Ardern Jacinda: Oral Questions — Questions to MinistersText is incorporated into the Bound VolumeArdern Jacinda: Oral Questions — Questions to Ministers[Sitting date: 02 December 2014. Volume:702;Page:985. Text is incorporated into the Bound Volume.]12.JACINDA ARDERN (Labour)to the Minister for Social Development: By what percentage have child poverty levels changed since the Government took office based on the constant value below 60 percent of median incomes and after housing cost measures included in the Ministry of Social Development’s report on household incomes?Hon ANNE TOLLEY (Minister for Social Development):The rate on that one measure specified went from 22 percent in the 2008-09 survey to 24 percent in the 2010-11 survey and back to 22 percent in the 2012-13 survey which shows that we are recovering from the recession. There is a range of measures in the Child Poverty Monitor released today and the Ministry of Social Development regularly looks at a range of measures but the issues around poverty are complex and research shows that a number of measures need to be used. This Government is focused on practical help rather than arguing over individual measurement. Things are improving but there is still a long way to go and as I say the issues can be complex and often intergenerational.Jacinda Ardern: Based on her interview with Radio New Zealand this morning where she stated: “What you describe as poverty is not what I might describe as poverty.” how does she describe poverty and how many children are living in it?Hon ANNE TOLLEY: Well that is absolutely correct. Poverty is a scale and it is very important and the research shows that it is very important to understand what aspect of poverty you are talking about. So what that member might describe as poverty may be quite different from what another measure is describing as poverty. That is exactly what the research shows.Jacinda Ardern: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. The member really only reiterated my question. My question was: how would the Minister describe poverty therefore and how many children are living in it? She can choose to answer one or the other but one would be nice.Mr SPEAKER: She certainly answered one. The question was not as the member has just said it was; it was a lot more full than that. It asked how the Minister would describe poverty and the Minister went on to describe it as a scale and that there were various aspects for measuring it. [Interruption] Order! If the member wants to question whether the answer is adequate she should show the manners to listen to my justifying that the Minister has addressed the question. If she wants to make further progress she should make it by using concise supplementary questions.Jacinda Ardern: What target will she set to reduce child poverty?Hon ANNE TOLLEY: This Government has already set results targets and reports regularly on progress. We are finding that that clarity and accountability are well received and are what matter to New Zealanders. I remind the member that the Salvation Army said in 2008: “Our measures of progress at this time next year should not just be those of how much our economy has grown … more relevant measures could be those of how few people are locked up in prison how few violent crimes have been committed and how much better children in poorer schools are achieving.” Those are the sorts of targets this Government has set and is reporting on regularly.Jacinda Ardern: I raise a point of order Mr Speaker. My question was very straightforward and explicit. It was: what target will she set to reduce child poverty?Mr SPEAKER: And again I accept that the member may have had difficulty listening to the answer because I did as well—there was a lot of noise coming from members around her—but there was discussion in the answer about targets and measures. One of them that I did pick up on was the measurement of incarceration rates. That is the Minister’s answer. [Interruption] Order! If the member is going to continue to raise a point of order every time she considers an answer to be an unsatisfactory addressing of the question I will attempt to explain to the member why I think it is satisfactory. But we will make no progress at all if the member is going to continue to yell at me when I am standing on my feet. Does the member have a further supplementary question?Jacinda Ardern: Can the Minister explain how targets to reduce incarceration rates have anything to do with improving the well-being of a child living in poverty?Hon ANNE TOLLEY: I would love to. There are about 23000 children at any one time living in New Zealand who have a parent in prison. If the member does not think that that affects long term the economic social and emotional well-being of children then that member has a very different concept of poverty from mine.