Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lindsey Giannini
Agree with nom, subject fails . Lindsey Giannini was crowned ''Miss Central Coast 2015'' allowing her to compete in the ''Miss New Jersey 2015'' pageant that she won. She also competed in the ''Miss America 2016'' pageant and she did not place but won the ''Quality of Life Award''. While 25 references look impressive there are things to look at. There are ten |primary pageant references and five of those are ead links|dead (404 error) links. Eight are from the local ''South Jersey Times'', four is from the local ''Shore News Today'', and two are from the local ''Press of Atlantic''. The one national ''USA Today'' reference is about her race car driver boyfriend that is an otability (people)#Invalid criteria|invalid criteria for notability. Of all the references, where she participated or won Wikipedia:Notability (events)|local pageants that is just |routine coverage, she did win ''Miss New Jersey''. This just doesn't provide OTABLE|notability because it |doesn't have a ''"demonstrable long-term impact on a significant region of the world or a significant widespread societal group ..."'' with IVERSE|"significant national or international coverage", to the individual subject. Winning a state pageant does not provide notability with any Wikipedia:Notability (events)#Duration of coverage|lasting significance. Coverage of http://www.pressofatlanticcity.com/missamerica/the-curse-of-miss-new-jersey/article_5416c286-2ce3-11e5-9b89-4b5bb1f3e9cd.html ''The curse of Miss New Jersey'' might be significant but Lindsey is just one of eighty in that group. With 15 references (not primary) the fact is still that she only won ''Miss New Jersey'' so the subject still fails the |general notability guidelines
— User:Otr500, 10:21, 26 October 2016 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARY||WP:D||WP:N||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTABLE||WP:GEOSCOPE||WP:DIVERSE||WP:GNG (Wikipedia:Notability)