Woods MeganHon Dr MEGAN WOODS (Minister of Housing): I know focus groups are expensive but when you see the deputy leader of the Opposition just run out every line they've tested for the last three months you know that this is a National Party bereft of policy. All we are hearing is trotted out clichés in a speech from Nicola Willis that quite frankly could have been 25 years ago. Where are the 21st century ideas from the Opposition?This week the world has gathered to further action on climate change at COP27. And what do we have happening here in New Zealand? Well we have ambition and we have success from the Government: 97 percent renewable energy generation last week and just today we announced a package of Government-funded innovative projects to cut transport emissions and costs including for the first time in the marine sector. But what have we seen from the National Party? What we have seen is the National Party falling into the abyss of their carbon black hole. They are no longer content with wallowing in their fiscal Bermuda Triangle they've now gone a'tunnelling and they're tunnelling down into a carbon black hole—to the tune of 23.92 million tonnes of carbon that the National Party now has to stand up and account to. They are the party of No" they are telling us what they won't do to cut emissions they've signed up to carbon budgets they've said they're all in—Christopher Luxon said it's one if his key priorities. So tell us what you're going to do. You've told us what you're not going to do you're not going to cut transport emissions you're not going to help industry cut their emissions so stump up and tell us where you're going to find 23 million tonnes worth of carbon cuts. Let's put that in context: that is more than two times Auckland's total emissions; that is 1.2 million cars that will have to be taken off the roads by 2030 if they're not going to come through with what they are actually going to do.So what have we seen? We've seen Christopher Luxon is in a mess over their climate policy despite saying it's one of his key priorities and all afresh from greenwashing it in New Zealand he comes in and says that he's going to lead the National Party into a bright future a carbon future. Well all we've seen is U-turn on U-turn on U-turn from Mr Luxon. I suggest the leader of the National Party Christopher Luxon is suffering from a sustained loss of traction. He better worry because "Crusher Collins" will be coming for him. We know what she likes to do. Don't lose—SPEAKER: Order! Sorry I'm going to interrupt you. Members should not refer to other members by nicknames. Full names thank you.Hon Dr MEGAN WOODS: Apologies Mr Speaker. Mr Luxon should be careful because Judith Collins will be coming for him. But I suggest that Mr Luxon also start putting together a new calendar one that is round one that has no dates one that has no detail. And I think what we do is we update the Gregorian calendar with the Luxonian calendar—you just spin it round and round you don't give any details you don't give any dates and you don't say what you're going to do.Because that is what we are seeing from the National Party. All they can come up with—they've said "Look we're going to leave it to the emissions trading scheme (ETS). The ETS can do this alone." New Zealanders need to understand what that means if we leave all this to the emissions trading scheme. This has been laid out really clearly. So their "We're not going to do anything" hands off go round and round in circles approach is going to mean that if we're going to remove transport emissions with things other than innovative projects like our Government has put forward—and they've just said no for—we will need to see a carbon price of around $575 a tonne to achieve the kind of cuts we need. This will mean an extra $1.30 at the pump for every litre of petrol if we leave this to the ETS alone—SPEAKER: Order! The member's time has expired."