4. Question No. 4—Housing and Urban DevelopmentHon JUDITH COLLINS (National—Papakura) to the Minister of Housing and Urban DevelopmentQuestion No. 4—Housing and Urban Development 4. Hon JUDITH COLLINS (National—Papakura) to the Minister of Housing and Urban Development: Has the KiwiBuild underwrite of Mike Greer Homes passed the additionality test and who undertakes and approves this test?Hon PHIL TWYFORD (Minister of Housing and Urban Development): Yes and the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development assesses each development and I'm advised that that includes assessment of the additionality requirement. Hon Judith Collins: How many of the 104 Mike Greer KiwiBuild homes were already built at the time he and Minister Robertson agreed to underwrite them? Hon PHIL TWYFORD: To the best of my knowledge I think that for 11 of those 104 properties construction was at least under way. But I want to reiterate the answer that I gave yesterday and that is the additionality test for these developments is applied not on individual homes but on the contract as a whole. The Mike Greer contract delivered 104 affordable homes for first-home buyers. Hon Judith Collins: Did he inform those that perform the additionality test that all 11 Mike Greer KiwiBuild houses so far offered to KiwiBuild buyers were already built when he agreed to underwrite them? Hon PHIL TWYFORD: It's the job of the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development to undertake those negotiations and apply the additionality test so they did know. Hon Judith Collins: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. I asked if the Minister advised them. He then told me that it was the job of the ministry to undertake the test. The point is did the Minister know; did he advise the ministry of that? SPEAKER: I thought right at the end of the answer he did answer that. Hon PHIL TWYFORD: They already knew. Hon Judith Collins: Oh they already knew? OK. Can the Minister release the street addresses of each of the 104 Mike Greer KiwiBuild homes so that the public can be reassured that they were not already built when he agreed to underwrite them? Hon PHIL TWYFORD: Well I'd have to say I wouldn't be particularly keen on that given the member's track record of personally targeting and harassing KiwiBuild homeowners.Hon Judith Collins: In what month does he believe conversations with Mike Greer reached a level where Mike Greer was confident enough to change his designs to offer more affordable housing? Hon PHIL TWYFORD: You'd have to ask Mike Greer that question. Hon Judith Collins: Is the Minister aware that the 12 houses at 27 Dida Park Drive Huapai were all built before the underwrite marketed before the underwrite and all done to a design dated February 2017? Hon PHIL TWYFORD: Well I'm advised that the Huapai deal enabled Mike Greer to speed up that entire development and to bring it to market by June 2020 and reduced the prices in the Huapai development by $2.5 million. Hon Judith Collins: I seek leave to table an overall floor plan dated 27 February 2017 for all of the properties at 27 Dida Park Drive and before you ask me Mr Speaker I've had to obtain this from Auckland Council with payment of a fee and after waiting some days. SPEAKER: I will put the question that that be tabled. Is there any objection? There is none. It may be tabled. Document by leave laid on the Table of the House.