Case: Keith M. KANESHIRO, in his Official Capacity as Prosecuting Attorney of City and County of Honolulu, on Behalf of State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. ELEVEN (11) PRODUCTS DIRECT Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $38,500.00), Four Hundred Fifty Seven Dollars in United States Currency ($457.00); One (1) Cam Security Digital Recording System (Estimated Value: $200.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $39,157.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner'z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; Wendy Wagner, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0567); Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Twelve (12) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $42,000.00), Seven Hundred Forty Four Dollars in United States Currency ($744.00); One (1) DVR (Estimated Value: $100.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $42,844.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner'z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Steve Ohira, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0568); Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Fifteen (15) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $52,500.00), One Thousand Eight Hundred Eighty Three Dollars in United ty as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant,States Currency ($1,883.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $54,383.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner'z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Sherilyn Gama, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0569); Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capaci Keith M. Kaneshiro, in His Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf v. Fourteen (14) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $49,000.00), Forty Seven Dollars in United States Currency ($47.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $49,047.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner'z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Anna Marie Blas Fejeran, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0570); Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Fifteen (15) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $52,500.00), Seven Hundred Seventy Nine Dollars in United States Currency ($779.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $53,279.00), Defendant-appellee; and Winner'z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Quyenh Nguyen, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0571)of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Ten (10) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $35,000.00), Two Hundred Ninety Dollars in United States Currency ($290.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $35,290.00), Defendant-appellee, and Winner'z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Jay-r Laforteza, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0572)
Abbreviation: Kaneshiro v. Eleven (11) Products Direct
Court: Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals
Jurisdiction: Hawaii
Decision Date: 2017-06-30
Docket Number: NO. CAAP-15-0000848; NO. CAAP-15-0000849; NO. CAAP-15-0000850; NO. CAAP-15-0000852; NO. CAAP-15-0000854; NO. CAAP-15-0000855
Citation: 140 Haw. 22
Volume: 140
Reporter: Hawaii Reports
Parties: Keith M. KANESHIRO, in his Official Capacity as Prosecuting Attorney of City and County of Honolulu, on Behalf of State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. ELEVEN (11) PRODUCTS DIRECT Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $38,500.00), Four Hundred Fifty Seven Dollars in United States Currency ($457.00); One (1) Cam Security Digital Recording System (Estimated Value: $200.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $39,157.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; Wendy Wagner, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0567) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Twelve (12) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $42,000.00), Seven Hundred Forty Four Dollars in United States Currency ($744.00); One (1) DVR (Estimated Value: $100.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $42,844.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Steve Ohira, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0568) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Fifteen (15) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $52,500.00), One Thousand Eight Hundred Eighty Three Dollars in United ty as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant,States Currency ($1,883.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $54,383.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Sherilyn Gama, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0569) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capaci Keith M. Kaneshiro, in His Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf v. Fourteen (14) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $49,000.00), Forty Seven Dollars in United States Currency ($47.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $49,047.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Anna Marie Blas Fejeran, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0570) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Fifteen (15) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $52,500.00), Seven Hundred Seventy Nine Dollars in United States Currency ($779.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $53,279.00), Defendant-appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Quyenh Nguyen, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0571)of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Ten (10) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $35,000.00), Two Hundred Ninety Dollars in United States Currency ($290.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $35,290.00), Defendant-appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Jay-r Laforteza, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0572)
Pages: 22–23

396 P.3d 1160
Keith M. KANESHIRO, in his Official Capacity as Prosecuting Attorney of City and County of Honolulu, on Behalf of State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. ELEVEN (11) PRODUCTS DIRECT Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $38,500.00), Four Hundred Fifty Seven Dollars in United States Currency ($457.00); One (1) Cam Security Digital Recording System (Estimated Value: $200.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $39,157.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; Wendy Wagner, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0567) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Twelve (12) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $42,000.00), Seven Hundred Forty Four Dollars in United States Currency ($744.00); One (1) DVR (Estimated Value: $100.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $42,844.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Steve Ohira, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0568) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Fifteen (15) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $52,500.00), One Thousand Eight Hundred Eighty Three Dollars in United ty as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant,States Currency ($1,883.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $54,383.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Sherilyn Gama, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0569) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capaci Keith M. Kaneshiro, in His Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf v. Fourteen (14) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $49,000.00), Forty Seven Dollars in United States Currency ($47.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $49,047.00), Defendant-Appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Anna Marie Blas Fejeran, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0570) Keith M. Kaneshiro, in his Official Capacity as the Prosecuting Attorney of The City And County of Honolulu, on Behalf of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Fifteen (15) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $52,500.00), Seven Hundred Seventy Nine Dollars in United States Currency ($779.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $53,279.00), Defendant-appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Quyenh Nguyen, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0571)of the State of Hawai'i, Petitioner-appellant, v. Ten (10) Products Direct Sweepstakes Machines (Total Estimated Value: $35,000.00), Two Hundred Ninety Dollars in United States Currency ($290.00) (Total Aggregate Value: $35,290.00), Defendant-appellee, and Winner’z Zone; April Whiting-Haraguchi, Tracy Yoshimura, PJY Enterprises; and Jay-r Laforteza, Interested Persons-Appellees (S.P. NO. 14-1-0572)
NO. CAAP-15-0000848
NO. CAAP-15-0000849
NO. CAAP-15-0000850
NO. CAAP-15-0000852
NO. CAAP-15-0000854
NO. CAAP-15-0000855
Intermediate Court of Appeals of Hawai'i.
DATED: Honolulu, Hawai'i, June 30, 2017.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIRST CIRCUIT, (S.P. NO. 14-1-0567), (S.P. NO. 14-1-0568), (S.P. NO. 14-1-0569), (S.P. NO. 14-1-0570), (S.P. NO. 14-1-0571), (S.P. NO. 14-1-0572)
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Vacate and remand.