49th Munich Security Conference 2013: Debating the geopolitics of energy: From right: Moderator Dr. Daniel Yergin (Vice Chairman, IHS Cambridge Energy Research Associates), Dr. Philipp Rösler (Federal Minister of Economics and Technology, Federal Republic of Germany), Günther Oettinger (Commissioner for Energy, European Union), Aleksandr Novak (Minister of Energy, Russian Federation), Jorma Ollila (Chairman of the Board of Directors, Royal Dutch Shell), Carlos Pascual (Ambassador, Special Envoy and Coordinator for International Energy Affairs, U.S. Department of State).