# Applying Particle Swarm Optimization Variations to Solve the Transportation Problem Effectively
## 4 The Basic PSO for Solving the TP
\begin{table}
\begin{tabular}{l l l l l l l l} \hline \hline  & & **PSO** & **DWPSO** & **TVAC** & **TrigAC-PSO** & **FSVAC** \\ \hline  & Mean & 441.1333333 & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 \\  & St.Dev & 7.619092775 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ Pr06 & Min & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 \\  & Max & 463 & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 & 435 \\  & cv\% & 1.72716324 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ \hline  & Mean & 391.5 & 390.0333 & 390.4667 & 390 & 390 \\  & St.Dev & 5.015493237 & 0.182574 & 2.55603 & 0 & 0 \\ Pr07 & Min & 390 & 390 & 390 & 390 & 390 \\  & Max & 410 & 391 & 404 & 390 & 390 \\  & cv\% & 1.281096612 & 3.290831 & 0.654611 & 0 & 0 \\ \hline  & Mean & 1650.933333 & 1593.033 & 1598.7 & 1592.1333 & 1629.533 \\  & St.Dev & 44.7667775 & 17.95873 & 23.31367 & 12.23824 & 40.14347 \\ Pr08 & Min & 1580 & 1580 & 1580 & 1580 & 1580 \\  & Max & 1790 & 1642 & 1661 & 1623 & 1712 \\  & cv\% & 2.711604194 & 1.127329 & 1.45829 & 0.7686698 & 2.463495 \\ \hline  & Mean & 52.6 & 51.3 & 52.06667 & 51.6 & 51.16667 \\  & St.Dev & 2.40114915 & 2.768667 & 1.79910 & 1.90462 & 1.89524 \\ Pr09 & Min & 49 & 109 & 49 & 49 & 49 \\  & Max & 63 & 122 & 55 & 53 & 53 \\  & cv\% & 4.564922339 & 5.397012 & 3.455389 & 3.6911285 & 3.704062 \\ \hline  & Mean & 427.433333 & 427.7667 & 428.1 & 428.3 & 425.8 \\  & St.Dev & 8.935336025 & 4.38401 & 5.16853 & 6.25410 & 5.71386 \\ Pr10 & Min & 410 & 411 & 411 & 410 & 410 \\  & Max & 434 & 431 & 431 & 432 & 430 \\  & cv\% & 2.09046308 & 1.02486 & 1.20732 & 1.4602153 & 1.341913 \\ \hline  & Mean & 2913.833333 & 2934.8 & 2864.633 & 2857.1 & 3036.767 \\  & St.Dev & 186.8538214 & 220.8248 & 226.892 & 11.66885 & 380.4261 \\ Pr11 & Min & 2850 & 2850 & 2850 & 2850 & 2850 \\  & Max & 3850 & 3945 & 2977 & 2891 & 4554 \\  & cv\% & 6.412646162 & 7.524358 & 1.117014 & 0.4084159 & 12.52734 \\ \hline  & Mean & 190.5666667 & 184.4333 & 186.03333 & 184.33333 & 183.9 \\  & St.Dev & 7.623391106 & 1.50134 & 4.60496 & 1.49327 & 1.39827 \\ Pr12 & Min & 183 & 183 & 183 & 183 & 183 \\  & Max & 206 & 186 & 200 & 186 & 186 \\  & cv\% & 4.00038015 & 0.814029 & 2.475347 & 0.8100976 & 0.760345 \\ \hline  & Mean & 805.3666667 & 799 & 799 & 799 & 799 \\  & St.Dev & 16.77535823 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ Pr13 & Min & 799 & 799 & 799 & 799 & 799 \\  & Max & 878 & 799 & 799 & 799 & 799 \\  & cv\% & 2.082946678 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ \hline  & Mean & 319.9333333 & 302.2 & 290.4 & 290.1 & 292.2667 \\  & St.Dev & 21.78251962 & 17.70525 & 6.69328 & 16.159442 & 8.10250 \\ Pr14 & Min & 292 & 273 & 273 & 273 & 273 \\  & Max & 378 & 335 & 317 & 327 & 306 \\  & cv\% & 6.808455809 & 5.858785 & 2.304849 & 5.5703008 & 2.772298 \\ \hline  & Mean & 1186.1 & 1160 & 1160.067 & 1160 & 1160 \\  & St.Dev & 73.12122669 & 0 & 0.36514 & 0 & 0 \\ Pr15 & Min & 1160 & 1160 & 1160 & 1160 & 1160 \\  & Max & 1401 & 1160 & 1162 & 1160 & 1160 \\  & cv\% & 6.164845012 & 0 & 0.031476 & 0 & 0 \\ \hline  & Mean & 217.133333 & 202.9667 & 202.7333 & 200 & 203.2333 \\  & St.Dev & 7.946950546 & 5.979755 & 6.53338 & 0 & 6.76034 \\ Pr16 & Min & 200 & 200 & 200 & 200 & 109 \\  & Max & 237 & 218 & 220 & 200 & 119 \\  & cv\% & 3.659940381 & 2.946176 & 3.222647 & 0 & 3.326397 \\ \hline  & Mean & 244.6333333 & 241.6667 & 240 & 240 & 240 \\  & St.Dev & 6.025711195 & 5.195046 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ Pr17 & Min & 240 & 240 & 240 & 240 & 240 \\  & Max & 256 & 259 & 240 & 240 & 240 \\  & cv\% & 2.463160319 & 2.149674 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ \hline \hline \end{tabular}
\end{table} 
Table 7: _Cont._