Graham Kennedy: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers Questions to Members 
Graham Kennedy: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers Questions to Members 
[Volume:670;Page:17039] 
5. 
Dr KENNEDY GRAHAM (Green) 
 to the  
Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery 
: Is he satisfied that there is enough coordination between central government agencies local council and non-governmental organisations in the response to the earthquake? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON (Associate Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery) 
 on behalf of the  
Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery 
: Yes. One example is the coordinated effort by Ministry of Social Development staff non-governmental organisations like the Salvation Army community groups and 400 volunteers in canvassing more than 70000 houses in the suburbs most affected by the quake to check on the well-being and safety of residents. A second example is the head of the UK urban search and rescue team Peter Crook being quoted in the  
New Zealand Herald  
as saying about the emergency response: “The organisation has been outstanding the best-organised emergency I’ve been to.” However as in any disaster of this magnitude there will always be examples of situations where coordination could have been improved. But the Minister is assured that the Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management is doing its upmost to work with the city council and central government agencies to respond to the disaster. That is what the declaration of a state of national emergency is designed to do. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: Is he concerned about the focus of effort between the central business district and the eastern suburbs? Has a fair balance been struck between the two? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON 
: Based on all the evidence I have seen I can say a very fair balance has been struck. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: What steps is he taking to ensure that vulnerable people in the east of Christchurch some of whom already live below the poverty line will not be pushed over the edge by this crisis? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON 
: I think that yesterday I indicated the number of civil defence grants that have been paid out to people and the number of emergency subsidies towards housing that have been paid out. I am absolutely confident that if anybody is in dire straits and does need help it is there. I made the offer yesterday that if any Canterbury member—because I think those members were all supplied with direct phone lines to the national coordinator—knows of a specific example that we have missed the member should please not hesitate to let somebody know and the issue will get dealt to. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: I thank the Associate Minister for that response. Having attended meetings this morning in the east I will get back to him on that. Has he attended any local community meetings in the eastern suburbs; if not will he accompany me to my next meeting? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON 
: The Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery is spending nearly all his time in Christchurch and hence I can say that yes he will have. I am doing most of the Wellington-end work so although I have visited the place and been into the central business district and seen some of the devastation of the buildings I have not attended any of those meetings. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: Will the proposed central agency that is designed to handle the earthquake listen to the people of Christchurch by having their representatives involved in decision making? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON 
: I think that as time unfolds the member will realise that a number of issues have to be dealt with right there and then immediately. When any human life is involved and a building is causing a risk a decision that would normally be taken over several weeks may have to be made in that minute. But I give an assurance that where life is not at risk or human safety is not at risk a measured careful process of making decisions will be followed. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: Will all the information that the central agency uses for decisions be made available to the public? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON 
: It would be a bold call for me to answer that all of the information would be. Where it is possible information will be made available to the public. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: Will the Government consider a cross-party group with direct advisory powers to Cabinet for the Christchurch rebuild? 
Hon MAURICE WILLIAMSON 
: I am really reluctant to give answers about anything of a hypothetical nature into the future because a lot of decisions are yet to be taken on this track. I assure the member there is a long long way to go. We will be working on this issue for a very long time so I cannot speculate on what may occur into the future. 
Dr Kennedy Graham 
: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. With respect the question was specific. It was not asking for speculation in the future but asking whether the Government will consider doing that now. 
Mr SPEAKER 
: I think the Minister indicated that the Government is not prepared to do that; otherwise he would have said yes. Although the Minister may not have used those precise words he has not jumped to his feet to say the Speaker’s interpretation was wrong.