premise: Basil Davenport (1905-1966) was a literary critic, United States academic, anthologist, author of science fiction novels, and other genres. He was born in Louisville, Kentucky on March 7, 1905, the son of Ira William Davenport and Emily Andrews Davison. He died on April 7, 1966, in New York County, New York, at the age of 61.
hypothesis: More than one literary critic was born in 1905.
reason: Reason:  We have no idea how many literary critics were born in 1905.  Why: Used the birth year for 1 literary critic.