Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carrie Diaz Eaton
I agree that she does not pass #C1. She also does not pass #C3, as her doctoral fellowship, teaching-development fellowship, and leadership-institute fellowship are not the kinds of fellows described in that criterion (major scholarly societies for which fellowship is a highly selective honor). They look more like financial support for students and certificate of attendance in teaching and leadership programs than like honors for high scholarly achievement. So the only remaining question is whether she passes #C2 for the John Jungck Prize for Excellence in Education https://www.smb.org/john-jungck-prize/. It appears to be an award at the national or international level; the question is whether it's a "highly prestigious" award as required by #C2. It does appear to be the top educational award of the SMB (their other awards are for service or research). Since it's an educational award, we can look at whether it's given for the kind of high achievement in education that would also pass #C4, or for lower-level work. The citation says that it's for her creation of an open-access web hub for educational materials (QUBES), for local mentorship, and for being the co-editor of an edited volume, among which only QUBES looks potentially significant to me. There's also some nontrivial (but non-independent) coverage of QUBES at https://www.bates.edu/news/2020/04/24/carrie-diaz-eaton-wins-grant-to-support-open-education/. It doesn't look like enough to me, but with better sourcing of QUBES I could be convinced to change my mind
— User:David, 21:36, 25 June 2020 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:PROF (Wikipedia:Notability)