Clinical trial NCT02899156
Conditions: Hypoactive Delirium
Keywords: delirium flumazenil hypoactive delirium benzodiazepine benzodiazepine antagonist critical care
Sponsor: University of California, Davis
Start date: 2016-03-01; Completion date: 2019-04-16
Enrollment: 22 participants; Allocation: RANDOMIZED; Intervention model: PARALLEL

Brief summary:
Delirium within the intensive care unit (ICU) is associated with poor outcomes such as increased mortality, ICU and hospital length of stay (LOS), and time on mechanical ventilation. Benzodiazepine (BZD) exposure is an independent risk factor for development of delirium. Reversal of hypoactive delirium represents a potential opportunity for reducing duration of delirium and subsequent complications.

This is a single-center randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of critically ill adult patients with benzodiazepine-associated hypoactive delirium. The hypothesis is that flumazenil continuous infusion may reverse hypoactive delirium associated with BZD exposure and thereby reduce duration of delirium and ICU LOS.

Detailed description:
Benzodiazepines are commonly used for discomfort, anxiety, agitation, and alcohol withdrawal syndrome (AWS) in the ICU. End organ dysfunction and extended exposure can increase the risk of complications associated with BZDs, which include increased ICU LOS, time on mechanical ventilation, and mortality.

Flumazenil as a 1, 4-imidazobenzodiazepine is a competitive antagonist for the benzodiazepine binding site with weak intrinsic or partial agonistic activity on the GABA receptor. Multiple studies have confirmed the safety and effectiveness of flumazenil for the reversal of sedation. Pilot studies have demonstrated safe reversal of over-sedation and statistically significant improvements in patient cooperation and time to extubation. The current standard for suspected BZD-associated hypoactive delirium is cessation of benzodiazepine administration and supportive care.

The role of continuous infusion flumazenil for rapid and sustained reversal of hypoactive delirium in the ICU has not been evaluated prospectively and therefore remains poorly defined.

Arms: arm 1: The flumazenil continuous infusion is started at an initial dose of 0.1 mg/hr., and can be titrated up to a maximum of 0.3 mg/hr. Dose titrations may occur every 60 minutes to maintain RASS scores of 0 to +1. The maximum rate is 0.3 mg/hr. arm 2: The placebo continuous infusion is started at an initial dose of 0.1 mg/hr (2 ml/hr)., and can be titrated up to a maximum of 0.3 mg/hr. Dose titrations may occur every 60 minutes to maintain RASS scores of 0 to +1. The maximum rate is 0.3 mg/hr.
Interventions: intervention 1: Flumazenil intervention 2: Placebo
Intervention descriptions: intervention 1: None intervention 2: 0.9% normal saline

Protocol documents:
Prot_SAP_000.pdf: 
Effect of Flumazenil on Hypoactive Delirium in the ICU: A Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Pilot 
Study 
NCT: 02899156 
Document Date: September 25, 2017 
Document Type: Study Protocol with Statistical Analysis 
Objectives 
The primary objectives was to determine the effect of flumazenil on delirium-free days for critically ill 
patients with benzodiazepine-associated hypoactive delirium. Delirium free days were defined as the 
number of days in the first 14 days during which the patient was alive without delirium or coma from any 
cause 
 
The primary safety objective was the occurrence of severe refractory agitation, which was defined as 
RASS of +2 to +4 that did not resolve by decreasing the infusion rate of study drug. 
 
Secondary outcomes included probability of delirium resolution, ICU LOS, maximum rate and duration 
of study infusion, rescue sedative use, and mechanical ventilator-free days. 
 
The hypothesis was that flumazenil continuous infusion may decrease duration of delirium by reversing 
benzodiazepine-associated hypoactive delirium.  
 
Study Design  
This was a single-center randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study.  Critically ill adult patients 
with suspected BZD-associated hypoactive delirium may be eligible.   
 
Upon completion of screening and determining eligibility, patients received a test dose of flumazenil.  If 
response was noted (defined as a change in RASS of +1 to +2), patients were randomized to receive 
standard of care and placebo infusion or standard of care and flumazenil infusion.  
  
Methods 
The PI or a co-investigator screened for subjects for inclusion via a daily drug utilization report of 
benzodiazepine use in the Intensive Care Units. Upon pre-qualification via EMR screening, the 
investigator performed an in-person assessment to confirm inclusion criteria have been met and patients 
do not meet exclusion criteria.   
 
Screening included: 
o review of the subjects current and prior to admission medication list (via medication 
reconciliation performed by PI/pharmacy medication reconciliation team, or urine 
drug toxicity screen) 
o review of past medical history (history of seizure, TBI, etc.) to identify exclusion 
criteria  
o review of available urine drug toxicity screen to identify ingestion of pro-convulsant 
or home benzodiazepine medication. If there was no available urine drug toxicity 
screen and the patient was greater than 72 hrs from admission there was no 
requirement for ordering one unless there was a high suspicion for recreational drug 
use prior to admission 
o review of available pregnancy test in females aged 18 -55 y.o.  If pregnancy testing 
was not already performed, the PI discussed ordering a pregnancy test with the 
primary ICU attending prior to enrollment.  If the pregnancy test was positive, the 
subject was not enrolled.  


o all patients who were screened will be tabulated in order to document reasons for 
exclusion.  PHI was not retained for this process.  
o confirmed documentation of RASS -3 to 0 and CAM-ICU positive 
o the study was then discussed with the primary attending physician caring for the 
patient and permission was obtained to approach patient and/or LAR to obtain 
consent.  At that time the patient’s home medication list was confirmed with the LAR 
to identify any history of taking pro-convulsants.  
 
 
Test dose administration and monitoring (ICU-only): 
o after consent was obtained enrollment into the trial occured, subjects received a test 
dose of flumazenil 0.1-0.5 mg as IV push over 15 seconds administered by the 
bedside nurse. May repeat every 5-10 minutes up to a MAX of 2 mg total (assess for 
up to 60 minutes after last dose) (onset of 0.6 mg dose in healthy volunteers was 5 
minutes).   
o for all patients meeting inclusion criteria and for whom consent had been obtained 
the PI entered each subjects test dose response (positive/negative) on a study log  
o subjects’ response was assessed by the PI, bedside nurse and a member of the 
primary care team who remained at bedside for 30 minutes after the last test was 
administered 
o a copy of the EKG was performed 10 minutes and 60 minutes after the first dose and 
was scanned into the subject’s profile  
o if response (defined as a change in RASS of +1 to +2) was noted, then randomization 
to standard of care and flumazenil or standard of care and placebo occurred 
o responders had a sign posted on his/her door to indicate that the patient was part of a 
study 
o patients that did not respond to test dose were not randomized 
o to ensure proper safety monitoring, the PI, a member of the primary care, and the 
bedside nurse (administering) were present to monitor for any complications for 30 
minutes after the last test dose.  
Infusion titration post-randomization (ICU-only): 
1. Responders to flumazenil:  
o standard of care + flumazenil 2.5 mg/50 mLs 0.9% NaCl, or 5% dextrose (0.05 
mg/mL) IV continuous infusion  
o Dosing range: 0.025 mg/hr – 0.3 mg/hr (0.5 -6 ml/hr)  
o Start at @ 2 mLs per hour (0.1 mg/hr., 2.4 mg/24 hours)  
o Titration by 1 mL (0.05 mg) or as clinically indicated per study 
investigator every 60 minutes for target RASS (0 to +1) 
**Patient care order placed for nurse to monitor RASS every 1 
hour (standard of care is every 2 hrs.). 
o Maximum Rate: 6 mLs/hr. (0.3 mg/hr.) 
o If RASS +2 to +3, decrease dose by 0.05mg (1 mL) or as clinically 
indicated per study investigator every 60 minutes or HOLD if at the 
lowest rate of 0.025 mg/hr (0.5ml/hr) and re-assess in 1 hour. 
o If RASS +4, HOLD regardless of rate and re-assess in 1 hour. 
 
o standard of care + placebo (50 mLs 0.9% NaCl, 5% dextrose) IV continuous 
infusion 


o Dosing range: 0.025 mg/hr – 0.3 mg/hr (0.5 -6 ml/hr)  
o Start at @ 2 mLs per hour  
o Titration by 1 mL (0.05 mg) or as clinically indicated per study 
investigator every 60 minutes for target RASS (0 to +1) 
o Maximum Rate: 6mLs/hr. (0.3 mg/hr.) 
o If RASS +2 to +3, decrease dose by 0.05mg (1 mL) or as clinically 
indicated per study investigator every 60 minutes or HOLD if at the 
lowest rate of 0.025 mg/hr (0.5ml/hr) and re-assess in 1 hour. 
o If RASS +4, HOLD regardless of rate and re-assess in 1 hour. 
2. PI or co-investigator assessed patient response daily during the intervention phase (no 
longer than 72 hours).  
o Daily interruption of infusion starting @ 0900 for 4 hours or until RASS of -
1 to -2 . 
A. Assess & document CAM-ICU and RASS BEFORE 
continuous infusion is interrupted 
B. At the end of the interruption, assess patient’s RASS and 
CAM-ICU.   
C. If patient regresses back to RASS -1 to -3 and CAM-ICU 
positive, then study infusion was restarted at the previous 
rate and re-assessed daily.   
D. If daily interruption results in no change in RASS or CAM-
ICU scores then study infusion was restarted @ the previous 
rate 
o Daily interruption occurred daily unless one of the following criteria were 
met resulting in discontinuation of study drug in the interim:  
A. Primary attending caring for patient deemed discontinuation 
appropriate 
a. Primary care team must prospectively notify the PI if 
the primary care team wishes to interrupt or 
discontinue the study infusion to provide clinical 
care to the patient.  
B. RASS +2 to +4 while on infusion and agitation not 
controlled with standard treatments (i.e. anti-psychotics)  
C. Rescue benzodiazepine needed due to signs of withdrawal 
according to the SHOT Scale   
D. Remains CAM-ICU negative after interruption 
E. ICU discharge (determined by physical transfer to lower 
level of care) 
F. Adverse event attributable to study drug (i.e. 
supraventricular arrhythmia, seizure)  
3. If episodic sedation was needed for a procedure (i.e. bronchoscopy) 
o Study drug could be held (i.e. 30-60 minutes prior) and once the procedure 
was completed the study infusion could be restarted at previous rate.   
 
As delineated above, the primary investigator and co-investigators were active participants in the study 
from pre-screening, enrollment, data collection, and data analysis. Relevant staff, including nursing 
personnel and medical staff, were utilized for coordination purposes.   
 
 


 
Statistical Analysis  
Baseline characteristics included age, sex, ICU service, Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) 
score, Charlson Comorbidity Index, days in hospital prior to enrollment, time since last benzodiazepine 
administration, benzodiazepine indication, lorazepam equivalents (lorazepam 1 mg = midazolam 2 mg = 
diazepam 5 mg), home benzodiazepine use, and RASS prior to test dose. The original sample size 
calculation indicated that 40 patients in each group were required to detect a 30% difference (sd ± 2 d) in 
delirium-free days, assuming p value less than 0.05 and 80% power. Descriptive statistics and the 
Wilcoxon rank-sum test were performed. The Kaplan–Meier method was used to characterize the 
probability of being delirium and coma free.