premise: Sir John Hawkins (29 March 1719 – 21 May 1789) was an English author and friend of Dr Samuel Johnson and Horace Walpole. He was part of Johnson's various clubs but later left The Literary Club after a disagreement with some of Johnson's other friends. His friendship with Johnson continued and he was made one of the executors of Johnson's will.
hypothesis: Sir John Hawkins continued his friendship with Horace Walpole after leaving The Literary Club
reason: It's not stated whether Hawkins continued his friendship with Walpole or not. I think the system got it wrong because the statement would be correct if one of the names was swapped