Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Robinson (referee) (2nd nomination)
Whether or not a source is or is not commercial is not a requisite of it's validity with regard to |verifiability. Though a questionable one, Online World of Wrestling does appear to be a legitimate source of valid information regarding wrestling as much as The Wrestling Observer would be. SLAM! Sports is clearly a valid source though it is not in question here. WWE.com, though not an independent source, is a legitimate source. The question is in what capacity is WWE.com providing the information? I.E., if WWE.com announced, in the future, the death of one of their present or former talent, should we shun it due to it coming from the WWE.com whether it is fact or not? A primary source can indeed be used as a proper resource granted that it is a |reliable source, under the guidelines set by  and . Granted, WWE.com may sometimes take liberties with facts and news - as anyone familiar with the Jeff Hardy situation regarding Survivor Series (2008) is well aware of, but it was - however, the first to post on Chris Benoit. That said, it does have merit as a valid resource. Admittedly, resources of information on Charles Robinson are extremely limited, however, it is indisputable that his role in World Championship Wrestling|WCW, one of the World Wrestling Entertainment|two largest wrestling promotions in the world during the '90s, was pivotal. That said, on the question of whether or not the article subject is notable, the answer is yes. Proving it, on the other hand, with a significant amount of third-party resources, especially as most news outlets - even those with a focus in the professional wrestling niche - do not give much in the way of coverage of referees as they do Managers/Valets and Pro. Wrestlers themselves, is difficult at best and borderline-impossible at worst. That said, I move for a keep of the article, but a weak one. Perhaps further valid sources will become available
— User:Evilgohan2, 05:24, 29 November 2010 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:V||WP:RS||WP:PRIMARY||WP:BLP (Wikipedia:Verifiability)