## 3 Proposed Method
### Improved SMA
\begin{table}
\begin{tabular}{c c c c c c c c} \hline \hline
**Func** & **Criteria** & **DQOBLSMA** & **OBLSMAL** & **ESMA** & **MEO** & **JADE** & **RWGWO** \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{F1} & Best & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(1.0936\times 10^{-54}\) & \(7.1160\times 10^{-14}\) & \(7.2435\times 10^{-73}\) \\  & Mean & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(1.3473\times 10^{-51}\) & \(1.3924\times 10^{-12}\) & \(9.9351\times 10^{-65}\) \\  & Worst & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(1.1718\times 10^{-50}\) & \(8.3623\times 10^{-12}\) & \(2.8903\times 10^{-63}\) \\  & Std & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.4983\times 10^{-51}\) & \(2.2303\times 10^{-12}\) & \(6.9913\times 10^{-64}\) \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{F2} & Best & \(1.6860\times 10^{-280}\) & \(1.8971\times 10^{-126}\) & \(1.2829\times 10^{-179}\) & \(1.2944\times 10^{-32}\) & \(8.7945\times 10^{-08}\) & \(8.4261\times 10^{-52}\) \\  & Mean & \(2.9368\times 10^{-231}\) & \(7.4709\times 10^{-113}\) & \(4.1210\times 10^{-175}\) & \(6.2425\times 10^{-31}\) & \(4.5037\times 10^{-06}\) & \(1.2077\times 10^{-47}\) \\  & Worst & \(8.8104\times 10^{-200}\) & \(2.1489\times 10^{-111}\) & \(8.3686\times 10^{-174}\) & \(2.2747\times 10^{-30}\) & \(7.1303\times 10^{-05}\) & \(7.7841\times 10^{-47}\) \\  & Std & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(5.1975\times 10^{-112}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(7.6873\times 10^{-31}\) & \(1.7166\times 10^{-05}\) & \(2.3314\times 10^{-47}\) \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{F3} & Best & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(1.3923\times 10^{-278}\) & \(3.5006\times 10^{-21}\) & \(3.4830\times 10^{+00}\) & \(2.2232\times 10^{+03}\) \\  & Mean & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(7.5255\times 10^{-205}\) & \(1.7481\times 10^{-17}\) & \(2.1172\times 10^{+01}\) & \(6.0553\times 10^{+03}\) \\  & Worst & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(2.2576\times 10^{-203}\) & \(1.1762\times 10^{-16}\) & \(5.6794\times 10^{+01}\) & \(1.1356\times 10^{+04}\) \\  & Std & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+000}\) & \(3.4991\times 10^{-17}\) & \(1.6585\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.4311\times 10^{+03}\) \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{F4} & Best & \(2.2279\times 10^{-273}\) & \(9.2369\times 10^{-122}\) & \(8.7764\times 10^{-173}\) & \(6.6498\times 10^{-15}\) & \(1.2412\times 10^{-1}\) & \(8.3027\times 10^{-07}\) \\  & Mean & \(1.4919\times 10^{-224}\) & \(1.3337\times 10^{-106}\) & \(1.4870\times 10^{-162}\) & \(5.1881\times 10^{-13}\) & \(6.6358\times 10^{-21}\) & \(2.1528\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Worst & \(4.4756\times 10^{-223}\) & \(3.9116\times 10^{-105}\) & \(4.2072\times 10^{-161}\) & \(5.2753\times 10^{-12}\) & \(1.7608\times 10^{+00}\) & \(2.9139\times 10^{+01}\) \\  & Std & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(9.4644\times 10^{-106}\) & \(1.0186\times 10^{-161}\) & \(1.2870\times 10^{-12}\) & \(4.2471\times 10^{-01}\) & \(7.2432\times 10^{+00}\) \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{F5} & Best & \(4.8100\times 10^{-04}\) & \(2.6149\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.3534\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.5670\times 10^{+01}\) & \(1.5204\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.8626\times 10^{+01}\) \\  & Mean & \(1.4718\times 10^{-01}\) & \(2.7476\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.7593\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.6755\times 10^{+01}\) & \(3.4093\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.8807\times 10^{+01}\) \\  & Worst & \(5.6207\times 10^{-01}\) & \(2.8866\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.8973\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.8759\times 10^{+01}\) & \(9.3404\times 10^{+01}\) & \(2.8898\times 10^{+01}\) \\  & Std & \(1.5834\times 10^{-01}\) & \(8.0237\times 10^{-01}\) & \(1.5217\times 10^{+00}\) & \(7.3628\times 10^{-01}\) & \(2.4394\times 10^{+01}\) & \(6.2979\times 10^{-02}\) \\ \hline \multirow{4}{*}{F6} & Best & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Mean & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(0.0

\begin{table}
\begin{tabular}{c c c c c c c c} \hline \hline
**Func** & **Criteria** & **DQOBLSMA** & **OBLSMAL** & **ESMA** & **MEO** & **JADE** & **RWGWO** \\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{F14} & Best & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(1.0937\times 10^{+00}\) & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) \\  & Mean & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(1.1304\times 10^{+00}\) & \(1.0641\times 10^{+00}\) & \(5.7783\times 10^{+00}\) & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(1.7229\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Worst & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(2.9821\times 10^{+00}\) & \(2.9821\times 10^{+00}\) & \(1.2671\times 10^{+01}\) & \(9.9800\times 10^{-01}\) & \(5.9288\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Std & \(3.4807\times 10^{-13}\) & \(5.2272\times 10^{-01}\) & \(4.8038\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9055\times 10^{+00}\) & \(2.7756\times 10^{-17}\) & \(1.6192\times 10^{+00}\) \\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{F15} & Best & \(3.0958\times 10^{-04}\) & \(3.0772\times 10^{-04}\) & \(5.8084\times 10^{-04}\) & \(3.0894\times 10^{-04}\) & \(3.0749\times 10^{-04}\) & \(4.1151\times 10^{-04}\) \\  & Mean & \(3.8029\times 10^{-04}\) & \(8.3277\times 10^{-04}\) & \(8.3114\times 10^{-04}\) & \(3.4423\times 10^{-03}\) & \(1.7361\times 10^{-03}\) & \(1.1214\times 10^{-03}\) \\  & Worst & \(6.3781\times 10^{-04}\) & \(1.2548\times 10^{-03}\) & \(1.2249\times 10^{-03}\) & \(2.0363\times 10^{-02}\) & \(2.0363\times 10^{-02}\) & \(2.6665\times 10^{-03}\) \\  & Std & \(9.0820\times 10^{-05}\) & \(3.3167\times 10^{-04}\) & \(2.3138\times 10^{-04}\) & \(7.2217\times 10^{-03}\) & \(5.8251\times 10^{-03}\) & \(5.9580\times 10^{-04}\) \\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{F16} & Best & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Mean & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Worst & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0316\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-1.0307\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Std & \(4.1555\times 10^{-10}\) & \(3.1460\times 10^{-08}\) & \(2.6995\times 10^{-10}\) & \(1.7352\times 10^{-10}\) & \(6.5564\times 10^{-16}\) & \(2.3316\times 10^{-04}\) \\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{F17} & Best & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) \\  & Mean & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9792\times 10^{-01}\) \\  & Worst & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9789\times 10^{-01}\) & \(3.9803\times 10^{-01}\) \\  & Std & \(3.2851\times 10^{-08}\) & \(1.4951\times 10^{-07}\) & \(3.9490\times 10^{-08}\) & \(5.0177\times 10^{-09}\) & \(0.0000\times 10^{-000}\) & \(4.2346\times 10^{-05}\) \\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{F18} & Best & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Mean & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.00029\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Worst & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0000\times 10^{+00}\) & \(3.0020\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Std & \(4.3415\times 10^{-07}\) & \(7.5551\times 10^{-07}\) & \(4.5784\times 10^{-11}\) & \(1.0614\times 10^{-06}\) & \(1.5740\times 10^{-15}\) & \(8.2802\times 10^{-03}\) \\ \hline \multirow{3}{*}{F19} & Best & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8626\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) \\  & Mean & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8628\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8627\times 10^{+00}\) & \(-3.8589\times 10^{+