Recommendation for a COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION delivering a Council opinion on the 2021 Convergence Programme of Bulgaria
Date: 2021-06-02
Institutions: Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Commission
Subjects: Bulgaria, economic recovery, economic reform, investment, organisation of health care, public finance, social security, stability pact, stability programme, structural adjustment

EN 

  EN 

   EUROPEAN COMMISSION  Brussels, 2.6.2021  COM(2021) 502 final  Recommendation for a COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION delivering a Council opinion on the 2021 Convergence Programme of Bulgaria {SWD(2021) 501}  
 
 
Recommendation for a 

COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION 

delivering a Council opinion on the 2021 Convergence Programme of Bulgaria 

THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION,  

Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, 

Having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 of 7 July 1997 on the strengthening of 
the  surveillance  of  budgetary  positions  and  the  surveillance  and  coordination  of  economic 
policies1, and in particular 9(2) thereof, 

Having regard to the Recommendation of the European Commission, 

Having regard to the resolutions of the European Parliament, 

After consulting the Economic and Financial Committee, 

Whereas: 

(1) 

(2) 

1 
2 

3 

4 

5 

On  20  March  2020,  the  Commission  adopted  a  Communication  on  the  activation  of 
the  general  escape  clause2  of  the  Stability  and  Growth  Pact.3  In  its  Communication, 
the  Commission  set  out its  view  that,  given  the expected  severe  economic  downturn 
resulting from  the COVID-19 outbreak, the  conditions  to  activate the general  escape 
clause were met. On 23 March 2020, the Ministers of Finance of the Member States 
agreed with the assessment of the Commission. The general escape clause has granted 
Member  States  budgetary  flexibility  to  deal  with  the  crisis.  It  has  facilitated  the 
coordination  of  budgetary  policies  in  times  of  severe  economic  downturn.  Its 
activation  allows  for  a  temporary  departure  from  the  adjustment  path  towards  the 
medium-term  budgetary  objective  of  each  Member  State,  provided  this  does  not 
endanger  fiscal  sustainability  in  the  medium  term.  On  17  September  2020,  in  its 
Annual  Sustainable  Growth  Strategy,  the  Commission  announced  that  the  general 
escape clause would remain active in 2021.4  
On 20 July 2020, the Council recommended Bulgaria5 to take all necessary measures, 
in line with the general escape clause, to effectively address the pandemic, sustain the 
economy and support the ensuing recovery. It also recommended Bulgaria to pursue, 

OJ L 209, 2.8.1997, p. 1. 
The  clause,  as  set  out  in  Articles  5(1),  6(3),  9(1)  and  10(3)  of  Regulation  (EC)  1466/97  and  Articles 
3(5) and 5(2) of Regulation (EC) 1467/97, facilitates the coordination of budgetary policies in times of 
severe economic downturn. 
Communication from the Commission to the Council on the activation of the general escape clause of   
the Stability and Growth Pact, Brussels, 20.3.2020, COM(2020) 123 final. 
Communication  from  the  Commission  on  Annual  Sustainable  Growth  Strategy  2021,  Brussels, 
17.9.2020, COM(2020) 575 final. 
Council  Recommendation  of  20  July  2020  on  the  National  Reform  Programme  of  Bulgaria  and 
delivering a Council opinion on the 2020 Convergence Programme of Bulgaria, OJ C 282, 26.8.2020, p. 
8. 

EN 

1 

  EN 

 
 
 
                                                 
(3) 

(4) 

(5) 

when economic conditions allow, fiscal policies aimed at achieving prudent medium-
term fiscal positions and ensuring debt sustainability, while enhancing investment. 

Next  Generation  EU,  including  the  Recovery  and  Resilience  Facility,  will  ensure  a 
sustainable,  inclusive  and  fair  recovery.  Regulation  (EU)  2021/241  establishing  the 
Recovery and Resilience Facility6 came into force on 19 February 2021. This Facility 
will  provide  financial  support  for  the  implementation  of  reforms  and  investment, 
entailing  a  fiscal  impulse  financed  by  the  EU.  It  will  contribute  to  the  economic 
recovery,  to  the  implementation  of  sustainable  and  growth-enhancing  reforms  and 
investment, notably to promote the green and digital transitions, and it will strengthen 
the  economies’  resilience  and  potential  growth.  In  turn,  it  will  also  help  public 
finances to return to more favourable positions in the near term and will contribute to 
strengthening sustainable public finances, growth and job creation in the medium and 
long term.  

On 3 March 2021, the Commission adopted a Communication providing further policy 
orientations  to  facilitate  the  coordination  of  fiscal  policies  and  the  preparation  of 
Member  States’  Stability  and  Convergence  Programmes.7  The  overall  fiscal  stance, 
taking into account national budgets and the Recovery and Resilience Facility, should 
remain  supportive  in  2021  and  2022.  At  the  same  time,  given  the  expectation  of 
economic activity  gradually normalising in the second half of 2021, Member States’ 
fiscal  policies  should  become  more  differentiated  in  2022.  Member  States’  fiscal 
policies should take into account the state of the recovery, fiscal sustainability and the 
need  to  reduce  economic,  social  and  territorial  divergences.  In  view  of  the  need  to 
support a sustainable recovery for the EU, Member States with low sustainability risks 
should  gear  their  budgets  towards  maintaining  a  supportive  fiscal  policy  in  2022, 
taking into account the impact of the Recovery and Resilience Facility. Member States 
with high debt levels should pursue prudent fiscal policies, while preserving nationally 
financed  investment  and  making  use  of  grants  under  the  Recovery  and  Resilience 
Facility to fund additional high-quality investment projects and structural reforms. For 
the  period  beyond  2022,  fiscal  policies  should  continue  to  take  into  account  the 
strength of the recovery, the degree of economic uncertainty and fiscal sustainability 
considerations.  A  refocusing  of  fiscal  policies  towards  achieving  prudent  medium-
term  fiscal  positions,  including  by  phasing  out  support  measures  in  due  course,  will 
contribute to ensuring fiscal sustainability in the medium term.  

The Communication of 3 March 2021 also announced the Commission’s view that the 
decision  on  the  deactivation  or  continued  application  of  the  general  escape  clause 
should be taken as an overall assessment of the state of the economy, with the level of 
economic activity in the EU or euro area compared to pre-crisis levels (end-2019) as 
key quantitative criterion. On the basis of the Commission’s 2021 spring forecast, on 2 
June the Commission considered that the conditions to continue to apply the general 
escape  clause  in  2022  and  to  deactivate  it  as  of  2023  were  met.  Country-specific 
situations will continue to be taken into account  after the deactivation of  the general 
escape clause.8 

(6) 

On  5  May  2021,  Bulgaria  submitted  its  2021  Convergence  Programme,  beyond  the 
deadline established in Article 8 of Regulation (EC) No 1466/97.  

6 
7 

8 

OJ L57, 18.2.2021, p.17. 
Communication  from  the  Commission  to  the  Council  on  one  year  since  the  outbreak  of  COVID-19: 
fiscal policy response, Brussels, 3.3.2021, COM(2021) 105 final. 
Communication from the Commission on Economic policy coordination in 2021: overcoming COVID-
19, supporting the recovery and modernising our economy, Brussels, 2.6.2021, COM(2021)500 final. 

EN 

2 

  EN 

 
                                                 
(7) 

(8) 

(9) 

(10) 

In  2020,  based  on  data  validated  by  Eurostat,  Bulgaria’s  general  government  deficit 
was  3.4%  of  GDP,  while  general  government  debt  increased  to  25%  of  GDP.  The 
annual  change  in  the  primary  budget  balance  amounted  to  -5.5%  of  GDP,  including 
discretionary budgetary measures of 3.2% of GDP in support of the economy and the 
operation of automatic stabilisers.  

On  2  June  2021,  the  Commission  issued  a  report  under  Article  126(3)  TFEU.  This 
report discusses the budgetary situation of Bulgaria, as its general government deficit 
in  2020  exceeded  the  3%  of  GDP  Treaty  reference  value.  The  report  concluded  that 
the deficit criterion was fulfilled.  

The  macroeconomic  scenario  underpinning  the  budgetary  projections  is  cautious  in 
2021  and  2022,  since  it  does  not  take  into  account  funding  under  the  Recovery  and 
Resilience  Facility.  Consequently,  the  presented  baseline  is  not  directly  comparable 
with the Commission forecast. Moreover, the Commission forecast expects a stronger 
growth rate in exports, based on more favourable assumptions for foreign demand.  

In its 2021 Convergence Programme, the government plans an increase of the general 
government  deficit  from  3.4%  of  GDP  in  2020  to  5.6%  of  GDP  in  2021,  while  the 
debt  ratio  is  planned  to  increase  to  27.4%  of  GDP  in  2021.  According  to  the 
programme, the change in the primary budget balance in 2021 compared with the pre-
crisis  level  (2019)  is  set  to  amount  to  -7.8%  of  GDP.  The  drivers  of  the  projected 
increases  in  the  nominal  and  primary  general  government  deficit  and  consequently 
debt are not explained in detail in the Convergence Programme and occur despite the 
expiration  of  some  of  the  discretionary  budgetary  measures.  These  projections  are 
above the Commission’s 2021 spring  forecast.  According to the Commission’s 2021 
spring  forecast,  the  deficit  is  expected  to  decrease  to  3.2%  of  GDP  in  2021  and  the 
debt  ratio  is  expected  to  decrease  to  24.5%  of  GDP  in  2021.  The  main  source  of 
difference  is  the  projection  of  other  revenue,  which  according  to  the  Convergence 
Programme  is  expected  to  decrease  by  2.5  percentage  points  of  GDP  in  2021,  well 
below  historical  levels.  The  drivers  of  this  reduction  are  not  explained  in  the 
Convergence Programme. 

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic and related economic downturn, Bulgaria has 
adopted budgetary measures to strengthen the capacity of its health system, contain the 
pandemic  and  provide  relief  to  those  individuals  and  sectors  that  have  been 
particularly  affected.  This  forceful  policy  response  has  cushioned  the  contraction  in 
GDP,  which,  in  turn,  curtailed  the  increase  in  government  deficit  and  public  debt. 
Fiscal measures should maximise support to the recovery without pre-empting future 
fiscal  trajectories.  Therefore, measures should  avoid  creating  a permanent burden on 
public  finances.  When  Member  States  introduce  permanent  measures,  they  should 
properly fund them to ensure budgetary neutrality in the medium term. The measures 
taken  by  Bulgaria  in  2020  and  2021  have  been  in  line  with  the  Council 
Recommendation  of  20  July  2020.  The  discretionary  measures  adopted  by  the 
government in 2020 and 2021 are temporary or matched by offsetting measures.  

(11)  The  2021  Convergence  Programme  assumes  investment  and  reforms  financed  by 
grants  under  the  Recovery  and  Resilience  Facility  amounting  to  0.02%  of  GDP  in 
2020,  0.3%  in  2021,  0.8%  in  2022,  1.4%  in  2023,  1.7%  in  2024,  2.6%  in  2025  and 
1.8% in 2026. The Commission’s spring forecast includes these grants in its budgetary 
projections.  

(12)  The established indicators of fiscal adjustment set out in Regulation (EC) No 1466/97 
need  to  be  considered  in  the  context  of  the  current  circumstances.  First,  there  is 

EN 

3 

  EN 

 
significant  uncertainty  surrounding  output  gap  estimates.  Second,  there  is  a  need  for 
fiscal policy to stand ready to rapidly adapt to the evolution of the pandemic, shifting 
from  emergency  relief  to  more  targeted  measures  once  health  risks  diminish.  Third, 
the  current  context  is  characterised  by  a  significant  policy  response  to  support 
economic activity. In the presence of sizeable transfers from the EU budget  (such as 
those  from  the  Recovery  and  Resilience  Facility),  the  established  indicators  do  not 
capture  the  full  impulse  provided  by  fiscal  policies  to  the  economy.  Against  this 
background,  the  structural  balance  does  not  appear  adequate  in  the  current 
circumstances.  The  expenditure  benchmark,  in  turn,  needs  to  be  adapted9  and 
complemented  with  additional  information  in  order  to  fully  gauge  the  fiscal  policy 
orientation.  

First,  and  similarly  to  the  approach  pursed  in  the  assessment  of  the  2021  Draft 
Budgetary  Plans,  temporary  emergency  measures  have  been  excluded  from  the 
expenditure  aggregate.  These  crisis-related  temporary  emergency  measures  support 
health  systems  and  compensate  workers  and  firms  for  the  losses  in  income  due  to 
lockdowns  and  supply  chain  disruptions;  their  reversal  by  the  public  authorities  is 
contingent on the return of the public health and economic situation to normality. 

Second, to assess the overall fiscal stance at the current juncture, the sizeable transfers 
from the EU budget (such as those from the Recovery and Resilience Facility) should 
be included in the relevant expenditure aggregate. 

Therefore, the fiscal stance is then measured by the change in primary expenditure (net 
of  discretionary  revenue  measures  and  excluding  crisis-related  temporary  emergency 
measures)  including  expenditure  financed  by  grants  under  the  Recovery  and 
Resilience Facility and other EU funds.  

Going  beyond  the  overall  fiscal  stance,  the  analysis  also  aims  at  assessing  whether 
national  fiscal  policy  is  prudent  and  its  composition  is  conducive  to  a  sustainable 
recovery  consistent  with  the  green  and  digital  transitions.  For  that  reason,  particular 
attention  is  paid  to  the  evolution  of  nationally  financed  primary  current  expenditure 
and investment. 

(13) 

In its 2021 Convergence Programme, Bulgaria’s general government deficit is planned 
to decrease to 2.7% of GDP in 2022, mainly due to a discontinuation of the temporary 
support  measures  adopted  in  2020  and  2021.  The  general  government  debt  ratio  is 
planned  to  increase  to  28.6%  of  GDP  in  2022.  The  projections  are  above  the 
Commission’s 2021 spring forecast. 

Based on the Commission’s forecast, the overall fiscal stance as defined above  – also 
including the impact on aggregate demand in 2022 from investment financed by both 
the  national  and  the  EU  budgets,  notably  the  Recovery  and  Resilience  Facility  –  is 
estimated  at -1.4%  of  GDP10.  The  positive  contribution  of  expenditure  financed  by 
Recovery and Resilience Facility grants and other EU funds is projected to increase by 
0.8 percentage points of GDP. Nationally financed investment is projected to provide 
a contractionary contribution of 0.4 percentage points of GDP.11 Nationally financed 

9 

10 

11 

In  particular,  the  4-year  smoothing  of  investment  used  in  the  expenditure  benchmark  does  not  allow 
assessing properly the fiscal support to the recovery provided by nationally financed investments. 
A negative sign of the indicator corresponds to an excess of the primary expenditure growth compared 
with medium-term economic growth, which indicates an expansionary fiscal policy. 
Other nationally financed capital expenditure is projected to provide a contractionary contribution of 0.1 
percentage points of GDP. 

EN 

4 

  EN 

 
                                                 
primary  current  expenditure  (net  of  discretionary  revenue  measures)  is  projected  to 
provide an expansionary contribution of 1 percentage point of GDP. 

(14)  The  quality  of  Member  States’  budgetary  measures  appear  particularly  important. 
Fiscal structural reforms aimed at improving the composition of national budgets can 
support  potential  growth,  create  much-needed  fiscal  space  and  help  ensuring  fiscal 
sustainability  over  the  longer  term,  including  in  view  of  climate  change  and  health 
challenges. On the revenue side, the COVID-19 crisis has reinforced the importance of 
reforms for more efficient and fairer public revenue systems. On the expenditure side, 
it  has  made  even  more  crucial  to  increase  the  level  and  quality  of  sustainable  and 
growth-enhancing  investments,  consistent  with  serving  the  objectives  of  enhancing 
growth  potential,  economic  and  social  resilience,  and  the  green  and  digital  twin 
transition. The Recovery and Resilience Plans will allow to improve the composition 
of national budgets. 

(15)  According to the programme’s medium-term budgetary plans, the general government 
deficit  is  planned  to  increase  to  3.1%  of  GDP  in  2023.  No  information  on  2024  is 
provided in the Convergence Programme. 

Based on the programme, the overall  fiscal  stance as defined above  – also  including 
the  impact  on  aggregate  demand  from  investment  financed  by  both  the  national  and 
the EU budgets, notably the Recovery and Resilience Facility – is estimated at -0.6% 
of GDP in 2023. The positive contribution of expenditure financed by Recovery and 
Resilience  Facility  grants  and  other  EU  funds  is  projected  to  increase  by  0.6 
percentage  points  of  GDP  in  2023.  Nationally  financed  investment  is  projected  to 
provide  an  expansionary  contribution  of  0.4  percentage  points  of  GDP  in  2023.12 
Nationally  financed  primary  current  expenditure  (net  of  discretionary  revenue 
measures)  is  projected  to  provide  a  contractionary  contribution  of  0.4  percentage 
points of GDP. 
The  current  estimate  of  the  10-year  average  nominal  potential  growth  is  5%.13 
However, this estimate does not include the impact of the reforms that are part of the 
Recovery and Resilience Plan and can boost Bulgaria’s potential growth. 

(16)  The  general  government debt  ratio is  planned to increase to  29.3% of GDP  in  2023. 
There is  no information  on 2024 in  Bulgaria’s Convergence Programme.  Bulgaria is 
considered  to  face  low  fiscal  sustainability  risks  over  the  medium  term,  as  per  the 
latest debt sustainability analysis.14 

(17) 

In view of the currently still exceptionally high degree of uncertainty, the fiscal policy 
guidance should remain  predominantly  qualitative. More precise quantified  guidance 
for  the  later  years  should  be  provided  in  2022,  if  the  degree  of  uncertainty  has 
sufficiently declined by then.  

The Council has assessed the 2021 Convergence Programme and the follow-up by the 
Bulgaria to the Council Recommendation of 20 July 2020. 

12 

13 
14 

Other  nationally  financed  capital  expenditure  is  projected  to  provide  an  expansionary  contribution  of 
0.1 percentage points of GDP. 
Estimated by the Commission, following the commonly agreed methodology.  
See Commission Staff Working Document – Statistical Annex providing background data relevant for 
the assessment of the 2021 Stability and Convergence Programmes. 

EN 

5 

  EN 

 
                                                 
HEREBY RECOMMENDS BULGARIA TO: 

1. 

2. 

3. 

In  2022,  pursue  a  supportive  fiscal stance,  including  the  impulse  provided  by  the 
Recovery and Resilience Facility, and preserve nationally financed investment. Keep 
the growth of nationally financed current expenditure under control.  

When economic conditions allow, pursue a fiscal policy aimed at achieving prudent 
medium-term fiscal positions and ensuring fiscal sustainability in the medium term. 
At the same time, enhance investment to boost growth potential. 

Pay  particular  attention  to  the  composition  of  public  finances,  both  on  the  revenue 
and  expenditure  sides  of  the  budget,  and  to  the  quality  of  budgetary  measures,  to 
ensure  a  sustainable  and  inclusive  recovery.  Prioritise  sustainable  and  growth-
enhancing  investment,  notably  supporting  the  green  and  digital  transition.  Give 
priority to fiscal structural reforms that will help provide financing for public policy 
priorities and contribute to the long-term sustainability of public finances, including 
by  strengthening  the  coverage,  adequacy,  and  sustainability  of  health  and  social 
protection systems for all. 

Done at Brussels, 2.6.2021 

For the Council 
The President 

EN 

6 

  EN