premise: Amelio Robles Avila was a colonel during the Mexican Revolution. He was born a woman with the name of Amelia Robles Ávila on November 3, 1889 in Xochipala, Guerrero. His father was named Casimiro Robles and his mother Josefa Ávila. His father was a wealthy farmer who owned 42 acres of land and owned a small Mezcal factory.
hypothesis: Casimiro Robles was born on November 3, 1859.
reason: The birth date of this person's father is never mentioned. It's difficult because a different, but similar birthdate is mentioned is the text which is enough to confuse the system.