Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of R&B musicians (2nd nomination)
this is a case where a category is appropriate and a list is not.  doesn't apply to categories, which are not articles in the mainspace, but it certainly applies here.  Per , lists like this need to abide by Wikipedia's policies and guidelines. This list fails  as sources aren't present that show that these people are indeed R&B musicians. It is also nothing but a |directory listing of information as it is only a laundry list without any further discussion or information about the participants.  How are they R&B musicians, where does it claim that they are?  Also, per the nom, this list is pretty |indiscriminate as there is no working definition of "R&B" that applies here.  The category works wonderfully, the list doesn't. (copy/paste of my !vote at the last AfD
— User:Themfromspace, 19:51, 20 April 2009 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:STAND||WP:V||WP:DIRECTORY||WP:INDISCRIMINATE (Wikipedia:Listcruft)