Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Idol controversy (2nd nomination)
It's possible this might be an attempt at creating a spinoff page to lessen the length of the original article. Considering how notable this series is, a separate article on the controversies is justified. And there are certainly plenty of sources. Needs to be policed for  and , especially to avoid the dreaded POV Fork Syndrome. And it needs a better lead. And the title needs to  be changed because it suggests this is about only one controversy. It could also possibly be expanded with sections on controversies in regional versions of the show (i.e. World Idol, Canadian Idol, etc). Other than these content issues I don't see a problem with the article's viability or "worthiness" (I don't like the term "unworthy" being used in AFD as it sounds a bit too much like ). I only say "weak keep" because maybe others won't mind the main Idol article ballooning with a controversies section
— User:23skidoo, 12:47, 6 May 2008 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:NPOV||WP:BLP||WP:IDONTLIKEIT (Wikipedia:Neutral point of view)