Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chikara Season 11
Firstly, please |assume good faith and do not assume that "Chikara superfans" are not making a distinction accurately, as nobody has addressed you as a "Chikara anti-fan." Secondly, the assertion that people are misinterpreting this deletion proposal as relating to the deletion of the main CHIKARA article is not accurate, and the distinction is indeed being properly made. Even though BabsChikara accurately responded to your point, that point can also be responded to by the fact that the sources that are used in this article are used only to reference 2012 (season 11) events. For instance, the Press Herald news publication specifically mentions Green Ant as a focal point of CHIKARA, and that is why that news publication is used only as a reference for that. As a second example, the Strathroy Age Dispatch specifically speaks of the Young Lions Cup, and therefore it is only used as a reference for that. These references provide evidence for the importance of CHIKARA in 2012 as opposed to just its general importance, which has already been established. Thirdly,  states that "articles labeled as fancruft" tend to be "unreferenced," and that is clearly not the case with this article. The assertion that this article "is the definition of" or even qualifies as fancruft is not accurate, and even if it is fancruft, which it is not, Wikipedia states that "If you come across fancruft, a kind approach is to assume that the article or topic can be improved." As BabsChikara has stated, this article has been improved and it meets the Wikipedia standards for inclusion for an article. Fourthly, this article simply is not a indiscriminate collection or list of information and it does not resemble the examples that  presents
— User:Turtlepump, 19:02, 8 February 2014 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:AGF||WP:FANCRUFT||WP:DISCRIMINATE (Wikipedia:Assume good faith)