Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finwë
Doing a quick |search engine test, I did not find #Reliable sources and notability|reliable third-party sources independent of the subject to presume |notability. In reliable sources, I only found trivial mentions, which, in my opinion, do not show that the topic meets the |general notability guideline by itself since most of them are analysis of Tolkien's work as a whole, not about the individual fictional character. Within the article, there are only two sources, one of them a |primary source, and none of them amounts more than a plot-description, which does not show how is this character notable in a real-world context. Most of the sources that I found are about the plot of Tolkien's work, not about the fictional character Finwë. I have yet to find a reliable source that addresses in detail the fictional character Finwë with more than one paragraph or that at least talks about the relevance of the character outside of Tolkien's work. Tolkien works are notable, as demonstrated by the many literary criticism essays, but |notability is not inherited to every |content fork. Per the policy WP:!|what Wikipedia is not, since this article is a |plot-only description of a fictional work with no real-world context or sourced analysis and I do not believe that there is evidence that shows that the fictional character itself meets the general notability guideline, I do not think that the article should be kept
— User:Jfgslo, 23:53, 9 May 2011 (UTC)
Stance: delete
Cited policy: WP:SET||WP:V||WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARY||WP:ITSA||WP:CFORK||WP:PLOT (Wikipedia:Search engine test)