premise: Johnny Kidd (born Frederick Albert Heath, 23 December 1935 – 7 October 1966) was an English singer and songwriter, best remembered as the lead vocalist for the rock and roll band Johnny Kidd & the Pirates. He was one of the few pre-Beatles British rockers to achieve worldwide fame, mainly for his 1960 hit, "Shakin' All Over".
hypothesis: Johnny Kidd did not play guitar for Johnny Kidd & the Pirates.
reason: The context doesn't say whether Johnny Kidd played guitar for the band or not, but I suggested he did not. I think the AI may have focused on matching whether Kidd participated at all with the band, rather than what his specific role was.  I almost used the word "never" but I kind of think the AI has an easier time with absolutes like that, for some reason.