Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Manukyan
I've carefully checked the updates since I first examined the article and have concluded that whilst it is true that he very much fails #Criteria for composers and lyricists|Criteria for composers and lyricists we do have published independent evidence of a minor concert performance and forthcoming CD release. Other articles have snuck into Wikipedia on less, so I am ambivalent about this now. Ultimately this matters little as this is not a vote but a recommendation to the reviewing administrator, and (s)he is going to have to be swayed, not me. Techincally, I still believe that delete is the only allowable result according to the rules - it just depends on how stringently they are applied
— User:Ros0709, 17:00, 14 January 2008 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:MUSIC (Wikipedia:Notability)