Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MMUnion (2nd nomination)
Come on, let's keep it |civil... It seems fairly clear that Knock-off-Nigel speaks from an American viewpoint. Nothing wrong with that, and certainly doesn't warrent any 'attack' comments, but regardles, hear ''me'' out (me being a second year Physics student at a UK university, me being fairly heavily involved in my Union, me being well aware of what UK SUs are). Student Unions are notable as a whole. ''Individual'' SUs are not. They are all pretty much carbon copies of one another - sure, one union will have slightly different policies than another, but on the whole they'll be the same. As I've said many a time, there are exceptions - a few UK SUs ''are'' notable, and they have the sources to back them up. Most, however, do not. I'm interested: you are completely insistant that SUs are notable. Why is this particular SU notable? How does it meet the  guidelines? I await your response
— User:Islander, 23:51, 6 March 2008 (UTC)
Stance: comment
Cited policy: WP:CIVIL||WP:N (Wikipedia:Civility)