Original sentence: He had two brothers — al-Rabi and Sallam; all three were declared enemies of Muhammad.Kinana ibn al-Rabi' (, also Kinana bin al-Rabi, Kinana ibn al-Rabi'a, Kinana ibn al-Rabi ibn Abu al-Huqayq) was a Jewish leader of seventh-century Arabia and an opponent of Muhammad; son of the poet al-Rabi ibn Abu al-Huqayq, who flourished at Medina in the seventh century, prior to the appearance of Muhammad at that town.The Jewish strongholds at Khaibar were soon after conquered by Muhammad, and Kinana was made a prisoner of war.The death of Kinana ibn al-Rabi is reported through only one source, and that is Ibn Hisham
Edited sentence: According to Nomani, tradionists have stated that Ibn Ishaq probably borrowed this story from the contemporary descendents of al-Rabi's tribe.Al-Rabi was executed after the Battle of Khaybar for hiding the tribe's treasure.He doubts Muhammad would have tortured al-Rabi, as he forgave the Jewess Raihana after the she tried to poison him.He had two brothers — al-Rabi and [[Sallam ibn al-Rabi|Sallam.He was exceuted, al-Mubarakpuri concludes, for breaching the agreement.Ibn Ishaq, however, doesn't specify any source for this story.Kinana ibn al-Rabi' (, also Kinana bin al-Rabi, Kinana ibn al-Rabi'a, Kinana ibn al-Rabi ibn Abu al-Huqayq) was a Jewish leader of seventh-century Arabia and an opponent of Muhammad; son of the poet al-Rabi ibn Abu al-Huqayq.Montgomery Watt supports the view that he was executed for concealing the treasure.Nomani also casts doubt on the accuraccy of the story due to its sources (see section below).Nomani also casts doubt on the story on the basis of its inconsistency with Muhammad's other actions.Shibli Nomani, however, argues that Kinana was put to death because he had killed Mahmud, the brother of Muhammad b.The story of al-Rabi narrated by Ibn Hisham has been taken from Ibn Ishaq