Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/1185 of 10 February 2023 supplementing Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council by establishing a minimum threshold for greenhouse gas emissions savings of recycled carbon fuels and by specifying a methodology for assessing greenhouse gas emissions savings from renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and from recycled carbon fuels
Date: 2023-02-10
Institutions: Directorate-General for Energy, European Commission
Subjects: air quality, carbon capture and storage, energy saving, fuel, greenhouse gas, motor fuel, recycled product, reduction of gas emissions, renewable energy, substitute fuel




L_2023157EN.01002001.xml










20.6.2023   


EN


Official Journal of the European Union


L 157/20








            COMMISSION DELEGATED REGULATION (EU) 2023/1185
of 10 February 2023
         
supplementing Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council by establishing a minimum threshold for greenhouse gas emissions savings of recycled carbon fuels and by specifying a methodology for assessing greenhouse gas emissions savings from renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and from recycled carbon fuels


THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,

Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,


Having regard to Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 December 2018 on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources (1), and in particular Articles 25(2) and 28(5) thereof,

Whereas:







(1)


Taking into account the need to substantially reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the transport sector and the possibility for each fuel to make significant greenhouse gas emissions savings by applying carbon capture and storage techniques, among other measures, and considering the greenhouse gas saving requirements set for other fuels in Directive (EU) 2018/2001, a minimum greenhouse gas emission saving threshold of 70 % should be set for all types of recycled carbon fuels.












(2)


Clear rules need to be set, based on objective and non-discriminatory criteria, for calculating greenhouse gas emissions savings for renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels and their fossil fuel comparators.












(3)


The greenhouse gas emissions accounting methodology should take into account the full life-cycle emissions from producing renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels and be based on objective and non-discriminatory criteria.












(4)


Credits should not be granted for capturing CO2 which has already been taken into account under other provisions of Union law. Therefore that kind of captured CO2 should not be considered as being avoided when determining the emissions from the inputs’ existing use or fate.












(5)


The origin of carbon used for the production of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels is not relevant for determining emission savings of such fuels in the short term, as currently many carbon sources are available and can be captured while making progress on decarbonisation. In an economy on a trajectory towards climate neutrality by 2050, sources of carbon that can be captured should become scarce in the medium- to long-term, increasingly restricted to CO2 emissions that are hardest to abate. In addition, the continued use of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels that contain carbon from non-sustainable fuel is not compatible with a trajectory towards climate neutrality by 2050 as it would entail the continued use of non-sustainable fuels and their related emissions. Therefore, capturing of emissions from non-sustainable fuels should not be considered as avoiding emissions indefinitely when determining the greenhouse gas emissions savings from the use of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels. Captured emissions from the combustion of non-sustainable fuels for the production of electricity should be considered avoided emissions up to 2035, as most should be abated by that date, while emissions from other uses of non-sustainable fuels should be considered avoided emissions up to 2040, as these emissions will remain longer. These dates will be subject to review in light of the implementation in the sectors covered by Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council (2) of the Union-wide climate target for 2040. The Union-wide climate target for 2040 is to be proposed by the Commission at the latest within six months of the first global stocktake carried out under the Paris Agreement, in accordance with Regulation (EU) 2021/1119 of the European Parliament and of the Council (3). The implementation of the target in Directive 2003/87/EC will further determine the expected scarcity of emissions in each sector.












(6)


Emissions from activities listed in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC, namely from industrial processes or from the combustion of non-sustainable fuels, should be prevented, even if they could be captured and used to produce renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels. These emissions are subject to carbon pricing to incentivise abating the emissions from non-sustainable fuels in the first place. Therefore, where such emissions are not taken into account upstream through an effective carbon pricing, those emissions must be accounted for and should not be considered as being avoided.












(7)


Renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels can be produced in various processes, which may yield a mixture of different types of fuels. The methodology to assess the greenhouse gas emissions savings should therefore be able to derive the actual emission savings from those processes, including processes that yield both renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels.












(8)


To determine the greenhouse gas emissions intensity of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels it is necessary to calculate the share of the energy content of such fuels in the output of a process. For this purpose, the fraction of each type of fuel should be determined by dividing the relevant energy input for the type of fuel in question by the total relevant energy inputs into the process. In case of the production of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin, it is necessary to determine whether the relevant electricity input should be considered as fully renewable. The relevant electricity input should be counted as fully renewable if the provisions under Article 27(3) fifth and sixth subparagraph of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 are fulfilled. Otherwise, the average share of electricity from renewable sources in the country of production, as measured two years before the year in question, should be used to determine the share of renewable energy. In case of the production of recycled carbon fuels, only liquid or solid waste streams of non-renewable origin which are not suitable for material recovery in accordance with Article 4 of Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council (4) and waste processing gas and exhaust gas of non-renewable origin which are produced as an unavoidable and unintentional consequence of the production process in industrial installations can be considered as relevant energy input for the production of recycled carbon fuels.












(9)


The fossil fuel comparator for renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels should be set at 94 gCO2eq/MJ in line with the value set out for biofuels and bioliquids in Directive (EU) 2018/2001.












(10)


The main objective of promoting recycled carbon fuels is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by improving the efficiency of use of eligible feedstock compared to present uses. Given that feedstock that can be used to produce recycled carbon fuels may already have been in use to produce energy, it is appropriate to take the greenhouse gas emissions resulting from the diversion of the use of those rigid inputs from its current use into account when calculating greenhouse gas emissions. The same should apply for rigid inputs obtained from incorporated processes and used to produce renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin.












(11)


If the electricity used to produce renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin is taken from the electricity grid and is not considered as fully renewable, the average carbon intensity of electricity consumed in the Member State where the fuel is produced should be applied, given that that best describes the greenhouse gas intensity of the whole process. Alternatively, electricity taken from the electricity grid that is used in the production process of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels that does not qualify as fully renewable according to Article 27(3) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001, could be attributed greenhouse gas emissions values depending on the number of full load hours the installation producing renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels is operating. If the electricity used to produce renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin is considered fully renewable according to the rules set out in Article 27 of Directive (EU) 2018/2001, a carbon intensity of zero should be applied to this electricity supply,





HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:



Article 1
This Regulation establishes a minimum threshold for greenhouse gas emissions savings of recycled carbon fuels and specifies the methodology to calculate the greenhouse gas emissions savings from renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and from recycled carbon fuels.


Article 2
The greenhouse gas emissions savings from the use of recycled carbon fuels shall be at least 70 %.


Article 3
The greenhouse gas emissions savings from renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and from recycled carbon fuels shall be determined in accordance with the methodology set out in the Annex.


Article 4
This Regulation shall enter into force on the twentieth day following that of its publication in the Official Journal of the European Union.




This Regulation shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in all Member States.
Done at Brussels, 10 February 2023.


For the Commission


The President

Ursula VON DER LEYEN
            





(1)  
            OJ L 328, 21.12.2018, p. 82.

(2)  Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003 establishing a scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Community and amending Council Directive 96/61/EC (OJ L 275, 25.10.2003, p. 32).

(3)  Regulation (EU) 2021/1119 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 June 2021 establishing the framework for achieving climate neutrality and amending Regulations (EC) No 401/2009 and (EU) 2018/1999 (OJ L 243, 9.7.2021, p. 1).

(4)  Directive 2008/98/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 November 2008 on waste and repealing certain Directives (OJ L 312, 22.11.2008, p. 3).




ANNEX

Methodology for determining greenhouse gas emissions savings from renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and from recycled carbon fuels

A.   METHODOLOGY








1.


Greenhouse gas emissions from the production and use of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuels shall be calculated as follows:
E = e i + e p + e td + e u – e ccs

where:







E


=


total emissions from the use of the fuel (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e i



=


e i elastic + e i rigid – e ex-use: emissions from supply of inputs (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e i elastic


=


emissions from elastic inputs (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e i rigid


=


emissions from rigid inputs (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e ex-use


=


emissions from inputs’ existing use or fate (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e p



=


emissions from processing (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e td



=


emissions from transport and distribution (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e u



=


emissions from combusting the fuel in its end-use (gCO2eq/MJ fuel)




e ccs



=


emission savings from carbon capture and geological storage (gCO2eq/MJ fu




Emissions from the manufacture of machinery and equipment shall not be taken into account.
The greenhouse gas emissions intensity of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuels shall be determined by dividing the total emissions of the process covering each element of the formula by the total amount of fuel stemming from the process and shall be expressed in terms of grams of CO2 equivalent per MJ of fuel (gCO2eq/MJ fuel). If a fuel is a mix of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin, recycled carbon fuels and other fuels, all (fuel) types shall be considered to have the same emission intensity.
The exception to this rule is the case of co-processing where renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels are only partially replacing a conventional input in a process.
In such a situation it shall be distinguished in the calculation of the greenhouse gas emissions intensity on a proportional basis of the energetic value of inputs between:






—


the part of the process that is based on the conventional input, and










—


the part of the process that is based on renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels assuming that the process parts are otherwise identical.




An analogous distinction between processes shall be applied where renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels are processed together with biomass.
The greenhouse gas emissions intensity may be calculated as an average for the entire production of fuels occurring during a period of at most one calendar month but may also be calculated for shorter time intervals. Where electricity qualifying as fully renewable according to the methodology set out in Directive (EU) 2018/2001 is used as input that enhances the heating value of the fuel or intermediate products, the time interval shall be in line with the requirements applying for temporal correlation. Where relevant, greenhouse gas emissions intensity values calculated for individual time intervals may then be used to calculate an average greenhouse gas emissions intensity for a period of up to one month, provided that the individual values calculated for each time period meet the minimum savings threshold of 70 %.












2.


Greenhouse gas emission savings from renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or from recycled carbon fuels shall be calculated as follows:
Savings = (E F – E)/E F

where:







E


=


total emissions from the use of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuel of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuel.




E F



=


total emissions from the fossil fuel comparator.




For all renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels, the total emissions from the fossil fuel comparator shall be 94 gCO2eq/MJ.












3.


If the output of a process does not fully qualify as renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuel, their respective shares in the total output shall be determined as follows:






(a)


the fraction of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin shall be determined by dividing the relevant renewable energy input into the process by the total relevant energy inputs into the process;










(b)


the fraction of recycled carbon fuel shall be determined by dividing the relevant energy input qualifying as a source for the production of recycled carbon fuels into the process by the total relevant energy inputs into the process.




The relevant energy for material inputs is the lower heating value of the material input that enters into the molecular structure of the fuel (1).
For electricity inputs that are used to enhance the heating value of the fuel or intermediate products the relevant energy is the energy of the electricity.
For industrial off-gases, it is the energy in the off-gas based on their lower heating value. In case of heat that is used to enhance the heating value of the fuel or intermediate product, the relevant energy is the useful energy in the heat that is used to synthesise the fuel. Useful heat is the total heat energy multiplied by the Carnot efficiency, as defined in Annex V, part C, point (1)(b) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001. Other inputs are only taken into account when determining the emission intensity of the fuel.












4.


When determining emissions from supply of inputs, it shall be distinguished between elastic inputs and rigid inputs. Rigid inputs are those whose supply cannot be expanded to meet extra demand. Thus, all inputs qualifying as a carbon source for the production of recycled carbon fuels are rigid, as well as outputs produced in fixed ratio by an incorporated process (2) and which represent less than 10 % of the economic value of the output. If it represents 10 % or more of the economic value, it shall be treated as elastic. In principle, elastic inputs are those whose supply can be increased to meet extra demand. Petroleum products from refineries fall into this category because refineries can change the ratio of their products.












5.


Electricity qualifying as fully renewable according to Article 27(3) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001, shall be attributed zero greenhouse gas emissions.












6.


One of the three following alternative methods shall be applied during each calendar year to attribute greenhouse gas emissions values to the electricity taken from the grid that does not qualify as fully renewable according to Article 27(3) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 and is used to produce renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels:






(a)


greenhouse gas emissions values shall be attributed according to part C of this Annex. This is without prejudice to the assessment under State aid rules;










(b)


greenhouse gas emissions values shall be attributed depending on the number of full load hours the installation producing renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels is operating. Where the number of full load hours is equal or lower than the number of hours in which the marginal price of electricity was set by installations producing renewable electricity or nuclear power plants in the preceding calendar year for which reliable data are available, grid electricity used in the production process of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels shall be attributed a greenhouse gas emissions value of zero gCO2eq/MJ. Where this number of full load hours is exceeded, grid electricity used in the production process of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels shall be attributed a greenhouse gas emissions value of 183 gCO2eq/MJ; or










(c)


the greenhouse gas emissions value of the marginal unit generating electricity at the time of the production of the renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin in the bidding zone may be used if this information is publicly available from the national transmission system operator.




If the method set in point (b) is used, it shall also be applied to electricity that is used to produce renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin and recycled carbon fuels and qualifies as fully renewable according to Article 27(3) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001.












7.


GHG emissions of elastic inputs that are obtained from an incorporated process shall be determined based on data from their actual production process. This shall include all emissions arising due to their production over the whole supply chain (including emissions arising from the extraction of the primary energy required to make the input, processing of the input and transportation of the input). Combustion emissions related to the carbon content of fuel inputs shall not be included (3).
However, GHG emissions from the elastic inputs that are not obtained from an incorporated process shall be determined based on the values included in Part B of this Annex. If the input is not included in the list, information of the emission intensity may be drawn from the latest version of the JEC-WTW report, the ECOINVENT database, official sources such as the IPCC, IEA or government, other reviewed sources such as the E3 and GEMIS database and peer reviewed publications.












8.


The supplier of each input, excluding those where the values are taken from part B of this Annex, shall calculate the emissions intensity (4) of the input following the procedures in this document, and report the value to the next production step or final fuel producer. The same rule applies to the suppliers of inputs further back in the supply chain.












9.


Emissions from rigid inputs shall include the emissions resulting from the diversion of those inputs from a previous or alternative use. These emissions shall take into account the loss of production of electricity, heat or products that were previously generated using the input as well as any emissions due to additional treatment of the input and transport. The following rules shall apply:






(a)


Emissions attributed to the supply of rigid inputs shall be determined by multiplying the lost production of electricity, heat or other products with the relevant emission factor. In case of lost electricity production, the emission factors to consider are for grid electricity generation in the country where the displacement occurred determined according to the appropriate methodology set out under points 5 or 6. In case of diverted material, the emissions to be attributed to the replacement material are calculated as for material inputs in this methodology. For the first 20 years after the start of production of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuels, the loss of production of electricity, heat and material shall be determined based on the average amount of electricity and heat that was produced from the rigid input over the last three years before the start of production of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuels. After 20 years of production, the loss of production of electricity, heat or other products shall be determined based on the minimum energy performance standards assumed in pertinent best available technology (BAT) conclusions. Where the process is not covered by a BAT, the estimation of lost production shall be based on a comparable process applying state of the art technology.










(b)


In case of rigid inputs that are intermediate streams in industrial processes, such as coke oven gas, blast furnace gas in a steelworks, or refinery gas in an oil refinery, if the effect of diverting it for fuel production cannot be measured directly, the emissions due to the diversion of inputs shall be determined based on simulations of the plant operation before and after it is modified to produce recycled carbon fuels. If the modification of the plant caused a reduction of output of some products, the emissions attributed to the rigid input shall include the emissions associated with replacing the lost products.










(c)


Where the process makes use of rigid inputs from new installations such as a new steelworks that uses its blast furnace gas for making recycled carbon fuels, the impact of diverting the input from the most economic alternative use shall be taken into account. Then the emission implications are calculated according to the minimum energy performance standards assumed in the pertinent BAT conclusions. For industrial processes which are not covered by a BAT, the saved emissions shall be calculated on the basis of the comparable process applying state of the art technology.
















10.


Emissions from existing use or fate include all emissions in the existing use or fate of the input that are avoided when the input is used for fuel production. These emissions shall include the CO2 equivalent of the carbon incorporated in the chemical composition of the fuel that would have otherwise been emitted as CO2 into the atmosphere. This includes CO2 that was captured and incorporated into the fuel provided that at least one of the following conditions is fulfilled:






(a)


the CO2 has been captured from an activity listed under Annex I of Directive 2003/87/EC and has been taken into account upstream in an effective carbon pricing system and is incorporated in the chemical composition of the fuel before 2036. This date shall be extended to 2041 in other cases than CO2 stemming from the combustion of fuels for electricity generation; or










(b)


the CO2 has been captured from the air; or










(c)


the captured CO2 stems from the production or the combustion of biofuels, bioliquids or biomass fuels complying with the sustainability and greenhouse gas saving criteria and the CO2 capture did not receive credits for emission savings from CO2 capture and replacement, set out in Annex V and VI of Directive (EU) 2018/2001; or










(d)


the captured CO2 stems from the combustion of renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuels complying with the greenhouse gas saving criteria, set out in Article 25(2) and Article 28(5) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 and this Regulation; or










(e)


the captured CO2 stems from a geological source of CO2 and the CO2 was previously released naturally.




Captured CO2 stemming from a fuel that is deliberately combusted for the specific purpose of producing the CO2 and CO2, the capture of which has received an emissions credit under other provisions of the law shall not be included.
Emissions associated with the inputs like electricity and heat and consumable materials used in the capture process of CO2 shall be included in the calculation of emissions attributed to inputs.












11.


The dates established in point 10(a) will be subject to review considering the implementation in the sectors covered by Directive 2003/87/EC of the Union-wide climate target for 2040 established in accordance with Article 4(3) of Regulation (EU) 2021/1119.












12.


Emissions from processing shall include direct atmospheric emissions from the processing itself, from waste treatment and from leakages.












13.


Emissions from combustion of the fuel refer to the total combustion emissions of the fuel in use.












14.


The greenhouse gases taken into account in emissions calculations, and their carbon dioxide equivalents, shall be the same as specified in Annex V, part C, point 4 of Directive (EU) 2018/2001.












15.


Where a process yields multiple co-products such as fuels or chemicals, as well as energy co-products such as heat, electricity or mechanical energy exported from the plant, greenhouse gas emissions shall be allocated to these co-products applying the following approaches in the following manner:






(a)


The allocation shall be conducted at the end of the process that produces the co-products. The emissions allocated shall include the emissions from the process itself, as well as the emissions attributed to inputs to the process.










(b)


The emissions to be allocated shall be e i
 plus any fractions of e p
, e td
 and e ccs
 that take place up to and including the process step at which the co-products are produced. If an input into the process is itself a co-product of another process, the allocation at the other process shall be done first to establish the emissions to be attributed to the input.










(c)


If any installation inside the project boundary treats only one of the project’s co-products, then the emissions from that installation shall be ascribed entirely to that co-product.










(d)


Where the process allows to change the ratio of the co-products produced, the allocation shall be done based on physical causality by determining the effect on the process’ emissions of incrementing the output of just one co-product whilst keeping the other outputs constant.










(e)


Where the ratio of the products is fixed and the co-products are all fuels, electricity or heat, the allocation shall be done by energy content. If allocation concerns exported heat on the basis of the energy content, only the useful part of the heat may be considered, as defined in Annex V, part C, point 16 of Directive (EU) 2018/2001.










(f)


Where the ratio of the products is fixed and some co-products are materials with no energy content, the allocation shall be done by the economic value of the co-products. The economic value considered shall be the average factory-gate value of the products over the last three years. If such data is not available, the value shall be estimated from commodity prices minus the cost of transport and storage (5).
















16.


Emissions from transport and distribution shall include emissions from the storage and distribution of the finished fuels. Emissions attributed to inputs e i
 shall include emissions from their associated transport and storage.












17.


Where a process for making renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuels produces carbon emissions that are permanently stored in accordance with Directive 2009/31/EC on the geological storage of carbon dioxide, this may be credited to the products of the process as a reduction in emissions under e ccs
. Emissions arising due to the storage operation (including transport of the carbon dioxide) will also need to be taken into account under e p
.




B.   ‘STANDARD VALUES’ FOR GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION INTENSITIES OF ELASTIC INPUTS
The GHG intensities of inputs other than electricity are shown in the table below:








 


Total emissions
gCO2eq/MJ


Upstream emissions
gCO2eq/MJ


Combustion emissions
gCO2eq/MJ




Natural gas


66,0 


9,7 


56,2 




Diesel


95,1 


21,9 


73,2 




Gasoline


93,3 


19,9 


73,4 




Heavy fuel oil


94,2 


13,6 


80,6 




Methanol


97,1 


28,2 


68,9 




Hard coal


112,3 


16,2 


96,1 




Lignite


116,7 


1,7 


115,0 













 


gCO2eq/kg




Ammonia


2 351,3 




Calcium chloride (CaCl2)


38,8 




Cyclohexane


723,0 




Hydrochloric acid (HCl)


1 061,1 




Lubricants


947,0 




Magnesium sulphate (MgSO4)


191,8 




Nitrogen


56,4 




Phosphoric acid (H3PO4)


3 124,7 




Potassium hydroxide (KOH)


419,1 




Pure CaO for processes


1 193,2 




Sodium carbonate (Na2CO3)


1 245,1 




Sodium chloride (NaCl)


13,3 




Sodium hydroxide (NaOH)


529,7 




Sodium methoxide (Na(CH3O))


2 425,5 




SO2



53,3 




Sulphuric acid (H2SO4)


217,5 




Urea


1 846,6 




C.   GHG EMISSION INTENSITY OF ELECTRICITY
The greenhouse gas emission intensity of electricity shall be determined at the level of countries or at the level of bidding zones. The greenhouse gas emission intensity of electricity may be determined at the level of bidding zones only, if the required data are publicly available. The calculation the carbon intensity of electricity, expressed as gCO2eq/kWh electricity, shall consider all potential primary energy sources for electricity generation, type of plant, conversion efficiencies and own electricity consumption in the power plant.
The calculation shall consider all carbon equivalent emissions, associated with the combustion and supply of the fuels used for electricity production. This relies on the amount of different fuels used in the electricity production facilities and the emission factors from fuel combustion and the upstream fuel emission factors.
Greenhouse Gases other than CO2 shall be converted to CO2eq by multiplying their Global Warming Potential (GWP) relative to CO2 over the 100-year time horizon as set out in Annex V, part C, point 4 to Directive (EU) 2018/2001. Because of their biogenic origin, CO2 emissions from the combustion of biomass fuels are not accounted for, but emissions of CH4 and N2O shall be accounted for.
For the calculation of the GHG emissions from fuels combustion, the IPCC default emission factors for stationary combustion in the energy industries shall be used (IPCC 2006). The upstream emissions shall include emissions from all the processes and phases required to make the fuel ready to supply the power production; they result from the extraction, refining and transport of the fuel used for electricity production.
In addition, all the upstream emissions from the cultivation, harvesting, collection, processing and transport of biomass shall be considered. Peat and the components of waste materials that are from fossil origins shall be treated as a fossil fuel.
The fuels used for gross electricity production in electricity only plants are determined based on the electricity production and the efficiency of conversion to electricity. In the case of Combined Heat and Power (CHP), the fuels used for heat produced in CHP shall be counted by considering alternative heat production with average overall efficiencies of 85 %, while the rest shall be attributed to electricity generation.
For nuclear power plants, the conversion efficiency from nuclear heat shall be assumed to be 33 % or data provided by Eurostat or a similar, accredited source.
No fuels are associated with electricity production from renewables that include hydro, solar, wind and geothermal. The emissions from the construction and decommissioning and waste management of electricity producing facilities are not considered. Thus, the carbon equivalent emissions associated with the renewable electricity (wind, solar, hydro and geothermal) production are considered to be equal to zero.
The CO2 equivalent emissions from gross electricity production shall include upstream emissions from JEC WTW v5 (Prussi et al, 2020) listed in Table 3 and the default emission factors for stationary combustion from IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories (IPCC 2006) listed in Tables 1 and 2. The upstream emissions for supplying the fuel used shall be calculated applying the JEC WTW v5 upstream emission factors (Prussi et al, 2020).
The calculation of the carbon intensity of electricity shall be done following the formula:













where:



e

gross_prod




=


CO2 equivalent emissions 














=


upstream CO2 equivalent emission factors 














=


CO2 equivalent emission factors from fuels combustion 








B

i




=


fuel consumption for electricity generation 














=


fuels used for electricity production




The amount of net electricity production is determined by the gross electricity production, own electricity consumption in the power plant and the electricity losses in pump storage.













where:



E

net




=


net electricity production 








E

gross




=


gross electricity production 








E

own




=


own internal electricity consumption in power plant 








E

pump




=


electricity for pumping 







The carbon intensity of net produced electricity shall be the total gross GHG emissions for producing or using the net electricity:





where: CI = CO2 equivalent emissions from electricity production 




Electricity production and fuel consumption data

Data on electricity production and fuel consumption shall be sourced from IEA Data and statistics that provides data on energy balances and electricity produced using various fuels, e.g. from IEA website, Data and Statistic section (‘Energy Statistics Data Browser’) (6).
For EU Member States, Eurostat data are more detailed and can be used instead. Where the greenhouse gas emission intensity is established at the level of bidding zones, data from official national statistics of the same level of detail as the IEA data shall be used. Fuel consumption data shall include available data at the highest level of detail available from national statistics: solid fossil fuels, manufactured gases, peat and peat products, oil shale and oil sands, oil and petroleum products, natural gas, renewables and biofuels, non-renewable waste and nuclear. Renewables and biofuels include biofuels, renewable municipal waste, hydro, ocean, geothermal, wind, solar and heat pumps.

Input data from literature sources


Table 1


Default emissions factors for stationary combustion [g/MJ fuel on a net calorific value]









Fuel


CO2



CH4



N2O






Solid fossil fuels




 


 


 




Anthracite


98,3 


0,001 


0,0015 




Coking coal


94,6 


0,001 


0,0015 




Other bituminous coal


94,6 


0,001 


0,0015 




Sub-bituminous coal


96,1 


0,001 


0,0015 




Lignite


101 


0,001 


0,0015 




Patent fuel


97,5 


0,001 


0,0015 




Coke oven coke


107 


0,001 


0,0015 




Gas coke


107 


0,001 


0,0001 




Coal tar


80,7 


0,001 


0,0015 




Brown coal briquettes


97,5 


0,001 


0,0015 






Manufactured gases




 


 


 




Gas works gas


44,4 


0,001 


0,0001 




Coke oven gas


44,4 


0,001 


0,0001 




Blast furnace gas


260 


0,001 


0,0001 




Other recovered gases


182 


0,001 


0,0001 





Peat and peat products



106 


0,001 


0,0015 





Oil shale and oil sands



73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 






Oil and petroleum products




 


 


 




Crude oil


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Natural gas liquids


64,2 


0,003 


0,0006 




Refinery feedstocks


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Additives and oxygenates


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Other hydrocarbons


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Refinery gas


57,6 


0,001 


0,0001 




Ethane


61,6 


0,001 


0,0001 




Liquefied petroleum gases


63,1 


0,001 


0,0001 




Motor gasoline


69,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Aviation gasoline


70 


0,003 


0,0006 




Gasoline-type jet fuel


70 


0,003 


0,0006 




Kerosene-type jet fuel


71,5 


0,003 


0,0006 




Other kerosene


71,5 


0,003 


0,0006 




Naphtha


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Gas oil and diesel oil


74,1 


0,003 


0,0006 




Fuel oil


77,4 


0,003 


0,0006 




White spirit and SBP


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Lubricants


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Bitumen


80,7 


0,003 


0,0006 




Petroleum coke


97,5 


0,003 


0,0006 




Paraffin waxes


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Other oil products


73,3 


0,003 


0,0006 




Natural gas


56,1 


0,001 


0,0001 






Waste




 


 


 




Industrial waste (non-renewable)


143 


0,03 


0,004 




Non-renewable municipal waste


91,7 


0,03 


0,004 










Note:


values have to be multiplied with GWP factors set out in Annex V, part C, point 4 to Directive (EU) 2018/2001.











Source:


IPCC, 2006.












Table 2


Default emissions factors for stationary combustion of fuels of biomass origin [g/MJ fuel on a net calorific value]









Fuel


CO2



CH4



N2O




Primary solid biofuels


0 


0,03 


0,004 




Charcoal


0 


0,2 


0,004 




Biogases


0 


0,001 


0,0001 




Renewable municipal waste


0 


0,03 


0,004 




Pure biogasoline


0 


0,003 


0,0006 




Blended biogasoline


0 


0,003 


0,0006 




Pure biodiesels


0 


0,003 


0,0006 




Blended biodiesels


0 


0,003 


0,0006 




Pure bio jet kerosene


0 


0,003 


0,0006 




Blended bio jet kerosene


0 


0,003 


0,0006 




Other liquid biofuels


0 


0,003 


0,0006 











Source:


IPCC, 2006.












Table 3


Fuel upstream emission factors [gCO2eq/MJ fuel on a net calorific value]







Fuel


Emission factor




Hard coal


15,9




Brown coal


1,7




Peat


0




Coal gases


0




Petroleum Products


11,6




Natural gas


12,7




Solid biofuels


0,7




Liquid biofuels


46,8




Industrial Waste


0




Municipal waste


0




Biogases


13,7




Nuclear


1,2











Source:


JEC WTW v5.








Table A includes the values for the GHG emission intensity of electricity at country level in the European Union. If the greenhouse gas emission intensity of electricity is determined at country level, these values shall be used for electricity sourced in the European Union until more recent data becomes available to determine the emission intensity of electricity (7).

Table A


Emission intensity of electricity in the European Union 2020







Country


Emission intensity of generated electricity (gCO2eq/MJ)




Austria


39,7 




Belgium


56,7 




Bulgaria


119,2 




Cyprus


206,6 




Czechia


132,5 




Germany


99,3 




Denmark


27,1 




Estonia


139,8 




Greece


125,2 




Spain


54,1 




Finland


22,9 




France


19,6 




Croatia


55,4 




Hungary


72,9 




Ireland


89,4 




Italy


92,3 




Latvia


39,4 




Lithuania


57,7 




Luxembourg


52,0 




Malta


133,9 




Netherlands


99,9 




Poland


196,5 




Portugal


61,6 




Romania


86,1 




Slovakia


45,6 




Slovenia


70,1 




Sweden


4,1 











Source:


JRC, 2022.










(1)  For material inputs containing water, the lower heating value is taken to be the lower heating value of the dry part of the material input (i.e. not taking into account the energy needed to evaporate the water). Renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuels of non-biological origin used as intermediate products for the production of conventional fuels are not considered.

(2)  Incorporated processes include processes that take place in the same industrial complex, or that supply the input via a dedicated supply infrastructure, or that supply more than half of the energy of all inputs to the production of the renewable liquid and gaseous transport fuel of non-biological origin or recycled carbon fuel.

(3)  If carbon intensities are taken from the table in part B, combustion emissions shall not be considered. This is because combustion emissions are counted in processing or in the combustion emissions of the final fuel.

(4)  Consistent with section 6 the emissions intensity shall not include the emissions embedded in the carbon content of the supplied input.

(5)  Note that it is the relative values of the co-products that matters, so general inflation is not an issue.

(6)  Example: https://www.iea.org/data-and-statistics/data-tools/energy-statistics-data-browser?country=GERMANY&energy=Coal&year=202.

(7)  Updated data will be made available by the European Commission on a regular basis.