Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HD 118598
As the nominator correctly points out, this star fails all notability criteria under . As for the solar analog argument, I searched the scholarly literature for mentions of this star, and it has not received significant attention for that (or any other) reason. If we disregard the notability criteria for stars like this, then we'd be flooded with potentially hundreds of millions of stubs which merely duplicate information from astronomical catalogues. As for the proper outcome of this AfD, I don't really have a strong preference between deleting and redirecting. I would support either outcome
— User:Astro4686, 00:05, 21 January 2017 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:NASTRO (Wikipedia:Notability)