# Search Patterns Based on Trajectories Extracted from the Response of Second-Order Systems
## 7 Experimental Results
### Performance Evaluation with CEC 2017
\begin{table}
\begin{tabular}{c l l l l l l l} \hline \hline  & & **ABC** & **CMAES** & **CSA** & **DE** & **MFOO** & **PSO** & **SOA** \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{17}(x)\)} & **AB** & 2395.86777 & 3482.11031 & 3378.54815 & 2177.58318 & 2441.465302 & 2294.79893 & 2174.93599 \\  & **MD** & 2389.4562 & 3468.22585 & 3372.19373 & 2187.84011 & 2454.470182 & 2268.3003 & 2159.79812 \\  & **SD** & 102.889656 & 285.667211 & 324.223747 & 85.3307491 & 250.2293907 & 294.2882 & 194.053384 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{28}(x)\)} & **AB** & 5,046,671.6 & 37,362,365 & 23,998,373.2 & 2,228,087.66 & 4,549,050.542 & 1,341,517.26 & 818,677.628 \\  & **MD** & 4,728,588.97 & 33,258,799.8 & 22,223,367.5 & 2,033,807.45 & 1,182,780.284 & 682,252.246 & 300,231.736 \\  & **SD** & 2,468,179.06 & 22,078,270.5 & 13,062,667.1 & 914,951.248 & 9,866,226.402 & 1,857,506.17 & 1,622,268.27 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{19}(x)\)} & **AB** & 16,681.7816 & 620,387,919 & 616,153,747 & 551,809,083 & 16,702,987.12 & 13,973,268.1 & 4686.90195 \\  & **MD** & 7134,24743 & 509,584,907 & 600,010,030 & 481,336.814 & 143,655.9903 & 51,084.259 & 3334.90276 \\  & **SD** & 24,639.1966 & 466,495,950 & 315,926,138 & 399,364.141 & 44,687,264.34 & 449,699.69 & 3974.19763 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{20}(x)\)} & **AB** & 2776.66582 & 2804.5126 & 2945.57725 & 2439.77572 & 2697.417352 & 2452.70485 & 2439.26615 \\  & **MD** & 2764.33673 & 2834.35184 & 2955.48441 & 2445.1877 & 2627.891978 & 2488.70557 & 2449.42599 \\  & **SD** & 94.7983596 & 199.062724 & 106.815418 & 88.0385339 & 220.4185834 & 179.132846 & 147.240337 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{21}(x)\)} & **AB** & 2523.44927 & 2641.22467 & 2739.23609 & 2514.75813 & 2506.000485 & 2434.7453 & 2421.58999 \\  & **MD** & 2524.34506 & 2643.05906 & 2741.53087 & 2518.37232 & 2499.78219 & 2433.21201 & 2426.32387 \\  & **SD** & 15.4046594 & 36.2479731 & 41.9080485 & 10.9762507 & 40.05305083 & 236.6970887 & 21.141776 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{22}(x)\)} & **AB** & 4836.58643 & 9577.04104 & 9095.47501 & 6970.19197 & 6645.22701 & 5532 20097 & 4165.49182 \\  & **MD** & 4242.35722 & 9932.08496 & 9057.945945 & 6750.16911 & 6848.785842 & 6923.54829 & 3767.22155 \\  & **SD** & 201.83573 & 1437.6621 & 763.435864 & 1310.37051 & 1508.145068 & 1932.03672 & 1801.85242 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{23}(x)\)} & **AB** & 2872.69194 & 3047.39462 & 3398.54677 & 2848.15024 & 2871.343894 & 2904.06627 & 2785.54406 \\  & **MD** & 2872.47313 & 3045.83859 & 3425.04431 & 2848.07645 & 2814.326953 & 2917.30159 & 2781.95288 \\  & **SD** & 10.9306383 & 35.8015482 & 80.91846 & 9.83856624 & 34.39809682 & 57.5467798 & 22.306126 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{24}(x)\)} & **AB** & 3029.76315 & 3180.2796 & 3622.26109 & 3048.38906 & 2970.576725 & 3097.14113 & 2998.32425 \\  & **MD** & 3029.47271 & 3188.3269 & 3620.25868 & 3050.32895 & 2969.979831 & 3072.58458 & 2996.90489 \\  & **SD** & 12.2834187 & 30.8119037 & 99.447193 & 14.170605 & 27.40350786 & 61.1357559 & 35.0296809 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{25}(x)\)} & **AB** & 2918.77003 & 3333.22102 & 6228.94202 & 2976.74179 & 3234.960327 & 3006.6561 & 2931.4471 \\  & **MD** & 2919.85456 & 2980.52118 & 6253.4295 & 2977.53996 & 3142.80023 & 2992.45175 & 2927.585824 \\ \cline{1-1}  & **SD** & 91.847821 & 759.162584 & 864.95632 & 16.7265818 & 310.0654881 & 102.116534 & 17.693953 \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{\(F_{26}(x)\)} & **AB** & 5896.23764 & 8340.37382 & 11,171.1937 & 5643.82962 & 5776.420284 & 5702.64017 & 4464.46857 \\ \cline{1-1}  & **MD** & 5889.23731 & 8393.26188 & 11,286.1812 & 5659.37067 & 5796.165191 & 5707.34766 & 4933.20537 \\ \cline{1-1}  & **SD** & 115.549909 & 452.740525 & 720.862035 & 138.81176 & 469.5232252 & 888.19