed that Amazon said that ''Beyond the Dunes'' was published "July 27, 2006", but the article says that ''Saudi Match Point'' was publish "April 2007" ... so instead of replacing the EL with a {{tl|cite book}} (I ''still'' might have done it if Breezer84 had just provided a specific ''page number'' to cite), I chose to replace it with a {{cn}} tag ... anybody else have a problem with that? &mdash
— User:68, 12:10, 30 May 2007 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:V||WP:RS (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)