VoteHon LOUISE UPSTON (National—Taupō): Point of order. Madam Chair I just want to express some consternation about what just occurred in that vote. You declared a vote on the Supplementary Order Paper as a Yes vote then based on some interference from the Labour Party you then changed the vote. And I'd like some explanation why because I think that is a very very serious matter. And if I'm not satisfied I will seek to have a recall of the Speaker.Hon CHRIS HIPKINS (Minister for COVID-19 Response): Speaking to that point of order the declaration of the Chairperson as to whether the Ayes have it or the Noes have it is an indication to the House of how the Chair interprets a vote and the Chair is at liberty to make that declaration however they choose to. If it is then contested it is ultimately a roll-call of party votes that determines the matter and that is exactly what happened. Members regularly contest the view of the Chair. The Opposition contests the view of the Chair as to whether the Ayes have it on a very very regular basis.Hon LOUISE UPSTON (National—Taupō): Speaking to the point of order that is not my recollection of actually what occurred. The Speaker—the Chair I should say sorry; we're in committee—had expressed that the Ayes had it and Melissa Lee's Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) should then stand. There was no request for a party vote. The Chair had expressed that the SOP had been voted in favour and carried on the voices and unless I am satisfied to a high degree that there was not interference and that the Chair did not accept that interference and then change the vote I will be seeking a recall of the Speaker.WILLOW-JEAN PRIME (Assistant Whip—Labour): Speaking to the point of order I did request a party vote.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Jenny Salesa): The party vote was actually called for. It was my mistake saying the Ayes have it instead of saying the Noes have it.Hon LOUISE UPSTON (National—Taupō): So that's a mistake. So I'm going to seek a recall of the Speaker. That is an egregious issue that's occurred in this committee stage on a very significant piece of legislation and I would like the Speaker recalled.Hon Chris Hipkins: You have to move that the Speaker be recalled.Chris Bishop: You have to move it.Hon LOUISE UPSTON: I move That the Speaker be recalled.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Jenny Salesa): The question is that the motion be agreed to. Those in favour say Aye; to the contrary No.Hon Louise Upston: Oh borderline call. Be very careful with that.Hon Chris Hipkins: You're wasting the Speaker's time.Hon Louise Upston: No the Chair had moved on. This is outrageous. This is a significant piece of legislation and if Labour are blocking it is absolutely outrageous. I would be very careful.Kieran McAnulty: It's the second time she's spat the dummy in about a couple of weeks.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Jenny Salesa): On the voice in terms of the Noes versus the Ayes the Noes have it. If you'd like to declare a party vote I can call for a party vote?Hon LOUISE UPSTON (National—Taupō): Yes I'd like a party vote.A party vote was called for on the question That the Speaker be recalled.Ayes 43New Zealand National 33; ACT New Zealand 10.Noes 75New Zealand Labour 65; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 10.Motion not agreed to.