Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyAnimeList (3rd nomination)
Reiterating a point from the previous AfD that seems to have been forgotten here (can't blame anyone really, previous AfD was full of tl;dr), but please be careful not to reduce the significance of the http://www.seekjapan.jp/article/jz/1525/Best+of+the+Web+'08 Best of the Web award, as it is not only an award by a 20 year old magazine, but it also contains an accompanying article that independently provides non-trivial coverage of MyAnimeList as one of its subjects. So even if a 20 year old magazine published both on and offline doesn't fulfill  #2, it clearly fits  #1. So to recap, for  you have
— NONE, NONE
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:WEB||WP:WEB||WP:WEB (Wikipedia:Notability)