Kedgley Sue: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers Questions to Members 
Kedgley Sue: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers Questions to Members 
[Volume:653;Page:2290] 
9.  
SUE KEDGLEY (Green) 
 to the  
Minister of Local Government 
: Does he stand by his statement concerning the royal commission’s report on Auckland governance that “I have some concerns about whether the report provides for adequate local representation in our many diverse communities and I want to look more closely at this issue”; if so why? 
Hon JOHN CARTER (Associate Minister of Local Government) 
 on behalf of the  
Minister of Local Government 
: 
Yes; because there are many diverse communities. That is why the Minister is in Auckland today meeting with Mike Lee chair of the Auckland Regional Council; Alasdair Thompson chief executive of the Northern Employers and Manufacturers Association; and Mike Cohen chair of New Zealand Community Boards and chairperson of the Devonport Community Board. 
Sue Kedgley 
: Does he agree that many of the commission’s proposals actually undermine rather than strengthen local democracy in Auckland such as its proposal to wipe out most community boards strip local councils of their powers and relegate them to the status of local branch offices and concentrate extraordinary power in the office of the mayor? 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: The Minister agrees that the report of the royal commission is a large and significant document. The Government is still considering the details of the report and no decisions have yet been made. The Government intends to make a response to the report in due course. 
Hon Shane Jones 
: In the new Auckland-wide unitary authority how many voters exist in that area and how will the 10 new region-wide councillors be accountable to that volume of voters? 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: To the best of my knowledge there are about 1 million voters but I can be corrected on that figure. In response to the second part of the question I say to the member that the report of the royal commission is a large and significant document. The Government is still considering the details of the report and no decisions have been made. The Government intends to respond to the report in due course. 
Sue Kedgley 
: Does he agree with commentator Gordon Campbell that: “In an era where Big Government is supposed to be such a bad word this proposal will entail a centralisation of power unimagined by any left wing activist with Stalinist tendencies.”; and will he seek to ensure that there are checks on the extraordinary concentration of power in the office of the mayor? 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: I have seen a number of comments by a number of commentators who have different views but I would say to the member that the report of the royal commission is a large and significant document. The Government is still considering the detail of the report and no decisions have been made. The Government intends to make a response to the report in due course. 
Dr Russel Norman 
: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. There was no attempt to address the question in that answer. 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: Speaking to the point of order— 
Mr SPEAKER 
: No I do not think I need help on this. The difficulty is that the question really asked for an opinion and the opinion the Minister gave may not have been quite the opinion that was being sought. But if one seeks an opinion in a question one will get an opinion. That is the dilemma with that kind of question. 
Keith Locke 
: When the Minister says the Government will be deciding in due course does that mean as has been reported that there will be a decision at this coming Monday’s Cabinet meeting on whether the Government goes along with the general lines of the royal commission’s report; and how much time will the good citizens of Auckland be given to comment on the far-reaching proposals of the royal commission? 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: The Government intends to respond to the commission’s report in due course but no date for that has been announced at this time. 
Hon Shane Jones 
: Why will he not confirm to the House the promise he made to Aucklanders during the election campaign that they would be extensively consulted over the future of the mega-city for Auckland? 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: The whole process of the royal commission was about consultation; there has been extensive consultation for more than 20 months. We have now received the report of the commission which is a significant document with many details and the Government will give a considered response to it in due course. 
Sue Bradford 
: Does the Minister share the concern of the Green Party and of many of the people in Auckland that having the mayor and 10 councillors elected at large undermines fair community input into the council from all parts of the region and will inevitably result in elections that only the rich and famous will have any chance at all of winning? 
Hon JOHN CARTER 
: One thing that does not occupy a lot of the time of the Minister is the concerns of the Greens. But I would say that the report of the royal commission is a large document. The Government is considering the details of it and will respond to it in due course.