Henare Peeni; Costello Casey; Robertson Grant; O'Connor GregHon PEENI HENARE (Labour): Tēnā koe. Thank you very much Mr Chair. My question will relate directly to clause 23 of this bill the repeal of section 105 of the Smokefree Environments and Regulated Products Act. I want to use the Associate Minister of Health's words which were about revisit review make sure the settings are right moving forward". Those were the words of the Minister in a recent contribution not 20 minutes maybe perhaps 30 minutes ago. "Revisit review" to make sure the settings are right so that they can get the desired outcome into the future.So directly to clause 23 the repeal of section 105 then. I can accept that the Government's going to push forward with respect to the generation aspect of the smoke-free legislation that this Government passed. I can accept that. But given the Minister's words around "revisit review make sure the settings are right" good policy development tells me that a review must take place. So then my question to the Minister is: why wouldn't there be a review? And not understanding the reckless behaviour that the review in the original part of the bill would actually be able to substantiate and explain to the Minister or any future Minister or a Government or anyone reading the particular review—the kind of reckless behaviour around retailers and the way that they sell to younger generations. I can accept that there's a generational aspect here. Oh it looked like the Minister was about—so if it's all right if she's prepared to then I'm prepared Mr Chair to have the back and forth you've indicated.Hon CASEY COSTELLO (Associate Minister of Health): I just go back to the retailer licensing and reconfirm that the repeal here is because the licensing framework that sat in here related to the reduced retailer numbers and that's why it's being repealed. In regard to the review aspect this review aspect related specifically to the reduced retailers. What I've been talking about is ensuring that through the statistics that we see and the measures that we're trying to achieve we're reviewing that we're doing the right thing to achieve those targets. This review related to the repeal within—the legislation that we're repealing.Hon PEENI HENARE (Labour): Thank you Mr Chair. I thank the Minister for confirming the need for good information for strong review to be able to inform decision making moving forward. I have already mentioned that I accept that the Minister and this Government are looking to repeal this particular—through clause 23 the repeal of section 105 of the Smokefree Environments and Regulated Products Act and that relates directly to sections 40A and 40B in the legislation. I accept the generational matter but this goes back to the point around—and my question of and understanding that in the licensing of retailers making sure that we understand the behaviour of retailers not just in general wholesale of cigarette or tobacco products but in fact to a younger generation. And I know there's an age being set here.However we want to understand (1) those who are reckless in the sale of tobacco products. We heard in the House from members on the other side of the Chamber earlier today that you know this is important that we get it right for retailers. I accept that. So therefore we need to understand who of the retailers are actually reckless or who are those who are skirting around the laws here. And the only way to do that I put to the Minister is through a review. How can the Minister give me and the general public more confidence that the kind of review that she's referring to—to ensure that she makes the right decisions moving forward? How can she give us confidence that there will be a review to make sure that those retailers not simply through their licensing arrangements aren't flouting the laws here despite there being a set age for those who can purchase tobacco products?Hon GRANT ROBERTSON (Labour): Point of order. Mr Chair I seek leave for the next call to be a five-minute call that consists of an exchange between Dr Ayesha Verrall and the Minister in the chair.CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Leave is sought for that purpose. Is there any objection? There is."