Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel (2nd nomination)
I would buy this as notable if it were about the tag team of Dick Slater and Peter Gabriel (and I'd pay money to see that!).  The keep voters make the same arguments that have been made in other AFDs, often the same people making the same argument, namely that the mere existence of citations pointing to reliable sources = evidence of notability.  In other words, as far as they're concerned, the agenda of their cherry-picked sources automatically becomes our agenda and it matters little or none if that agenda extends to providing comprehensive coverage of what's notable about the topic of professional wrestling.  There are simply far too many examples of what's wrong with that approach, so I won't dwell on such.  However, one which stood out is the fact that we have :Category:American Wrestling Association teams and stables which is reasonably well-populated, but no article on The High Flyers.  Greg Gagne and Jim Brunzell teamed together and appeared on the top or middle of the card for close to a decade and a half, including many years in which the AWA regularly appeared in 15–20,000-seat arenas.  I suppose none of that matters when compared with every little present-day fleeting trending topic mentioned by present-day fanboy news sites.  Likewise, no article on The Crush Gals, who were absolutely freaking huge at the height of their popularity, while we do have an article on The Jumping Bomb Angels, who were nowhere near as big a deal but made a small handful of appearances on WWF television.  Like I said, I could go on forever about that but would rather not.  To sum it up, this approach begs the question: which part of "|Wikipedia is not a newspaper" requires further debate/discussion or deserves to be disregarded
— User:RadioKAOS, 17:09, 24 September 2016 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:NOTNEWS (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)