Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juliet E. McKenna
I am not going to register a !Vote in this discussion, mainly because I know Juliet a little. But I observe that, with the exception of {{U|Shoessss}}, not one of the "Keep" comments above attempts to address the special meaning of "notability" as used by Wikipedia, which is about what has been written ''about'' the subject, not what the subject has done. Stephen Poore has mentioned some things she has done, but none of the references he gives are independent. Shoesss is arguing based on the alternative criteria specified in |NAUTHOR; but they too require (independent) references, which have not so far been forthcoming
— User:ColinFine, 22:08, 1 June 2018 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:NAUTHOR (Wikipedia:Notability)