Motions — Paris—Terrorist AttacksText is incorporated into the Bound VolumeMotions — Paris—Terrorist Attacks[Sitting date: 17 November 2015. Volume:710;Page:8015. Text is incorporated into the Bound Volume.]MotionsParis—Terrorist AttacksHon BILL ENGLISH (Acting Prime Minister): I seek leave to move a motion without notice condemning the terrorist attacks in Paris on Friday 13 November.Mr SPEAKER: Is there any objection to that course of action being followed? There is none.Hon BILL ENGLISH: I move That this House condemn the terrorist attacks in Paris and extend its condolences to the families and friends of those killed and injured. I would also like to acknowledge Her Excellency Mrs Florence Jeanblanc-Risler French Ambassador to New Zealand who is in the Speaker’s gallery today. New Zealanders were deeply shocked by the brutal events that unfolded in Paris 3 days ago. Our hearts go out to the innocent people caught up in this despicable act of terrorism. In particular we extend our deepest condolences to those who have lost loved ones as well as those who were injured some of whom are still fighting for their lives.As our Prime Minister has said New Zealand stands shoulder to shoulder with France in the global fight against terror. Sadly this is the latest in a series of terrorist attacks on innocent communities around the world. Like France New Zealand values—if not takes for granted—peace security and freedom. These attacks in Paris were directed at these core values. It is abhorrent to us that people going about their daily lives were gunned down in cold blood in an act designed purely for the purpose of killing as many as possible. This is an assault on the democratic freedoms that we cherish.After the attacks the New Zealand Government responded immediately to check on the well-being of New Zealanders known to be in Paris. The Prime Minister also conveyed his sympathies to the President of France. The Prime Minister will express those sympathies in person to the President when he attends the conference of the parties on climate change in Paris later this month. Finally I can inform the House that a condolence book has been set up in the foyer of Parliament for visitors and staff to express their condolences. Thank you.ANDREW LITTLE (Leader of the Opposition): A city that represents the best about our civilisation has been attacked by those who wanted to return us to the worst kind of barbarism and the Opposition stands with the Government and condemns the attacks in the strongest possible terms. We support the efforts to track down and bring to justice the perpetrators of this atrocity.Let us remember why these attacks occur. It is not only about extremists killing innocent civilians. The perpetrators of these acts do them to cause fear and terror amongst all citizens of the free world. They win when we succumb to the fear that they foster. They win when we respond only with anger and hatred. They win when we turn on ourselves and on our peaceful communities and on others in our communities. They win when our only response is revenge and retribution. They win when we feel that the only way to be safe is when we abandon our freedoms and curtail our rights as citizens of the free world. When confronted with the barbarism of the sort that we saw on the weekend—barbarism that kills and maims the innocent—the urge for revenge and retribution is real and it is human. In our shock and in our anger we want to avenge to exact an equal price but it is when the urge for revenge is greatest that our humanity must take over—our sense of ourselves as loving and peaceful and just people.For just as the perpetrators of this gross violence wish us to cower in fear to their warped tyranny so also do they want to see us abandon our humanness—and we must never do that. Because to do so is to yield to their fearmongering and we must never concede to fear. As we deal with our shock our anger our revulsion our vitriol our insistence on justice in the face of the grossest injustice we must never fear the path of peace. We might have differences of party in this Parliament but we are united by our humanity. Let us stand in solidarity with the people of Paris and all France and in solidarity with all peoples of the world to achieve a just peace.Dr KENNEDY GRAHAM (Green): The Green Party stands with the people of France in their moment of grief and trauma. To paraphrase a valiant leader from a century ago: your sons and daughters so cruelly slain in the city of Paris this Friday evening are our sons and daughters today for we are united in sorrow and respect. Our hearts go out to the families of the fallen.We live in a new age in which humanity is divided not only by ideas but by standards. Our emerging notion of global morals and values our sense of how to conduct ideas and interests and how to aspire to manage human conflict humanely have themselves become subject to challenge. The means of conflict are never pretty but the world is witness today to two forms of belief: one holds that there exists a threshold of behaviour below which no human by virtue of being human is expected or permitted to sink; the other is that there is no such threshold. What we have witnessed in the deserts in recent years and what we have witnessed in this new century of ours in the streets of our cities all around the world is barbarity of a kind unprecedented in the modern age. It is not that humans have never acted thus in the past—it is that we believed that we had through pain and effort civilised ourselves to a higher point. However modestly so we believe our values and morals today to be of a higher kind.As we look ahead the art of global leadership—to be shared by the leaders of all nations—will be to agree on how to respond to such barbarity with stern and far-reaching effect while retaining the values we already hold dear as a young and fragile global community. We do not pretend today to have infallible insight into how that challenge is to be met beyond affirming that our existing principles and institutions enshrined essentially in the UN Charter and in the Statute of Rome are to be strictly respected. We are at a moment of reckoning. We cannot in the heat of the moment lose sight of what we have achieved over the past century of what we hold dear of where we wish to head. Perhaps we need to have a debate in this House on these very issues.Meanwhile let us pay our respect to the fallen in Paris and also in Beirut and Ankara and Moscow and Boston and Garissa in Gaza and Jerusalem and Sana’a and in the skies above Egypt. Let us pay our respect to the peoples and the Governments of these countries and indeed of all countries on this planet that we share.Rt Hon WINSTON PETERS (Leader—NZ First): New Zealand should speak on this crisis with one voice and so we add our voice to this motion and we support views expressed by other members of this House. We want the French people to know that New Zealand is with them in their hour of grief and anguish at this despicable terrorist outrage. Vive la France.Hon TE URUROA FLAVELL (Co-Leader—Māori Party):E Te Whare Pāremata ō tātau tēnā tātau katoa tēnei te tū ake ki te tautoko i ngā kōrero kua kōrerohia. Kai te whakaae atu ki te ia o te kōrero ki te wairua o te kōrero ēngari kia hāngai tonu taku kōrero ki te hunga kua mate me taku kī atu: “E Tū e he aha te taonga i haere ai koutou ki te mate? He tara tārau tē tē! He pā tehetehe! He huruhuru whare riha! He papa pounamu ki te ringa kia māwhiti te karu e!”. He kupu kōrero tērā mō te hunga kua ngaro i te tirohanga kanohi.Tata ki te rua rau tāngata i parekuratia ai nā te āhuatanga o te hunga—ko ētahi i mate ko ētahi i puta ko ētahi kāre anō kia kitea ēngari i mahi rā i wā rātau mahi nā runga i te riri nā runga i te aha rānei ko wai ka mōhio! Waiho tērā hunga ki a rātau anō i te tuatahi me tangi ki ngā mate e kōrerohia nei ngā whānau te hunga i noho nei e kaputī nei e kanikani nei e mātakitaki nei i te āhuatanga o tā rātau noho i Wīwī e kore mōhio nō rātau ā i reira tētahi nanakia e whakaaro ake nei ā ki te kōhuru i a rātau. Nō reira me pēnei rawa te kōrero koutou i Te Pō e moe e moe e moe! Koutou te whenua o Wīwī e tū pakari nei ki mua i te aroaro o te hoariri tēnā koutou tēnā koutou tēnā koutou kia kaha kia toa kia manawa nui!I ngā tau kua hipa ake ko Te Māori i haere ki Wīwī. I hiahia nō Te Ao Māori otirā tēnei whenua ki te āwhina i a Wīwī i roto i ngā uauatanga o te pakanga. Ko Te Pakanga Tuatahi tērā ā nā runga i ngā āki o Tā Apirana Ngata mā o tā Te Rangi Hīroa mā eke atu ngā Māori ki tērā whenua. Nā Te Ao Māori anō rātau i whakaako ki ō rahi ērā momo āhuatanga otirā i ako nei ngā Māori i ngā waiata o Wīwī. I tēnei rā ko Te Ao Māori tēnei e tū ake ki te tautoko i a koutou i te wā o te tangi te wā o te aroha te wā o te pōuri kia taea ai koutou te puta ki te whai ao ki te ao mārama! Nō reira koinei tētahi paku kupu ki a koutou kai aku rangatira Wīwī otirā ngā mea o Wīwī e noho nei i Aotearoa nei e whakaaro nui nei mō tō koutou whānau kai wīwī e noho ana. Ka tangi ake hoi anō tē taea te aha! Kia kaha kia toa kia manawa nui!Tētahi waiata hai āwhina hei whakamāmā i te āhuatanga o te ngau o mamae ka whai mai ā kō ake nei. He kōrero e pēnei ana te kōrero: Mā wai rā e taurima te marae? Ēhara i te mea ko te marae o Te Ao Māori ēngari arā ko te whenua te kōrero! Mā te aroha mā te whakaaro nui ā tētahi ki tētahi! Tēnā he wai.[To this House of Parliament of ours acknowledgments to us all. I rise in support of the contributions made. I agree with the flow and spirit of the discourse but my address must remain focused on those who died by saying to them: “Alas oh Tū what was the treasure that caused you collectively your death? A condiment of ecstasy—no no! Thrusts of naked manhood! Hair that houses nits! Greenstone tiki in hand you may well stare; woe is me!”. Those are words from a lament that expresses deep grief for the dead lost from the sight of mankind.Approximately 200 people were affected by the terrorist attack. Some were killed some escaped and some have not been found yet. But no one knows the reason for the attack—whether it was in anger or whatever. Leave that lot there among their own; our task in the first instance is to grieve over the deaths alluded to here the families the ones who were merely socialising having a cup of tea dancing and seeing how people live their lives in France unaware that a villain was present and thinking about murdering them. So let me put it this way: you in the Void sleep rest slumber; you the country of France standing strong before the enemy I salute acknowledge and commend you. Be strong brave and stout of heart.In years past it was the Māori indeed who went to France. Māoridom—in other words this country—wanted to help France during the difficulties of war. That was the First World War and through the urgings of Sir Apirana Ngata Sir Te Rangi Hīroa and others Māori arrived in that country. Māoridom also taught them to work alongside your masses and in all those kinds of things. Furthermore these Māorilearnt French songs. This is Māoridom standing here today to support you in your moment of grief empathy and remorse that will enable you to emerge into the world of light and understanding. So this is but a small tribute to you collectively my esteemed ones of France but at the same time to those living here in New Zealand from France. We have huge considerations for your families living back there in France. We grieve but are unable to do anything! Be strong courageous and stout of heart.A song to help and ease the pain that gnaws will follow shortly. It is a tale that goes like this: who indeed will tend to the marae? It is not as if it is referring to the marae of Māoridom but rather to the country. That is what this tale is about. A feeling of empathy and a high regard of one for the other will tend to the country. Now then a song.]WaiataMā te tika mā te pono mā te aroha koinei ngā kaupapa nui tēnā koutou kia ora tātau![Fairness sincerity and compassion—these then are important principles. Acknowledgments to you collectively and my regards to us all.]DAVID SEYMOUR (Leader—ACT): On behalf of the ACT Party I would like to add my voice to those who have gone before and express the deepest sympathy and condolence to the victims their families and those still recovering from injury but also to all of the French people in this time of great suffering. As earlier speakers have alluded to this attack does lead to questions about how a society like ours which has been so lucky to inherit the tenets of freedom responsibility and tolerance should deal with and respond to those who do wish to do harm and are not tolerant. For my part I think that we should be prepared to have that debate and never be afraid to state the values that make our country great but today we should be giving our condolences to the people of France. Thank you.Motion agreed to.