Logie Jan: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to MinistersText is incorporated into the Bound VolumeLogie Jan: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers[Sitting date: 06 May 2014. Volume:698;Page:17483. Text is incorporated into the Bound Volume.]7.JAN LOGIE (Green) to theMinister of Justice: Does she stand by her statement “we need to encourage these women and children to be comfortable coming forward to report domestic and sexual violence”; if so what has she done to encourage women to report domestic violence?Hon JUDITH COLLINS (Minister of Justice): Yes; the Government has already achieved significant progress with improving the support for victims of domestic and sexual violence. As a result of the $50 offender levy $12.6 million has been collected since July 2010. There are 15 new grants and services available to victims including discretionary grants to support victims of sexual violence and funding for the nationalSexual Violence Survivor Advocate as well as specialist victim advisers to provide assistance for parents or caregivers who attend court to support child witnesses. As Minister of Justice I have initiated a major work stream which is nearing completion and which will include a range of further initiatives to provide better support and access to justice for victims of domestic and sexual violence.Jan Logie: Will women feel encouraged to report domestic violence when they see her the Minister of Justice defending Maurice Williamson’s interference—Mr SPEAKER: Order! [Interruption] Order! That question now has no connection with the primary question. I do not want to take supplementary questions away from the member. I invite her to ask a question that is in relation to the primary question.Hon Members: Point of order.Mr SPEAKER: Well I cannot take three at once. I will not take any; they have all sat down.Jan Logie: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. My initial question was relating to encouraging women to report. My second question was whether women will feel encouraged to report based on the leadership provided by that Minister. It was directly relevant.Mr SPEAKER: If the member simply asks that question it will be in order but when it is a reference to a resignation that has occurred etc. that is not in order. So if the member wants to stand and ask the question that she has just raised in the point of order it may well be acceptable.Jan Logie: Will women feel encouraged to report domestic violence when they see her the Minister of Justice providing leadership in domestic violence supporting a Minister’s interference in a police case?Mr SPEAKER: Order! I gave the member one more chance. She was on the right track until the last part. I will give her only one—[Interruption] Order! I will give her one more opportunity. Otherwise we will move to the next question.Grant Robertson: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. I would ask you to reflect on that ruling you have just made. The question from Jan Logie was a broad statement around domestic and sexual violence. She has asked a question of the Minister. I cannot understand why her referencing a matter that is in the public arena rules the question out of order.Mr SPEAKER: Well the member might not understand it but I invite the member to look very carefully at the Standing Orders—Grant Robertson: Which one?Mr SPEAKER: Well 384 if the member needs it and I invite him to read it if he wants to. Supplementary questions are at the discretion of the Speaker. I have been very patient with the member. I will give the member her last opportunity. Otherwise we are moving to the next question.Jan Logie: Will women feel encouraged to report domestic violence when they see her the Minister of Justice providing public defence in relation to a high-profile case of domestic violence?Hon JUDITH COLLINS: Of course I have not done that. What I have done is to say that the Prime Minister was quite right to receive the resignation of my colleague Mr Williamson in the circumstances. I have also at the same time—Rt Hon Winston Peters: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker.Mr SPEAKER: Order! I apologise to the Minister.Rt Hon Winston Peters: On three occasions you found that the original question was erroneous or outside the Standing Orders because of a reference to a certain case. Now you find that the Minister of Justice is quite within the borders of the Standing Orders having referred to the case that you ruled out from being referred to in the first place. Can we have some consistency here please.Mr SPEAKER: I would have thought the Minister’s answer was helpful to the House but if the member is objecting to the answer then I will curtail the answer and we will move on. Are there further supplementary questions?Jan Logie: If tackling domestic violence is a priority why has the Ministry of Justice funding for family and domestic violence services dropped under her Government from$8.7 million in 2010 to $7.3 million in 2013 despite an increase in family violence arrests last year?Hon JUDITH COLLINS: These days we take much more of a cross-Government approach to the funding of domestic violence and sexual violence. In fact I can tell the member that the Ministry of Social Development is also contributing to the funding. Also in addition to that another portfolio accident compensation has spent—I think it is from memory—around $40 million a year on sensitive claims resulting from sexual violence.Jan Logie: I seek leave to table a report compiled by the library showing a decrease in funding from the Government from the Ministry of Social Development as well as the Ministry of Justice as well as the It’s Not OK campaign—Mr SPEAKER: Order! It has been well described. On the basis that it is not freely available to members I will put the leave. Leave is sought to table this library report on a funding trend. Is there any objection to it being tabled? There is none. It can be tabled.Document by leave laid on the Table of the House.Jan Logie: How can women feel comfortable reporting domestic violence when Ministers have slashed funding for family violence and used their power to help a man charged with abuse simply—Mr SPEAKER: Order! Again we are right back in the same position we were earlier. I will invite the member—[Interruption] Order! I will invite the member to re-ask her question. I suggest that if she just keeps it to the first part it will be in order.Dr Russel Norman: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. The Minister of Justice herself introduced the Mr Williamson case. That is what the Minister did. It is now on the record. We now have a right to respond—Mr SPEAKER: Order! A member sitting not too far from the member took objection to the Minister raising that. On that basis I curtailed the answer. [Interruption] Order! We can move on very quickly. I have been exceedingly patient with the member. I will ask her if she wants to ask further supplementary questions that she does it according to the Standing Orders.Jan Logie: How can women feel comfortable reporting domestic violence when Ministers have slashed funding for support prevention and treatment services and lost their way in terms of providing political leadership on the importance of a consistent response to domestic violence?Hon JUDITH COLLINS: I reject the allegation in the second part of that member’s question. I can say to that member that this Government is deeply committed to bringing an end to domestic and sexual violence. In fact that member well knows and many people in this House will well know that there are people in this House whose close family members have been killed as a result of domestic violence.