VoteIn CommitteeDebate resumed.Part 1 Preliminary provisions (continued)A party vote was called for on the question That the question be now put.Ayes 65New Zealand Labour 46; New Zealand First 9; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 8; ACT New Zealand 1; Ross.Noes 55New Zealand National 55.Motion agreed to.The question was put that the following amendment in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry to the proposed amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 1 be agreed to: Replace clause 4A with:4AMeaning of competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying(1)In this Act a person is competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying if the person is able to—(a)understand the information relevant to the decision relating to access to assisted dying and the effect of the decision; and(b)retain that information to the extent necessary to make the decision; and(c)use or weigh that information as part of the process of making the decision; and(d)communicate the decision and the person's views and needs as to the decision in some way including by speech gestures or other means.(2)For the purposes of subsection (1)(a) a person is taken to understand information relevant to a decision if the person understands an explanation of the information given to the person in a way that is appropriate to the person's circumstances whether by using modified language visual aids or any other means.(3)In determining whether or not a person is competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying regard must be had to the following—(a)a person may be competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying in regard to some decisions and not others;(b)if a person is not competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying in regard to a particular decision it may be temporary and not permanent;(c)it should not be assumed that a person is not competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying to make a decision—(i)on the basis of the person's appearance; or(ii)because the person makes a decision that is in the opinion of the others unwise;(d)a person is competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying in regard to a decision if it is possible for the person to make a decision with practicable and appropriate support.(4)For the purpose of subsection (1) a person is presumed to be competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying unless there is evidence to the contrary.(5)A person who is assessing whether a person has competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying for the purposes of this Act must take reasonable steps to conduct the assessment at a time and in an environment in which the person's competent to make an informed decision about assisted dying can be most accurately assessed.(6)In this section practicable and appropriate support includes the following:(a)using information or formats tailored to the particular needs of a person;(b)communicating or assisting a person to communicate with the person's decision;(c)giving a person additional time and discussing the matter with the person;(d)using technology that alleviates the effects of a person's disability. A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 44Bakshi (P)HayesO'Connor STwyfordBennett DHipango (P)ParmarUpston (P)BidoisKanongata'a-SuisuikiPenkWagnerBridgesLee DPughWalkerBrownLee MRurawheWhaitiriBrownleeLoheniRussellWoodCarterMacindoe (P)SalesaWoodhouseClark (P)McClay (P)ScottDeanMcKelvieSmith NDowieMuller (P)StrangeGarciaNgaroTirikatene (P)Teller:GoldsmithO'Connor D (P)TolleyBarryNoes 73AdamsGhahraman (P)Mark (P)SioAndersen (P)Henare (P)MartinSmith SArdern (P)HipkinsMcAnulty (P)Stanford (P)BallHudsonMitchell CSwarbrickBaylyHughesMitchell M (P)TabuteauBennett PHuo (P)Nash (P)TinettiBishop (P)JacksonO'Connor Gvan de MolenCoffey (P)JonesParker (P)WallCollinsKaye (P)PattersonWarren-ClarkCraigKingPeters (P)WebbCurranKurigerPrimeWilliamsDavidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)RadhakrishnanWillisDavisLittle (P)RobertsonWoodsDooceyLogie (P)Ross (P)YangDysonLubeckSageYuleEagle (P)Luxton (P)SepuloniFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)SeymourFalloonMallardShawTeller: Genter (P)MarcroftSimpsonAllanAmendment to the amendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 1 except clause 4 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 75Allan Ghahraman (P)Marcroft Simpson Andersen (P)Goldsmith (P)Mark (P)Smith SArdern (P)Henare (P)Martin Stanford (P)Ball Hipkins McAnulty (P)Swarbrick Bayly Hudson Mitchell CTabuteau Bennett PHughes Mitchell M (P)Tinetti Bidois Huo (P)Nash (P)van de Molen Bishop (P)Jackson O'Connor GWall Coffey (P)Jones Parker (P)Warren-Clark Collins Kaye (P)Patterson Webb Craig KingPeters (P)Willis Curran Kuriger Prime Wood Davidson (P)Lee DRadhakrishnan Woods Davis Lees-Galloway (P)Robertson Yang Doocey Little (P)Ross (P)Dyson Logie (P)Russell Eagle (P)Lubeck Sage Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)Sepuloni Falloon Mahuta (P)Seymour Teller:Genter (P)Mallard Shaw Adams Noes 42Bakshi (P)Hayes Parmar Twyford Bennett DHipango (P)Penk Upston (P)Bridges (P)Lee MPugh Wagner (P)Brown Loheni Rurawhe Walker Brownlee Macindoe (P)Salesa Whaitiri Carter McClay (P)Scott Williams Clark (P)McKelvie Sio Woodhouse Dean Muller (P)Smith NYule Dowie Ngaro Strange Garcia O'Connor D (P)Tirikatene (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor STolley BarryAmendments agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to clause 4 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 74AllanGenter (P)Mahuta (P)SeymourAndersen (P)Ghahraman (P)MarcroftShawArdern (P)Goldsmith (P)Mark (P)SimpsonBallHenare (P)MartinSmith SBaylyHipkinsMcAnulty (P)Stanford (P)Bennett PHudsonMitchell CSwarbrickBidoisHughesMitchell M (P)TabuteauBishop (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)TinettiCoffey (P)JacksonO'Connor GWallCollinsJonesParker (P)Warren-ClarkCraigKaye (P)PattersonWebbCurranKing (P)Peters (P)WillisDavidson (P)KurigerPrimeWoodDavisLee DRadhakrishnanWoodsDooceyLees-Galloway (P)RobertsonYangDysonLittle (P)Ross (P)YuleEagle (P)Logie (P)RussellFaafoi (P)LubeckSageTeller:FalloonLuxton (P)SepuloniAdamsNoes 44Bakshi (P)Hipango (P)ParmarUpston (P)Bennett DKanongata'a-SuisuikiPenkvan de MolenBridges (P)Lee MPughWagner (P)BrownLoheniRurawheWalkerBrownleeMacindoe (P)SalesaWhaitiriCarterMallardScottWilliamsClark (P)McClay (P)SioWoodhouseDeanMcKelvieSmith NDowieMuller (P)StrangeGarciaNgaro (P)Tirikatene (P)Guy (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyTeller:HayesO'Connor STwyfordBarryAmendments agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): Louisa Wall's amendment to Part 1 to replace clause 3 and delete clause 4 as set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 235 is out of order as being inconsistent with the previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Chris Penk's amendment replacing the definition of assisted dying" in clause 3 set out on SOP 205—Hon Paula Bennett: I raise a point of order Madam Chairperson. Sorry I think the doors need to be unlocked.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): Oh I beg your pardon. Thank you. Unlock the doors. Sorry I had the wrong piece of paper. So Chris Penk's amendment is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Melissa Lee's amendment replacing the definition of "attending medical practitioner" in clause 3 set out on SOP 269 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. The Hon Maggie Barry's amendment to Part 1 relating to decision-making capacity is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Agnes Loheni's amendment replacing the definition of "independent medical practitioner" in clause 3 set out on SOP 265 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 267 in the name of Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi to clause 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 45Bakshi (P)Goldsmith (P)Ngaro (P)Tolley Barry Guy (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford Bayly Hayes O'Connor SUpston (P)Bennett DHipango (P)Parmar Wagner (P)Bidois Kanongata'a-Suisuiki Penk Walker Bridges (P)Lee DPugh Whaitiri Brown Lee MRurawhe Wood Brownlee Loheni Salesa Woodhouse Clark (P)Macindoe (P)Scott Dean McClay (P)Smith NDowie McKelvie Strange Teller:Garcia Muller (P)Tirikatene (P)CarterNoes 73Allan Henare (P)Martin Sio (P)Andersen (P)Hipkins (P)McAnulty (P)Smith SArdern (P)HudsonMitchell CStanford (P)Ball Hughes Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick Bennett PHuo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau Bishop (P)Jackson O'Connor GTinetti Coffey (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de Molen Collins Kaye (P)Patterson Wall Craig King (P)Peters (P)Warren-Clark Curran Kuriger Prime Webb Davidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Radhakrishnan Williams Davis Little (P)Robertson Willis Doocey Logie (P)Ross (P)Woods (P)Dyson Lubeck Russell Yang Eagle (P)Luxton (P)Sage Yule Faafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Falloon Mallard Seymour Genter (P)Marcroft Shaw Teller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Simpson Adams Amendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 266 in the name of Paulo Garcia to clause 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 38Bakshi (P)GarciaMcKelvieSmith NBarryGoldsmith (P)Muller (P)TolleyBaylyGuy (P)Ngaro (P)Upston (P)Bennett DHayesO'Connor SWagner (P)BidoisHipango (P)ParmarWalkerBridges (P)Lee DPenkWoodhouseBrownLee MPughYoung (P)BrownleeLoheniReti (P)DeanMacindoe (P)SalesaTeller:DowieMcClay (P)ScottCarterNoes 82AllanHipkins (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Andersen (P)HudsonMitchell M (P)StrangeArdern (P)HughesNash (P)SwarbrickBallHuo (P)O'Connor GTabuteauBennett PJacksonO'Connor D (P)TinettiBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)Tirikatene (P)Clark (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPattersonTwyfordCoffey (P)Kaye (P)Peters (P)van de MolenCollinsKing (P)PrimeWallCraigKurigerRadhakrishnanWarren-ClarkCurranLees-Galloway (P)RobertsonWebbDavidson (P)Little (P)Ross (P)WhaitiriDavisLogie (P)RurawheWilliamsDooceyLubeckRussellWillisDysonLuxton (P)SageWoodEagle (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Woods (P)Faafoi (P)MallardSeymourYangFalloonMarcroftShawYuleGenter (P)Mark (P)SimpsonGhahraman (P)MartinSio (P)Teller:Henare (P)McAnulty (P)Smith SAdamsAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 268 in the name of Chris Penk to clause 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 36Bakshi (P)GarciaMuller (P)Upston (P)BarryGoldsmith (P)Ngaro (P)van de MolenBaylyGuy (P)O'Connor SWagner (P)Bennett DHayesParmarWalkerBidoisHipango (P)PenkYoungBridges (P)Lee DPughBrownLee MReti (P)BrownleeLoheniScottDeanMacindoe (P)Smith NTeller:DowieMcKelvieTolleyCarterNoes 82AllanHipkins (P)Mitchell CSmith SAndersen (P)HudsonMitchell M (P)Stanford (P)Ardern (P)HughesNash (P)StrangeBallHuo (P)O'Connor GSwarbrickBennett PJacksonO'Connor D (P)TabuteauBishop (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)TinettiClark (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPatterson (P)Tirikatene (P)Coffey (P)Kaye (P)Peters (P)TwyfordCollins (P)King (P)PrimeWallCraigKuriger RadhakrishnanWarren-ClarkCurranLees-Galloway (P)RobertsonWebbDavidson (P)Little (P)Ross (P)WhaitiriDavisLogie (P)RurawheWilliamsDooceyLubeckRussellWillisDysonLuxton (P)SageWoodEagle (P)Mahuta (P)SalesaWoods (P)Faafoi (P)MallardSepuloni (P)YangFalloonMarcroftSeymourYuleGenter (P)Mark (P)ShawGhahraman (P)MartinSimpsonTeller:Henare (P)McAnulty (P)Sio (P)AdamsAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 272 in the name of Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi to clause 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 31Bakshi (P)GuyO'Connor SWagner (P)BarryHayes (P)Parmar (P)Walker Bennett DHipango (P)Penk Young (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)Pugh (P)BrownLoheni Reti (P)BrownleeMacindoe (P)Scott (P)DeanMcKelvie Smith NDowie (P)Muller (P)TolleyTeller:GarciaNgaro (P)Upston (P)Carter Noes 87Allan Henare (P)Mitchell CStrangeAndersen (P)Hipkins (P)Mitchell M (P)SwarbrickArdern (P)Hudson (P)Nash (P)TabuteauBallHughes O'Connor D (P)TinettiBayly (P)Huo (P)O'Connor GTirikatene (P)Bennett PJackson Parker (P)Twyford (P)Bidois Jones (P)Patterson (P)van de Molen Bishop (P)Kanongata'a-Suisuiki Peters (P)Wall Clark (P)Kaye (P)PrimeWarren-Clark Coffey (P)King (P)RadhakrishnanWebb Collins (P)KurigerRobertsonWhaitiri Craig Lee D Ross (P)Williams Curran Lees-Galloway (P)RurawheWillis Davidson (P)Little (P)RussellWoodDavis Logie (P)SageWoods (P)Doocey (P)Lubeck SalesaYang Dyson Luxton (P)Sepuloni (P)Yule Eagle (P)Mahuta (P)SeymourFaafoi (P)Mallard ShawFalloon Marcroft SimpsonGenter (P)Mark (P)Sio (P)Ghahraman (P)Martin Smith S (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)McAnulty (P)Stanford (P)Adams Amendments not agreed to.The result corrected after originally being announced as Ayes 32 Noes 87.Hon GERRY BROWNLEE (National—Ilam): I raise a point of order Madam Chairperson. According to Standing Order 3 page 2 I seek leave for the committee to suspend its activities now and resume at the start of members' orders on 21 August.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): What Standing Order are you quoting?Hon GERRY BROWNLEE (National—Ilam): Page 2 of the Standing Orders book.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): 32?Hon GERRY BROWNLEE: Page 2 under the provision of leave. Perhaps for clarity Madam Chair can I say it says that "leave or leave of the House or leave of the committee means permission to do something that is granted without a dissentient voice".CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): Can I just check with the member: you are seeking leave to report progress?Hon GERRY BROWNLEE (National—Ilam): No. The idea of this is that the committee of the whole House determines its own destiny and what I'm saying is that we simply suspend this process now and resume it at the start of members' orders of the day on 21 August.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): Which would be achieved by reporting progress. We're talking the same thing but the words—Hon Gerry Brownlee: No they're two different things Madam Chair.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): So the difficulty I have if I may make the suggestion to the member is that as the committee of the whole House we cannot tell the House what to do. We have no powers over that. So if the member seeks leave—[Interruption] Hang on just let me finish. If you seek leave that we report progress then when the committee resumes it will resume at the same place. You will achieve that in a way that is consistent with the functions of the committee of the whole House.Hon GERRY BROWNLEE (National—Ilam): I read to you again from Standing Orders: "leave of the committee"—CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): I understand that—I understand that.Hon GERRY BROWNLEE: —"means permission to do something that is granted without dissentient voice". I've asked us to do something; all I want is for the leave to be put.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): I understand that Mr Brownlee. What I'm saying to you then is that in the committee of the whole House we do not have the power when the House is resumed to set the Order Paper. So all we will have done is suspended. That's all we will have done. We cannot tell the House that we want to resume. So I mean I can put that leave if that's what you wish. I'm trying to be helpful to you by suggesting that we report progress. OK so I'll put that leave. Is there any objection? OK there is objection.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 271 in the name of Agnes Loheni to clause 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 37Bakshi (P)GarciaMcKelvie (P)TolleyBarryGoldsmith (P)Muller (P)Upston (P)Bayly (P)GuyNgaro (P)Wagner (P)Bennett DHayes (P)O'Connor SWalker (P)BidoisHipango (P)Parmar (P)WoodhouseBridges (P)Lee DPenkYoung (P)BrownLee M (P)Pugh (P)BrownleeLoheniReti (P)DeanMacindoe (P)Scott (P)Teller:Dowie (P)McClay (P)Smith NCarterNoes 83AllanHudson (P)Nash (P)SwarbrickAndersen (P)HughesO'Connor GTabuteauArdern (P)Huo (P)O'Connor D (P)TinettiBallJacksonParker (P)Tirikatene (P)Bennett PJones (P)PattersonTwyford (P)Bishop (P)Kanongata'a-SuisuikiPeters (P)van de MolenClark (P)Kaye (P)PrimeWallCoffey (P)King (P)RadhakrishnanWarren-ClarkCollins (P)KurigerRobertsonWebbCraigLees-Galloway (P)Ross (P)WhaitiriCurranLittle (P)RurawheWilliamsDavidson (P)Logie (P)RussellWillisDavisLubeckSageWoodDoocey (P)Luxton (P)SalesaWoods (P)DysonMahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)MallardSeymourYule (P)Faafoi (P)MarcroftShawFalloonMark (P)SimpsonGenter (P)Martin Sio (P)Ghahraman (P)McAnulty (P)Smith S (P)Henare (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Teller:Hipkins (P)Mitchell M (P)StrangeAdamsAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 270 in the name of Chris Penk to Part 1 be agreed to.Amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 273 in the name of Melissa Lee to clause 3 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 44Bakshi (P)Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarry (P)GuyO'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett DHipango (P)PenkWagner (P)BidoisKanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti (P)WhaitiriBrownLee M (P)RurawheYoung (P)BrownleeLoheniSalesaClark (P)Macindoe (P)Scott (P)DeanMcKelvie (P)Smith NDowie (P)Muller (P)StrangeTeller:GarciaNgaro (P)Tirikatene (P)CarterNoes 74AllanHenare (P)MartinSio (P)Andersen (P)Hipkins (P)McAnulty (P)Smith S (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)BallHughesMitchell M (P)SwarbrickBennett PHuo (P)Nash (P)TabuteauBishop (P)JacksonO'Connor GTinettiCoffey (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCollins (P)Kaye (P)PattersonWallCraigKing (P)Peters (P)Warren-ClarkCurranKurigerPrimeWebbDavidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)RadhakrishnanWilliams (P)DavisLittle (P)RobertsonWillisDoocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)WoodDysonLubeckRussellWoods (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)SageYang (P)Faafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Yule (P)FalloonMallardSeymourGenter (P)MarcroftShawTeller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)SimpsonAdamsAmendment not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 274 in the name of Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi to Part 1 be agreed to.Amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 275 in the name of Agnes Loheni to Part 1 be agreed to.Amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 283 in the name of Simeon Brown to clause 4 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 48Bakshi (P)GuyO'Connor STwyford (P)BarryHayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bayly (P)Hipango (P)PenkWagner (P)Bennett DKanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Walker (P)BidoisLee DReti (P)WhaitiriBridges (P)Lee M (P)Rurawhe WoodBrownLoheniRussellWoodhouseBrownleeMacindoe (P)SalesaYoung (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Scott (P)DeanMcKelvie (P)Smith NDowie (P)Muller (P)StrangeGarciaNgaro (P)Tirikatene (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyCarterNoes 72AllanHenare (P)MartinSmith S (P)AndersenHipkins (P)McAnulty (P)Stanford (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CSwarbrickBallHughesMitchell M (P)TabuteauBennett PHuo (P)Nash (P)TinettiBishop (P)Jackson O'Connor Gvan de MolenCoffey (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)WallCollins (P)Kaye (P)PattersonWarren-ClarkCraigKing (P)Peters (P)WebbCurranKurigerPrimeWilliamsDavidson (P)Lees-Galloway (P)RadhakrishnanWillisDavisLittle (P)RobertsonWoods (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)DysonLubeckSageYule (P)Eagle (P)Luxton (P)Sepuloni (P)Faafoi (P)Mahuta (P)SeymourFalloonMallardShawGenter (P)MarcroftSimpsonTeller:Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Sio (P)AdamsAmendment not agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): Simeon Brown's amendment to clause 4(c) to replace "terminal illness" set out on SOP 284 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Chris Penk's amendment to clause 4(c)(i) to insert "on the balance of probabilities" set out on SOP 276 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Simon O'Connor's amendment to clause 4(c)(i) to insert "beyond reasonable doubt" set out on SOP 277 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Simon O'Connor's amendment to clause 4(c)(i) to insert a reference to refusing medical treatment set out on SOP 280 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Paulo Garcia's amendment to clause 4(c)(i) to require unanimous agreement of medical practitioners set out on SOP 281 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Simeon Brown's amendment to clause 4(c)(i) to replace "6 months" with "1 month" set out on SOP 282 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259. Simeon Brown's amendment to clause 4(d) to refer to "increasing disability" set out on SOP 285 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour's SOP 259.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 261 in the name of the Hon Dr Nick Smith to Part 1 be agreed to.Amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 286 in the name of Simeon Brown to Part 1 be agreed to.Amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 263 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry to Part 1 be agreed to.Amendments not agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That Part 1 as amended be agreed to.Ayes 70AndersenHenare (P)Mark (P)SimpsonArdern (P)Hipkins (P)MartinSmith S (P)BallHudson (P)McAnulty (P)Stanford (P)Bennett P (P)HughesMitchell CSwarbrickBishop (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)TabuteauCoffey (P)JacksonNash (P)TinettiCollins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor Gvan de MolenCraigKaye (P)Parker (P)WallCurranKing (P)PattersonWarren-ClarkDavidson (P)Kuriger (P)Peters (P)WebbDavis (P)Lees-Galloway (P)PrimeWilliamsDoocey (P)Little (P)RadhakrishnanWillisDysonLogie (P)RobertsonWoods (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)SageYule (P)FalloonMahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Genter (P)MallardSeymourTeller: Ghahraman (P)MarcroftShawAdamsNoes 50AllanGoldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Tirikatene (P)Bakshi (P)GuyO'Connor STolleyBarryHayes (P)Parmar (P)Twyford (P)Bayly (P)Hipango (P)PenkUpston (P)Bennett DKanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)Wagner (P)BidoisLee DReti (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)RurawheWhaitiriBrownLoheniRussellWoodCarterMacindoe (P)SalesaWoodhouseClark (P)McClay (P)Scott (P)Young (P)DeanMcKelvie (P)Sio (P)Dowie (P)Muller (P)Smith NTeller:GarciaNgaro (P)StrangeBrownleePart 1 as amended agreed to.House resumed.The Chairperson reported the KiwiSaver (Oranga Tamariki Guardians) Amendment Bill without amendment and progress on the End of Life Choice Bill.Report adopted.The House adjourned at 11.38 p.m."