Bennett Paula: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers Questions to MembersText is incorporated into the Bound VolumeBennett Paula: Questions for Oral Answer — Questions to Ministers Questions to Members[Sitting date: 11 October 2007. Volume:642;Page:12301. Text is incorporated into the Bound Volume.]8.PAULA BENNETT (National) to theMinister of Education: Are creches at pools gyms Sunday schools and at-home babysitters now all required to be licensed; if so why?Hon RUTH DYSON (Minister of Labour)on behalf of theMinister of Education: Creches at pools gyms and Sunday schools have had to be licensed since 1989. At-home babysitters have never had to be licensed. The regulations are designed to keep children safe. As I have already made clear in answer to questions from the member and her colleagues the regulations are currently under review and anyone with a view on this matter is encouraged to make a submission.Paula Bennett: Will the ministry be contacting babysitters in their homes to tell them to be licensed?Hon RUTH DYSON: Perhaps it would assist the member if I could repeat the answer to the primary question which clearly she has missed. At-home babysitters have never had to be licensed.Paula Bennett: Did the ministry phone a Nelson woman who had lost her job after the gym creche she worked at was closed down at her home on 27 September and tell her she was breaking the law by babysitting children in her home and what is next—will neighbours and grandparents who babysit children have to become qualified and licensed centres?Hon RUTH DYSON: I think it is hugely ironic that over the last few weeks the National Party has been kicking up a frenzy about unqualified and unsuitable teachers who are in charge of our classrooms and now the member is advocating that anybody can have care of our children without any regulatory protection at all.Hon Dr Nick Smith: I raise a point of order Madam Speaker. The member’s question which affected a constituent of mine who was phoned by the ministry was very specific and asked whether the ministry phoned this woman who had lost her job as a consequence of the ministry closing down her creche and told her that she was unable to babysit children at her home. I listened to the Minister’s answer. She was making no attempt whatsoever to answer it.Madam SPEAKER: Please be seated. The Minister was taking a very long time to get to the point of her answer. I ask her to please complete her answer.Hon RUTH DYSON: I have completed it.Madam SPEAKER: Well would the member please then repeat her answer.Hon RUTH DYSON: The point I was making was that babysitters in the home have not ever been required to be licensed and are not now. If the member is advocating that children are cared for by parents in creches that do not have qualified staff with supervisory skills then it is totally in opposition to the position Katherine Rich has been whipping up a frenzy about up and down the country concerning unqualified untrained and unsuitable teachers being in charge of our children. The member needs to make up her mind. Does she want our children to be safe or not?Madam SPEAKER: The question did relate to a specific case. Would the Minister please address that case.Hon RUTH DYSON: The issue is about whether the person in question was operating a creche or babysitting and that was the response I appropriately gave in answer to that question.Moana Mackey: What steps has the Government taken to increase access to quality early childhood education?Hon RUTH DYSON: Under the Labour-led Government we have made huge progress towards making quality early childhood education available to every New Zealand child. We have created approximately 5400 early childhood places through the discretionary grants scheme increased the number of qualified early childhood teachers introduced a funding system that acknowledges cost drivers for centres reviewed regulations to make them more clear and transparent and introduced 20 hours a week free early childhood education for 3 and 4-year-olds. This policy I note is under threat from National which opposes it.Paula Bennett: Has the Minister already approved an exemption as stated by the Ministry of Education’s southern managerCoralanne Child that “One change that is confirmed for next year is the introduction of an exemption from regulations for centres such as gym creches provided they operate for no more than 4 hours per week.”; if so will the Minister now be setting the timetable for when these parents can exercise—does she suggest that opening one morning a week or for 1 hour four times a week is suitable?Hon RUTH DYSON: The regulations have been in place since 1989. They are under review. I urge the member if she has a positive contribution to make to do so. It is my view that parents should be able to exercise and should also know that their children are safe at that time.Paula Bennett: I raise a point of order Madam Speaker. I think that the question I asked was incredibly to the point. It was not answered at all. I asked whether the Minister has already approved an exemption.Madam SPEAKER: I listened carefully because I anticipated that would be the case. I think the Minister in this case did address the question.Paula Bennett: If the Minister can approve an exemption of 4 hours a week without a whole lot of palaver then why cannot the ministry just let some common sense prevailand put some basic safety precautions in place and let these parents decide when they will exercise and who will look after their own children?Hon RUTH DYSON: The exemptions are outlined in the regulatory regime that has been in place since 1989. If creches meet the conditions for an exemption then I consider they should apply.Paula Bennett: I seek the leave of the House to table theNelson Mail article that says “Babysitter steps in to help gym mums”.Madam SPEAKER: Leave is sought to table that article. Is there any objection? There is objection.