Premise: oh when i first got her i mean Sheba was just a little tiny thing got her at ten weeks and and Kitty Cat took it upon herself to train her and she and Kitty Cat would jump all over her and beat her up and all you'll hear is Sheba you know  all the time well now she's bigger than Kitty Cat and she's giving Kitty Cat some payback

Hypothesis: We didn't get Sheba until she was a year old. 
Relation: contradiction