Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh fight
per the points raised by Vaticidalprophet, MainPeanut, Cheeftun, and Phil Boswell. The original argument wherein a dog gets rescued from ice is just . So the dog got rescued. Are we supposed to make articles for every single rescue that have equally "miraculous" circumstances? Unlike an uncommon yet still frequent event like "dog rescued after four days", there's not a lot of (and possibly even near zero) instances where multiple people gathered from the continental United States&mdash;most of which bearing the name "Josh"&mdash;in order to participate in an event sparked from a "meme" as part of internet culture. The circumstances behind the event - mainly the method of how it was initially planned and its (surprisingly positive) outcomes - also warrant its uniqueness, and will likely serve as a basis for |future events of similar nature
— User:Chlod, 10:16, 26 April 2021 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:DOGBITESMAN||WP:EFFECT (Wikipedia:Notability)