VoteThe question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 396 in the name of the Hon Tim Macindoe to clause 1 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)GuyO'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)UpstonBennett DHipangoPenkWagner (P)BidoisKanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrownLee MRurawheWilliams (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniRussellWood (P)CarterMacindoeSalesa (P)WoodhouseClarkMcClay (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith NYule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)StrangeGarcia (P)NgaroTirikatene (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarryNoes 70Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)MarcroftShaw (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith SBennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanfordBishopHuo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)Jackson (P)NashTabuteau (P)Collins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinetti (P)Craig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCurranKing (P)Patterson (P)WallDavidsonKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavisLees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Radhakrishnan (P)WillisDysonLogie (P)Robertson (P)WoodsEagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Faafoi (P)LuxtonSage (P)FalloonMahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Teller:Genter (P)Mallard (P)SeymourAdamsAmendment not agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That clause 1 be agreed to.Ayes 70Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)MarcroftShaw (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Smith SBall (P)Hudson (P)McAnultyStanfordBennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CSwarbrick (P)BishopHuo (P)Mitchell M (P)Tabuteau (P)Coffey (P)Jackson (P)NashTinetti (P)Collins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTolleyCraig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCurran (P)King (P)Patterson (P)WallDavidson (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavisLees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Radhakrishnan (P)WillisDysonLogie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Faafoi (P)LuxtonSage (P)FalloonMahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Teller:GenterMallard (P)SeymourAdamsNoes 50Bakshi (P)GuyO'Connor STwyford (P)BaylyHayes (P)Parmar (P)UpstonBennett DHipangoPenkWagner (P)BidoisKanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrownLee MRurawheWilliams (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniRussellWood (P)CarterMacindoeSalesa (P)WoodhouseClarkMcClay (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Sio (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Smith NGarcia (P)NgaroStrangeTeller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Tirikatene (P)BarryClause 1 agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 361 in the name of Jenny Marcroft to the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 287 in the name of Jenny Marcroft to clause 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 63Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)McAnultySimpson (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mitchell CStanfordArdern (P)Hipkins (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)NashTabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)O'Connor GTinetti (P)BishopJones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCollins (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)Warren-ClarkCraig (P)King (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)CurranKuriger (P)Prime (P)Woods (P)Davidson (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)YangDavisLittle (P)Robertson (P)Yule (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)DysonLubeckRussellEagle (P)LuxtonSage (P)Faafoi (P)MarcroftSepuloni (P)FalloonMark (P)SeymourTeller:GenterMartin (P)Shaw (P)AdamsNoes 57Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BaylyHipangoO'Connor SUpstonBennett DHudson (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)BidoisJackson (P)PenkWalker (P)Bridges (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WallBrownLee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrownlee (P)Lee MRurawheWilliams (P)CarterLoheniSalesa (P)WillisClarkMacindoeScott (P)Wood (P)Coffey (P)Mahuta (P)Sio (P)WoodhouseDean (P)Mallard (P)Smith NYoung (P)Dowie (P)McClay (P)Smith SGarcia (P)McKelvie (P)StrangeGoldsmith (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Teller:GuyNgaroTolleyBarryAmendment to the amendment agreed to.The question was put that the amendment as amended set out on Supplementary Order Paper 287 in the name of Jenny Marcroft to clause 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment as amended be agreed to.Ayes 63Allan (P)GenterMartin (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)Ghahraman (P)McAnultySimpson (P)Ardern (P)Henare (P)Mitchell CStanfordBall (P)Hipkins (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bennett DHughes (P)NashTabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)O'Connor GTinetti (P)BishopJones (P)Parker (P)Warren-ClarkCollins (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)Webb (P)Craig (P)King (P)Peters (P)Woods (P)CurranKuriger (P)Prime (P)Yang (P)Davidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Yule (P)DavisLittle (P)Robertson (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)DysonLubeckRussellEagle (P)LuxtonSage (P)Faafoi (P)MarcroftSepuloni (P)Teller:FalloonMark (P)SeymourAdamsNoes 57Bakshi (P)HipangoO'Connor SUpstonBaylyHudson (P)Parmar (P)van de MolenBidoisJackson (P)PenkWagner (P)Bridges (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)BrownLee DReti (P)WallBrownlee (P)Lee MRurawheWhaitiriCarterLoheniSalesa (P)Williams (P)ClarkMacindoeScott (P)WillisCoffey (P)Mahuta (P)Sio (P)Wood (P)Dean (P)Mallard (P)Smith NWoodhouseDowie (P)McClay (P)Smith SYoung (P)Garcia (P)McKelvie (P)StrangeGoldsmith (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)GuyNgaroTolleyTeller:Hayes (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryAmendment as amended agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): Chris Penk's amendment to clause 2 replacing 12 months" with "3 years" set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 264 is out of order as being inconsistent with the previous decision of the committee on Jenny Marcroft's SOP 287.A personal vote was called for on the question That clause 2 as amended be agreed to.Ayes 66Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)MarcroftSeymourAndersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Shaw (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)MartinSimpson (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith SBennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanfordBishopHuo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Collins (P)Jones (P)NashTabuteau (P)Craig (P)Kaye (P)O'Connor GTinetti (P)Curran (P)King (P)Parker (P)WallDavidson (P)Kuriger (P)Patterson (P)Warren-ClarkDavisLees-Galloway (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Prime (P)WillisDysonLogie (P)Radhakrishnan (P)WoodsEagle (P)LubeckRobertson (P)Yang (P)Faafoi (P)LuxtonRoss (P)FalloonMahuta (P)Sage (P)Teller:GenterMallard (P)Sepuloni (P)AdamsNoes 54Bakshi (P)GuyO'Connor STwyford (P)BaylyHayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett DHipangoPenkvan de MolenBidoisJackson (P)Pugh (P)Wagner (P)Bridges (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiReti (P)Walker (P)BrownLee DRurawheWhaitiriBrownlee (P)Lee MRussellWilliams (P)Carter (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Wood (P)ClarkMacindoe (P)Scott (P)WoodhouseCoffey (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith NYule (P)Dowie (P)MullerStrangeGarcia (P)NgaroTirikatene (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarryClause 2 as amended agreed to.Bill to be reported with amendment presently."