Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin D. Edwards
Thanks for the caveats re GoogleScholar, Nsk92. I still have doubts about whether the subject satisfies . For starters, there are only three reviews, not six, of the 'Exotic Journeys' book listed in WorldCat, and five reviews, rather than six, of the Gothic book (you counted six and six because some of the reviews are listed twice, for some reason). Three reviews of one book and five of another does not strike me as particularly unusual, especially in the field of English (lots of profs, lots of journals), and especially when the topic of the book is historical Americana (Exotic Journeys) or Americana/Race issues (the Gothic book). There are just two reviews of his third and most recent book on WorldCat, which is on Gothic Canada. (If his books were being reviewed because he is notable, rather than b/c the topic is relevant to a broader cross-section of academic, I would expect him to have consistently high review counts
— NONE, NONE
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:PROF (Wikipedia:Notability)