Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caribbean Airlines Flight 523 (2nd nomination)
extensive coverage by independent sources show that it passes the |GNG. However, WP:AIRCRASH is just an essay, not policy. Also, as far as standalone articles are concerned it only says "''If an accident or incident meets the criteria for inclusion in an airport, airline or aircraft article it may be notable enough for a stand-alone article if it also meets the criteria provided by the general notability guideline, a notability of events guideline and a guide on the use of news reports''". So, the essay is redundant here, as it doesn't set a lower bar than the broader rules on notability which have been agreed by the community
— User:Bobrayner, 16:06, 4 September 2011 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:GNG (Wikipedia:Notability)