Yang JianDr JIAN YANG (National): This Government is not an ambitious Government at all. Now this is such a disappointing Budget—it's widely regarded as a disappointing Budget—yet they are very pleased with the Budget. The Prime Minister warned before Budget day time and time again that this would be a very boring Budget and it turned out it is indeed a very boring Budget. It is also a very disappointing Budget. This Budget has no great or new ideas. Have a look at these current and past policy initiatives for Vote Statistics. The current Government has only one—one policy initiative. The previous Government had seven—seven new policy initiatives. This is a good reflection of the Budget as a whole because we cannot see the solutions despite the fact that the Labour - New Zealand First Government has been talking about crises day after day. In the end they can't come up with any good solutions.This is not surprising. In the past seven months this Government has not been able to come up with enough of their own bills and rely on the previous National Government's bills to prolong debate time. So this is the Government without good ideas and sometimes I feel sorry for the Government because it is so hard for them to come up with good ideas. They talk about these crises day after day. They are very good at alarming New Zealanders with these fictional crises. In the end sometimes they are carried away by these fictional crises and make big promises but later on they find they can't deliver—they simply cannot deliver. That is why this Budget is littered with broken promises.International education for example contributes $4.5 billion to our economy—the fourth-largest export earner in New Zealand. They promised to basically destroy the industry because they wanted to cut immigration numbers by 20000 to 30000 each year to help resolve the housing crisis. Now what they are doing—they're doing nothing because they can't deliver. They have to break their promise because they realised that that industry international education is so important and they can't really simply cut the number by 20000 or 30000.Another example is KiwiBuild one of the trump cards of the Government. Basically they're saying that in 10 years 100000 houses—in the end it is quickly becoming a laughing stock. Remember that Chinese-sounding names fiasco? It is still fresh to the Chinese community but now this Government's trying to ask the Chinese community to help because they need the assistance of Chinese developers. The problem is KiwiBuild is so fundamentally flawed that no one can save it. We come to the fact that they've been talking about a crisis talking about spending but have no plan to earn more for the country. However they're very good at taxing people. We understand they have the fuel taxes but there is one more tax that people have not really paid attention to and that is the border tax. All international travellers will have to pay about $22 going to and from New Zealand—$22. This is a border tax although they don't call it a tax. They call it a biosecurity and customs levy.But the tourism industry has seen through it and basically says this is a new tax. The tourism industry has been so important to us creating thousands and thousands of jobs. Basically over 8 percent of total employment is in the tourism industry contributing billions and billions of dollars—I understand it is about $15 billion each year or 21 percent of our total export earnings—yet the Government is going to introduce a new tax and at the same time they're going to cut the budget for Tourism New Zealand by $6 million. So the tourism industry is already under pressure because of the quick rise of the minimum wage. And now the Labour - New Zealand First Government is trying to destroy this top earner of foreign exchange.