VoteCHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): The question is that Hon Dr Duncan Webb's amendment set out on Amendment Paper 31 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to. Ayes 36AbelJacksonRussell (P)WebbBelich (P)LearySepuloni (P)WhiteBennett (P)Lyndon (P)Swarbrick (P)WilliamsCarter (P)McAnulty (P)Tana (P)Willis SDavidson M (P)McLellanTangaere-Manuel (P)Woods (P)Edmonds (P)Menéndez March (P)Tinetti (P)Xu-NanGenter (P)O'Connor G (P)TuionoHalbert (P)Paul (P)Twyford (P)Henare (P)Pham (P)Verrall (P)HernandezRurawhe (P)Wade-BrownNoes 78AndersonDavidson RMcCallum (P)SeymourArbuckleDoocey (P)McClay (P)Simmonds (P)Bates (P)Fleming (P)McKeeSimpsonBayly (P)FosterMeagerSmithBidois (P)GarciaMitchellSoseneBishop (P)Goldsmith (P)MooneyStanford (P)BoyackGrigg (P)NakhleStephensonBrewerHamiltonNimon (P)TraskBrookingHipkins (P)ParkerUffindell (P)Brown (P)Hoggard (P)Parmar (P)Unkovich (P)Brownlee (P)Jones (P)PattersonUpston (P)ButterickKirkpatrickPenk (P)UtikereCameron (P)KurigerPeters (P)van de Molen (P)Campbell (P)Lee (P)Potaka (P)van VeldenCheungLu (P)Pugh (P)Watts (P)ChhourLuxon (P)Radhakrishnan (P)WeddCollins (P)Luxton CRedmayneWeeninkCostello (P)Luxton J (P)Reti (P)Willis N (P)Costley (P)MacLeodRutherfordCourtMarcroft (P)SalesaAmendment not agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Helen White's amendment to clause 1 set out on Amendment Paper 39 is ruled out of order as being the same as an amendment that was previously not agreed.Helen White's remaining amendments set out on Amendment Paper 39 are ruled out of order as being outside the scope of the bill.The question is that the Hon Dr Duncan Webb's amendment set out on Amendment Paper 30 be agreed to.A personal vote was called for on the question That the amendment be agreed to.Ayes 38AbelHernandez (P)Rurawhe (P)Verrall (P)Andersen (P)LearyRussell (P)Wade-Brown (P)Belich (P)Lyndon (P)Sepuloni (P)WebbBennett (P)McAnulty (P)Sosene (P)WhiteCarter (P)McLellanSwarbrick (P)Williams (P)Davidson M (P)Menéndez March (P)Tana (P)Willis SEdmonds (P)O'Connor D (P)Tangaere-Manuel (P)Woods (P)Genter (P)O'Connor GTinetti (P)Xu-Nan (P)Halbert (P)Paul (P)Tuiono (P)Henare (P)Pham (P)Twyford (P)Noes 77AndersonDavidson RMcCallum (P)Seymour (P)ArbuckleDoocey (P)McClay (P)Simmonds (P)Bates (P)Fleming (P)McKeeSimpson (P)Bayly (P)FosterMeagerSmith (P)Bidois (P)Garcia (P)Mitchell (P)Stanford (P)Bishop (P)Goldsmith (P)MooneyStephensonBoyackGrigg (P)NakhleTraskBrewerHamiltonNimon (P)Uffindell (P)BrookingHipkins (P)Parker (P)Unkovich (P)Brown (P)Hoggard (P)Parmar (P)Upston (P)Brownlee (P)Jones (P)PattersonUtikereButterickKirkpatrickPenk (P)van de Molen (P)Cameron (P)KurigerPeters (P)van VeldenCampbell (P)Lee (P)Potaka (P)Watts (P)Cheung (P)Lu (P)Pugh (P)WeddChhour (P)Luxon (P)Radhakrishnan (P)WeeninkCollins (P)Luxton C (P)RedmayneWillis N (P)Costello (P)Luxton J (P)Reti (P)Costley (P)MacLeodRutherfordCourtMarcroft (P)SalesaAmendment not agreed to.The result corrected after originally being announced as Ayes 28 Noes 77.CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): The question is that the Hon Dr Duncan Webb's amendment set out on Amendment Paper 32 be agreed to.Amendment not agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): The question is that Helen White's amendment to clause 4 set out on Amendment Paper 38 be agreed to.Amendment not agreed to.Clauses 1 to 9 agreed to.CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): I will report this bill without amendment.Hon Dr Duncan Webb: Personal vote—personal vote.CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Oh sorry was that a personal vote? My apologies I missed that. Sorry a personal vote was called for.Hon Members: After you'd reported it!CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): A personal vote will be held. Ring the bells.