Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beheaded Children Contest
Killthepixelnow seems to be directing comments toward me as the first detailed voter, so I checked out the new sources. Killthepixelnow is arguing that the band has received "coverage" but has missed the fact that this term has a distinct meaning in Wikipedia. "Coverage" must be in |reliable sources that are |independent of the band and its own promotional efforts, and even if they appear in such sources, the "coverage" must discuss the band in a |significant fashion. From the new list supplied by Killthepixelnow, we can see that the band has been ''listed'' in album directories, ''mentioned'' in social media, ''discussed'' by bloggers, ''uploaded'' to YouTube, etc. etc. Very little of that is reliable, independent, or significant ''coverage'' under Wikipedia's definitions. Remember that Wikipedia is an encyclopedic resource in which people/things have to qualify for inclusion. And calling for sympathy because they are tragically "underground" won't help either
— User:doomsdayer520, 13:38, 25 August 2020 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:SIGCOV (Wikipedia:Reliable sources)