Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sparkling Generation Valkyrie Yuuki (2nd nomination)
WCCA is a notable award ( is passed), as proven by the 2nd AfD discussion which showed a consensus on that point. That's why the WCCA has its own article as well as subpages for each of the nominees and winners throughout the years. An admin ruling that the award is notable should not be overridden based solely on the vague allusion to a past discussion by a single editor. While we should assume good faith, we should also remember that how people interpret what conclusions are reached are subject to their personal bias and should therefore not be taken at face value (as WhisperToMe seems to have done here). With no details on the contents of those past discussions, the precedence of the 2nd WCCA AfD stands: the WCCA is a notable, independent award that satisfies  for the webcomics that have been awarded one. WhisperToMe's assertion to the contrary should be discounted as being poorly supported
— User:Buspar, 08:23, 15 November 2008 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:WEB||WP:WEB (Wikipedia:Notability)