LEGAL DOCUMENT

Case: Phebe Ann Brown v. John Brown
Citation: 2 R.I. 381
Court: Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Jurisdiction: Rhode Island
Decision Date: 1852-09
Docket Number: 
Pages: 381–382
Volume: 2
Reporter: Rhode Island Reports

Parties: Phebe Ann Brown v. John Brown.

Phebe Ann Brown v. John Brown.
A~potition for divorce is sufficiently specific, if it state the grounds of cti- • vorcc in the language of the statute, except where the petitioner relies upon a charge of gross misbehavior and wicketo.ess repugnant to and in violation of the marriage contract, in which case, the acts relied upon to make out the charge must be specified.

Petition for divorce charging the defendant with extreme cruelty, continual drunkenness and other gross misbehavior and wickedness repugnant to and in violation of the marriage contract. The counsel for the petitioner having stated that they relied upon the charge of extreme cruelty, the respondent’s counsel moved the Court to order a specification of the facts constituting the charge.
But the Court said that the uniform practice of the Court had been to consider the petition sufficiently specific if it stated the grounds for divorce in the language of the statute, except in the case of gross misbehavior, in which the Court had required to specify in what the misbehavior consisted. That to require the plaintiff to state all the matters which went to make out the charge of extreme cruelty would be infinite, but, at the same time, the Court said they would guard against surprise upon the defendant, and if at the trial, he was not prepared to meet the evidence of the petitioner from surprise, they would grant a continuance for him to prepare, and would not give the petitioner an advantage from the generality to the charge.'