Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cemeteries in Somerset County, New Jersey (second nomination)
or move to project space. In the original AFD and this one I see all the poor arguments for and against deleting, such as: "Listcruft" "I like it" "I don't like it" "Other stuff exists" "We worked hard on it" "It is useful" "Indiscriminate"(no, a list of stuff I saw on the sidewalk while I was walking to work would be indiscriminate. To be on this list it must be a cemetary in a certain geographic location). Major questions: 1)Is the "Political Graveyard," which is the only source, even a reliable and independent source, to show that this satisfies ? 2)Are all counties or other geographic units in the world entitled to similar lists, based on cemetary lists maintained by the governmental units or genealogical societies, in the eyes of "Keep" !voters, or is this county special because of the Famous Dead People not mentioned in the list? Checking #Purpose of lists I do not see that this satisfies the first two possibiilities. It does not fit "Information: lists organized chronologically, grouped by theme, or annotated lists." It does not fit "Navigation: Lists can be used as a table of contents." In the third area, "Development" I note "any lists which exist primarily for development or maintenance purposes (such as a list of red link articles needed) should be in project or user space not the main space, if the list is not otherwise encyclopedic." The guideline seems to indicate this list belongs in project space rather than main space, being a directory of mostly non-notable cemetaries. (edited
— User:Edison, 15:52, 12 September 2007 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:V||WP:LISTS (Wikipedia:Verifiability)