European Parliament resolution of 15 March 2007 on local authorities and development cooperation (2006/2235(INI))
Date: 2007-03-15
Institutions: Committee on Development, European Parliament
Subjects: EU aid, cooperation policy, developing countries, development aid, development policy, economic cooperation, governance, local authority

13.12.2007

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 301 E/249

Thursday 15 March 2007

P6_TA(2007)0083

Local authorities and development cooperation

European Parliament

resolution of 15 March 2007 on local authorities and development

cooperation (2006/2235(INI))

The European Parliament,

— having regard to Article 179 of the EC Treaty,

— having regard to the joint statement by the Council and the representatives of the governments of the
Member States meeting within the Council, the European Parliament and the Commission on European
‘The European Consensus’ (1), of 20 December 2005, which establishes
Union Development Policy:
ownership and partnership as the primary common principles of development cooperation, with
which the signatories thereto undertook to support decentralisation and good governance and which
encourages ‘increased involvement of local authorities’,

— having regard to Regulation (EC) No 1905/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of

18 December 2006 establishing a financing instrument for development cooperation (2),

— having regard to the Partnership Agreement between the members of the African, Caribbean and Pacific
Group of States, of the one part, and the European Community and its Member States, of the other
part, signed in Cotonou on 23 June 2000 (3), as amended by the Agreement amending the Partnership
Agreement, signed in Luxembourg on 25 June 2005 (4) (‘the Cotonou Agreement’), and in particular
Articles 4, 28, 30(2), 43(4) and 58(2) thereof,

— having regard to the Charter of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of Europe (CLRAE)
adopted by the Council of Europe Committee of Ministers on 14 January 1994 at its 506th meeting
of Ministers' Deputies,

— having regard to the Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament,
the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions of 25 January 2006
entitled ‘The Thematic Programme Non-State Actors and Local Authorities in Development’, which
reaffirms that local authorities are fully-fledged stakeholders in development and proposes to involve
them ‘in
support’
(COM(2006)0019),

development

including

financial

dialogue

through

process,

and

the

— having regard to the Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament
and the European Economic and Social Committee of 12 October 2005 entitled ‘EU Strategy for Africa:
Towards a Euro-African pact to accelerate Africa's development’ (that strategy having been adopted by
the European Council of 15-16 December 2005) in which the Commission undertakes to support
decentralisation and develop the capacities of local authorities, stressing the strategic importance of
partnership and twinnings between European and African towns and municipalities in order to support
the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and promote the conditions required
for their achievement (COM(2005)0489),

— having regard to the Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament
and the European Economic and Social Committee of 20 October 2003 on governance and develop-
ment, which establishes
European cooperation
as
(COM(2003)0615),

governance

a priority

area of

good

(1) OJ C 46, 24.2.2006, p. 1.
(2) OJ L 378, 27.12.2006, p. 41.
(3) OJ L 317, 15.12.2000, p. 3. Agreement last amended by Decision No 1/2006 of the Council of ACP-EC Ministers

(OJ L 247, 9.9.2006, p. 22).
(4) OJ L 209, 11.8.2005, p. 27.

C 301 E/250

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

13.12.2007

Thursday 15 March 2007

— having regard to the Commission's Introductory Note to the departments of its Directorate General for
Development and delegations in the ACP-ALA-MED countries (African, Caribbean and Pacific; Asian
and Latin American; Mediterranean) and CEEC (Central and Eastern European Countries) of 23 Decem-
ber 1999 (DEV/1424/2000), which advocates ‘that (decentralised) stakeholders be involved upstream in
policy formulation and programming’ and puts forward an Operational Guide for delegations in all
developing countries,

— having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 1659/98 of 17 July 1998 on decentralised cooperation (1),

— having regard to budget line B7-6002, entitled ‘decentralised cooperation’, which is intended to pro-

mote this approach in all developing countries,

— having regard to the opinion of the Committee of the Regions of 16 November 2005 on ‘Decentralised

cooperation in the reform of the EU's development policy’ (CdR 224/2005)

— having regard to the outcome statement of the Heads of State and Government on the MDGs at the
60th session of the United Nations General Assembly in September 2005, which underlines ‘the impor-
tant role of local authorities in contributing to the achievement of […] the Millennium Development
Goals’,

— having regard to report A/59/354 of the Secretary-General of the United Nations, submitted to the
59th session of the United Nations General Assembly on 13 September 2004, which recognises the
role of local authorities and global networks of local authorities, most notably the United Cities and
Local Governments (UCLG), as one of the UN's main partners in development and humanitarian issues
at local level,

— having regard to the Final Declaration of the ministers and representatives of governments at the Fourth
World Water Forum held in Mexico between16 and 22 March 2006, which states that efficient colla-
boration with local authorities is a key factor in meeting water-related challenges and MDGs,

— having regard to the Declaration of the World Summit on Sustainable Development, held in Johannes-
burg between 26 August and 4 September 2002, which states that the role and capacities of local
authorities must be strengthened to ensure sustainable development,

— having regard to the Final Declaration of the Second United Nations Conference on Human Settlement
(Habitat II), held in Istanbul between 3 and 15 June 1996, which recognises that local authorities are
closest partners of States in the implementation of the United Nations Agenda on human settlements,

— having regard to the Declaration on Environment and Development adopted at the Second Earth Sum-
mit, held in Rio de Janeiro between 3 and 14 June 1992, which stresses the key role of local authorities
in the implementation of Agenda 21, adopted by the signatories of the abovementioned declaration,

— having regard to the Declaration of the Constituent Congress of the UCLG held in Paris between 2 and
5 May 2004, at which 3000 mayors and elected representatives from local authorities the world over
undertook to implement MDGs at local level and work towards greater local autonomy and democracy
and towards cooperation between towns to promote development,

— having regard to the Final Declaration of the General Assembly of the Council of European Municipa-
lities and Regions (CEMR), held in Innsbruck between 10 and 12 May 2006, and the chapter entitled
‘From Local to Global’, which stresses the role of Europe and local authorities in the world,

— having regard to Rule 45 of its Rules of Procedure,

— having regard to the report of the Committee on Development (A6-0039/2007),

(1) OJ L 213, 30.7.1998, p. 6. Regulation last amended by Regulation (EC) No 625/2004 of the European Parliament

and of the Council (OJ L 99, 3.4.2004, p. 1).

13.12.2007

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 301 E/251

Thursday 15 March 2007

The expertise and added value of local authorities in development cooperation

A. whereas the achievement of the MDGs is an EU priority and whereas the crucial role of local autho-
rities in the implementation of these goals has been recognised by the United Nations, and in particu-
lar by the UN Secretary-General, who stated at the Millennium Summit in 2005: ‘How can we expect
to reach the Millennium Development Goals […] without making progress in areas such as education,
hunger, health, water, sanitation and gender equality? Cities and local authorities have a critical role to
play in all these areas. […] While our Goals are global, they can most effectively be achieved through
action at local level’,

B.

C.

whereas at the present rate it would take 110 years to achieve the MDGs set for 2015 and whereas the
experience of local authorities in a wide variety of development-related areas, such as water manage-
ment, the fight against AIDS, gender policy, waste management, social cohesion and local economic
development, should be recognised by the EU as a necessary contribution to the achievement of
MDGs,

whereas every child has the right to be enrolled in a registry office at birth and an essential role is
played by local authorities in this matter and there is a direct connection between this practice and the
application of the relevant human rights standards protecting children from exploitation through
work,

D. whereas good governance is one of the EU's priority objectives and whereas local democracy and
decentralisation lie at the very heart of democratic governance under the above-mentioned European
Consensus on Development,

E.

whereas, in 20 years' time, 60 % of the world's population will live in towns and cities and whereas
towns and cities will, as a result, have a major role to play in improving the living conditions of the
poorest sections of the population,

F.

whereas local authorities around the world acquire experience through:

— local authority-to-local authority projects funded or promoted by European local authorities
themselves, in partnership with Southern local authorities over a period of more than 30 years,

— local authority-to-local authority projects funded by the EU under the URB-AL (Latin America),
Asia URBS and, to a lesser extent, MEDA (Southern Mediterranean), ACCESS (Central and Eastern
Europe), Tacis (Eastern Europe and Central Asia) and CARDS (Balkans) programmes and the Mul-
tiannual Microproject Programmes (MMP) in the ACP countries,

— national or regional cooperation programmes to support decentralisation or local development, in
which local authorities and their associations are involved as operators, with the support of the
EU and other donors (United Nations, bilateral agencies, World Bank or regional development
banks, etc.),

G. whereas local authorities have the necessary political legitimacy, know-how and experience of running

local affairs and are able to mobilise other local stakeholders around them,

H. whereas, although the importance of involving local authorities in the cooperation process has been
acknowledged in the Cotonou Agreement and the European Consensus on Development, no perma-
nent mechanism has been set up to ensure that they can take part in dialogue with the Commission in
Europe and in developing countries; whereas, however, such a mechanism does exist in the case of
non-State actors,

In Europe

I.

whereas local authorities are already skilled players with long experience in development aid: they have
been experts in all areas of urban development and rural affairs for more than 30 years and are
constantly stepping up and diversifying their activities, thereby forming a solidarity network spanning
the five continents; whereas many of these activities are currently supported and financed by the
various States,

C 301 E/252

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

13.12.2007

Thursday 15 March 2007

J.

K.

L.

whereas national and regional associations of European local authorities are playing an increasingly
important role in terms of information, capacity building and dialogue and can thus become one of
the ‘key channels’ of the EU and other development partners for involving the local authorities they
represent in dialogue with the Commission in Europe,

whereas European local governments and their associations play a key role in informing, mobilising
and sensitising public opinion within the EU on a local basis, directly involving citizens; whereas this
contributes to the promotion of the values of solidarity and development aid, as shown by the ‘Mil-
lennium Cities Campaign’ launched in July 2005 by the UCLG with the support of the United Nations;
whereas, in this context, the European section of the UCLG, the CEMR, has been mobilising European
cities since April 2006 to promote and implement the MDGs,

whereas, in a growing number of municipalities and regions, local development awareness plans and
programmes are not confined to one-off actions but have instead established a comprehensive training
and information programme for local populations,

M. whereas local authorities are key players in the field of development, helping to dynamise and coordi-

nate economic and social operators at local level,

N. whereas the twinning links between towns and cities in Europe and in the South currently do not
receive any financial support from the EU, despite the growing number of cooperation initiatives set
up by European towns vis-à-vis their counterparts in Southern countries,

O. whereas immigrant populations in Europe play an important role in development cooperation and
offer added value in terms of their potential contributions, their skills and their closeness to their
countries of origin; whereas, in this context, decentralised cooperation is a key and appropriate area
of intervention for immigrant communities' international solidarity organisations with regard both to
activities set up in their countries of origin and to development education and awareness-raising pro-
jects in the host country,

In developing countries

P.

whereas ‘decentralised cooperation’, as defined by the EU since the Fourth Lomé Conevntion
(Lomé IV), signed on 15 December 1989, reflects a desire no longer to take decisions on aid to
developing countries solely with the third countries concerned, but to involve local authorities in
policy decisions and in implementing aid in order to ensure that it is more effective and viable;
whereas the aim is to make a lasting change to European cooperation procedures on the basis of
people's expectations so that projects are better geared to real needs,

Q. whereas participation in and ownership of development policies, which are priority principles for the
EU, must include the involvement of local authorities, since the fact that they extend over the whole
territory enables them to conduct a proximity policy and to communicate the expectations of the
people on a day-to-day basis, in particular in the most remote regions,

R.

S.

whereas local authorities have experience of local needs in all developing countries, in areas as diverse
as sanitation, education, health, housing, the promotion of women in local decision-making bodies,
information systems on drugs, tourism management, the protection of the urban historical heritage,
the development of local health services, water management and public transport,

whereas the decentralisation and State reforms currently taking place in most regions of the world
have resulted in local authorities asserting themselves as a sphere of government that is both distinct
and representative, with new responsibilities in extremely varied sectors of political activity, which are
essential for combating poverty and achieving the MDGs, such as primary health care, water, sanita-
tion, access to education, environmental protection, local economic development, HIV/AIDS preven-
tion and gender equality,

13.12.2007

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 301 E/253

T.

whereas the involvement of local authorities can contribute to strengthening local democracy and
democratisation of aid management at local level, in view of the role which national associations of
local authorities can play in this area in Southern countries,

Thursday 15 March 2007

U. whereas, wherever they have electoral

local authorities, midway
between national government and civil society, makes them an ideal intermediary to promote the
consultation between the various partners in the development process that is required for effective
and coordinated aid,

legitimacy, the strategic role of

V.

whereas local authorities which, being closer to local conditions than central government or interna-
tional donors, contribute specific added value, are better equipped to assess the local
impact of
national and international development strategies, and thus able to provide assistance that is better
geared to the specific needs of the areas under their administration,

W. whereas, with adequate resources,

local authorities could act as a stable framework enabling new

players to express themselves, organise themselves and adjust to European partnership requirements,

X.

Y.

whereas their specific knowledge of the area under their administration makes local authorities a
crucial lever in combating poverty and inequality,

whereas, for instance, in the Latin American region, the rapid development of urbanisation is placing
urban policies at the forefront of development issues and making towns and urban conurbations the
main interlocutors of governments in dealing with major social problems (migration, youth, poverty
and employment),

Z.

whereas there is a need to promote dialogue between local authorities and non-State actors for the
purpose of devising and implementing local development projects funded by the Community,

AA. whereas the involvement of local authorities in developing countries calls for a process of ownership
of development cooperation strategies, which requires, among other things, improvements in their
access to information, their organisational resources and representation mechanisms, and their capa-
cities for dialogue and initiative on cooperation policies, and involvement in national, regional and
international dialogue and consultation bodies,

AB. whereas the UCLG has a role to play in the restructuring and presentation of the needs of local

authorities in developing countries,

AC. whereas, despite this expertise in development, the role of local authorities in development has so far

been under-estimated and under-exploited,

Providing local authorities with the resources to play their role in the achievement of the Millennium
Development Goals

1.
Recalls that the Commission has for a long time been committed to giving local authorities a role as
full partners in development aid, its latest commitments being, for ACP countries, the Cotonou Agreement
and, for all developing countries, the moral underpinning of the abovementioned European Consensus on
Development;

2.
Recognises that the involvement of local authorities in development policies is essential for achieving
the MDGs and ensuring good governance; believes that ownership of development policies is a significant
step towards transparency and democracy in development aid and enables more effective and more viable
projects and programmes to be devised on the basis of beneficiaries' real needs;

3.
Stresses the importance of North-South and South-South partnerships between local authorities and
their representative associations in contributing to the strengthening of good governance and the achieve-
ment of the MDGs;

C 301 E/254

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

13.12.2007

Thursday 15 March 2007

4.
Calls on the Commission to support and strengthen direct cooperation between European local autho-
rities and their international partners; calls, in particular, for steps to be taken to ensure the continuity,
including in financial terms, of the solidarity networks set up by the URB-AL, Asia URBS and other pro-
grammes, due to end in 2007 at the latest, which all represent commitments made to people;

5.
Stresses that the principles of ownership, participation and good governance call for a multi-stake-
holder approach in which the various development partners, whether third countries, local authorities or
non-State actors, act in a complementary and coherent manner;

Stresses that local governments should enlist the support of the other local stakeholders (universities,

6.
social agents, development NGOs, companies, etc.) and stimulate citizens' participation in public life;

7.
Calls on the local stakeholders to work together with international organisations to monitor industry
and agriculture with the aim of preventing child labour and cooperating in the construction and mainte-
nance of adequate school facilities with trained teaching staff and free transport and meals, so that all
children are able to attend school;

Considers it important, however, to make a clear distinction between the specific role of local autho-
8.
rities and that of non-State actors, in terms of their sphere of competence, legitimacy and democratic con-
trol, experience in the management of local affairs and involvement in the implementation of public poli-
cies;

9. Welcomes the political recognition and the specific funds granted to local authorities by the above-
mentioned instrument for development cooperation (DCI): (a) local authorities are involved upstream in the
definition of the cooperation strategies of developing countries, the drawing up of geographic and thematic
programmes, their implementation and their evaluation; (b) up to 15 % of the thematic programme ‘non-
State actors and local authorities’ may be allocated directly to local authorities; (c) European local authorities
will be integrated in a structured political dialogue with the Community institutions and the other Northern
development stakeholders;

Calls on the Commission to refer,

10.
in future development cooperation financing instruments and
legislative texts, to the role of local authorities and their representative associations as ‘political partners’
and to ensure that they are involved in all phases of the cooperation process and have direct access to
Community funding;

11.
Calls on the Commission to specify in the country strategy papers the procedures and mechanisms
for more closely involving local authorities, their representative organisations and civil society partners in all
phases of the cooperation process (dialogues and formulation of strategy papers, programming, implemen-
tation, reviews, evaluations) and for EU delegations to be informed thereof in order to ensure their imple-
mentation;

12.
Calls on the Commission and the Council to recognise associations of Southern local authorities as
effective interfaces between local authorities on the one hand and the governments of the Member States
and the EU on the other, in defining strategies and implementing development policies;

13.
Regrets that, to date, local authorities in developing countries have only been involved in the imple-
mentation of projects and not in the definition of development policies, even in ACP countries, despite the
revision of the Cotonou Agreement which places political dialogue with local authorities at the heart of the
partnership; undertakes, therefore, to carry out a detailed political follow-up with associations of elected
representatives of the implementation of the DCI within both the EU and developing countries, in particular
by examining country strategy papers, and to inform local authorities of new opportunities open to them
and, in the event of difficulties on the ground raised by local authorities, to forward information to the
Commission;

13.12.2007

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 301 E/255

Thursday 15 March 2007

Stresses,

in this connection,

14.
the Commission's above-mentioned Introductory Note of
23 December 1999 put forward an Operational Guide for delegations in all developing countries which
clearly explained how to involve local authorities and non-State actors in each phase of the cooperation
process, advocated that decentralised stakeholders be ‘involved upstream in policy formulation and program-
ming’, and which remains a useful guide for the implementation of new development instruments;

that

15. Welcomes the fact that, in its abovementioned Communication of 25 January 2006, the Commission
reaffirms that local authorities are full stakeholders in development and proposes ‘involving non-State actors
and local authorities in the development process, including through dialogue and financial support’; stresses
that, in accordance with the new DCI provisions, this will mean providing for their involvement in the
devising of national strategies and geographic programmes, given that this is where Community cooperation
policy guidelines are defined; regrets therefore that, in the same Communication, the Commission restricts
the possibility of local authority involvement and considers it as secondary, in accordance with the principle
of subsidiarity, in relation to geographic programmes; considers, therefore, that cooperation between local
authorities and central government will make development aid more effective and enable more effective use
to be made of the funding earmarked and also allow aid to reach those most in need;

16.
Stresses the need to establish an ongoing dialogue and consultation between the EU and local autho-
rities and their representative associations at all levels, national, regional and global, in particular by invol-
ving them as observers in forums for dialogue between the EU and partner countries, such as the Joint
Parliamentary Assembly and the ACP-EU Council of Ministers, on the same terms as the representatives of
non-State actors;

17.
Calls for local authorities and their representative associations to be allowed to benefit from direct
and appropriate funding: (a) under DCI geographic programmes, in view of their role in local governance
and the importance of their participation in the achievement of the MDGs; (b) in the ‘non-State actors and
local authorities’ thematic programme, given that the enhancement of their capacity for dialogue and parti-
cipation in the cooperation process (organisation and representation, establishment of consultation, dialogue
and lobby mechanisms) in Europe and developing countries calls for financial support that is more in
keeping with their new responsibilities;

Calls, therefore, on the Commission for the revision of the coming development instruments in

18.
2008/2009:

— to ensure that decentralisation and local authority action become a focus of Community aid in devel-

oping countries;

— to see to it that a significant proportion of EU budgetary aid for geographic programmes to developing
countries is allocated directly to local authorities, in consultation with central governments, in order to
improve governance of aid in developing countries, to strengthen local democracy and to improve
access for populations to Community funds, in accordance with the principles laid down in the Euro-
pean Consensus on Development,

— to increase the budget line of the thematic programme on ‘Non-State actors and local authorities’, given
their comprehensive role in the achievement of the MDGs, in particular the role of local authorities in
the supply of local public services,

— to accelerate support for capacity building of ACP local government and information sharing under the
Cotonou Agreement, notably through the ACP Local Government Platform and its membership, includ-
ing the prompt putting into effect of the funding bid endorsed by the Committee of ACP Ambassadors
in October 2003;

— where decentralisation is not a focal point, to support the action of local authorities through aid to the
country's decentralisation policy in terms of capacities, fund availability, budgetary support, legislative
support or other forms of support;

— to set up mechanisms in order to allocate sectoral aid on a territorial basis with a view to ensuring that
local authorities play the role conferred on them by decentralisation laws, since local authorities provide
added value as regards the implementation of sectoral programmes, in particular in terms of health,
education and essential public services, but are at present often excluded from this process;

C 301 E/256

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

13.12.2007

Thursday 15 March 2007

19.
Stresses the importance of a structured dialogue between European local authorities and Community
institutions, as defined by the DCI, so that European local authorities are provided with a framework in
which they can effectively cooperate and dialogue with development institutions and other stakeholders;

Calls on the Commission to establish a partnership with a platform of associations representing local
20.
authorities active in the field of cooperation, modelled on Concord (European NGO Confederation for Relief
and Development) for NGOs, to facilitate dialogue and cooperation with Community institutions, coordinate
cooperation between local authorities and assist local authorities in implementing development policies, and
in particular strengthen the capacities of its members;

Calls on the Commission to set up an international monitoring centre for local democracy and

21.
decentralisation, in partnership with local authority organisations, to:
— monitor the involvement of local authorities in the process of cooperation with the EU (political dia-
logue, formulation of development strategies, programming, implementation and evaluation) and alert
the institutions of difficulties encountered on the ground,

— draw up a world map of local governance, listing projects, stakeholders, and budgets available to local
authorities around the world in order to facilitate coordination, coherence and synergy between the
various local government partners,

— create tools for the purpose of providing information and supporting the involvement of local autho-
rities in the European cooperation process, such as updated information on new opportunities available
to local authorities since the reform of aid, technical aid in order to respond to calls for tenders and
calls for proposals, etc.;

— monitor and analyse compliance with standards relating to democracy and human rights, notably those
relating specifically to local democracy and good governance as set out in relevant Community and
other internationally agreed standards such as those of the UN, the African Union, or the Common-
wealth;

22.
Calls on the Commission to promote structural measures aimed at providing an impetus to and
support for decentralisation and local capacity building in partner countries, together with greater democ-
racy and citizen participation;

Proposes the use of the mechanisms for revising cooperation strategies, including that of the Coto-
23.
nou Agreement, to monitor progress made in the involvement of local authorities in the cooperation pro-
cess and to seek to remove legal, political and organisational constraints on the involvement of local autho-
rities in the cooperation process;

Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council, the Commission and the parliaments

24.
and governments of the Member States.

*

*

*