Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jean-Pierre Giroud
Top cites on Google scholar for JP-Giroud (after filtering out the medical ones with a similar author name) are 396, 238, 204, 190, 174, 142, 139, 136, 121, 118, ... with 10 papers having over 100 cites and an h-index of 31. That's enough to convince me of a pass of #C1, even if his awards are too low-level for notability that way. And membership in the US National Academy of Engineering (for which I just added a source independent of the subject) is a clear pass of #C3. This article is indeed a mess but that's not an issue for AfD. And the nomination statement about what the author has said about sourcing is also not particularly relevant; it comes across more as one editor's misunderstanding how Wikipedia works than as proof that proper sources are unavailable
— User:David, 17:49, 16 April 2018 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:PROF (Wikipedia:Notability)