VoteThe question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 358 in the name of Anahila Kanongata'a-Suisuiki to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett D (P)Hipango Penkvan de MolenBidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPughWalker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Whaitiri (P)Brown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)Williams (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)MacindoeScott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Strange (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTirikatene (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarryNoes 69Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourAndersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)ShawArdern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Simpson (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bishop (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Collins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCraig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)WallCurran (P)King (P)Patterson (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)Davis (P)Lees-GallowayPrime (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Woods (P)DysonLogie (P)Robertson (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)RussellFalloonMahuta (P)Sage (P)Teller:Genter (P)Mallard (P)Sepuloni (P)AdamsAmendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 352 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Williams (P)Brown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)Wood (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)MacindoeScott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)GarciaNgaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Allan (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)SioAndersen (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith SArdern (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell C Stanford (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiCoffey (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCollins (P)Kaye (P)PattersonWallCraig (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCurran (P)Kuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Davidson (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davis (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)DysonLubeckRussellEagle (P)Luxton (P)Sage (P)Faafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonMallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)ShawTeller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)AdamsAmendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 356 in the name of Maggie Barry to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)van de MolenBennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Whaitiri (P)Brown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)Williams (P)Brownlee (P)Loheni (P)Salesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)MacindoeScott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 70AdamsGhahraman (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourAllan (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)ShawAndersen (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)McAnulty (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CSmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Stanford (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTabuteau (P)Collins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)TinettiCraig (P)King (P)Patterson (P)WallCurran (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lees-GallowayPrime (P)Webb (P)Davis (P)Little (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)RussellFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sage (P)Teller:Genter (P)MallardSepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 68AdamsGhahraman (P)Mark (P)ShawAllan (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Simpson (P)Andersen (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiCoffey (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)WallCollins (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)Warren-ClarkCraig (P)King (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)Curran (P)Kuriger (P)Prime (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Woods (P)Davis (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)Dyson LubeckRussellEagle (P)Luxton (P)Sage (P)Faafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Teller:Genter (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourFalloonNoes 52Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)van de Molen (P)Bayly (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Lee DReti (P)Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)Williams (P)Brown (P)Loheni (P)Salesa (P)Wood (P)Brownlee (P)MacindoeScott (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)MallardSio (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley (P)Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Barry Amendments agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Ruth Dyson): Louisa Wall's amendment deleting clauses 19 to 22A set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 235 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 212 in the name of Chris Penk be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Williams (P)Brown (P)Lee M (P)Rurawhe (P)Wood (P)Brownlee (P)Loheni (P)Salesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)MacindoeScott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71AdamsHenare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCraig (P)Kuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Curran (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)Davis (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)LubeckRussellDysonLuxton (P)Sage (P)Eagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)ShawTeller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 213 in the name of Simon O'Connor be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 57Bakshi (P)Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Tolley (P)Bayly (P)Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Bennett D (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bidois (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bridges (P)Hughes (P)Pugh (P)Walker (P)Brown (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiReti (P)Whaitiri (P)Brownlee (P)Lee DRurawhe (P)Williams (P)Carter (P)Lee M (P)Sage (P)Wood (P)Clark (P)Logie (P)Salesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Davidson (P)Loheni (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Dean (P)Macindoe (P)ShawYule (P)Dowie (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Garcia (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Genter (P)Muller (P)Swarbrick (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Ngaro (P)Tirikatene (P)BarryNoes 63AdamsHipkins (P)McAnulty (P)Smith S (P)Allan (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Andersen (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)TabuteauArdern (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)TinettiBall (P)Jones (P)O'Connor Gvan de MolenBennett P (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)WallBishop (P)King (P)Patterson (P)Warren-Clark (P)Coffey (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)Collins (P)Lees-GallowayPrime (P)Willis (P)Craig (P)Little (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Woods (P)Curran (P)Lubeck Robertson (P)Yang (P)Davis (P)Luxton (P)Ross (P)Doocey (P)Mahuta (P)RussellDysonMallard (P)Sepuloni (P)Eagle (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourFaafoi (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Teller:Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 332 in the name of Melissa Lee be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 46Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bayly (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)Reti (P)Whaitiri (P)Brown (P)Loheni (P)Rurawhe (P)Williams (P)Brownlee (P)Macindoe (P)Salesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)McClay (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)Muller (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Ngaro (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)O'Connor D (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)BarryNoes 74AdamsGhahraman (P)Mallard (P)SeymourAllan (P)Goldsmith (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bidois (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Coffey (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCollins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCraig (P)King (P)Patterson (P)WallCurran (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lee DPrime (P)Webb (P)Davis (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRussellFaafoi (P)Luxton (P)SageTeller:Genter (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 333 in the name of Jo Hayes be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Williams (P)Brown (P)Lee M (P)Rurawhe (P)Wood (P)Brownlee (P)Loheni (P)Salesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71AdamsHenare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McAnulty (P)Smith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCraig (P)Kuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Curran (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)Davis (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)LubeckRussellDysonLuxton (P)SageEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 334 in the name of Melissa Lee be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 46Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bayly (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)Reti (P)Whaitiri (P)Brown (P)Loheni (P)Rurawhe (P)Williams (P)Brownlee (P)Macindoe (P)Salesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)McClay (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)Muller (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Ngaro (P)Tirikatene (P)GarciaO'Connor D (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)BarryNoes 74Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Mallard (P)SeymourAllan (P)Goldsmith (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bidois (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Coffey (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCollins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCraig (P)King (P)Patterson (P)WallCurran (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lee DPrime (P)Webb (P)Davis (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRussellFaafoi (P)Luxton (P)SageTeller:Genter (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 335 in the name of Agnes Loheni be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Williams (P)Brown (P)Lee M (P)Rurawhe (P)Wood (P)Brownlee (P)Loheni (P)Salesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)GarciaNgaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor G (P)TinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCraig (P)Kuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Curran (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)LubeckRussellDysonLuxton (P)SageEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to. The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 336 in the name of Paulo Garcia be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)Williams (P)Brown (P)Lee M (P)Rurawhe (P)Wood (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)HipkinsMcAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCraig (P)Kuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)Curran (P)Lees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)LubeckRussellDysonLuxton (P)SageEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 338 in the name of Chris Penk be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 46Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bayly (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)Reti (P)Whaitiri (P)Brown (P)LoheniRurawhe (P)WilliamsBrownlee (P)Macindoe (P)Salesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)McClay (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)Muller (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Ngaro (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)O'Connor D (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)BarryNoes 74Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Mallard (P)SeymourAllan (P)Goldsmith (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)HipkinsMartin (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bidois (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)CoffeyJones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCollins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCraig (P)King (P)Patterson (P)WallCurranKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lee DPrime (P)Webb (P)DavisLees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRussellFaafoi (P)Luxton (P)SageTeller:Genter (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 339 in the name of Simon O'Connor be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)van de MolenBennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WilliamsBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 70Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourAllan (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)HipkinsMartin (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySio (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CSmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Stanford (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTabuteau (P)Collins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)Tinetti Craig (P)King (P)Patterson (P)WallCurranKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)DavisLittle (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)RussellFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)SageTeller:Genter (P)Mallard (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 344 in the name of Paulo Garcia be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 46Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bayly (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee MReti (P)WhaitiriBrown (P)LoheniRurawhe (P)WilliamsBrownlee (P)Macindoe (P)Salesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)McClay (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)Muller (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)NgaroTirikatene (P)Garcia (P)O'Connor D (P)Tolley (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)BarryNoes 74Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Mallard (P)SeymourAllan (P)Goldsmith (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)HipkinsMartin (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bidois (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Coffey (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCollins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCraig (P)King (P)Patterson (P)Wall (P)CurranKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lee DPrime (P)Webb (P)DavisLees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRussellFaafoi (P)Luxton (P)SageTeller:Genter (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 345 in the name of Agnes Loheni be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WhaitiriBridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WilliamsBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WoodBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)HipkinsMcAnulty (P)Smith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffeyKaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollinsKing (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCraigKuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)CurranLees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)Little (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)LubeckRussellDysonLuxton (P)SageEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 346 in the name of Melissa Lee be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)van de MolenBennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WilliamsBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)WoodCarter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 70Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourAllan (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Shaw (P)Andersen (P)HipkinsMartin (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)McAnulty (P)Sio (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CSmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Stanford (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Swarbrick (P)CoffeyJones (P)O'Connor GTabuteauCollins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)TinettiCraigKing (P)Patterson (P)WallCurranKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkDavidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)DavisLittleRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)RussellFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)SageTeller:Genter (P)Mallard (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 347 in the name of Jo Hayes be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WhaitiriBridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WilliamsBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WoodBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)HipkinsMcAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffeyKaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCraigKuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)CurranLees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)LittleRobertson (P)Woods (P)DavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)LubeckRussellDysonLuxton (P)SageEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 348 in the name of Melissa Lee be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WhaitiriBridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WilliamsBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WoodBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffeyKaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-Clark (P)CraigKuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)CurranLees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)LittleRobertson (P)Woods (P)DavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)Lubeck (P)RussellDysonLuxton (P)SageEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)Shaw (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 359 in the name of Anahila Kanongata'a-Suisuiki be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)Williams (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Wood (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Strange (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTirikatene (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor DTolley (P)BarryNoes 70Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourAllan (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)ShawAndersen (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)CoffeyJones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCollins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCraigKing (P)Patterson (P)WallCurranKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-Clark (P)Davidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)DavisLittleRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLubeck (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)RussellFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sage (P)Teller:Genter (P)Mallard (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 354 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 48Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WhaitiriBridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WilliamsBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)Woodhouse (P)Brownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Young (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Yule (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 72Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Ball (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-Clark (P)CraigKuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)CurranLees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)LittleRobertson (P)WoodDavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Woods (P)Doocey (P)Lubeck (P)RussellYang (P)DysonLuxton (P)Sage (P)Eagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)ShawTeller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 357 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Walker (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WhaitiriBridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WilliamsBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WoodBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)NgaroTolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)BarryNoes 71Adams (P)Henare (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)SwarbrickBall (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett P (P)Jackson (P)O'Connor GTinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Patterson (P)WallCollins (P)King (P)Peters (P)Warren-Clark (P)CraigKuriger (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)CurranLees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Davidson (P)LittleRobertson (P)Woods (P)DavisLogie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Doocey (P)Lubeck (P)RussellDysonLuxton (P)Sage (P)Eagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mallard (P)SeymourGenter (P)Marcroft (P)ShawTeller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 214 in the name of Simon O'Connor be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)van de MolenBennett D (P)HipangoPenk (P)Wagner (P)Bidois (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrown (P)Lee MRurawhe (P)WilliamsBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)WoodCarter (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange (P)Yule (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)Garcia (P)Ngaro Tolley (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)Barry Noes 70Adams (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft (P)SeymourAllan (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)ShawAndersen (P)Hipkins (P)Martin (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySio (P)Ball (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CSmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Stanford (P)Bishop (P)Jackson (P)Nash (P)SwarbrickCoffeyJones (P)O'Connor GTabuteau (P)Collins (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)TinettiCraigKing (P)Patterson (P)WallCurranKuriger (P)Peters (P)Warren-Clark (P)Davidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)Webb (P)DavisLittleRadhakrishnan (P)Willis (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)DysonLubeck (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)RussellFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sage (P)Teller:Genter (P)Mallard (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonAmendment not agreed to.