Question: Question Suppose that I have implemented two Python types using the C extension API and that the types are identical (same data layouts/C struct) with the exception of their names and a few methods. Assuming that all methods respect the data layout, can you safely change the type of an object from one of these types into the other in a C function? Notably, as of Python 3.9, there appears to be a function Py_SET_TYPE, but the documentation is not clear as to whether/when this is safe to do. I'm interested in knowing both how to use this function safely and whether types can be safely changed prior to version 3.9. Motivation I'm writing a Python C extension to implement a Persistent Hash Array Mapped Trie (PHAMT); in case it's useful, the source code is here (as of writing, it is at this commit). A feature I would like to add is the ability to create a Transient Hash Array Mapped Trie (THAMT) from a PHAMT. THAMTs can be created from PHAMTs in O(1) time and can be mutated in-place efficiently. Critically, THAMTs have the exact same underlying C data-structure as PHAMTs—the only real difference between a PHAMT and a THAMT is a few methods encapsulated by their Python types. This common structure allows one to very efficiently turn a THAMT back into a PHAMT once one has finished performing a set of edits. (This pattern typically reduces the number of memory allocations when performing a large number of updates to a PHAMT). A very convenient way to implement the conversion from THAMT to PHAMT would be to simply change the type pointers of the THAMT objects from the THAMT type to the PHAMT type. I am confident that I can write code that safely navigates this change, but I can imagine that doing so might, for example, break the Python garbage collector. (To be clear: the motivation is just context as to how the question arose. I'm not looking for help implementing the structures described in the Motivation, I'm looking for an answer to the Question, above.)

Answer: The supported way It is officially possible to change an object's type in Python, as long as the memory layouts are compatible... but this is mostly limited to types not implemented in C. With some restrictions, it is possible to do # Python attribute assignment, not C struct member assignment obj.__class__ = some_new_class  to change an object's class, with one of the restrictions being that both the old and new classes must be "heap types", which all classes implemented in Python are and most classes implemented in C are not. (types.ModuleType and subclasses of that type are also specifically permitted, despite types.ModuleType not being a heap type. See the source for exact restrictions.) If you want to create a heap type from C, you can, but the interface is pretty different from the normal way of defining Python types from C. Plus, for __class__ assignment to work, you have to not set the Py_TPFLAGS_IMMUTABLETYPE flag, and that means that people will be able to monkey-patch your classes in ways you might not like (or maybe you see that as an upside). If you want to go that route, I suggest looking at the CPython 3.10 _functools module source code for an example. (They set the Py_TPFLAGS_IMMUTABLETYPE flag, which you'll have to make sure not to do.)  The unsupported way There was an attempt at one point to allow __class__ assignment for non-heap types, as long as the memory layouts worked. It got abandoned because it caused problems with some built-in immutable types, where the interpreter likes to reuse instances. For example, allowing (1).__class__ = SomethingElse would have caused a lot of problems. You can read more in the big comment in the source code for the __class__ setter. (The comment is slightly out of date, particularly regarding the Py_TPFLAGS_IMMUTABLETYPE flag, which was added after the comment was written.) As far as I know, this was the only problem, and I don't think any more problems have been added since then. The interpreter isn't going to aggressively reuse instances of your classes, so as long as you're not doing anything like that, and the memory layouts are compatible, I think changing the type of your objects should work for now, even for non-heap-types. However, it is not officially supported, so even if I'm right about this working for now, there's no guarantee it'll keep working. Py_SET_TYPE only sets an object's type pointer. It doesn't do any refcount fixing that might be needed. It's a very low-level operation. If neither the old class nor the new class are heap types, no extra refcount fixing is needed, but if the old class is a heap type, you will have to decref the old class, and if the new class is a heap type, you will have to incref the new class. If you need to decref the old class, make sure to do it after changing the object's class and possibly incref'ing the new class.