Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neil Cartwright
As author I'm always going to say this, but this player is exceptional in regards to the club he plays for. Hinckley United are only 10 years old and this article relates to a player that has been at the club all that time, coming through the youth teams and then breaking into the first team, becoming the record appearance holder and captaining the team on many occasions. There is a reliable source on the internet for references (or rather was at the time of events), but at this level website authors are also volunteers and so space for news is recycled every year. For 'national' websites that have kept information online, I have added into references. Regardless if he fails , I personally believe those guidlines are too rigid and will prevent natural progression and growth of articles, but that is another argument for elsewhere
— User:Mattythewhite, 22:36, 25 November 2007 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:BIO (Wikipedia:Notability)