Minutes of the sitting of 17 April 2023
Date: 2023-04-17
Institutions: European Parliament
Subjects: European Parliament, parliamentary debate




C_202400813EN.000101.fmx.xml












Official Journal of the European Union


EN
Series C














18.1.2024







            17 April 2023
            MINUTES OF THE SITTING OF 17 APRIL 2023
            
         
(C/2024/813)

Contents







1.

Resumption of the session
3










2.

Opening of the sitting
3










3.

Statements by the President
3










4.

Approval of the minutes of the previous sittings
3










5.

Composition of Parliament
3










6.

Request for the waiver of immunity
4










7.

Composition of political groups
4










8.

Composition of committees and delegations
4










9.

Interpretation of Rules of Procedure (action taken)
5










10.

Negotiations ahead of Parliament's first reading (Rule 71) (action taken)
5










11.

Negotiations ahead of Parliament's first reading (Rule 71)
5










12.

Signing of acts adopted in accordance with the ordinary legislative procedure (Rule 79)
6










13.

Order of business
7










14.

Deforestation Regulation ***I (debate)
9










15.

Revision of the EU Emissions Trading System ***I — Monitoring, reporting and verification of greenhouse gas emissions from maritime transport ***I — Carbon border adjustment mechanism ***I — Social Climate Fund ***I — Revision of the EU Emissions Trading System for aviation ***I (debate)
9










16.

Composition of committees and delegations
11










17.

Institutional relations between the EU and the Council of Europe (short presentation)
12










18.

Sustainable carbon cycles (short presentation)
12










19.

eGovernment accelerating digital public services that support the functioning of the single market (short presentation)
12










20.

The implementation of civilian CSDP and other EU civilian security assistance (short presentation)
12










21.

One-minute speeches on matters of political importance
13










22.

Agenda of the next sitting
13










23.

Approval of the minutes of the sitting
13










24.

Closure of the sitting
13








LIST OF DOCUMENTS SERVING AS A BASIS FOR THE DEBATES AND DECISIONS OF PARLIAMENT
14










1.

Questions for oral answer (submission)
14










2.

Documents received
14








ATTENDANCE REGISTER
18



ANNEX





RESULT OF ROLL-CALL VOTES
20










1.

Tuesday's agenda — Request from the PPE Group
20










2.

Tuesday's agenda — Request from the S&D, Verts/ALE and The Left groups
21










3.

Tuesday's agenda — Request from the ECR and PPE groups
22




Minutes of the sitting of 17 April 2023
                  

IN THE CHAIR: Roberta METSOLA

President

1.   Resumption of the session
The session adjourned on Thursday 30 March 2023 was resumed.
2.   Opening of the sitting
The sitting opened at 17.03.
3.   Statements by the President
The President pointed out that it had now been 20 days since Evan Gershkovich, a reporter for The Wall Street Journal, had been detained in Russia. She reiterated her call for his safe release and underlined Parliament's commitment to seeing him go free as quickly as possible.
The President made a statement on the worrying condition of Alexei Navalny, a Russian opposition politician and Sakharov Prize laureate who was in prison in Russia. On behalf of Parliament, she reiterated her call for his immediate and unconditional release.
The President went on to point out that, as Russia's illegal invasion of Ukraine continued, Russia had an obligation to ensure that prisoners of war were treated humanely and in accordance with the Geneva Convention. She emphasised that the perpetrators of war crimes would be brought to justice.
The President made a statement on the worsening situation in Sudan, where violent clashes had caused many deaths and undermined efforts to ensure a democratic transition in the country. On behalf of Parliament, she strongly condemned the acts of violence and called on all parties to cease hostilities and ensure the safety of the entire population and the stability of the country.
4.   Approval of the minutes of the previous sittings
The minutes of the sittings of 29 March 2023 and 30 March 2023 were approved.
5.   Composition of Parliament
The Italian authorities had notified the President that Simona Baldassarre and Luisa Regimenti had been appointed assessors of the Region of Lazio, and that Pierfrancesco Majorino had been elected counsellor of the Region of Lombardy.
Laura Huhtasaari had been elected to the Finnish Parliament with effect from 12 April 2023.
Parliament noted that, in accordance with Article 7(2) and (3) of the Act of 20 September 1976 concerning the election of members of the European Parliament by direct universal suffrage, those offices were incompatible with that of member of the European Parliament.
In accordance with Rule 4, Parliament declared that vacancies existed with effect from 3 April 2023, 4 April 2023, 5 April 2023 and 12 April 2023 respectively.
The Italian authorities had given notice that Mercedes Bresso, Francesca Peppucci and Maria Veronica Rossi had been elected to the European Parliament replacing Pierfrancesco Majorino, Luisa Regimenti and Simona Baldassarre respectively with effect from 6 April 2023.
The Finnish authorities had given notice that Pirkko Ruohonen-Lerner had been elected to the European Parliament replacing Laura Huhtasaari with effect from 12 April 2023.
Parliament took due note of their election.
Under Rule 3(2), until such time as their credentials had been verified or a ruling had been given on any dispute, and provided that they had previously made a written declaration stating that they did not hold any office incompatible with that of Member of the European Parliament, Mercedes Bresso, Francesca Peppucci, Maria Veronica Rossi et Pirkko Ruohonen-Lerner would take their seats in Parliament and on its bodies and would enjoy all the rights attaching thereto.
6.   Request for the waiver of immunity
The Belgian authorities had forwarded a request for the immunity of Alexis Georgoulis to be waived in connection with an investigation being conducted by the Public Prosecutor's Office attached to the Brussels Court of Appeal.
Pursuant to Rule 9(1), the request had been referred to the committee responsible, in this case the JURI Committee.
7.   Composition of political groups
Teuvo Hakkarainen was no longer a member of the ID Group and had joined the ECR Group as of 6 April 2023.
8.   Composition of committees and delegations
The S&D and ID groups had notified the President of the following decisions changing the composition of the committees and delegations:






—


DEVE Committee: Mercedes Bresso










—


ENVI Committee: Maria Veronica Rossi










—


FEMM Committee: Maria Veronica Rossi










—


SANT Subcommittee: Maria Veronica Rossi










—


Special Committee on foreign interference in all democratic processes in the European Union, including disinformation, and the strengthening of integrity, transparency and accountability in the European Parliament: Mercedes Bresso










—


Delegation for relations with the Arab Peninsula: Niels Fuglsang










—


Delegation to the EU-North Macedonia Joint Parliamentary Committee: Maria Veronica Rossi










—


Delegation to the EU-Türkiye Joint Parliamentary Committee: Mercedes Bresso










—


Delegation to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Union for the Mediterranean: Mercedes Bresso
The decisions took effect as of that day.




9.   Interpretation of Rules of Procedure (action taken)

The interpretation of Rule 9(6) provided by the AFCO Committee had been announced in plenary on 29 March 2023
                  (minutes of 29.3.2023, item 9).
As it had not been contested by a political group or at least the threshold number of Members established in Rule 236(4), this interpretation was deemed to have been adopted (P9_TA(2023)0095).
10.   Negotiations ahead of Parliament's first reading (Rule 71) (action taken)

The decisions of the JURI and AGRI committees to enter into interinstitutional negotiations had been announced on 29 March 2023
                  (minutes of 29.3.2023, item 8).
Since no requests for vote pursuant to Rule 71(2) had been received, the committees responsible had been able to begin negotiations upon expiry of the deadline set.
11.   Negotiations ahead of Parliament's first reading (Rule 71)

The committees responsible had decided to enter into interinstitutional negotiations pursuant to Rule 71 on the basis of the following reports:






—


LIBE Committee — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council addressing situations of crisis and force majeure in the field of migration and asylum (COM(2020)0613 — C9-0308/2020 — 2020/0277(COD)) — Rapporteur: Juan Fernando López Aguilar (A9-0127/2023);










—


LIBE Committee — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council introducing a screening of third country nationals at the external borders and amending Regulations (EC) No 767/2008, (EU) 2017/2226, (EU) 2018/1240 and (EU) 2019/817 (COM(2020)0612 — C9-0307/2020 — 2020/0278(COD)) — Rapporteur: Birgit Sippel (A9-0149/2023);










—


LIBE Committee — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on asylum and migration management and amending Council Directive 2003/109/EC and the proposed Regulation (EU) XXX/XXX [Asylum and Migration Fund] (COM(2020)0610 — C9-0309/2020 — 2020/0279(COD)) — Rapporteur: Tomas Tobé (A9-0152/2023);










—


LIBE Committee — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2019/816 establishing a centralised system for the identification of Member States holding conviction information on third-country nationals and stateless persons (ECRIS-TCN) to supplement the European Criminal Records Information System and Regulation (EU) 2019/818 on establishing a framework for interoperability between EU information systems in the field of police and judicial cooperation, asylum and migration and amending Regulations (EU) 2018/1726, (EU) 2018/1862 and (EU) 2019/816 for the purpose of introducing a screening of third country nationals at the external borders (COM(2021)0096 — C9-0088/2021 — 2021/0046(COD)) — Rapporteur: Birgit Sippel (A9-0148/2023);










—


ECON, LIBE committees — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the prevention of the use of the financial system for the purposes of money laundering or terrorist financing (COM(2021)0420 — C9-0339/2021 — 2021/0239(COD)) — Rapporteurs: Eero Heinäluoma, Damien Carême (A9-0151/2023);










—


ECON, LIBE committees — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing the Authority for Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism and amending Regulations (EU) No 1093/2010, (EU) 1094/2010, (EU) 1095/2010 (COM(2021)0421 — C9-0340/2021 — 2021/0240(COD)) — Rapporteurs: Eva Maria Poptcheva, Emil Radev (A9-0128/2023);










—


ECON, LIBE committees — Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the mechanisms to be put in place by the Member States for the prevention of the use of the financial system for the purposes of money laundering or terrorist financing and repealing Directive (EU) 2015/849 (COM(2021)0423 — C9-0342/2021 — 2021/0250(COD)) — Rapporteurs: Luděk Niedermayer, Paul Tang (A9-0150/2023);










—


TRAN Committee — Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Union guidelines for the development of the trans-European transport network, amending Regulation (EU) 2021/1153 and Regulation (EU) No 913/2010 and repealing Regulation (EU) 1315/2013 (COM(2021)0812 — C9-0472/2021 — 2021/0420(COD)) — Rapporteurs: Barbara Thaler, Dominique Riquet (A9-0147/2023);










—


LIBE Committee — Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on a single application procedure for a single permit for third-country nationals to reside and work in the territory of a Member State and on a common set of rights for third-country workers legally residing in a Member State (recast) (COM(2022)0655 — C9-0163/2022 — 2022/0131(COD)) — Rapporteur: Javier Moreno Sánchez (A9-0140/2023);










—


LIBE Committee — Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council concerning the status of third-country nationals who are long-term residents (recast) (COM(2022)0650 — C9-0162/2022 — 2022/0134(COD)) — Rapporteur: Damian Boeselager (A9-0145/2023);










—


IMCO Committee — Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2011/83/EU concerning financial services contracts concluded at a distance and repealing Directive 2002/65/EC (COM(2022)0204 — C9-0175/2022 — 2022/0147(COD)) — Rapporteur: Arba Kokalari (A9-0097/2023).




In accordance with Rule 71(2), requests for the decisions to be put to the vote could be submitted until midnight the following day, 18 April 2023.
Negotiations could start at any time after the expiry of that deadline if no request for a vote on the decisions to enter into negotiations had been made.
12.   Signing of acts adopted in accordance with the ordinary legislative procedure (Rule 79)

On 19 April 2023, the President of Parliament, together with the President of the Council, would sign the following acts adopted under the ordinary legislative procedure:






—


Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2019/631 as regards strengthening the CO2 emission performance standards for new passenger cars and new light commercial vehicles in line with the Union's increased climate ambition (00066/2022/LEX — C9-0131/2023 — 2021/0197(COD));










—


Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2018/841 as regards the scope, simplifying the reporting and compliance rules, and setting out the targets of the Member States for 2030, and Regulation (EU) 2018/1999 as regards improvement in monitoring, reporting, tracking of progress and review (00075/2022/LEX — C9-0125/2023 — 2021/0201(COD));










—


Decision of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Decision (EU) 2015/1814 as regards the number of allowances to be placed in the market stability reserve for the Union greenhouse gas emission trading system until 2030 (00005/2023/LEX — C9-0124/2023 — 2021/0202(COD));










—


Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2018/1806 listing the third countries whose nationals must be in possession of visas when crossing the external borders and those whose nationals are exempt from that requirement (Kosovo) (00013/2023/LEX — C9-0123/2023 — 2016/0139(COD));










—


Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2018/842 on binding annual greenhouse gas emission reductions by Member States from 2021 to 2030 contributing to climate action to meet commitments under the Paris Agreement, and Regulation (EU) 2018/1999 (00072/2022/LEX — C9-0122/2023 — 2021/0200(COD)).




13.   Order of business
The final draft agenda for the plenary sittings of April 2023 (PE 746.423/PDOJ) had been made available to Members in accordance with Rule 157(3).

Proposed changes to the final draft agenda pursuant to Rule 158(1)

With the agreement of the political groups:

Monday

The sitting was extended until 23.00.

Tuesday

The vote on the report by Biljana Borzan on ‘empowering consumers for the green transition’ (A9-0099/2023) (item 74 on the final draft agenda) was postponed to the May 2023 part-session.
The statement by the Vice-President of the Commission / High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy on the situation in Peru (item 49 on the final draft agenda) was moved to the third item in the afternoon, after Question Time with the Commission (item 64 on the final draft agenda).

Wednesday

The item on ‘Iran, the case of Bernard Phelan and the case of Toomaj Salehi’
                  (item 81 on the final draft agenda) that had been scheduled for the debates on cases of breaches of human rights, democracy and the rule of law (Rule 144) was removed from the draft agenda.
The House agreed to the proposals.
Other proposed changes:

Tuesday

The PPE Group had requested that the Council and Commission statements on ‘the need for EU solidarity towards Italy facing an emergency situation due to the increased flows of migrants’ be added as the second item in the morning after the key debate (item 61 on the final draft agenda).

The following spoke: Manfred Weber, on behalf of the PPE Group, who moved the request.
The S&D, Verts/ALE and The Left groups requested that the Council and Commission statement on ‘the need for European solidarity in saving lives in the Mediterranean, in particular in Italy’ be added to the agenda, after the debate on the ‘Guidelines for the 2024 budget — Section III’
                  (item 31 on the final draft agenda). The sitting would be extended until 23.00 as a result.
The following spoke: Iratxe García Pérez, on behalf of the S&D Group, who moved the request, Stéphane Séjourné, against both requests, and Manfred Weber, on behalf of the PPE Group, against the request made by the S&D, Verts/ALE and The Left groups.
In a roll-call vote (151 in favour, 227 against, 5 abstentions), Parliament rejected the PPE Group's request.
In a roll-call vote (252 in favour, 119 against, 13 abstentions), Parliament approved the request made by the S&D, Verts/ALE and The Left groups.
The Council and Commission statements on ‘the need for European solidarity in saving lives in the Mediterranean, in particular in Italy’ were therefore added as the fourth item in the afternoon, after the debate on the ‘Guidelines for the 2024 budget — Section III’
                  (item 31 on the final draft agenda) and the sitting was extended until 23.00.
The ECR Group requested that an oral question on ‘unjustified interference by the Commission in the chosen nature policy of a Member State’ be added to the agenda for the afternoon, after the debate on the ‘Guidelines for the 2024 budget — Section III’
                  (item 31 on the final draft agenda).
The following spoke: Bert-Jan Ruissen, on behalf of the ECR Group, who moved the request.
The PPE Group requested that a Commission statement on ‘unjustified interference by the Commission in the chosen nature policy of a Member State and the impact of the proposal for a regulation on nature restoration with regard to food and energy security’ be added to the agenda.
The following spoke: Christine Schneider, on behalf of the PPE Group, who moved the request, Anja Hazekamp, against both requests, and Bert-Jan Ruissen, who accepted the PPE Group's request.
Parliament rejected the request by roll-call vote (171 in favour, 206 against, 8 abstentions).

Wednesday

The PPE Group requested that the debate on ‘Repression in Russia, in particular the cases of Vladimir Kara-Murza and Alexei Navalny’ be added as the second item in the debates on cases of breaches of human rights, democracy and the rule of law (Rule 144).
The following spoke: Michael Gahler, on behalf of the PPE Group, who moved the request, and Bernard Guetta.
Parliament approved the request by electronic vote (352 in favour, 2 against, 13 abstentions).
The following tabling deadlines were set:






—


Motions for resolutions: Tuesday, 18 April 2023 at 12.00;










—


Amendments to motions for resolutions, and joint motions for resolutions: Wednesday, 19 April 2023 at 13.00;










—


Amendments to joint motions for resolutions: Wednesday, 19 April 2023 at 14.00.




The order of business was thus established.
IN THE CHAIR: Othmar KARAS

Vice-President

14.   Deforestation Regulation ***I(debate)

Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the making available on the Union market as well as export from the Union of certain commodities and products associated with deforestation and forest degradation and repealing Regulation (EU) No 995/2010 [COM(2021)0706 — C9-0430/2021 — 2021/0366(COD)] — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteur: Christophe Hansen (A9-0219/2022)
An initial debate had taken place on 12 September 2022
                  (minutes of 12.9.2022, item 15).
An initial vote had been held on 13 September 2022 and the matter had been referred back to the committee responsible for interinstitutional negotiations under Rule 59(4) (minutes of 13.9.2022, item 15).
Christophe Hansen introduced the report.
The following spoke: Karin Karlsbro (rapporteur for the opinion of the INTA Committee) and Anna Cavazzini (rapporteur for the opinion of the IMCO Committee).
The following spoke: Stella Kyriakides (Member of the Commission).
The following spoke: Hildegard Bentele (rapporteur for the opinion of the DEVE Committee), Petri Sarvamaa (rapporteur for the opinion of the AGRI Committee), Alexander Bernhuber, on behalf of the PPE Group, Delara Burkhardt, on behalf of the S&D Group, Nils Torvalds, on behalf of the Renew Group, Pär Holmgren, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, Beata Mazurek, on behalf of the ECR Group, Matteo Adinolfi, on behalf of the ID Group, Anja Hazekamp, on behalf of The Left Group, Maria Angela Danzì, non-attached Member, Liudas Mažylis, Kathleen Van Brempt, Pascal Canfin, Marie Toussaint, who also responded to a blue-card speech by Bogdan Rzońca, Mathilde Androuët, João Pimenta Lopes and Elsi Katainen, who also responded to a blue-card speech by Miapetra Kumpula-Natri.
The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Eugen Tomac, Katarína Roth Neveďalová, Michaela Šojdrová, Mauri Pekkarinen, Stanislav Polčák and Ljudmila Novak.
The following spoke: Stella Kyriakides and Christophe Hansen.
The debate closed.
Vote: minutes of 19.4.2023, item 11.3.
15.   Revision of the EU Emissions Trading System ***I — Monitoring, reporting and verification of greenhouse gas emissions from maritime transport ***I — Carbon border adjustment mechanism ***I — Social Climate Fund ***I — Revision of the EU Emissions Trading System for aviation ***I(debate)

Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2003/87/EC establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Union, Decision (EU) 2015/1814 concerning the establishment and operation of a market stability reserve for the Union greenhouse gas emission trading scheme and Regulation (EU) 2015/757 [COM(2021)0551 — C9-0318/2021 — 2021/0211A(COD)] — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteur: Peter Liese (A9-0162/2022)
An initial debate had taken place on 7 June 2022
                  (minutes of 7.6.2022, item 2).
An initial vote had been held on 8 June 2022 and the matter had been referred back to the committee responsible for reconsideration under Rule 59(4) (minutes of 8.6.2022, item 10.4).
A second vote had been held on 22 June 2022 and the matter had been referred back to the committee responsible for interinstitutional negotiations under Rule 59(4) (minutes of 22.6.2022, item 13.1).
Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2003/87/EC establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Union, Decision (EU) 2015/1814 concerning the establishment and operation of a market stability reserve for the Union greenhouse gas emission trading scheme and Regulation (EU) 2015/757 [COM(2021)0551 — C9-0046/2023 — 2021/0211B(COD)] — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteur: Peter Liese (A9-0134/2023)
Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a carbon border adjustment mechanism [COM(2021)0564 — C9-0328/2021 — 2021/0214(COD)] — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteur: Mohammed Chahim (A9-0160/2022)
An initial debate had taken place on 7 June 2022
                  (minutes of 7.6.2022, item 2).
Before it was put to the vote on 8 June 2022, the report had been referred back to committee under Rule 198 (minutes of 8.6.2022, item 10.6).
An initial vote had been held on 22 June 2022 and the matter had been referred back to the committee responsible for interinstitutional negotiations under Rule 59(4) (minutes of 22.6.2022, item 13.3).
Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a Social Climate Fund [COM(2021)0568 — C9-0324/2021 — 2021/0206(COD)] — Committee on Employment and Social Affairs — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteurs: David Casa and Esther de Lange (A9-0157/2022)
An initial debate had taken place on 7 June 2022
                  (minutes of 7.6.2022, item 2).
The vote on the Commission proposal had been adjourned under Rule 200(4) on 8 June 2022
                  (minutes of 8.6.2022, item 10.5).
The vote on the Commission proposal had been held on 22 June 2022 and the matter had been referred back to the committee responsible for interinstitutional negotiations under Rule 59(4) (minutes of 22.6.2022, item 13.2).
Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2003/87/EC as regards aviation's contribution to the Union's economy-wide emission reduction target and appropriately implementing a global market-based measure [COM(2021)0552 — C9-0319/2021 — 2021/0207(COD)] — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteur: Sunčana Glavak (A9-0155/2022)
An initial debate had taken place on 7 June 2022
                  (minutes of 7.6.2022, item 2).
An initial vote had been held on 8 June 2022 and the matter had been referred back to the committee responsible for interinstitutional negotiations under Rule 59(4) (minutes of 8.6.2022, item 10.7).
Peter Liese and Mohammed Chahim introduced reports A9-0162/2022, A9-0134/2023 and A9-0160/2022.
IN THE CHAIR: Michal ŠIMEČKA

Vice-President

David Casa, Esther de Lange and Sunčana Glavak introduced reports A9-0157/2022 and A9-0155/2022.
The following spoke: José Manuel Fernandes (rapporteur for the opinion of the BUDG Committee), Valérie Hayer (rapporteur for the opinion of the BUDG Committee), Margarida Marques (rapporteur for the opinion of the BUDG Committee), Mauri Pekkarinen (rapporteur for the opinion of the ITRE Committee) and Izabela-Helena Kloc (rapporteur for the opinion of the ITRE Committee).
The following spoke: Paolo Gentiloni (Member of the Commission).
The following spoke: Evin Incir (rapporteur for the opinion of the DEVE Committee), Damien Carême (rapporteur for the opinion of the ECON Committee), Henrike Hahn (rapporteur for the opinion of the ECON Committee), Beata Szydło (rapporteur for the opinion of the ITRE Committee), Andrey Novakov (rapporteur for the opinion of the TRAN Committee), Leila Chaibi (rapporteur for the opinion of the TRAN Committee) (the President reminded the House of the rules on conduct), Jan-Christoph Oetjen (rapporteur for the opinion of the TRAN Committee), Tom Berendsen (rapporteur for the opinion of the REGI Committee), Zbigniew Kuźmiuk (rapporteur for the opinion of the AGRI Committee), Jerzy Buzek, on behalf of the PPE Group, Tiemo Wölken, on behalf of the S&D Group, Michael Bloss, on behalf of the Verts/ALE Group, Alexandr Vondra, on behalf of the ECR Group, who also responded to a blue-card speech by Peter Liese, Danilo Oscar Lancini, on behalf of the ID Group, Silvia Modig, on behalf of The Left Group, Edina Tóth, non-attached Member, Jessica Polfjärd, Milan Brglez, Emma Wiesner, Jutta Paulus, Robert Roos, Catherine Griset, Malin Björk, Lefteris Nikolaou-Alavanos, Maria Spyraki, Heléne Fritzon, Marie-Pierre Vedrenne, Manuela Ripa, Johan Van Overtveldt, Dominique Bilde, Petros Kokkalis, Enikő Győri, Massimiliano Salini, Javi López, Ondřej Knotek, Sara Matthieu, Johan Nissinen, Gunnar Beck, Maria Angela Danzì, Gheorghe Falcă, who also declined to take a blue-card speech from Eugen Tomac, Miapetra Kumpula-Natri, Claudia Gamon, Katrin Langensiepen, Zdzisław Krasnodębski, Roman Haider, Agnès Evren, Achille Variati, Klemen Grošelj, Bas Eickhout, Bert-Jan Ruissen, Ivan David, Angelika Niebler, Cyrus Engerer, José Ramón Bauzá Díaz, Marie Toussaint, Sara Skyttedal, Marek Paweł Balt, Dragoș Pîslaru, Henna Virkkunen, Günther Sidl, Pernille Weiss, Daniela Rondinelli, François-Xavier Bellamy, Petar Vitanov, Tomislav Sokol and Gabriel Mato.
The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Franc Bogovič, Barry Andrews, Nicolae Ștefănuță, Beata Mazurek and Mick Wallace.
IN THE CHAIR: Marc ANGEL

Vice-President

The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Stanislav Polčák, João Pimenta Lopes and Clare Daly.
The following spoke: Dubravka Šuica (Vice-President of the Commission), Peter Liese, Mohammed Chahim, David Casa, Esther de Lange and Sunčana Glavak.
The debate closed.
Vote: minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.3, minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.4, minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.5, minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.6 and minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.7.
16.   Composition of committees and delegations
The Renew Group had notified the President of the following decision changing the composition of the committees and delegations:






—


IMCO Committee: Vlad-Marius Botoș to replace Marco Zullo
The decision took effect as of that day.




17.   Institutional relations between the EU and the Council of Europe (short presentation)

Report on the institutional relations between the EU and the Council of Europe [2022/2137(INI)] — Committee on Constitutional Affairs. Rapporteur: Loránt Vincze (A9-0056/2023)
Loránt Vincze made the presentation.
The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Alexander Bernhuber, Mick Wallace, Clare Daly and François Alfonsi.
The following spoke: Dubravka Šuica (Vice-President of the Commission).
The item closed.
Vote: minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.8.
18.   Sustainable carbon cycles (short presentation)

Report on sustainable carbon cycles [2022/2053(INI)] — Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. Rapporteur: Alexander Bernhuber (A9-0066/2023)
Alexander Bernhuber made the presentation.
The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Stanislav Polčák, Clare Daly and Mick Wallace.
The following spoke: Dubravka Šuica (Vice-President of the Commission).
The item closed.
Vote: minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.9.
19.   eGovernment accelerating digital public services that support the functioning of the single market (short presentation)

eGovernment accelerating digital public services that support the functioning of the single market [2022/2036(INI)] — Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection. Rapporteur: Tomislav Sokol (A9-0065/2023)
Tomislav Sokol made the presentation.
The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Alexander Bernhuber.
The following spoke: Dubravka Šuica (Vice-President of the Commission).
The item closed.
Vote: minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.10.
20.   The implementation of civilian CSDP and other EU civilian security assistance (short presentation)

Report on the implementation of civilian CSDP and other EU civilian security assistance [2022/2196(INI)] — Committee on Foreign Affairs. Rapporteur: Alviina Alametsä (A9-0091/2023)
Alviina Alametsä made the presentation.
The following spoke under the catch-the-eye procedure: Alexander Bernhuber, Clare Daly and Mick Wallace.
The following spoke: Dubravka Šuica (Vice-President of the Commission).
The item closed.
Vote: minutes of 18.4.2023, item 4.11.
21.   One-minute speeches on matters of political importance
In accordance with Rule 172, the following Members who wished to draw Parliament's attention to matters of political importance spoke for one minute:
Stanislav Polčák, Katarína Roth Neveďalová, Georgios Kyrtsos, Cristian Terheș, Gianantonio Da Re, Clare Daly, Dino Giarrusso, Peter Pollák, Ivo Hristov, Vlad-Marius Botoș, Johan Nissinen, Patricia Chagnon, Mick Wallace, Lívia Járóka, Eugen Tomac, Victor Negrescu, Izaskun Bilbao Barandica, Charlie Weimers, Thierry Mariani, Younous Omarjee, Michaela Šojdrová, Elena Yoncheva, Michiel Hoogeveen, Gunnar Beck, Sandra Pereira and João Pimenta Lopes.
22.   Agenda of the next sitting
The agenda of the next day's sitting had been established (‘Agenda’
                  PE 746.423/OJ).
23.   Approval of the minutes of the sitting
In accordance with Rule 202(3), the minutes of the sitting would be put to the House for approval at the beginning of the afternoon of the next sitting.
24.   Closure of the sitting
The sitting closed at 22.51.



Alessandro Chiocchetti

Secretary-General



Katarina Barley

Vice-President










            17 April 2023


1.   Questions for oral answer (submission)

The following question for oral answer with debate had been placed on the agenda (Rule 136):






—


O-000016/2023 by Younous Omarjee, on behalf of the REGI Committee, to the Commission: Cohesion dimension of EU State aid and de minimis rules (B9-0016/2023).




2.   Documents received
The following documents had been received:






1)


from other institutions






—


Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on driving licences, amending Directive (EU) 2022/2561 of the European Parliament and of the Council, Regulation (EU) 2018/1724 of the European Parliament and of the Council and repealing Directive 2006/126/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council and Commission Regulation (EU) No 383/2012 (COM(2023)0127 — C9-0035/2023 — 2023/0053(COD))
In accordance with Rules 145(1) and 146(1), the President would consult the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on this proposal.
referred to responsible: TRAN opinion: IMCO, LIBE










—


Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Union-wide effect of certain driving disqualifications (COM(2023)0128 — C9-0036/2023 — 2023/0055(COD))
In accordance with Rules 145(1) and 146(1), the President would consult the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on this proposal.
referred to responsible: TRAN opinion: JURI, LIBE










—


Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on common rules promoting the repair of goods and amending Regulation (EU) 2017/2394, Directives (EU) 2019/771 and (EU) 2020/1828 (COM(2023)0155 — C9-0117/2023 — 2023/0083(COD))
In accordance with Rule 145(1), the President would consult the European Economic and Social Committee on this proposal.
referred to responsible: IMCO opinion: ENVI, JURI










—


Council Decision on the conclusion, on behalf of the Union, of the Agreement between the European Union and Japan on certain provisions of agreements between Member States of the European Union and Japan for air services (07028/2023 — C9-0119/2023 — 2022/0419(NLE))
referred to responsible: TRAN










—


Proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the approval and market surveillance of non-road mobile machinery circulating on public roads and amending Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 (COM(2023)0178 — C9-0120/2023 — 2023/0090(COD))
In accordance with Rule 145(1), the President would consult the European Economic and Social Committee on this proposal.
referred to responsible: IMCO opinion: ENVI










—


Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directives 2009/102/EC and (EU) 2017/1132 as regards further expanding and upgrading the use of digital tools and processes in company law (COM(2023)0177 — C9-0121/2023 — 2023/0089(COD))
In accordance with Rule 145(1), the President would consult the European Economic and Social Committee on this proposal.
referred to responsible: JURI opinion: IMCO










—


Partial renewal of Members of the Court of Auditors — HU nominee (07926/2023 — C9-0126/2023 — 2023/0803(NLE))
referred to responsible: CONT










—


Council Decision amending Decision (EU) 2019/1754 on the accession of the European Union to the Geneva Act of the Lisbon Agreement on Appellations of Origin and Geographical Indications (07423/2023 — C9-0127/2023 — 2023/0022(NLE))
referred to responsible: JURI opinion: INTA, ENVI, AGRI










—


Proposal for a decision of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Decision No 1313/2013/EU on a Union Civil Protection Mechanism (COM(2023)0194 — C9-0132/2023 — 2023/0095(COD))
referred to responsible: ENVI opinion: AFET, DEVE, BUDG, REGI














2)


from committees






2.1)


reports






—


***I Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on common rules for the internal markets in renewable and natural gases and in hydrogen (recast) (COM(2021)0803 — C9-0468/2021 — 2021/0425(COD)) — ITRE Committee — Rapporteur: Jens Geier (A9-0035/2023)










—


* Report on the proposal for a Council regulation on the methods and procedure for making available own resources based on the Emissions Trading System, the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism and reallocated profits and on the measures to meet cash requirements (COM(2022)0101 — C9-0131/2022 — 2022/0071(NLE)) — BUDG Committee — Rapporteurs: José Manuel Fernandes, Valérie Hayer (A9-0046/2023)










—


***I Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on geographical indication protection for craft and industrial products and amending Regulations (EU) 2017/1001 and (EU) 2019/1753 of the European Parliament and of the Council and Council Decision (EU) 2019/1754 (COM(2022)0174 — C9-0148/2022 — 2022/0115(COD)) — JURI Committee — Rapporteur: Marion Walsmann (A9-0049/2023)










—


Report on the institutional relations between the EU and the Council of Europe (2022/2137(INI)) — AFCO Committee — Rapporteur: Loránt Vincze (A9-0056/2023)










—


***I Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council laying down measures for a high common level of cybersecurity at the institutions, bodies, offices and agencies of the Union (COM(2022)0122 — C9-0122/2022 — 2022/0085(COD)) — ITRE Committee — Rapporteur: Henna Virkkunen (A9-0064/2023)










—


eGovernment accelerating digital public services that support the functioning of the single market (2022/2036(INI)) — IMCO Committee — Rapporteur: Tomislav Sokol (A9-0065/2023)










—


Report on sustainable carbon cycles (2022/2053(INI)) — ENVI Committee — Rapporteur: Alexander Bernhuber (A9-0066/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the general budget of the European Union for the financial year 2021, Section VIII — European Ombudsman (COM(2022)0323[[08]] — C9-0234/2022 — 2022/2088(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Mikuláš Peksa (A9-0067/2023)










—


*** Recommendation on the draft Council decision on the conclusion, on behalf of the European Union, of the Protocol amending the Marrakesh Agreement establishing the World Trade Organization, as regards the Agreement on fisheries subsidies (14557/2022 — C9-0404/2022 — 2022/0364(NLE)) — INTA Committee — Rapporteur: Bernd Lange (A9-0068/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Innovative Health Initiative Joint Undertaking (before 30.11.2021 the Innovative Medicines Initiative 2 Joint Undertaking) for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[51]] — C9-0277/2022 — 2022/2131(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Ryszard Czarnecki (A9-0069/2023)










—


Report on amendments to Parliament's Rules of Procedure concerning question time, the central rostrum, the blue-card procedure, the explanations of votes, the transparency register and the Ombudsman (2023/2014(REG)) — AFCO Committee — Rapporteur: Gabriele Bischoff (A9-0072/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the general budget of the European Union for the financial year 2021, Section IV — Court of Justice of the European Union (COM(2022)0323[[04]] — C9-0230/2022 — 2022/2084(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Mikuláš Peksa (A9-0073/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the general budget of the European Union for the financial year 2021, Section VI — European Economic and Social Committee (COM(2022)0323[[06]] — C9-0232/2022 — 2022/2086(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Mikuláš Peksa (A9-0074/2023)










—


***I Report on the proposal for a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Council Regulation (EC) No 1217/2009 as regards conversion of the Farm Accountancy Data Network into a Farm Sustainability Data Network (COM(2022)0296 — C9-0206/2022 — 2022/0192(COD)) — AGRI Committee — Rapporteur: Jérémy Decerle (A9-0075/2023)










—


Report on EU Rapid Deployment Capacity, EU Battlegroups and Article 44 TEU: the way forward (2022/2145(INI)) — AFET Committee — Rapporteur: Javi López (A9-0077/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Clean Aviation Joint Undertaking (before 30.11.2021 the Clean Sky 2 Joint Undertaking) for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[46]] — C9-0272/2022 — 2022/2126(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Joachim Stanisław Brudziński (A9-0078/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the European Public Prosecutor's Office for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[11]] — C9-0237/2022 — 2022/2091(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Mikuláš Peksa (A9-0079/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Key Digital Technologies Joint Undertaking (before 30.11.2021 the ECSEL Joint Undertaking) for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[47]] — C9-0273/2022 — 2022/2127(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Ryszard Czarnecki (A9-0082/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Clean Hydrogen Joint Undertaking (before 30.11.2021 the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking) for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[50]] — C9-0276/2022 — 2022/2130(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Ryszard Czarnecki (A9-0083/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the general budget of the European Union for the financial year 2021, Section II — European Council and Council (COM(2022)0323[[03]] — C9-0229/2022 — 2022/2083(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Mikuláš Peksa (A9-0085/2023)










—


***I Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of the environment through criminal law and replacing Directive 2008/99/EC (COM(2021)0851 — C9-0466/2021 — 2021/0422(COD)) — JURI Committee — Rapporteur: Antonius Manders (A9-0087/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the European High Performance Computing Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[48]] — C9-0274/2022 — 2022/2128(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Ryszard Czarnecki (A9-0089/2023)










—


Report on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Europe's Rail Joint Undertaking (before 30.11.2021 the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking) for the financial year 2021 (COM(2022)0323[[53]] — C9-0279/2022 — 2022/2133(DEC)) — CONT Committee — Rapporteur: Ryszard Czarnecki (A9-0090/2023)










—


Report on the implementation of civilian CSDP and other EU civilian security assistance (2022/2196(INI)) — AFET Committee — Rapporteur: Alviina Alametsä (A9-0091/2023)










—


Report on the role of cohesion policy in addressing multidimensional environmental challenges in the Mediterranean basin (2022/2059(INI)) — REGI Committee — Rapporteur: François Alfonsi (A9-0094/2023)










—


Report on general guidelines for the preparation of the 2024 budget, Section III — Commission (2022/2184(BUI)) — BUDG Committee — Rapporteur: Janusz Lewandowski (A9-0124/2023)










—


***I Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2003/87/EC establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Union, Decision (EU) 2015/1814 concerning the establishment and operation of a market stability reserve for the Union greenhouse gas emission trading scheme and Regulation (EU) 2015/757 (COM(2021)0551[[02]] — C9-0046/2023 — 2021/0211B(COD)) — ENVI Committee — Rapporteur: Peter Liese (A9-0134/2023)










—


***I Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2003/87/EC establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Union, Decision (EU) 2015/1814 concerning the establishment and operation of a market stability reserve for the Union greenhouse gas emission trading scheme and Regulation (EU) 2015/757 (COM(2021)0551[[01]] — C9-0318/2021 — 2021/0211A(COD)) — ENVI Committee — Rapporteur: Peter Liese (A9-0162/2022)














2.2)


recommendations for second reading






—


***II Recommendation for second reading on the Council position at first reading with a view to the adoption of a regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EU) 2018/1806 listing the third countries whose nationals must be in possession of visas when crossing the external borders and those whose nationals are exempt from that requirement (Kosovo) (05103/1/2023 — C9-0047/2023 — 2016/0139(COD)) — LIBE Committee — Rapporteur: Thijs Reuten (A9-0076/2023)



















            17 April 2023


Present:
Adamowicz Magdalena, Ademov Asim, Adinolfi Isabella, Adinolfi Matteo, Agius Saliba Alex, Aguilar Mazaly, Aguilera Clara, Alametsä Alviina, Albuquerque João, Alexandrov Yordanov Alexander, Alfonsi François, Al-Sahlani Abir, Amaro Álvaro, Ameriks Andris, Anderson Christine, Andrews Barry, Andrieu Eric, Androuët Mathilde, Androulakis Nikos, Angel Marc, Annemans Gerolf, Ansip Andrus, Ara-Kovács Attila, Arena Maria, Arias Echeverría Pablo, Arłukowicz Bartosz, Asimakopoulou Anna-Michelle, Aubry Manon, Auštrevičius Petras, Avram Carmen, Azmani Malik, Balt Marek Paweł, Bartolo Pietro, Băsescu Traian, Basso Alessandra, Bauzá Díaz José Ramón, Bay Nicolas, Beck Gunnar, Beer Nicola, Beghin Tiziana, Belka Marek, Bellamy François-Xavier, Benifei Brando, Benjumea Benjumea Isabel, Beňová Monika, Bentele Hildegard, Berendsen Tom, Berg Lars Patrick, Bergkvist Erik, Bernhuber Alexander, Biedroń Robert, Bielan Adam, Bielowski Theresa, Bijoux Stéphane, Bilbao Barandica Izaskun, Bilčík Vladimír, Bilde Dominique, Bischoff Gabriele, Biteau Benoît, Björk Malin, Blaško Hynek, Blinkevičiūtė Vilija, Bloss Michael, Bocskor Andrea, Boeselager Damian, Bogovič Franc, Bonfrisco Anna, Borchia Paolo, Borzan Biljana, Botenga Marc, Botoș Vlad-Marius, Bourgeois Geert, Boyer Gilles, Breyer Patrick, Brglez Milan, Brudziński Joachim Stanisław, Bruna Annika, Buda Daniel, Bullmann Udo, Burkhardt Delara, Bușoi Cristian-Silviu, Buxadé Villalba Jorge, Buzek Jerzy, Campomenosi Marco, Cañas Jordi, Canfin Pascal, Carême Damien, Carvalhais Isabel, Carvalho Maria da Graça, Casa David, Casanova Massimo, Caspary Daniel, Castaldo Fabio Massimo, del Castillo Vera Pilar, Cavazzini Anna, Ceccardi Susanna, Cerdas Sara, Chabaud Catherine, Chagnon Patricia, Chahim Mohammed, Chaibi Leila, Charanzová Dita, Chastel Olivier, Christensen Asger, Cicurel Ilana, Cimoszewicz Włodzimierz, Ciocca Angelo, Cioloș Dacian, Ciuhodaru Tudor, Clune Deirdre, Colin-Oesterlé Nathalie, Collard Gilbert, Comi Lara, Comín i Oliveres Antoni, Conte Rosanna, Cormand David, Corrao Ignazio, Crețu Corina, Cseh Katalin, Cuffe Ciarán, Cutajar Josianne, Czarnecki Ryszard, van Dalen Peter, Dalunde Jakop G., Daly Clare, D'Amato Rosa, Danti Nicola, Danzì Maria Angela, Da Re Gianantonio, Dauchy Marie, David Ivan, De Basso Ilan, De Castro Paolo, Decerle Jérémy, Deli Andor, Delli Karima, De Man Filip, De Meo Salvatore, Demirel Özlem, Deparnay-Grunenberg Anna, Dobrev Klára, Doleschal Christian, Donáth Anna Júlia, Donato Francesca, Dorfmann Herbert, Duda Jarosław, Düpont Lena, Durá Ferrandis Estrella, Durand Pascal, Ďuriš Nicholsonová Lucia, Dzhambazki Angel, Ecke Matthias, Ehler Christian, Eickhout Bas, Engerer Cyrus, Ernst Cornelia, Eroglu Engin, Ertug Ismail, Estaràs Ferragut Rosa, Evren Agnès, Falcă Gheorghe, Farreng Laurence, Ferber Markus, Fernandes José Manuel, Fernández Jonás, Ferrandino Giuseppe, Ferrara Laura, Fest Nicolaus, Fidanza Carlo, Fiocchi Pietro, Fitzgerald Frances, Flanagan Luke Ming, Flego Valter, Fourlas Loucas, Frankowski Tomasz, Franssen Cindy, Franz Romeo, Fritzon Heléne, Fuglsang Niels, Furore Mario, Gahler Michael, Gallée Malte, Gálvez Muñoz Lina, Gamon Claudia, Gancia Gianna, García-Margallo y Marfil José Manuel, García Muñoz Isabel, Gardiazabal Rubial Eider, Garraud Jean-Paul, Gazzini Matteo, Geese Alexandra, Geier Jens, Gemma Chiara, Georgiou Giorgos, Geuking Helmut, Gheorghe Vlad, Ghidoni Paola, Giarrusso Dino, Gieseke Jens, Glavak Sunčana, Glucksmann Raphaël, Goerens Charles, González Mónica Silvana, González Casares Nicolás, González Pons Esteban, Gozi Sandro, Grant Valentino, Gregorová Markéta, Griset Catherine, Groothuis Bart, Grošelj Klemen, Grudler Christophe, Gruffat Claude, Gualmini Elisabetta, Guerreiro Francisco, Guetta Bernard, Guillaume Sylvie, Gusmão José, Gyöngyösi Márton, Győri Enikő, Gyürk András, Hahn Svenja, Hahn Henrike, Haider Roman, Hajšel Robert, Hakkarainen Teuvo, Halicki Andrzej, Hansen Christophe, Häusling Martin, Hautala Heidi, Hayer Valérie, Hazekamp Anja, Heide Hannes, Heinäluoma Eero, Herzberger-Fofana Pierrette, Hetman Krzysztof, Hidvéghi Balázs, Hlaváček Martin, Hohlmeier Monika, Hojsík Martin, Holmgren Pär, Hölvényi György, Homs Ginel Alicia, Hoogeveen Michiel, Hortefeux Brice, Hristov Ivo, Hübner Danuta Maria, Huitema Jan, Ijabs Ivars, Ilčić Ladislav, Incir Evin, in 't Veld Sophia, Jadot Yannick, Jahr Peter, Jakeliūnas Stasys, Jaki Patryk, Jalkh Jean-François, Jamet France, Járóka Lívia, Jerković Romana, Jongerius Agnes, Joron Virginie, Joveva Irena, Juknevičienė Rasa, Jurgiel Krzysztof, Jurzyca Eugen, Juvin Hervé, Kalinowski Jarosław, Kalniete Sandra, Kammerevert Petra, Kanev Radan, Kanko Assita, Karas Othmar, Karleskind Pierre, Karlsbro Karin, Karski Karol, Katainen Elsi, Kelleher Billy, Keller Fabienne, Keller Ska, Kelly Seán, Kempa Beata, Kizilyürek Niyazi, Kloc Izabela-Helena, Knotek Ondřej, Kohut Łukasz, Kokalari Arba, Kokkalis Petros, Kolaja Marcel, Kolakušić Mislav, Konstantinou Athanasios, Kopacz Ewa, Kopcińska Joanna, Körner Moritz, Köster Dietmar, Kountoura Elena, Kovařík Ondřej, Kovatchev Andrey, Krah Maximilian, Krasnodębski Zdzisław, Kruk Elżbieta, Kubilius Andrius, Kuhnke Alice, Kuhs Joachim, Kumpula-Natri Miapetra, Kuźmiuk Zbigniew, Kyrtsos Georgios, Kyuchyuk Ilhan, Lacapelle Jean-Lin, Lagodinsky Sergey, Lancini Danilo Oscar, Lange Bernd, de Lange Esther, Langensiepen Katrin, Larrouturou Pierre, Laureti Camilla, Lebreton Gilles, Lega David, Leitão-Marques Maria-Manuel, Lenaers Jeroen, Lexmann Miriam, Liese Peter, Limmer Sylvia, Lins Norbert, Lizzi Elena, Loiseau Nathalie, Løkkegaard Morten, López Javi, López Aguilar Juan Fernando, López Gil Leopoldo, López-Istúriz White Antonio, Lucke Karsten, Luena César, Łukacijewska Elżbieta Katarzyna, Lundgren Peter, Lutgen Benoît, McAllister David, MacManus Chris, Madison Jaak, Maestre Martín De Almagro Cristina, Maldeikienė Aušra, Maldonado López Adriana, Manders Antonius, Mandl Lukas, Mariani Thierry, Marinescu Marian-Jean, Markey Colm, Marquardt Erik, Marques Margarida, Marques Pedro, Martusciello Fulvio, Matias Marisa, Matić Predrag Fred, Mato Gabriel, Matthieu Sara, Maurel Emmanuel, Maxová Radka, Maydell Eva, Mayer Georg, Mazurek Beata, Mažylis Liudas, Mebarek Nora, Melbārde Dace, Melchior Karen, Melo Nuno, Mesure Marina, Metsola Roberta, Metz Tilly, Meuthen Jörg, Michels Martina, Mihaylova Iskra, Mikser Sven, Milazzo Giuseppe, Millán Mon Francisco José, Miller Leszek, Minardi Eric, Miranda Ana, Mituța Alin, Modig Silvia, Montserrat Dolors, Morano Nadine, Moreno Sánchez Javier, Moretti Alessandra, Mortler Marlene, Możdżanowska Andżelika Anna, Müller Ulrike, Mureșan Siegfried, Mussolini Alessandra, Nagtegaal Caroline, Nart Javier, Negrescu Victor, Nemec Matjaž, Nesci Denis, Neumann Hannah, Nica Dan, Niebler Angelika, Niedermayer Luděk, Nienass Niklas, Nikolaou-Alavanos Lefteris, Nissinen Johan, Noichl Maria, Novak Ljudmila, Novakov Andrey, Oetjen Jan-Christoph, Ohlsson Carina, Olbrycht Jan, Olekas Juozas, Olivier Philippe, Omarjee Younous, Orville Max, O'Sullivan Grace, Paet Urmas, Pagazaurtundúa Maite, Panza Alessandro, Papadakis Kostas, Papadimoulis Dimitrios, Paulus Jutta, Pedicini Piernicola, Pekkarinen Mauri, Peksa Mikuláš, Pelletier Anne-Sophie, Penkova Tsvetelina, Peppucci Francesca, Pereira Sandra, Peter-Hansen Kira Marie, Petersen Morten, Picula Tonino, Pieper Markus, Pignedoli Sabrina, Pimenta Lopes João, Pineda Manu, de la Pisa Carrión Margarita, Pisapia Giuliano, Pîslaru Dragoș, Polčák Stanislav, Polfjärd Jessica, Pollák Peter, Ponsatí Obiols Clara, Poptcheva Eva Maria, Poręba Tomasz Piotr, Puigdemont i Casamajó Carles, Radačovský Miroslav, Radtke Dennis, Rafaela Samira, Rafalska Elżbieta, Rangel Paulo, Rasmussen Bergur Løkke, Regner Evelyn, Rego Sira, Reil Guido, Repasi René, Ressler Karlo, Riba i Giner Diana, Ries Frédérique, Rinaldi Antonio Maria, Rinzema Catharina, Ripa Manuela, Riquet Dominique, Rivasi Michèle, Rivière Jérôme, Roberti Franco, Rodríguez-Piñero Inma, Rodríguez Palop Eugenia, Rodríguez Ramos María Soraya, Rónai Sándor, Rondinelli Daniela, Rooken Rob, Rookmaker Dorien, Roos Robert, Roose Caroline, Ros Sempere Marcos, Rossi Maria Veronica, Roth Neveďalová Katarína, Rougé André, Ruissen Bert-Jan, Ruiz Devesa Domènec, Ruohonen-Lerner Pirkko, Rzońca Bogdan, Salini Massimiliano, Sánchez Amor Nacho, Sander Anne, Sant Alfred, Santos Isabel, Sardone Silvia, Sarvamaa Petri, Saryusz-Wolski Jacek, Satouri Mounir, Schaldemose Christel, Schaller-Baross Ernő, Schieder Andreas, Schmiedtbauer Simone, Schneider Christine, Schuster Joachim, Schwab Andreas, Seekatz Ralf, Semedo Monica, Semsrott Nico, Sidl Günther, Sikorski Radosław, Silva Pereira Pedro, Šimečka Michal, Sinčić Ivan Vilibor, Sippel Birgit, Skyttedal Sara, Smeriglio Massimiliano, Šojdrová Michaela, Sokol Tomislav, Solé Jordi, Solís Pérez Susana, Sonneborn Martin, Spurek Sylwia, Spyraki Maria, Stancanelli Raffaele, Stanishev Sergei, Štefanec Ivan, Ștefănuță Nicolae, Strik Tineke, Strugariu Ramona, Szydło Beata, Tang Paul, Tarczyński Dominik, Tax Vera, Terheș Cristian, Tertsch Hermann, Thaler Barbara, Thun und Hohenstein Róża, Tinagli Irene, Tobé Tomas, Tobiszowski Grzegorz, Toia Patrizia, Tomac Eugen, Tomaszewski Waldemar, Tomc Romana, Toom Yana, Torvalds Nils, Tošenovský Evžen, Tóth Edina, Toussaint Marie, Tovaglieri Isabella, Trillet-Lenoir Véronique, Trócsányi László, Tudorache Dragoș, Uhrík Milan, Ujhelyi István, Urtasun Ernest, Ušakovs Nils, Vaidere Inese, Vana Monika, Van Brempt Kathleen, Vandendriessche Tom, Vandenkendelaere Tom, Van Overtveldt Johan, Van Sparrentak Kim, Variati Achille, Vautmans Hilde, Vedrenne Marie-Pierre, Verheyen Sabine, Verhofstadt Guy, Vilimsky Harald, Villanueva Ruiz Idoia, Villumsen Nikolaj, Vincze Loránt, Vind Marianne, Virkkunen Henna, Vitanov Petar, von Cramon-Taubadel Viola, Vondra Alexandr, Voss Axel, Vrecionová Veronika, Vuolo Lucia, Vázquez Lázara Adrián, Waitz Thomas, Wallace Mick, Walsh Maria, Walsmann Marion, Warborn Jörgen, Waszczykowski Witold Jan, Weimers Charlie, Weiss Pernille, Wiener Sarah, Wiesner Emma, Wiezik Michal, Winkler Iuliu, Winzig Angelika, Wiseler-Lima Isabel, Wiśniewska Jadwiga, Wölken Tiemo, Yenbou Salima, Yoncheva Elena, Zahradil Jan, Zalewska Anna, Zambelli Stefania, Zarzalejos Javier, Ždanoka Tatjana, Zdechovský Tomáš, Zīle Roberts, Zimniok Bernhard, Złotowski Kosma, Zoido Álvarez Juan Ignacio, Zorrinho Carlos, Zovko Željana, Zullo Marco, Zver Milan
Excused:
Berlato Sergio, Bricmont Saskia, Brunet Sylvie, Buschmann Martin, Freund Daniel, Monteiro de Aguiar Cláudia, Ochojska Janina, Tardino Annalisa, Uspaskich Viktor, Yon-Courtin Stéphanie






            17 April 2023




1.   Tuesday's agenda — Request from the PPE Group


In favour: 151




ECR
: Aguilar, Bielan, Bourgeois, Dzhambazki, Fidanza, Hoogeveen, Ilčić, Jaki, Jurgiel, Jurzyca, Kanko, Krasnodębski, Kruk, Kuźmiuk, Legutko, Mazurek, Milazzo, Nesci, de la Pisa Carrión, Rafalska, Rookmaker, Roos, Ruissen, Rzońca, Tarczyński, Van Overtveldt, Weimers, Złotowski


ID
: Adinolfi Matteo, Anderson, Androuët, Annemans, Basso, Bilde, Bruna, Campomenosi, Chagnon, Conte, Da Re, Dauchy, De Man, Garraud, Ghidoni, Griset, Jamet, Joron, Krah, Kuhs, Lacapelle, Lancini, Lizzi, Minardi, Reil, Rossi, Rougé, Vandendriessche, Zanni


NI
: Danzì, Deli, Gyöngyösi, Győri, Hidvéghi, Juvin, Meuthen, Schaller-Baross, Tóth, Trócsányi


PPE
: Adamowicz, Ademov, Amaro, Arias Echeverría, Arłukowicz, Băsescu, Bellamy, Bentele, Berendsen, Bernhuber, Bogovič, Carvalho, Casa, Comi, van Dalen, De Meo, Düpont, Ferber, Fernandes, Frankowski, Franssen, Gahler, Geuking, Gieseke, Halicki, Hansen, Hetman, Hölvényi, Kalniete, Kanev, Kubilius, de Lange, Lenaers, Liese, Lins, Lutgen, Maldeikienė, Manders, Mandl, Markey, Mato, Mažylis, Montserrat, Mortler, Mureșan, Mussolini, Niedermayer, Novak, Olbrycht, Pereira Lídia, Polčák, Pollák, Rangel, Salini, Sander, Sarvamaa, Schmiedtbauer, Schneider, Sikorski, Skyttedal, Šojdrová, Spyraki, Štefanec, Thaler, Tomac, Vandenkendelaere, Verheyen, Vincze, Virkkunen, Voss, Vuolo, Walsmann, Warborn, Weber, Weiss, Winkler, Winzig, Wiseler-Lima, Zarzalejos, Zoido Álvarez, Zovko, Zver


Renew
: Müller


S&D
: Roberti


Against: 227




ID
: Mariani


NI
: Furore, Nikolaou-Alavanos, Papadakis Kostas, Ponsatí Obiols, Puigdemont i Casamajó


Renew
: Al-Sahlani, Andrews, Auštrevičius, Azmani, Bijoux, Bilbao Barandica, Botoș, Boyer, Cañas, Canfin, Chabaud, Charanzová, Chastel, Christensen, Cicurel, Cioloș, Danti, Decerle, Ďuriš Nicholsonová, Eroglu, Farreng, Ferrandino, Flego, Gamon, Gheorghe, Goerens, Gozi, Groothuis, Grošelj, Grudler, Hahn Svenja, Hayer, in 't Veld, Joveva, Karleskind, Karlsbro, Katainen, Keller Fabienne, Knotek, Kovařík, Kyrtsos, Loiseau, Melchior, Mituța, Nagtegaal, Nart, Oetjen, Orville, Pagazaurtundúa, Pekkarinen, Pîslaru, Rafaela, Ries, Rinzema, Riquet, Séjourné, Semedo, Šimečka, Strugariu, Toom, Torvalds, Trillet-Lenoir, Tudorache, Vautmans, Vedrenne, Verhofstadt, Wiesner, Yenbou


S&D
: Agius Saliba, Albuquerque, Angel, Ara-Kovács, Arena, Bartolo, Belka, Benifei, Beňová, Bergkvist, Biedroń, Brglez, Burkhardt, Carvalhais, Cerdas, Chahim, Cimoszewicz, Ciuhodaru, Crețu, Cutajar, De Basso, De Castro, Dobrev, Durand, Ecke, Engerer, Ertug, Fernández, Fritzon, Fuglsang, García Muñoz, García Pérez, Gardiazabal Rubial, Geier, Glucksmann, Gualmini, Guillaume, Hajšel, Heide, Heinäluoma, Homs Ginel, Hristov, Incir, Kammerevert, Kohut, Köster, Lange, Laureti, Leitão-Marques, López, Lucke, Marques Margarida, Marques Pedro, Matić, Mebarek, Miller, Moreno Sánchez, Moretti, Negrescu, Nemec, Noichl, Ohlsson, Regner, Reuten, Rodríguez-Piñero, Rónai, Rondinelli, Ros Sempere, Roth Neveďalová, Ruiz Devesa, Sánchez Amor, Schieder, Schuster, Sidl, Silva Pereira, Sippel, Smeriglio, Ušakovs, Van Brempt, Variati, Vind, Wölken


The Left
: Aubry, Björk, Botenga, Chaibi, Demirel, Ernst, Gusmão, Hazekamp, Kokkalis, Kountoura, MacManus, Matias, Mesure, Michels, Modig, Papadimoulis, Pelletier, Pereira Sandra, Pimenta Lopes, Villumsen


Verts/ALE
: Alfonsi, Auken, Biteau, Bloss, Boeselager, Breyer, Carême, Cavazzini, Cormand, Cuffe, Dalunde, Delbos-Corfield, Delli, Franz, Gallée, Geese, Gregorová, Gruffat, Guerreiro, Hahn Henrike, Hautala, Herzberger-Fofana, Holmgren, Jadot, Keller Ska, Kolaja, Kuhnke, Lagodinsky, Lamberts, Langensiepen, Marquardt, Matthieu, Metz, Miranda, Neumann, Nienass, O'Sullivan, Paulus, Peksa, Peter-Hansen, Reintke, Riba i Giner, Roose, Satouri, Solé, Strik, Urtasun, Vana, Van Sparrentak, Waitz, Wiener


Abstention: 5




ID
: Fest


S&D
: Balt, Schaldemose


Verts/ALE
: Corrao, Pedicini


Corrections to votes and voting intentions





Against

: Roberti
2.   Tuesday's agenda — Request from the S&D, Verts/ALE and The Left groups


In favour: 252




ECR
: Aguilar, Dzhambazki, Ilčić, Kuźmiuk, Legutko, de la Pisa Carrión, Rafalska, Rookmaker, Rzońca, Złotowski


ID
: Mariani


NI
: Danzì, Furore, Gyöngyösi, Nikolaou-Alavanos, Papadakis Kostas, Peppucci


PPE
: Adamowicz, Ademov, Amaro, Arias Echeverría, Arłukowicz, Băsescu, Bentele, Berendsen, Bernhuber, Bogovič, Carvalho, Casa, Comi, van Dalen, De Meo, Düpont, Ferber, Fernandes, Frankowski, Franssen, Gahler, Geuking, Gieseke, Halicki, Hansen, Hetman, Hölvényi, Kalniete, Kanev, Kubilius, de Lange, Lega, Lenaers, Liese, Lins, Maldeikienė, Manders, Mandl, Markey, Mato, Mažylis, Montserrat, Mortler, Mureșan, Mussolini, Niedermayer, Novak, Olbrycht, Pereira Lídia, Polčák, Pollák, Rangel, Salini, Sander, Sarvamaa, Schmiedtbauer, Schneider, Sikorski, Skyttedal, Šojdrová, Spyraki, Štefanec, Thaler, Tomac, Vandenkendelaere, Verheyen, Vincze, Virkkunen, Voss, Vuolo, Walsmann, Warborn, Weber, Weiss, Winzig, Wiseler-Lima, Zoido Álvarez, Zovko


Renew
: Joveva


S&D
: Agius Saliba, Albuquerque, Angel, Ara-Kovács, Arena, Balt, Bartolo, Belka, Benifei, Beňová, Bergkvist, Biedroń, Brglez, Burkhardt, Carvalhais, Cerdas, Chahim, Cimoszewicz, Ciuhodaru, Crețu, Cutajar, De Basso, De Castro, Dobrev, Durand, Ecke, Engerer, Ertug, Fernández, Fritzon, García Muñoz, García Pérez, Gardiazabal Rubial, Geier, Glucksmann, Gualmini, Guillaume, Hajšel, Heide, Heinäluoma, Homs Ginel, Hristov, Incir, Kammerevert, Kohut, Köster, Kumpula-Natri, Lange, Laureti, Leitão-Marques, López, Lucke, Marques Margarida, Marques Pedro, Matić, Mebarek, Miller, Moreno Sánchez, Moretti, Negrescu, Nemec, Noichl, Ohlsson, Regner, Reuten, Roberti, Rodríguez-Piñero, Rónai, Rondinelli, Ros Sempere, Roth Neveďalová, Ruiz Devesa, Sánchez Amor, Schieder, Schuster, Sidl, Silva Pereira, Smeriglio, Ušakovs, Van Brempt, Variati, Vind, Wölken


The Left
: Aubry, Björk, Botenga, Chaibi, Demirel, Ernst, Gusmão, Hazekamp, Kokkalis, Kountoura, MacManus, Matias, Mesure, Michels, Modig, Papadimoulis, Pelletier, Pereira Sandra, Pimenta Lopes, Villumsen


Verts/ALE
: Alfonsi, Auken, Biteau, Bloss, Boeselager, Breyer, Carême, Cavazzini, Cormand, Corrao, Cuffe, Dalunde, Delbos-Corfield, Delli, Franz, Gallée, Geese, Gregorová, Gruffat, Guerreiro, Hahn Henrike, Hautala, Herzberger-Fofana, Holmgren, Jadot, Keller Ska, Kolaja, Kuhnke, Lagodinsky, Lamberts, Langensiepen, Marquardt, Matthieu, Metz, Miranda, Neumann, Nienass, O'Sullivan, Paulus, Pedicini, Peksa, Peter-Hansen, Reintke, Riba i Giner, Roose, Satouri, Solé, Strik, Urtasun, Vana, Van Sparrentak, Waitz, Wiener


Against: 119




ECR
: Bielan, Fidanza, Jaki, Jurgiel, Krasnodębski, Kruk, Mazurek, Milazzo, Nesci, Tarczyński, Van Overtveldt, Weimers


ID
: Adinolfi Matteo, Anderson, Androuët, Annemans, Basso, Bilde, Bonfrisco, Bruna, Campomenosi, Chagnon, Conte, Da Re, Dauchy, De Man, Fest, Garraud, Ghidoni, Griset, Jamet, Joron, Krah, Kuhs, Lacapelle, Lancini, Lizzi, Minardi, Reil, Rossi, Rougé, Vandendriessche, Zanni


NI
: Deli, Győri, Hidvéghi, Juvin, Meuthen, Ponsatí Obiols, Schaller-Baross, Tóth, Trócsányi


PPE
: Winkler, Zver


Renew
: Al-Sahlani, Andrews, Auštrevičius, Azmani, Bijoux, Bilbao Barandica, Botoș, Boyer, Cañas, Canfin, Charanzová, Chastel, Christensen, Cicurel, Cioloș, Danti, Decerle, Ďuriš Nicholsonová, Eroglu, Farreng, Ferrandino, Gamon, Gheorghe, Goerens, Gozi, Groothuis, Grudler, Guetta, Hahn Svenja, Hayer, in 't Veld, Karleskind, Karlsbro, Katainen, Keller Fabienne, Knotek, Kovařík, Kyrtsos, Loiseau, Melchior, Mituța, Nagtegaal, Nart, Oetjen, Orville, Pagazaurtundúa, Pekkarinen, Pîslaru, Rafaela, Ries, Rinzema, Riquet, Séjourné, Semedo, Šimečka, Strugariu, Toom, Torvalds, Trillet-Lenoir, Tudorache, Vautmans, Vedrenne, Verhofstadt, Wiesner, Yenbou


Abstention: 13




ECR
: Bourgeois, Hoogeveen, Jurzyca, Kanko, Roos, Ruissen


PPE
: Lutgen


Renew
: Chabaud, Flego, Grošelj, Müller


S&D
: Fuglsang, Schaldemose


Corrections to votes and voting intentions





Abstention

: Vind
3.   Tuesday's agenda — Request from the ECR and PPE groups


In favour: 171




ECR
: Aguilar, Bielan, Bourgeois, Dzhambazki, Fidanza, Hoogeveen, Ilčić, Jaki, Jurgiel, Jurzyca, Krasnodębski, Kruk, Kuźmiuk, Legutko, Mazurek, Milazzo, Nesci, de la Pisa Carrión, Rafalska, Rookmaker, Roos, Ruissen, Rzońca, Tarczyński, Van Overtveldt, Weimers, Złotowski


ID
: Adinolfi Matteo, Anderson, Androuët, Annemans, Basso, Bilde, Bruna, Campomenosi, Chagnon, Conte, Da Re, Dauchy, De Man, Fest, Garraud, Ghidoni, Griset, Jamet, Joron, Krah, Kuhs, Lacapelle, Lancini, Lizzi, Mariani, Minardi, Reil, Rossi, Rougé, Vandendriessche, Zanni


NI
: Deli, Gyöngyösi, Győri, Hidvéghi, Juvin, Meuthen, Peppucci, Schaller-Baross, Tóth, Trócsányi


PPE
: Adamowicz, Ademov, Amaro, Arias Echeverría, Arłukowicz, Băsescu, Bellamy, Bentele, Berendsen, Bernhuber, Bogovič, Carvalho, Casa, Comi, van Dalen, De Meo, Düpont, Ferber, Fernandes, Frankowski, Franssen, Gahler, Geuking, Gieseke, Halicki, Hansen, Hetman, Hölvényi, Kalniete, Kanev, de Lange, Lega, Lenaers, Lexmann, Liese, Lins, Lutgen, Maldeikienė, Manders, Mandl, Markey, Mato, Mažylis, Montserrat, Mortler, Mureșan, Mussolini, Niedermayer, Novak, Olbrycht, Pereira Lídia, Polčák, Pollák, Rangel, Salini, Sander, Sarvamaa, Schmiedtbauer, Schneider, Sikorski, Skyttedal, Šojdrová, Spyraki, Štefanec, Thaler, Tomac, Vandenkendelaere, Verheyen, Vincze, Virkkunen, Voss, Vuolo, Walsmann, Warborn, Weber, Weiss, Winkler, Winzig, Wiseler-Lima, Zarzalejos, Zdechovský, Zoido Álvarez, Zovko, Zver


Renew
: Azmani, Christensen, Eroglu, Ferrandino, Goerens, Groothuis, Hahn Svenja, Katainen, Knotek, Kovařík, Müller, Nagtegaal, Nart, Oetjen, Orville, Rinzema, Semedo, Vautmans, Wiesner


Against: 206




ID
: Bonfrisco


NI
: Danzì, Furore, Nikolaou-Alavanos, Papadakis Kostas, Ponsatí Obiols, Puigdemont i Casamajó


Renew
: Al-Sahlani, Andrews, Auštrevičius, Bijoux, Bilbao Barandica, Botoș, Boyer, Cañas, Canfin, Chastel, Cicurel, Cioloș, Danti, Ďuriš Nicholsonová, Farreng, Flego, Gamon, Gheorghe, Guetta, Hayer, in 't Veld, Joveva, Karleskind, Karlsbro, Keller Fabienne, Kyrtsos, Loiseau, Melchior, Mituța, Pagazaurtundúa, Pekkarinen, Pîslaru, Rafaela, Ries, Riquet, Šimečka, Strugariu, Toom, Torvalds, Trillet-Lenoir, Tudorache, Vedrenne, Verhofstadt, Yenbou


S&D
: Agius Saliba, Albuquerque, Angel, Ara-Kovács, Arena, Balt, Bartolo, Belka, Benifei, Beňová, Bergkvist, Biedroń, Brglez, Burkhardt, Carvalhais, Cerdas, Chahim, Cimoszewicz, Ciuhodaru, Crețu, Cutajar, De Basso, De Castro, Dobrev, Durand, Ecke, Engerer, Ertug, Fernández, Fritzon, Fuglsang, García Muñoz, García Pérez, Gardiazabal Rubial, Geier, Glucksmann, Gualmini, Guillaume, Hajšel, Heide, Heinäluoma, Homs Ginel, Hristov, Incir, Kammerevert, Kohut, Kumpula-Natri, Lange, Laureti, Leitão-Marques, López, Lucke, Marques Margarida, Marques Pedro, Matić, Mebarek, Miller, Moreno Sánchez, Moretti, Negrescu, Nemec, Noichl, Ohlsson, Regner, Reuten, Roberti, Rodríguez-Piñero, Rónai, Rondinelli, Ros Sempere, Roth Neveďalová, Ruiz Devesa, Sánchez Amor, Schaldemose, Schieder, Schuster, Sidl, Silva Pereira, Sippel, Smeriglio, Ušakovs, Van Brempt, Variati, Vind, Wölken


The Left
: Aubry, Björk, Botenga, Chaibi, Demirel, Ernst, Gusmão, Hazekamp, Kokkalis, Kountoura, Matias, Mesure, Michels, Modig, Papadimoulis, Pelletier, Villumsen


Verts/ALE
: Alfonsi, Auken, Biteau, Bloss, Boeselager, Breyer, Carême, Cavazzini, Cormand, Corrao, Cuffe, Dalunde, Delbos-Corfield, Delli, Franz, Gallée, Geese, Gregorová, Gruffat, Guerreiro, Hahn Henrike, Hautala, Herzberger-Fofana, Holmgren, Jadot, Keller Ska, Kolaja, Kuhnke, Lagodinsky, Lamberts, Langensiepen, Marquardt, Matthieu, Metz, Miranda, Neumann, Nienass, O'Sullivan, Paulus, Pedicini, Peksa, Peter-Hansen, Reintke, Riba i Giner, Roose, Satouri, Solé, Strik, Urtasun, Vana, Van Sparrentak, Waitz, Wiener


Abstention: 8




Renew
: Chabaud, Charanzová, Decerle, Gozi, Grošelj, Grudler, Séjourné


The Left
: MacManus



ELI: 
ISSN 1977-091X (electronic edition)