VoteThe question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 304 in the name of Simon O'Connor to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett DHipangoPenkWagner (P)BidoisKanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)Pugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DRetiWhaitiri (P)Brown (P)Lee MRurawheWilliamsBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesaWoodCarter (P)MacindoeScott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)YuleDowie (P)MullerStrangeGarciaNgaroTirikatene (P)Teller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarryNoes 70AllanGhahraman (P)MarcroftSeymourAndersen (P)Henare (P)MarkShawArdern (P)Hipkins (P)MartinSimpsonBallHudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bishop (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)JacksonNash (P)TabuteauCollins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCraig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCurranKing (P)PattersonWallDavidsonKurigerPeters (P)Warren-ClarkDavisLees-GallowayPrimeWebb (P)Doocey (P)LittleRadhakrishnan (P)WillisDysonLogie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)RussellFalloonMahuta (P)SageTeller:GenterMallard (P)Sepuloni (P)AdamsAmendment to the amendments not agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Hon Anne Tolley): The question is—I really do think that you should be sitting down Mr O'Connor. I don't care where.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 306 in the name of Melissa Lee to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 51Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)PenkWagner (P)Bayly (P)Hipango Pugh (P)Walker (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)Reti Whaitiri (P)BidoisLee DRurawhe Williams Bridges (P)Lee MSalesa (P)Wood BrownLoheni Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Brownlee (P)Macindoe Sio (P)Young (P)Carter (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Yule Clark (P)McKelvie (P)Strange Dean (P)MullerTirikatene (P)Dowie (P)NgaroTolleyGarcia O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)Goldsmith (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Teller:Guy (P)Parmar (P)van de Molen Barry Noes 69AllanGhahraman (P)Marcroft Seymour Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark Shaw Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin Simpson (P)BallHudson (P)McAnulty Smith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bishop (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)Jackson Nash (P)Tabuteau Collins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinetti Craig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)Wall Curran King (P)PattersonWarren-ClarkDavidson Kuriger Peters (P)Webb (P)Davis Lees-Galloway Prime Willis Doocey (P)Little Radhakrishnan (P)Woods (P)Dyson Logie (P)Robertson (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)RussellFalloonMahuta (P)SageTeller:GenterMallard (P)Sepuloni (P)Adams Amendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 318 in the name of Paulo Garcia to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.Amendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 302 in the name of Chris Penk to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 49Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett D (P)HipangoPenkWagner (P)BidoisKanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)Pugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DRetiWhaitiri (P)BrownLee MRurawheWoodBrownlee (P)LoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Carter (P)MacindoeScott (P)Young (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)YuleDean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Dowie (P)MullerStrangeGarciaNgaroTirikateneTeller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarryNoes 71AllanHenare (P)MartinSmith S (P)Andersen (P)Hipkins (P)McAnultyStanford (P)Ardern (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell CSwarbrick (P)BallHughes (P)Mitchell M (P)TabuteauBennett P (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)TinettiBishop (P)JacksonO'Connor Gvan de MolenCoffey (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)WallCollins (P)Kaye (P)PattersonWarren-ClarkCraig (P)King (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)CurranKurigerPrimeWilliamsDavidsonLees-GallowayRadhakrishnan (P)WillisDavisLittleRobertson (P)Woods (P)Doocey (P)Logie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)DysonLubeckRussellEagle (P)Luxton (P)SageFaafoi (P)Mahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)FalloonMallard (P)SeymourGenterMarcroftShawTeller:Ghahraman (P)MarkSimpson (P)AdamsAmendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 320 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry to proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 50Bakshi (P)Guy (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Bayly (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Bennett D (P)Hipango Penk Wagner (P)Bidois Kanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)Pugh (P)Walker (P)Bridges (P)Lee DReti Whaitiri (P)BrownLee M (P)Rurawhe Williams Brownlee (P)Loheni Salesa (P)Wood Carter (P)Macindoe Scott (P)Woodhouse (P)Clark (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)Young (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Yule Dowie (P)Muller StrangeGarcia Ngaro TirikateneTeller:Goldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)TolleyBarry Noes 70Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft Seymour Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Shaw Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin Simpson (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)McAnultySmith S (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell CStanford (P)Bishop (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Coffey (P)Jackson Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Collins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTinettiCraig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)van de MolenCurran King (P)Patterson WallDavidson KurigerPeters (P)Warren-ClarkDavis Lees-GallowayPrime Webb (P)Doocey (P)LittleRadhakrishnan (P)WillisDyson Logie (P)Robertson (P)Woods (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Yang (P)Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)Russell Falloon Mahuta (P)Sage Teller:Genter Mallard (P)Sepuloni (P)AdamsAmendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 321 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry to the proposed amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment to the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 51Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)PenkWagner (P)Bayly (P)HipangoPugh (P)Walker (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)Reti Whaitiri (P)BidoisLee D Rurawhe Williams (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)Russell WoodBrownLoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Brownlee (P)MacindoeScott (P)Young (P)Carter (P)McClay (P)Sio (P)YuleClark (P)McKelvie (P)Smith N (P)Dean (P)Muller (P)StrangeDowie (P)NgaroTirikateneGarcia O'Connor D (P)TolleyGoldsmith (P)O'Connor STwyford (P)Teller:Guy (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)BarryNoes 69Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)Marcroft ShawAndersen (P)Henare (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Martin Smith S (P)BallHudson (P)McAnulty Stanford (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell C Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Huo (P)Mitchell M (P)Tabuteau (P)Coffey (P)Jackson Nash (P)Tinetti Collins (P)Jones (P)O'Connor Gvan de Molen Craig (P)Kaye (P)Parker (P)Wall Curran King (P)PattersonWarren-Clark Davidson Kuriger Peters (P)Webb (P)Davis Lees-Galloway Prime Willis Doocey (P)Little Radhakrishnan (P)Woods (P)DysonLogie (P)Robertson (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)LubeckRoss (P)Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)SageFalloonMahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Teller:Genter Mallard Seymour Adams Amendment to the amendments not agreed to.The question was put that the amendments set out on Supplementary Order Paper 259 in the name of David Seymour to Part 2 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendments be agreed to.Ayes 69Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)Mark (P)Shaw Andersen (P)Henare (P)Martin Simpson (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)McAnulty Smith S (P)Ball (P)Hudson (P)Mitchell C Stanford (P)Bennett P (P)Hughes (P)Mitchell M (P)Swarbrick (P)Bishop (P)Huo (P)Nash (P)Tabuteau (P)Coffey (P)Jackson O'Connor GTinetti Collins (P)Jones (P)Parker (P)Wall Craig (P)Kaye (P)Patterson Warren-ClarkCurran King (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)Davidson KurigerPrimeWillis Davis Lees-Galloway Radhakrishnan (P)WoodDoocey (P)Little Robertson (P)Woods (P)Dyson Logie (P)Ross (P)Yang (P)Eagle (P)Lubeck Russell Faafoi (P)Luxton (P)Sage FalloonMahuta (P)Sepuloni (P)Teller:Genter Marcroft Seymour Adams Noes 51Bakshi (P)Hayes (P)Parmar (P)van de Molen Bayly (P)HipangoPenk Wagner (P)Bennett D (P)Kanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)Pugh (P)Walker (P)Bidois Lee DReti Whaitiri (P)Bridges (P)Lee M (P)Rurawhe Williams BrownLoheniSalesa (P)Woodhouse (P)Brownlee (P)Macindoe Scott (P)Young (P)Carter (P)MallardSio (P)Yule Clark (P)McClay (P)Smith N (P)Dean (P)McKelvie (P)Strange Dowie (P)Muller (P)Tirikatene Garcia Ngaro TolleyGoldsmith (P)O'Connor D (P)Twyford (P)Teller:Guy (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)Barry Amendments agreed to.