Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Candice Kumai
u|Megalibrarygirl}}, a review in a publication that falls under outine is not a critical review even if the reviewer is identified as a "critic". That would be the case if her books were on par with a publication like Mastering the Art of French Cooking, which is considered a milestone cookbook that altered the culinary landscape of the United States and in turn vaulted Julia Child to celebrity status. A standard, routine review in the Bakersfield Times, the New York Times or other newspaper, major or minor, by no means is considered receiving critical attention as required by part 4 of uthor. By ''critical attention'' as stated in that part of the otability guidelines, means that actual study of the works of the creator must be in depth regarding the work and its effects in society. While you will find lots of critical works on Ms. Child and her works, I believe you will have a considerable larger task in locating a true critical assessment of Ms. Kumai's work
— User:Jerem43, 07:08, 17 August 2016 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:R||WP:A||WP:N (Wikipedia:Redirect)