Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carol Sklenicka
do not retitle. The nomination is fundamentally misguided. It is based on the increasingly common, and disturbingly given credibility, heresy that something in Wikipedia policy dictates that creative people cannot "inherit" notability from their work. This nonsense is, of course, expressly contradicted by policy, guideline, and practice; as  states, "the notability guidelines, for creative professions, books, films and music, do allow for inherited notability". The great majority of creative folks (and notable people in general) live unexceptional personal lives. Editors who expect that people must behave like Kardashians to merit individual articles don't understand what users come to an encyclopedia for. But we don't center our coverage on articles like Drumming of Charlie Watts, Comic strips of Charles Schulz, Baseball career of Sandy Koufax, or Scientific work of Wolfgang Pauli. The AFD process would be greatly improved if any NOMINATOR who cited NOTINHERITED without understanding it was topic banned for a month, length doubling with each subsequent offense
— User:Hullaballoo, 05:07, 28 August 2021 (UTC)
Stance: keep
Cited policy: WP:INHERITED (Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions)