Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phoenix in popular culture (2nd nomination)
I share this perspective. It is the article, not the topic, that is trivial. My own feeling is that when a subject is notable but an article fails to draw on the resources that provide notability, then the article ought to be stubified until a contributor undertakes to draft something that actually reflects the notability of the subject. However, consensus is to treat these as "editorial" issues even when nothing noteworthy about the subject has been submitted for edit. As a consequence, many articles that are |NOT Wikipedic persist on the spurious grounds that one ''could'' write a Wikipedic article on the subject, even if it would have to be a completely ''different'' article
— User:Ningauble, 14:30, 24 September 2008 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NOT (Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not)