Fayetteville Mutual Insurance Company Building Located at 320 Hay Street in Fayetteville, Cumberland County, North Carolina, the Fayetteville Mutual Insurance Company building is a two-story. trapezoidal shaped brick building c. 1853. It is an example of the commercial vernacular Greek Revival. The company was formed in 1853 to make property and fire insurance available locally rather that from out of town or out of state agencies.