Reti ShaneDr SHANE RETI (National—Whangarei): Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. It's really a privilege to stand and address the Budget which for me is a show-me-the-money Budget". They may be awash with money but for me it's "show me the money". Where exactly is it? Where has it gone?Well let's start with surgical mesh. Where's the money for surgical mesh? In 2006 the Labour Party stated "This is the most widespread crisis involving surgical devices in health and the Ministry of Health has adopted a hands off approach." Where is the money? Where's the cost-benefit analysis Minister that you're currently doing to show that a mesh register can be built? Where are some steps towards the universally agreed recommendations from the Health Committee that progress be made on surgical mesh or any of the recommendations? Where is the money? Show me the money. Show us that you can keep your pre-election promises and actually give this very important issue due diligence and due attention. Show me the money.I then want to talk to personal health services. Four million dollars axed from personal health services. Well which ones are actually going to be axed? Let's have a look at what the options are. Is it going to be Healthline? Is it hospices? Maybe cancer control? Mobile surgical? Long-term cardio vascular? Oral health? InterRAI which is the software that rest homes run to quality assure the work they're doing? Or diabetes? Where's the money going to come from? Where are you going to take that $4 million from in personal health services? Oh and by the way if you look at their reporting framework not only is $4 million gone from that budget but there's extra work. There's actually a whole category of cardiac services for clinicians and others to do. So less money; more work. That's not a formula that anyone can certainly apply. Show me the money.There are other parts of this Budget that don't make sense. Health information sectors—a very meagre $2.2 million increase. Now how is that going to roll out? So you've got the National Oracle Solution currently being reviewed by Deloitte—I'll come back to that—that's clearly failing. Where's the top-up going to come from for that? We know there's going to be a top-up because I got your Official Information Act (OIA) request back Minister last night. I can see that the ministry's looking to top it up. Where's the money coming from? You've only put $2.2 million into the health information services budget. That's not even going to come close. That'll probably pay for the $150000—that's the number you didn't want to tell me in the House Minister—that you're paying Deloitte for their pretend-to-be-independent budget. That was in the OIA request last night as well. We'll see how independent that is in the coming few weeks.What else have you got coming down the line? Well let's talk again about what you've taken away. So a measly $2.2 million—DEPUTY SPEAKER: I haven't. I haven't.Dr SHANE RETI: Sorry Madam Deputy Speaker—what this Government has taken away from health information services. The electronic oral health record $340000 a year outward each year for the next four years—gone. The population health data warehouse $136000 a year established under our Government—gone not present. Health information technology's a problem that's going to come back and bite this Government and all they've done is put $2.2 million a very small amount towards it.Disability one of the few vote areas that actually has a shrinking-lid policy on their additional support. How can their disability support services reduce each year from $58 million to $54 million to $46 million to $42 million? How does that work? Do you think chronic disabilities suddenly get better? Is that what the thinking is? Well I'm here to tell you it's not. That's not what happens. One of the only vote areas where there's a shrinking-lid policy and—shame on you—it's in the disability sector. Furthermore their core funding has only increased by 0.003 percent; that's even less than inflation—again shame on you. We could talk about Rural Health Alliance Aotearoa New Zealand (RHĀNZ) and rural mental health but I actually want to send a message to the Māori caucus of Government: where were you? Are you afraid of Grant Robertson? Is the Māori caucus afraid of Grant Robertson? Is the Labour Māori caucus too afraid to challenge the Minister of Finance and say "Give us the money; we need this funding."? Where is the money for Whānau Ora? Where is the money for Māori economic development? It's not there. Where were the warriors? They weren't brave enough to stand up to the Minister and say "Minister we need this funding."In fact I think the funding's gone to conservation. I think the only brown thing I saw in this Budget was the survival of I think a brown mudded shank bird somewhere in New Zealand; that was the only brown funding I saw in this Budget in conservation. That's where the Māori funding's gone. It's not good enough. I expected the Māori Labour caucus to stand up and challenge the Minister. Don't be afraid of him. Stand up for us. Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker.DEPUTY SPEAKER: Just to remind the member—just before I call I remind the member that there's a Standing Order which I just haven't found about accusing other members of the House about not having courage."