Collins JudithHon JUDITH COLLINS (National—Papakura): Thank you Mr Speaker. Now wasn't that a lovely contribution from the member who has resumed her seat Poto Williams. I thought it was lovely. I thought she's so nice she could be in the National Party. She made some very nice comments and I want to echo them around some of the things that people did during the lockdown. I'd also say to the member and to the House that actually other people experienced loss during the lockdown lost family members. My little dog Holly I think many people know had a massive stroke and ended up having to go to doggy heaven during the lockdown. We had a family member who was found to have cancer during the lockdown and couldn't receive any treatment because it was new treatment hadn't already been started—found out about his diagnosis of stage 3 cancer on the phone. These are some of the issues that many families went through and many had even worse situations with a parent or a family member dying and not being able to be with that family member. That's why to find out that the quarantine of two women was so slack that they were allowed with this COVID-19 virus to get into a car and to drive to Wellington from Auckland—we are told from the Minister David Clark the Minister who was lax and not present during so much of the COVID-19 lockdown that we are supposed to believe that they didn't stop for petrol or fuel on the way. We are told that they didn't use any toilet facilities on the way. We on this side are told by a member of the public who knows of these people that they got lost on the way that they called for help for someone they knew to come and get them on the right track and that they greeted that person with a kiss and a hug.What is really damning is that these people should have been tested on day three and day 12 of their quarantine and they weren't. They were setting off in a car a borrowed car to go all the way from Auckland to Wellington. Now if we think about the fact that one of them is reported to have had COVID-19 symptoms and was allowed to do all of this we'd have to say Well what's happened to the rest of the quarantine?" So these people who we are now told today in the media not from the Minister but in the media have had 320—320—close contacts.This virus that the rest of us have followed all the rules about have gone without for have missed family situations for events have dealt with all sorts of difficulties and the rest of the country has followed the rules—it now turns out that the Ministry of Health—the Ministry of Health—overseeing this quarantine couldn't get it right. I've got no problem with compassionate leave if the rules are followed and people are kept safe. The purpose of these rules is to keep the public safe. It doesn't really matter what the rules are as long as they work. In this case the rules were there they weren't followed and the public is now not safe.So these women were allowed to attend an event in Wellington—320 close contacts all of whom now have to be found all of whom now have to be checked. Presumably all will have to be in a form of isolation. And who is going to come to the rescue of the Ministry of Health? The army and I don't even know whether or not they're going to have any masks or gloves or testing themselves. This Minister of Health has let the country down. He's let every family down. He's let everyone down who's had to endure anything during that COVID-19 lockdown that stopped them earning a living that stopped them being with a family member who was dying and that stopped them getting their cancer treatment. He's let down all these people because he didn't make sure that the job was done. He should go. If he can't make it work if he can't keep two people quarantined what hope for anyone?"