premise: The Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society is a refereed theological journal published by the Evangelical Theological Society. It was first published in 1958 as the "Bulletin of the Evangelical Theological Society", and was given its present name in 1969.
hypothesis: The Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society is a religious publication. 
reason: The words "evangelical" and "theological" indicate the publications religious nature. I think the system had trouble with it because the word "religious" does not occur in the statement. 