Case T-425/04, T-444/04, T-450/04 and T-456/04: Judgment of the General Court of 21 May 2010 — France v Commission (State aid — Financial measures in favour of France Télécom — Draft shareholder’s advance — Public declarations by a member of the French Government — Decision declaring the aid incompatible with the common market and not ordering its recovery — Action for annulment — Interest in bringing proceedings — Admissibility — Meaning of State Aid — Advantage — State resources — Duty to state reasons)
Date: 2010-05-21
Institutions: General Court
Subjects: European Commission, France, State aid, action for annulment (EU), control of State aid, telecommunications industry








C_2010179EN.01002801.xml










3.7.2010   


EN


Official Journal of the European Union


C 179/28






Judgment of the General Court of 21 May 2010 — France v Commission
(Case T-425/04, T-444/04, T-450/04 and T-456/04) (1)

(State aid - Financial measures in favour of France Télécom - Draft shareholder’s advance - Public declarations by a member of the French Government - Decision declaring the aid incompatible with the common market and not ordering its recovery - Action for annulment - Interest in bringing proceedings - Admissibility - Meaning of State Aid - Advantage - State resources - Duty to state reasons)
(2010/C 179/46)
Language of the case: French

Parties


Applicants: (in Case T-425/04) French Republic (represented by: initially, G. de Bergues, R. Abraham and S. Ramet, subsequently, E. Belliard, M. de Bergues and S. Ramet and lastly, E. Belliard, M. de Bergues, A.-L. Vendrolini and J.-C. Niollet, Agents); (in Case T-444/04) France Télécom SA (Paris, France) (represented by: initially, A. Gosset-Grainville and S. Hautbourg, subsequently, S. Hautbourg, lawyers); (in Case T-450/04) Bouygues SA (Paris); Bouygues Télécom SA (Boulogne-Billancourt, France) (represented by: J. Vogel, F. Sureau, D. Théophile and J. Blouet Gaillard, lawyers); and (in Case T-456/04) Association française des opérateurs de réseaux et services de telecommunications (AFORS Télécom) (Paris) (represented by O. Fréget, F. Herrenschmidt, M. Struys and L. Eskenazi, lawyers)

Defendant: European Commission (represented by: C. Giolito and J. Buendía Sierra and subsequently C. Giolito and D. Grespan, Agents)

Interveners in support of the defendant: (in Cases T-450/04 and T-456/04) French Republic (represented by: (in Case T-450/04) E. Belliard, M. de Bergues, A.-L. Vendrolini and J.-C Niollet, and (in Case T-456/04) M. de Bergues, Agents); (in Case T-444/04) Bouygues SA (Paris); Bouygues Télécom SA (Boulogne-Billancourt) (represented by: J. Vogel, F. Sureau, D. Théophile and J. Blouet Gaillard, lawyers); and (in Cases T-450/04 and T-456/04) France Télécom SA (Paris) (represented by: initially, A. Gosset-Grainville and S. Hautbourg, subsequently, by S. Hautbourg, lawyers)

Re:

Actions for annulment of Commission Decision 2006/621/EC of 2 August 2004 on the State Aid implemented by France for France Télécom (OJ 2006 L 257, p. 11).

Operative part of the judgment

The Court:






1.


Annuls Article 1 of Commission Decision 2006/621/EC of 2 August 2004 on the State Aid implemented by France for France Télécom;










2.


Declares that it is no longer necessary to adjudicate on the claims for annulment of Article 2 of Decision 2006/621;










3.


In Cases T-425/04 and T-444/04, orders the European Commission to bear its own costs and to pay those incurred by the French Republic and by France Télécom SA;










4.


In Cases T-425/04 and T-444/04, orders Bouygues SA and Bouygues Télécom SA to bear their own costs;










5.


In Cases T-450/04, orders Bouygues SA and Bouygues Télécom SA to bear their own costs and to pay half of the costs incurred by the Commission;










6.


In Case T-450/04, orders the Commission to bear half of its own costs;










7.


In Case T-456/04, orders the Association française des opérateurs de réseaux et services de télécommunications (AFORS Télécom) and the Commission to bear their own costs;










8.


In Cases T-450/04 and T-456/04, orders French Republic and France Télécom to bear their own costs.






(1)  OJ C 19, 22.1.2005.