Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smudge (band)
Hi there {{u|Dan arndt}}, {{u|Lankiveil}}, and {{u|Shaidar cuebiyar}}. I am changing my vote, as I would say the article sourcing overall has been improved enough to establish notability - thank you for improving it. However, I want to point out that it is ''not'' because of the McFarlane entry or the AllMusic entry. These are not reliable sources. McFarlane is not journalistic, nor does it have the traditional fact-checking and editorial control that is expected of a reliable source (it's effectively a blog of Ian McFarlane, a nice one, to be sure though). Why do I think the AllMusic entry isn't a reliable source? Nick Corr doesn't appear to have written ''anything else, whatsoever'' for AllMusic, I find that quite odd if he's a journalist for them. I'm an IT person and I think any number of IT-related forums and blogs are a fantastic resources, but are definitely not |reliable sources
— User:Waggie, 02:04, 5 June 2017 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:RS (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)