Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karui Shosetsu Magazine
Where to begin.... Well I'll start with the beginning, the creation of the page (whatever it's content) fails Wp:CONFLICT. The ANN coverage is precisely one short news item (didn't check the forum, it doesn't affect notability) and 1000 downloads while not a small achivement, is hardly an arguement to prove notability - 1000 downloads is a very small number for downloads. It's irrelevant to wikipedia if people are talking about it on blogs and forums, neither have any impact on notability. Other stuff existing does not automatically mean this page should, wikipedia doensn't work like that and it doesn't strengthen your case () - quite the opposite really as several pages like you describe have been deleted this week. All the references are either 1st party, blogs or an illegal scanlation site, I can't find a single compelling reason to keep
— User:Dandy, 10:34, 1 February 2009 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS (Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions)