Proposal for a COUNCIL IMPLEMENTING DECISION authorising Italy to apply, in determined geographical areas, reduced rates of taxation on gas oil and LPG used for heating purposes in accordance with Article 19 of Directive 2003/96/EC
Date: 2014-06-27
Institutions: European Commission
Subjects: Italy, diesel fuel, fuel tax, heating, tax relief













EUR-Lex - 52014PC0395 - EN











|



52014PC0395

Proposal for a COUNCIL IMPLEMENTING DECISION authorising Italy to apply, in determined geographical areas, reduced rates of taxation on gas oil and LPG used for heating purposes in accordance with Article 19 of Directive 2003/96/EC /* COM/2014/0395 final - 2014/0200 (NLE) */









EXPLANATORY MEMORANDUM
1.           CONTEXT OF THE PROPOSAL
·                        
Grounds for and objectives of the proposal
Taxation of energy products and electricity
in the EU is governed by Council Directive 2003/96/EC ([1]) (hereafter referred to as the ‘Energy
Taxation Directive’ or the ‘Directive’).
Pursuant to Article 19(1) of the Directive, in addition to the provisions foreseen in
particular in the Articles 5, 15 and 17, the Council, acting unanimously on a
proposal from the Commission, may authorise any Member State to introduce
further exemptions or reductions in excise duties for specific policy
considerations.
The objective of this proposal is to allow Italy to apply, in certain particularly disadvantaged areas, reduced rates of taxation to
gas oil and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) used for heating purposes to
partially off-set the high heating costs of residents in such geographical
areas. The high heating costs are either due to very severe climate conditions
or due to severe climate condition or insularity of such zones combined with
difficult fuel procurement.
·                        
General context
By letter dated 31 May 2012, the Italian
authorities requested authorisation to apply, in certain particularly
disadvantaged geographical areas, reduced rates of taxation to gas oil and LPG
used for heating purposes by way of a renewal of Council Decision 2008/318/EC
of 7 April 2008 authorising Italy to apply, in determined geographical areas,
reduced rates of taxation on gas oil and LPG used for heating purposes in
accordance with Article 19 of Directive 2003/96/EC ([2]). This Decision authorised Italy to apply, until 31 December 2012,
in certain particularly disadvantages areas reduced rates of excise duty on
domestic fuel and LPG used for heating. In addition the Italian authorities have
included in its request an extension of the scope of the authorisation to municipalities
which are part of provinces where over 70 % of the municipalities are
classified in climate zone F but they themselves do not fall within climate
zone F. Additional information and clarifications were provided by the Italian
authorities on 4 December 2012, 16 July 2013, 31 December 2013, 22 January 2014.
With letter dated 19 March 2014 the Italian authorities informed the Commission
that they request a renewal of the authorisation granted by Council Decision
2008/318/EC for a new period of six years without adding to the list new
municipalities as initially requested. 
In justification of its request for
derogation, Italy points to its diversified territory with variable climate and
geographical conditions. The national levels of excise duty on gas oil and LPG
used for heating in Italy are relatively high. In order to avoid excessive
burden on certain consumers particularly dependent on heating, Italy has introduced reduced rates of taxation in certain parts of its territory and would like
to continue to apply the same reduction as introduced in 2006. The tax
reduction amounts to EUR 129.11 per 1 000 litres in the case of gas oil (driving the applicable tax rate
down to EUR 274.10 per 1 000 litres) and to EUR 159.07 per 1 000 kg of LPG (driving the applicable tax rate down to EUR 30.87 per 1 000 kg). The
applicable tax rates are above the minimum levels of taxation prescribed by the
Directive.
The tax reduction is applicable in
geographical areas fulfilling the following criteria:
Under Article 8(10) of Italian Law No
448/1998, the advantage applies to supplies of the fuels in question (gas oil
and LPG) used in municipalities:
·                        
classified in climate zone F, as referred to in
Presidential Decree No 412 of 26 August 1993;
·                        
which do not have a gas supply network and are
classified in climate zone E, as referred to in the abovementioned Presidential
Decree 412/1993. In this case, as provided for in Article 8(10)(c) point 4) of
Law No 448/1998, the advantage will be withdrawn as soon as the municipality
becomes connected to the gas supply network. 
·                        
in the region of Sardinia and the smaller
islands, as long as the natural gas network has not been made available in the
commune concerned; this part of the regimes covers all Italian islands apart
from Sicily. 
The tax advantage cannot be combined with
other excise duty reductions.
According to the Italian authorities, the
tax differentiation is based on objective criteria and intends to ensure
geographical continuity with the rest of the Italian territory, i.e. it aims at
putting the population of the eligible areas on more comparable footing with
the rest of the Italian population by means of reducing their
disproportionately high heating costs. The amount of the tax reduction is the
same for all users; it is only aimed at partially alleviating the additional
heating costs of the population of the eligible areas which are due to cold
climate or difficulties with fuel procurement.
According to the Italian authorities the
additional costs for mountainous regions for transport of LPG are 120 %
higher than the rest of the country and for gas oil 132 % higher.
According to the Italian authorities, for
climate zones E and F, the tax reduction equals on average to 11 – 12 % of
the price of gas oil and LPG for heating purposes. 
These figures have to be compared with the
average heating costs: these are, due to climate conditions, by 90 %
higher than the national average in climate zone E and by 170 % higher than
the national average in climate zone F. 
The specificity of the islands consists in
the fact that due to their geographical particularities, the fuel supply is
restricted in scope and as a result it is more expensive than on the Italian
mainland due to additional transport costs. The Italian authorities confirmed
that the tax reduction does not result in overcompensation and does not drive
the prices of LPG and gas oil below the price on the mainland. With regard to the application of the subsidy in the smaller
islands, in the locations in question the logistics chain is inevitably more
expensive than that in mainland Italy. The higher costs are the result of a
lack of primary logistics, which gives rise to higher distribution costs.
Higher costs are also due to often problematic road access, higher motor fuel
costs than those on the mainland and the transportation costs for accessing the
smaller islands and the limited quantities of individual supplies. The Italian
authorities have estimated these higher costs as being approximately 10 –15 % higher than the corresponding costs
in mainland Italy.
The Italian authorities explain that during
the last three years the measure has reduced the end purchase price of LPG and
gas oil used for heating by approximately 10 %.
The Italian authorities explain that there is
no development of natural gas network in those areas which is an additional
disadvantage for these mountain communes, Sardinia and the small islands. 
The annual budgetary expenditure of the measure is around EUR 230 million. 
·                        
Existing provisions in the area of the
proposal
Council
Directive 2003/96/EC of 27 October 2003 restructuring the Community framework
for the taxation of energy products and electricity and Council Decision 2008/318/EC of 7 April 2008 authorising Italy to
apply, in determined geographical areas, reduced rates of taxation on gas oil
and LPG used for heating purposes in accordance with Article 19 of Directive
2003/96/EC.
Consistency with the other policies and
objectives of the Union
Each request for derogation under Article
19 of the Energy Taxation Directive must be examined by the Commission taking
into account the proper functioning of the internal market, the need to ensure
fair competition and EU health, environment, energy and transport policies.
The tax differentiation partially
alleviates the additional heating costs incurred by citizens in certain
geographical areas of Italy that are particularly disadvantaged compared to the
rest of the territory and for which, therefore, the standard tax rate
applicable to LPG and gas oils used for heating purposes would result in an excessive
tax burden. The geographical disadvantage translates into additional heating
costs which are due to severe climate conditions or insularity of such zones,
combined with unavailability of alternative heating resources, in particular
unavailability of access to the natural gas network.
The reduced rate of taxation both for gas
oil and LPG remains higher than the EU minimum levels of taxation set out in
the Energy Taxation Directive and it only partially alleviates the additional
heating costs incurred in the geographical areas in question.
It can be thus considered that the
reduction is compatible with the goal of providing a tax incentive for the
purpose of energy efficiency. The measure has not been found to be incompatible
with the relevant EU policies on the environment and energy. 
Furthermore, the measure is acceptable from
the point of view of the proper functioning of the internal market and the need
to ensure fair competition. It merely seeks to partially offset the additional
heating costs associated with the objective conditions of the areas in
question. The tax reduction is not cumulative with any other sorts of tax
reduction and it does not apply to other use of the heating fuels then space
heating.
Article 19(2) of the Energy Tax Directive
further provides that measures adopted under its provisions must be limited in
time, and sets a maximum period of six years, with a possibility of renewal. The
Commission's understanding is that as this is a tax measure of temporary nature
its prolongation should provide Italy with sufficient time to make an
assessment of the environmental effect of the measure but also to put in place incentives
to improve energy efficiency and evaluate those. The prolongation of the
measure should provide the Italian authorities with enough time to collect the
information necessary for such an assessment. It will also give the signal that
in the future the focus would be on more targeted energy saving measures in
order to improve energy efficiency and have a positive effect on the
environment. For these reasons at the present stage, it appears appropriate to
grant the authorisation for three years.
State aid rules
The reduced tax rates of EUR 274.10
per 1 000 l for gas oil and EUR 30.87 per 1 000 kg for
LPG used for heating envisaged by the Italian authorities are above the EU minimum levels of taxation
pursuant to Article 9 of Directive 2003/96/EC. The
measure is therefore covered by Article 25 of Regulation 800/2008/EC ([3]) (the ‘General Block Exemption Regulation’) and would thus be
considered compatible with the internal market and exempted from the
notification requirement. The period of validity of the General Block Exemption
Regulation was originally limited to 31 December 2013 but it was extended by
Commission Regulation 1224/2013/EU ([4])
to 30 June 2014. In case new State aid rules are adopted by the Commission
prior to the Council's decision on this proposal the notification obligations
will need to be reassessed under the new rules.
2.           RESULTS OF CONSULTATIONS
WITH THE INTERESTED PARTIES AND IMPACT ASSESSMENTS
 ·                         Consultation of interested parties 
 This proposal concerns only Italy. 
 ·                         Collection and use of expertise 
 There was no need for external expertise. 
 ·                         Impact assessment This proposal concerns an authorisation for an individual Member State upon its own request. 
3.           LEGAL ELEMENTS OF THE
PROPOSAL
The proposal aims at authorising Italy to derogate from the general provisions of Council Directive 2003/96/EC and to apply
a reduced rate of taxation to gas oil and LPG used for
heating purposes.
Legal basis
Article 19 of Council Directive 2003/96/EC.
Subsidiarity principle
The field of indirect taxation covered by
Article 113 TFEU is not in itself within the exclusive competence of the
European Union within the meaning of Article 3 TFEU.
However, the exercise by Member States of
their competences in this field is strictly circumscribed and limited by
existing EU law. Pursuant to Article 19 of Directive 2003/96/EC, only the
Council is empowered to authorise a Member State to introduce further
exemptions or reductions within the meaning of that provision. Member States
cannot substitute themselves for the Council. 
The proposal therefore respects the
principle of subsidiarity.
Proportionality principle
The proposal respects the principle of
proportionality. The tax reduction does not exceed what is necessary to attain
the objective in question (cf. the considerations on the internal market and
fair competition aspects, above).
Choice of instruments
Instrument(s) proposed: Council
Implementing Decision.
Article 19 of Directive 2003/96 makes
provision for this type of measure only.
4.           BUDGETARY IMPLICATION
The measure does not impose any financial
or administrative burden on the Union. The proposal therefore has no impact on
the budget of the Union.
2014/0200 (NLE)
Proposal for a
COUNCIL IMPLEMENTING DECISION
authorising Italy to apply, in determined
geographical areas, reduced rates of taxation on gas oil and LPG used for
heating purposes in accordance with Article 19 of Directive 2003/96/EC
THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION,
Having regard to the Treaty on the
Functioning of the European Union, 
Having regard to Council
Directive 2003/96/EC of 27 October 2003 restructuring the Community framework
for the taxation of energy products and electricity ([5]) and in particular Article 19(1) thereof,
Having regard to the proposal from the
European Commission,
Whereas:
(1)       Pursuant to Article 19(1)
of Directive 2003/96/EC, Italy was authorised to apply in certain particularly
disadvantages areas reduced rates of excise duty on gas oil and LPG used for
heating. The authorisation was granted until 31 December 2012 by Council
Decision 2008/318/EC of 7 April 2008 authorising Italy to apply, in determined
geographical areas, reduced rates of taxation on gas oil and LPG used for
heating purposes in accordance with Article 19 of Directive 2003/96/EC ([6]).
(2)       By
letter dated 31 May 2012 the Italian authorities requested authorisation to
apply in certain particularly disadvantaged geographical areas, reduced rates
of taxation on gas oil and LPG used for heating purposes by way of extension of
a practice followed under the above-mentioned Council Decision in some areas,
and this before it has expired. Additional information
and clarifications were provided by the Italian authorities on 4 December 2012,
16 July 2013, 31 December 2013 and 22 January 2014. By letter dated 19 March
2014 the Italian authorities requested a renewal of the authorisation granted
by Council Decision 2008/318/EC without changes in its territorial scope. The authorisation was requested for the period from 1 January 2013
to 31 December 2018.  
(3)       Italy has very diversified
territory with variable climate and geographical conditions. Taking into
account the particularities of its territory, Italy has introduced reduced
rates of taxation to gas oil and LPG with the purpose of partially offsetting
the disproportionately high heating costs for residents in certain geographical
areas.
(4)       The tax differentiation is
based on objective criteria and aims at putting the population of the eligible
areas on more comparable footing with the rest of the Italian population by
means of reducing their disproportionately high heating costs which are due to
severe climate conditions or difficulties with fuel procurement in comparison
with the rest of the Italian territory.
(5)       The tax reduction is
applicable in geographical areas fulfilling the following criteria: i) most
severe climate conditions within the Italian territory (communes falling into
zone F as defined in the Presidential decree No 412 of 1993 ([7])), severe climate
conditions combined with difficulties with fuel procurement (communes falling
into zone E as defined in the Presidential decree No 412 of 1993 as long as the
natural gas network has not been made available in the commune), geographical
isolation combined with difficult and costly fuel procurement: Sardinia and
small islands. Since the development of the natural gas network would to an
important extent reduce the additional heating costs and would lead to greater
diversity of fuel supply, where appropriate, the application of the reduced
rates is restricted until the completion of the natural gas network in the
communes concerned.
(6)       The measure has been
reviewed by the Commission and been found not to distort competition or hinder
the operation of the internal market and it is not considered incompatible with
EU's policy on the environment, energy and transport. The reduced rate of
taxation both for gas oil and LPG remains higher than the EU minimum levels of
taxation set out in the Directive 2003/96/EC and it only partially alleviates
the additional heating costs incurred in the geographical areas in question.
(7)       The measure in question
applies only to space heating purposes (both for private individuals and
businesses); it does not apply for other forms of business use of the said
products. According to the Italian authorities the amount of the tax advantage
for business users is in each particular case covered by the Commission
Regulation (EU) No 1407/2013 of 18 December 2013 on the application of Articles
107 and 108 of the TFEU to de minimis aid ([8]).
Nevertheless, if the benefit to any single undertaking exceeds the ceiling laid
down in that Regulation, it should be notified to the Commission in accordance
with Council Regulation (EU) No 734/2013 of 22 July 2013 amending Regulation
(EC) No 659/1999 laying down detailed rules for the application of Article 93
of the EC Treaty ([9]).
(8)        Considering the potential
environmental effects of the measure, it appears appropriate to grant the
authorisation for three years. This period of application would provide Italian
authorities with enough time to assess the environmental effect of the measure
and it will also indicate that in the future more targeted energy saving
measures would need to be put in place in order to improve energy efficiency
and ensure a positive effect on the environment,
HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION: 
Article 1
Italy is hereby
authorised to apply reduced rates of taxation to gas
oil and LPG used for heating purposes in the following disadvantaged
geographical areas:  
1.     
Communes falling in the climate zone F as
established by the Presidential Decree of 26 August 1993 No 412.
2.     
Communes falling in the climate zone E as
established by the Presidential Decree of 26 August 1993 No 412.
3.     
Communes of Sardinia and small islands ([10]).
In order to avoid any overcompensation, the
reduction must not go beyond the additional costs of heating in the areas in
question. In the particular case of Sardinia and small islands, as a
consequence, the tax reduction must not drive the price below the price of the
same fuel on the Italian mainland.
The reduced rate shall comply with the
requirements of Council Directive 2003/96/EC, and in particular with the
minimum levels of taxation laid down in Article 9 of that Directive.
Article 2
The eligibility of the geographical areas
referred to in the annex under point 2 and 3 is conditional on the
non-availability of the natural gas network in the commune.
Article 3
This Decision shall take effect on the day of its notification. It shall expire three years thereafter.
Article 4
This Decision is addressed to the Republic of Italy.
Done at Brussels,
                                                                       For
the Council
                                                                       The
President
([1])            Council
Directive 2003/96/EC of 27 October 2003 restructuring the Community framework
for taxation of energy products and electricity (OJ L 283, 31.10.2003 p. 51;
Directive last amended by Directives 2004/74/EC and 2004/75/EC (OJ L 157,30.4.2004,
p. 87 and p. 100).
([2])            OJ
L 109, 19.4.2008, p. 27–29.
([3])            Commission
Regulation (EC) No 800/2008/EC of 6 August 2008 declaring certain categories of
aid compatible with the common market in application of Articles 87 and 88 of
the Treaty, OJ L 214, 9.8.2008,
p. 3.
([4])            OJ
L 320, 30.11.2013.
([5])            OJ
L 283, 31.10.2003, p. 51, Directive as last amended by Directive 2004/75/EC (OJ
L 157, 30.4.2004, p. 100).
([6])            OJ
L 109, 19.4.2008, p. 27–29. 
([7])            The
Presidential decree No 412 of 1993 divides the Italian territory into six
climate zones (A to F). The classification is based on the unit ‘grades per day’
which represents the amount of days per year in which the outside temperature
differs from the optimum 20 C° and thus heating is needed.
([8])            OJ
L 352 of 24.12.2013, p.1.
([9])            OJ
L 204 of 31.7.2013, p. 15.
([10])           All
Italian islands, except Sicily.