Commission Regulation (EC) No 1551/2006 of 17 October 2006 imposing a provisional anti-dumping duty on imports of certain frozen strawberries originating in the People’s Republic of China
Date: 2006-10-17
Institutions: European Commission
Subjects: China, anti-dumping duty, frozen product, import, originating product, soft fruit

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/3

COMMISSION REGULATION (EC) No 1551/2006

of 17 October 2006

imposing a provisional anti-dumping duty on imports of certain frozen strawberries originating in
the People’s Republic of China

THE COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES,

Having regard to the Treaty establishing the European Community,

Having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 384/96 of 22 December 1995 on protection against dumped
imports from countries not members of the European Communities (1)
(the basic Regulation), and in
particular Article 7 thereof,

After consulting the Advisory Committee,

Whereas:

1.

INITIATION

A. PROCEDURE

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

On 19 January 2006 the Commission announced by a notice published in the Official Journal of the
European Union (2) the initiation of an anti-dumping proceeding with regard to imports into the
Community of certain frozen strawberries originating in the People’s Republic of China (PRC).

The proceeding was initiated as a result of a complaint lodged on 5 December 2005 by the Polish
Freezing Industry Union (the complainant) on behalf of producers representing a major proportion,
in this case more than 25 %, of the total Community production of certain frozen strawberries. The
complaint contained evidence of dumping of the product concerned and of material injury resulting
therefrom, which was considered sufficient to justify the initiation of a proceeding.

2. PARTIES CONCERNED BY THE PROCEEDING

The Commission officially advised the complaining Community producers, other Community
producers, the exporting producers, suppliers,
importers and users as well as user associations
known to be concerned, and the representatives of the PRC of the opening of the proceeding.
Interested parties were given an opportunity to make their views known in writing and to request
a hearing within the time limit set in the notice of initiation.

complainant producers, other

exporting producers,
The
interested parties, who so
importers, users and user associations made their views known. All
requested and showed that there were particular reasons why they should be heard, were granted
a hearing.

cooperating Community producers,

treatment

In order to allow exporting producers in the PRC to submit a claim for market economy treatment
the Commission sent market economy
(MET) or individual
they so wished,
treatment and individual
to the Chinese companies known to be
concerned. Five companies requested MET pursuant to Article 2(7) of the basic Regulation or
individual treatment should the investigation establish that they did not meet the conditions for
MET and one company requested only IT.

treatment claim forms

(IT),

if

(1) OJ L 56, 6.3.1996, p. 1. Regulation as last amended by Regulation (EC) No 2117/2005 (OJ L 340, 23.12.2005,

p. 17).

(2) OJ C 14, 19.1.2006, p. 14.

L 287/4

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(6)

(7)

In the notice of initiation, the Commission indicated that sampling for the determination of dumping
and injury in accordance with Article 17 of the basic Regulation may be applied. In order to enable
the Commission to decide whether sampling would be necessary and, if so, to select a sample, all
Community producers, exporting producers and unrelated importers were asked to make themselves
known to the Commission and to provide, as specified in the notice of initiation, basic information
on their activities related to the product concerned during the investigation period (1 January to 31
December 2005). After examination of the information submitted, and given the low number of
exporting producers in the PRC and unrelated importers which indicated their willingness to
cooperate, it was decided that sampling was only necessary with regard to Community producers.

The Commission sent questionnaires to all parties known to be concerned and to all other companies
that made themselves known within the deadlines set out in the notice of initiation. A total of 26
Community producers responded to the sample form. Questionnaire replies were received from eight
sampled complainant Community producers, five exporting producers in the PRC, two traders related
located in China, four unrelated importers and nine unrelated users in the Community. Submissions
were made by one more unrelated importer and one user. Submissions were also received from three
importer associations and four user associations.

(8)

The Commission sought and verified all the information deemed necessary for a provisional deter-
mination of dumping, resulting injury and Community interest and carried out verifications at the
premises of the following companies:

(a) Community producers (all based in Poland):

— Real SA, Siedlce

— Chłodnia SA, Kielce

— Polfrys Sp. z o.o., Swidwin

— Globus Polska, Lipno

— Przedsiebiorstwo Produkcyjno-Handlowe ‘Fructodor’ Sp. z o.o., Bolimow

— Hortino Lpow Sp. z o.o., Lezajsk

— POW Gomar, Pinczow

— Unifreeze Sp z. o.o., Miesiączkowo

(b) Exporting producers in the PRC

— Harbin Gaotai Food, Binzhou Town

— Dalian Dili Delicious Foods, Zhuanghe City

— Baoding Binghua Food, Baoding

— Yantai Yongchang Foodstuff, Laiyang City

— Dandong Junao Foodstuff, Fengcheng City

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/5

(c) Related traders in the PRC

— Shijiazhuang Fortune Foods, Shijiazhuang

— Shijiazhuang Golden Berry Trading, Shijiazhuang

(d) Community users

— Dirafrost Frozen Fruits Industry NV, Herk-de-Stad, Belgium

(9)

In light of the need to establish a normal value for exporting producers in the PRC to which MET
might not be granted, a verification to establish normal value on the basis of data from an analogue
country took place at the premises of the following companies:

Producers in Turkey

— Fine Food Gida Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S., Bursa

— Bidas Gida Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S., Bursa

— Penguen Gida Sanayi A.S., Bursa

3. SAMPLING

(10) With regard to the Community producers the Commission selected, in accordance with Article 17(1)
of the basic Regulation, a sample of eight companies based on the largest representative volume of
production in the Community (around 14 %), which could be reasonably investigated within the time
available. In accordance with Article 17(2) of the basic Regulation, the association of Community
producers was consulted and raised no objection. In addition, the remaining Community producers
were requested to provide certain general data for the injury analysis.

4.

INVESTIGATION PERIOD (IP)

(11)

The investigation of dumping and injury covered the period from 1 January to 31 December 2005
(IP). The examination of trends relevant for the assessment of injury covered the period from 1
January 2002 to the end of the investigation period (period considered).

5. PRODUCT CONCERNED AND LIKE PRODUCT

5.1. General

(12)

Frozen strawberries are normally used by the food processing industry for the production of jams,
fruit juices, yoghurts and other dairy products. Only a small part is sold to the retail industry and
catering industry for direct consumption. Frozen strawberries must normally be consumed within a
one-year period in order to ensure that the characteristics in terms of taste and colour are preserved.
The product is normally produced to standard specifications which are then altered to fit the
demands of the end user.

5.2. Product concerned

(13)

The product concerned is strawberries, uncooked or cooked by steaming or boiling in water, frozen,
whether or not containing added sugar or other sweeteners, originating in the People’s Republic of
China currently classifiable within CN codes 0811 10 11, 0811 10 19 and 0811 10 90. These CN
codes are only given for information.

L 287/6

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(14)

The investigation has shown that, despite differences in varieties, quality, size and post-processing, the
different types of the product concerned all share the same basic physical and biological character-
istics and are basically used for the same purposes. They are therefore considered to constitute one
single product.

5.3. Like product

(15)

It has been argued by some interested parties that there are significant differences between the
product concerned and the product produced by the Community industry. These differences relate
mainly to the differences in the strawberry varieties and species used, the quality and the final use of
the product. However, the investigation has shown that all types of the product concerned produced
and sold on the domestic market of the PRC, and on the domestic market of Turkey, which served as
analogue country, as well as the frozen strawberries produced and sold in the Community by the
Community producers were, despite differences in some factors such as, inter alia, quality and post
treatments, shapes and sizes, found to have the same basic physical and biological characteristics and
uses.

(16)

It is therefore provisionally concluded that all types of frozen strawberries form one product and are
considered to be alike within the meaning of Article 1(4) of the basic Regulation.

6. MARKET ECONOMY TREATMENT

B. DUMPING

(17)

Pursuant to Article 2(7)(b) of the basic Regulation, in anti-dumping investigations concerning imports
originating in the PRC, normal value shall be determined in accordance with paragraphs 1 to 6 of the
said Article for those producers which were found to meet the criteria laid down in Article 2(7)(c) of
the basic Regulation.

(18)

Briefly, and for ease of reference only, the MET criteria are set out in summarised form below:

1. Business decisions and costs are made in response to market conditions and without State

interference.

2. Accounting records are independently audited, in line with international accounting standards and

applied for all purposes.

3. There are no significant distortions carried over from the former non-market economy system.

4. Legal certainty and stability is provided by bankruptcy and property laws.

5. Currency exchanges are carried out at the market rate.

(19)

In the present investigation, five exporting producers in the PRC requested MET pursuant to Article
2(7)(b) of the basic Regulation and replied to the MET claim form within the given deadlines. Where
a subsidiary or any other company related to the applicant in the PRC is an exporter of the product
concerned, the related party was also invited to complete the MET claim form and visited on the
it is the Commission’s consistent practice to examine whether a group of related
spot. Indeed,
companies as a whole fulfils the conditions for MET.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/7

(20)

The investigation revealed that one of the five Chinese exporting producers fulfilled all conditions to
be granted MET. The remaining four claims had to be rejected.

(21)

The following table summarises the determination for each company not granted MET, against each
of the five criteria as set out in Article 2(7)(c) of the basic Regulation:

Company

1

2

3

4

5

Criteria

1

2

3

4

5

not met

not met

not met

not met

not met

not met

met

met

met

not met

met

met

not met

not met

not met

met

met

met

met

met

met

met

met

met

met

(22) On this basis, the following exporting producer in the PRC was granted MET:

Yantai Yongchang Foodstuff.

(23)

Regarding the four companies that could not be granted MET, three of them were found not to meet
criterion 1. Two companies, although owned by private shareholders, were found to have business
licences with particularly short validity terms, which made them dependent on the willingness of the
authorities to issue a new business licence each time the validity of the existing business licence came
to an end, thereby also leaving scope for State interference. The uncertainty about the businesses’
future was also mirrored by the shareholders’ reluctance to provide the companies with sufficient
capital, constituting a major problem in the capital-intensive market of frozen strawberries. Regarding
the third company, it was established that purchase prices of fresh strawberries, i.e. the major raw
material input to produce/process frozen strawberries, were fixed for the whole season irrespective of
quality and seasonal fluctuations. Therefore that company could not demonstrate that the costs of its
major inputs substantially reflected market values.

(24) Notwithstanding the fact that two companies met criterion 1 it is noted that all five companies
benefited from a subsidy. All companies were found to purchase fresh strawberries from local
farmers. The farmers did not pay any VAT on these strawberry sales.
the
producers of the product concerned deducted an ‘implied VAT’ on these purchases from the VAT
liable on their sales of frozen strawberries. However, while the companies may have benefited from
lower costs as a result of this mechanism, the effect on overall costs remains limited and any benefit
to the companies from these lower costs could be corrected by a normal value adjustment.

In turn, however,

(25) None of the four companies that were not granted MET met criterion 2. In some of these cases, the
accounts were not kept in a coherent manner and violated international accounting standards. Also,
the audits did not point at several accounting inconsistencies or at a severe financial situation of one
company. These facts shed doubts on the reliability and independence of the audits. In two other
cases, accounting inaccuracies were observed which are in conflict with international accounting
standards. Again,
It was therefore
concluded that the four companies in question could not demonstrate that they had one clear set
of basic accounting records which are independently audited in line with international standards.

these accounting law breaches.

the audits did not point at

L 287/8

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(26)

Three of the four companies that were not granted MET failed to meet criterion 3. In one case the
land-use rights had neither been evaluated nor referred to in the balance sheet. Also, this company
rented warehouses from third parties but the rent charged did not single out electricity costs. Then,
an irregular depreciation practice and the evidence of barter trade regarding fixed assets were
In case of another company land-use rights were rented at
observed for the same company.
favourable conditions and depreciation inconsistencies were also found. Regarding the third
company, six out of seven loans were not secured by any guarantees. In these three cases, it was
concluded that the third criterion was not met because the production costs and/or the financial
situation of these companies were subject to significant distortions carried over from the former non-
market economy system.

7.

INDIVIDUAL TREATMENT (IT)

(27)

Pursuant to Article 2(7)(a) of the basic Regulation, a country-wide duty, if any, is established for
countries falling under that Article, except in those cases where companies are able to demonstrate
that they meet all criteria set out in Article 9(5) of the basic Regulation.

(28)

Individual treatment could be granted to the following exporting producer:

Junao Foodstuff Co., Ltd.

8. NORMAL VALUE

8.1. General methodology

(29)

In accordance with Article 2(2) of the basic Regulation, the Commission first established for the
exporting producer concerned whether its total domestic sales of frozen strawberries were represen-
tative, i.e. whether the total volume of such sales represented at least 5 % of its total volume of
export sales of the product concerned to the Community.

(30)

The Commission subsequently identified those product types sold domestically by the company
having overall representative domestic sales that were identical or directly comparable with the
types sold for export to the Community.

(31)

For each type sold by the exporting producers on its domestic market and found to be directly
comparable with the type of frozen strawberries sold for export to the Community, it was established
whether domestic sales were sufficiently representative for the purposes of Article 2(2) of the basic
Regulation. Domestic sales of a particular product type were considered sufficiently representative
when the volume of that product type sold on the domestic market to independent customers during
the IP represented at least 5 % of the total volume of the comparable product type sold for export to
the Community.

(32)

The Commission subsequently examined for the company concerned whether each type of the
product concerned sold domestically in representative quantities could be considered as being sold
in the ordinary course of trade pursuant to Article 2(4) of the basic Regulation. This was done by
establishing for each product type the proportion of profitable sales to independent customers on the
domestic market during the investigation period.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/9

8.2. Determination of normal value for exporting producers granted MET

(33)

The determination of normal value for exporting producers granted MET was done in accordance
with the methodology set out above. The investigation showed that the exporting producer granted
MET had overall representative domestic sales. Furthermore, it was found that domestic prices were
made in the ordinary course of trade, i.e. domestic prices could be used for all types sold by the
Chinese producer.

8.3. Determination of normal value for all exporting producers not granted MET or

granted IT

(a) Analogue country

(34) According to Article 2(7) of the basic Regulation, normal value for companies to which MET could
not be granted, was established on the basis of the prices or constructed value in an analogue
country.

(35)

In the notice of initiation, the Commission indicated its intention to use the USA as an appropriate
analogue country for the purpose of establishing normal value for the PRC and interested parties
were invited to comment.

(36)

Some European processors objected to this proposal, indicating that the USA was not considered an
appropriate analogue country because of its different production patterns, particularly the labour
costs. Questionnaires were sent to all known producers in the USA but no reply was received. The
USA could therefore not be chosen as analogue country.

(37)

The Commission therefore considered alternative solutions and it was found that Turkey could be
considered an appropriate analogue country.
Indeed, the investigation revealed that Turkey is a
competitive market for the said product with various domestic producers of different sizes. The
domestic producers were found to produce similar product types as in the PRC, driven by the
specifications requested by the European processors, and have similar production methods. The
Turkish market was therefore deemed sufficiently representative for the purpose of establishing
normal value. No objections were raised to this choice of analogue country.

(38) All known producers in Turkey were contacted and three companies accepted to cooperate. A
questionnaire was therefore sent to these producers and the data submitted in their reply was
verified on the spot.

(39) While the association representing users agreed to the choice of Turkey as an analogue country, one
exporter disagreed with that choice, arguing that Turkish strawberries are of much better quality than
the Chinese ones. Allegedly, they were often wild in contrast to the Chinese farmed strawberries and
of different varieties.

(b) Determination of normal value in the analogue country

(40)

Following the choice of Turkey as an analogue country and pursuant to Article 2(7)(a) of the basic
Regulation, normal value for the exporting producers not granted MET or granted IT was established
on the basis of verified information received from the three producers in the analogue country, i.e. on
the basis of prices paid or payable, in accordance with the methodology set out above.

L 287/10

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(41)

The domestic sales of the three Turkish producers of the like product were found to be representative
compared to the product concerned exported to the Community by the exporting producers in the
PRC.

(42)

The investigation showed that their sales volumes, sold at a net sales price equal to or above the unit
cost, represented more than 80 % of the total sales volume of each producer. Therefore, their
domestic sales were considered to be made in the ordinary course of trade.

9. EXPORT PRICES

(43) As the product concerned was in all cases exported to independent customers in the Community, the
export price was established in accordance with Article 2(8) of the basic Regulation, namely on the
basis of export prices actually paid or payable.

10. COMPARISON

(44)

The normal value and export prices were compared on an ex-works basis. For the purpose of
ensuring a fair comparison between the normal value and the export price, due allowance in the
form of adjustments was made for differences affecting prices and price comparability in accordance
the basic Regulation. Appropriate adjustments concerning transport and
with Article 2(10) of
insurance, credit, commission and bank charges were granted where they were found to be
reasonable, accurate and supported by verified evidence. Regarding the normal value data
stemming from the analogue country, an adjustment was made regarding physical differences
pursuant to Article 2(10)(a) of the basic Regulation as it was found that strawberries produced
and sold in Turkey were of better quality than those exported by Chinese producers (see recital
40). Equally, Turkish strawberries were of better quality than those produced by the Community
industry. This adjustment was provisionally estimated at 30 % of the Turkish sales value. This
percentage reflected approximately the price difference between Turkish strawberries sold on the
domestic market and that of Community industry sales prices.

11. DUMPING MARGIN

11.1. Determination of dumping margins for the cooperating exporting producer granted

MET/IT

(a) MET

(45)

For the company granted MET the weighted average normal value of the product concerned exported
to the Community was compared with the weighted average export price, as provided for under
Article 2(11) and (12) of the basic Regulation.

On this basis the provisional weighted average dumping margin expressed as a percentage of the CIF
Community frontier price duty unpaid is;

Yantai Yongchang Foodstuff Co. 0 %.

(b) IT

(46)

For the company granted IT, the weighted average normal value established for the analogue country
was compared with the weighted average export price to the Community, as provided for under
Article 2(11) of the basic Regulation.

(47) On this basis, the provisional weighted average dumping margin expressed as a percentage of the CIF

Community frontier price duty unpaid is:

Dandong Junao Foodstuff Co. 31,1 %.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/11

(48)

(49)

12. DETERMINATION OF DUMPING MARGINS FOR ALL OTHER EXPORTING PRODUCERS

In order to calculate the country-wide dumping margin applicable to all other exporters in the PRC,
the Commission first established the level of cooperation. A comparison was made between the total
imports of the product concerned originating in the PRC calculated on the basis of Eurostat and the
volume of exports as reported in the questionnaire replies submitted by the exporters in the PRC. On
this basis it was established that the level of cooperation was low, i.e. 37 % of the overall Chinese
exports to the Community.

The dumping margin was consequently calculated as follows: The export price for cooperating
exporters was established on the basis of the verified information they had provided. Secondly, an
export price was established on the basis of Eurostat data, thus counting the Eurostat-reported
quantity that exceeded the quantities reported by cooperating exporters. The two export prices
were then weighted in accordance with their respective quantities and were compared with the
weighted average normal value established for the analogue country. The use of Eurostat data was
necessary in the absence of more information on export prices for determining the country-wide
duty.

(50) On this basis the country-wide level of dumping was provisionally established at 66,9 % of the CIF

Community frontier price.

13. COMMUNITY PRODUCTION

C. INJURY

(51)

In the course of the present investigation it was found that frozen strawberries were manufactured in
the Community by:

— 26 Community producers which were complainants or explicitly supported the complaint. None
of these producers was related to any Chinese exporters or importers of the product concerned
from the PRC,

— a large number of Community producers that did not take a position on the complaint (silents)
and did not cooperate with the investigation. Many of these producers are known to be related to
the user/importer sector.

14. DEFINITION OF THE COMMUNITY INDUSTRY

(52)

The proceeding was initiated as a result of a complaint lodged by the Polish Freezing Industry Union
(the complainant) on behalf of 25 producers representing a major proportion of
the total
Community production of certain frozen strawberries.

(53)

the complaining Community producers

together with other
The investigation showed that
Community producers supporting the complaint and that replied to the sample exercise had
produced around 41 100 tonnes of frozen strawberries in the IP. This represents around 29 % of
the total volume of the like product produced in the Community and thus constitutes a major
proportion of the Community production. The 25 complaining Community producers and the
one other Community producer supporting the complaint are therefore deemed to constitute the
Community industry within the meaning of Articles 4(1) and 5(4) of the basic Regulation. It was
argued by certain interested parties that some of the 26 cooperating companies had withdrawn their
support for the proceedings. However, to the contrary, none of the 26 companies has withdrawn
their support.

L 287/12

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

15. SAMPLING FOR INJURY ASSESSMENT PURPOSES

(54) As explained in recital 10 above, in view of the large number of producers of frozen strawberries in
the Community, the Commission selected a sample in accordance with Article 17 of the basic
Regulation consisting of eight producers that represented the largest representative volume of
production that could reasonably be investigated within the time available.

(55)

The accumulated production of the eight Community producers selected for the sample that fully
cooperated in the investigation was around 19 200 tonnes during the IP, or around 14 % of the
estimated total Community production of frozen strawberries.

16. COMMUNITY CONSUMPTION

(56) During the period considered the Community consumption developed as follows:

Tonnes

2002

2003

2004

IP

Community consumption

202 353

213 083

238 144

210 285

Index 2002 = 100

100

105

118

104

(57)

Community consumption was established on the basis of the total volume of production of frozen
strawberries by the Community industry and other producers of the product in the Community plus
imports from all
third countries and excluding all exports. The figures concerning the total
production of the product concerned by the Community industry and other producers in the
Community derive from estimates from the relevant authorities and associations in the Member
States where frozen strawberries are produced, notably IERiGEZ for Poland, FruitVeb for Hungary,
Assomela for Italy and the Ministry of Agriculture in Spain. Imported and exported quantities were
derived from Eurostat.

(58)

It should be noted that the consumption figures include volumes of frozen strawberries that were
stocked. However, as neither reliable sales nor stock data could be obtained for all Community
producers of the like product, data concerning the total production of the like product from all
Community producers is considered to be the most reliable source.

(59) As presented in the above table, the consumption of frozen strawberries in the Community has been
relatively stable over the period considered with the exception of 2004 where consumption increased
by 13 % in comparison to the previous year. This increase can however be explained by a combi-
nation of a return to high production level in the Community because of a good harvest and the
continuation of large import volumes. In the IP the consumption stabilised at the level of the years
2002 and 2003.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/13

17.

IMPORTS INTO THE COMMUNITY FROM THE PRC

17.1. Volume and market share of imports of the product concerned

(60)

The evolution of imports from the country concerned, in volume and market share, has been the
following:

Import volumes

2002

2003

2004

IP

8 941

37 925

30 622

43 025

100

424

342

481

PRC in tonnes

Index 2002 = 100

Source: Eurostat.

Market shares of the imports

2002

2003

2004

IP

PRC

4 %

18 %

13 %

20 %

(61) Whereas the consumption of

frozen strawberries remained relatively stable during the period
considered, the imports from the country concerned have risen by around 381 % during the same
period. In consequence, the estimated market share of the PRC has increased significantly during the
period considered from 4 % in 2002 to 20 % in the IP.

17.2. Prices of imports and price undercutting

EUR/tonne

2002

2003

2004

IP

745

738

605

100

99

81

461

62

Import prices from the PRC

Index 2002 = 100

Source: Eurostat.

(62)

The above table shows the development of average import prices from the PRC. Over the period
considered prices fell continuously by a total of 38 %.

(63) A comparison of selling prices on the Community market during the IP was made between the prices
of the sampled Community industry and imports from the country concerned. The relevant sales
prices of the sampled Community industry were those to independent customers, adjusted where
necessary to an ex-works level, i.e. excluding freight costs in the Community and after deduction of
discounts and rebates. These prices were compared with the sales prices charged by the Chinese
exporting producers net of discounts and adjusted where necessary to cif Community frontier with an
appropriate adjustment for the customs clearance costs and post-importation costs.

(64)

The comparison showed that during the IP imports of the product concerned were sold in the
the Community industry’s prices, when expressed as a
Community at prices which undercut
percentage of
the latter by 6,0 % based on the data submitted by the cooperating exporting
producers and by 6,4 % based on Eurostat data which covers all imports. From this level of under-
cutting and the price development of the Community industry (see recital 74), as explained below, it
is clear that substantial price depression had already taken place.

L 287/14

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

18. SITUATION OF THE PRODUCERS IN THE COMMUNITY

(65)

In line with standard practice, the following recitals break down data collected in the injury invest-
igation into two sections. The first of these relate to the Community industry represented by the eight
sampled companies. The second section relates to a set of data concerning all producers of the
product concerned in the Community. This data was obtained from national authorities and asso-
ciations of Member States where the product concerned was produced.

18.1. Situation of the Community industry

(66)

In accordance with Article 3(5) of the basic Regulation, the examination of the impact of the dumped
imports on the Community industry included an evaluation of all economic factors and indices
having a bearing on the state of the industry from 2002 to the IP.

(67)

the eight cooperating
The Community industry data below is the aggregated information of
Community producers included in the sample. This data represents the 26 cooperating producers
which submitted sampling returns.

18.1.1. Production, production capacity and capacity utilisation

(68)

The table below indicates the evolution of production, production capacity and capacity utilisation of
the sampled Community producers:

Production (tonnes)

Indices 2002 = 100

2002

2003

2004

IP

26 000

16 555

26 912

19 198

100

64

104

74

Production capacity (tonnes)

34 546

36 384

39 934

39 934

Indices 2002 = 100

Capacity utilisation

Indices 2002 = 100

100

105

116

116

75 %

46 %

67 %

48 %

100

60

90

64

(69) As shown in the table above, production during the period considered decreased by 26 % while the
capacity increased by 16 %. The capacity utilisation decreased over the same period by 36 %. The
decrease in capacity utilisation can only partly be related to the increase in capacity. The main reason
for the drop in capacity utilisation is the decrease in production,
i.e. the harvest in the year in
question.

(70)

Production of frozen strawberries is closely linked to the production of fresh strawberries. The size
and quality of the harvest is therefore decisive for the production volume of the product concerned.
The harvest of 2003 was poor leading to a decrease in production whereas the abundant harvest of
2004 led to the reverse, thereby leading to a slight increase of production levels in comparison with
2002. Between 2004 and the IP, production dropped by 29 %. However, bearing in mind that
production of frozen strawberries is dependent on the size of the fresh fruit harvest, the fall
in
production from 2004 to the IP is not considered to be a useful injury indicator for this product.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/15

18.1.2. Stocks

(71)

The figures below represent the volume of stocks of the sampled Community industry at the end of
each period.

Stocks (tonnes)

Index 2002 = 100

2002

2003

2004

IP

10 969

9 482

21 055

13 586

100

86

192

124

(72)

It should be noted that stocked frozen strawberries must normally be consumed and thus sold within
a one-year period in order to ensure that the characteristics in terms of taste and colour are
preserved.

(73)

Stocks have increased considerably during the period considered. The decrease in stock in the year
2003 was a result of the poor harvest that in turn had an impact on the availability of raw materials
to the Community industry in this year. In 2004 stocks increased significantly due to the abundant
yield of the harvest 2004. In comparison with 2002 the stocks increased by 92 % in 2004. Following
this peak, stock levels returned to more normal levels in the IP but were still 24 % higher than in
2002. Between 2004 and the IP a rather massive sell off of the stocks took place to ensure that the
frozen strawberries still had the required quality.

18.1.3. Sales volume, market share and average sales prices

(74)

The figures below represent the sales volume, market share and average unit sales prices of the
sampled Community industry.

Sales volume of sampled Community industry in tonnes

27 428

18 201

14 647

26 240

2002

2003

2004

IP

Indices 2002 = 100

Market share

Indices 2002 = 100

Average sales prices (EUR/tonne)

Indices 2002 = 100

100

66

53

96

13,6 %

8,5 %

6,2 %

12,5 %

100

934

100

63

45

1 382

1 019

148

109

92

671

72

(75)

The Community industry’s sales volumes and market share went down in 2003 as a result of the lack
of raw materials i.e. fresh strawberries, in that year. The sales and market share decreased even further
in 2004 despite a return to normal production levels. This decrease in sales led to increased stock
levels. In the IP the sales volume recovered partly from the selling-off of the stock. The return of the
large sales volumes was however at the expense of the average sales price that saw a massive decrease
from EUR 1 019 per tonne in 2004 to EUR 671 per tonne in the IP, i.e. by 34 %.

L 287/16

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(76)

The average prices of the product concerned sold by the sampled Community industry decreased by
28 % in the period considered leading to a substantial price depression in the IP. As mentioned above
the drop in average prices was most significant between the year 2004 and the IP where a 34 %
decrease in sales prices occurred. Indeed, the massive sell off of stock from 2004 to the IP had to be
made at very low prices.

18.1.4. Profitability, return on investments and cash flow

(77)

The profitability shown below relates to sales on the Community market and is expressed as return
on turnover (RoT), return on investments, (ROI) and cash flow.

2002

2003

2004

IP

Profitability on Community sales (RoT)

6,5 %

9,4 %

– 1,5 %

– 12,5 %

Indices 2002 = 100

100

144

– 23

– 191

Return on investments (RoI)

55 %

36 %

– 4 %

– 24 %

Indices 2002 = 100

Cash flow (as percentage of turnover)

Indices 2002 = 100

100

2 %

100

66

3 %

143

– 7

– 1 %

– 64

– 44

0 %

5

(78)

The RoT above shows a steep fall between 2002 and the IP. The fall corresponds to a decline of
almost 300 %. This is particularly serious because the apparent reasonable profits made in 2002 and
2003 have been followed by unsustainable losses of 12,5 % in the IP.

(79)

The RoT, RoI and cash flow all show that, over the period considered, the situation of the sampled
producers has deteriorated.

18.1.5. Investments and ability to raise capital

(80)

The trend for the investments of the sampled Community industry is shown in the following table.

Investments (EUR)

Indices 2002 = 100

2002

2003

2004

IP

3 106 428

9 963 701

10 122 277

12 131 394

100

321

326

391

(81) Despite the negative development seen for profitability above, the Community industry has increased
its investments in the product concerned in order to improve its competitiveness in respect of the
product concerned. The investments were mainly made for new buildings and to update cold storage
buildings and equipment. These steps have significantly contributed to improving the sampled
Community industry's efficiency.

(82) No evidence was provided to the Commission in respect of a reduced or increased ability to raise

capital over the period considered.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/17

18.1.6. Employment, productivity and wages

Number of employees

Indices 2002 = 100

Productivity (tonne/employee)

Indices 2002 = 100

Wages (EUR)

Indices 2002 = 100

2002

390

100

67

100

2003

301

77

55

82

2004

445

114

60

91

IP

368

94

52

78

2 572 050

1 644 557

2 065 347

2 182 047

100

64

80

85

(83) As seen above, the sampled Community industry adapted the number of employees in relation to the
production levels. The number of employees peaked in 2004 as a result of the return to high
production volumes following the low volume of 2003. Due to the decrease in production in the
IP the productivity and the employment numbers declined. The cost of wages has decreased in the
period considered. The decrease in productivity per employee is largely explained by the sharp drop
in production as a consequence from increased imports. The investments made by the Community
industry during the IP are expected to increase the efficiency and productivity of the industry in the
mid and long term.

18.1.7. Magnitude of the actual margin of dumping

(84)

The dumping margins are specified above in the dumping section. All margins established but the
one for a company that was awarded MET are clearly above de minimis. Furthermore, given the
volumes and the prices of the dumped imports, the impact of the actual margin of dumping cannot
be considered to be negligible.

18.1.8. Effects of past dumping or subsidisation

(85)

The Community industry is not recovering from the effects of past dumping or subsidisation since no
such previous investigations have been made.

18.2. Macroeconomic data of Community production as a whole

(86)

The following data concerns the Community production as a whole.

(87)

It should be recalled from the consumption data, that no official figures on total Community sales
volumes are available.
In order to estimate the total sales volume of producers active on the
Community market, the production of the said producers was reduced by an amount for exports.

Production volume available for sale (production
minus exports) (tonnes)

Indices 2002 = 100

Market share

Indices 2002 = 100

2002

2003

2004

IP

139 705

108 865

145 596

124 320

100

69 %

100

78

51 %

74

104

61 %

89

89

59 %

86

L 287/18

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(88) As explained above, the above table is based on the relevant production volume minus exports. It
therefore shows the quantities available for sale, which would either be sold during the same season
or stocked and then sold in the following season. This data is therefore production based rather than
sales based. Nevertheless, the above data would suggest a decrease over the period investigated, both
in terms of total sales volume (– 11 %) and market share (– 14 %) of the Community industry as a
whole.

18.3. Conclusion on injury

(89)

In the first place, it is noted that the following injury indicators showed negative trends during the
period considered: sales prices and quantities, profitability, stocks, capacity utilisation, production,
employment, wages, productivity, cash flow and market share. However, for the reasons given above,
the trend in production and capacity utilisation are not deemed to be particularly useful indicators of
injury for this product. On the contrary, positive developments were identified in respect of
investments and production capacity.

(90)

It is recalled that during the period considered, the volume of dumped imports of the product
concerned from the PRC has increased by over 300 % while the sales prices declined sharply
(– 38 %). Moreover,
the Community industry were substantially
the sales prices of
undercut by those of the dumped imports of the product concerned by around 6 %.

in the IP,

(91) As a consequence, during the period considered the situation of the Community industry substan-
tially deteriorated. Stock levels increased by 24 %, reaching serious levels at the end of 2004. At the
same time, sales prices and in particular sales volumes were significantly reduced in 2004. It was not
until the IP that the sales volume returned to the 2002 levels but this was at the expense of reducing
prices to unsustainable levels. Notwithstanding the industry’s continuing investments to increase its
in prices caused profitability levels to plummet to – 12,5 % in the IP.
competitiveness, this fall
Moreover, its cash flow and return on investment also declined, reaching negative levels in the IP.

(92)

Furthermore, over the period investigated there has been a decline in the total number of persons
employed as well as productivity.

(93)

To conclude, the injury consists primarily in price depression along with an increase in stocks. This
resulted in heavy losses for the Community producers during the IP.

(94)

Bearing in mind that the Community-wide consumption and market shares of the entire Community
industry had to be estimated, care has been taken to restrict this aspect of the injury analysis to the
Community industry included in the sample.

(95)

Taking into account all of these factors, the provisional conclusion reached is that the Community
industry has suffered material injury within the meaning of Article 3 of the basic Regulation.

19. PRELIMINARY REMARK

D. CAUSATION

(96)

In accordance with Article 3(6) and (7) of the basic Regulation, it was also examined whether there is
a causal link between the dumped imports from the PRC and the injury suffered by the Community
industry. Known factors other than the dumped imports, which could at the same time have injured
the Community industry, were also examined to ensure that the possible injury caused by these other
factors was not attributed to the dumped imports.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/19

20.

IMPACT OF THE IMPORTS FROM THE PRC

(97)

It is recalled that import volumes from the PRC increased by around 380 % and their estimated
market share almost quadrupled during the period considered. In addition, as has been explained at
recital 62, import prices from the PRC fell by 38 % and substantial price undercutting was taking
place.

(98)

(99)

The Community industry reacted to the large import volumes at sharply reduced price levels, by
decreasing its sales price in 2004. Despite this decrease, the average sales price of the Chinese imports
remained more than 30 % lower than the Community industry’s prices. As a result, sales by the
Community fell significantly in this season and left the Community producers with a very high level
of stock at the end of the year. Given the limitation of cold storage capacity and, more importantly,
taking into account the fact that frozen strawberries have a limited life span, the end-2004 stock had
to be sold off in the IP. Given that Chinese prices in the IP had dropped further in comparison to
2004, the Community industry had again to drop its prices (by almost 24 %) in order to sell off these
stocks. The sales in the IP were well below profit and are no longer sustainable. The situation of the
Community industry in the IP was further aggravated by the massive increase of more than 40 % in
import volumes from the PRC. It is therefore clear that there is a strong link between the significant
increase in imports volumes at ever-lower prices and the injury observed with the Community
industry.

21.

IMPACT OF IMPORTS FROM THIRD COUNTRIES

The volume of non-Chinese imports decreased by 20 % during the period considered. It is therefore
very unlikely that
imports originating in other third countries, such as Morocco, could have
contributed in any significant way to the injury suffered by the Community industry. On the
contrary, it would appear that third country exporting producers have also lost market shares as a
result of the imports from the PRC. In addition, the average prices of imports from other third
countries were in the IP 78 % higher than those originating in the PRC and around 20 % higher than
those of the sampled Community industry. It can therefore be provisionally concluded from the
decreasing market share and their relatively high price levels that third country exporting producers’
sales did not cause injury to the Community industry. The following table indicates the import
volumes and average prices from imports originating in the main other third countries (i.e.
Morocco and Turkey).

Imports from Morocco (tonnes)

25 532

35 253

47 079

30 406

2002

2003

2004

IP

Index 2002 = 100

Average prices (EUR/tonne)

Index 2002 = 100

Market share

Index 2002 = 100

100

820

100

138

994

12

18

824

100

119

691

84

11,7 %

15,0 %

18,7 %

13,0 %

100

128

Imports from Turkey (tonnes)

10 503

9 312

Index 2002 = 100

Average prices (EUR/tonne)

Index 2002 = 100

Market share

Index 2002 = 100

100

1 394

100

4,8 %

100

89

1 659

119

4,0 %

82

160

7 089

67

1 514

109

2,8 %

58

111

6 121

58

1 337

96

2,6 %

54

L 287/20

EN

22.

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

IMPACT OF CHANGES IN EXPORT PERFORMANCE OF THE COMMUNITY INDUSTRY

(100)

It has also been argued that a drop in the export performance, in particular to the US market, has
contributed to the injury sustained by the Community industry. According to Eurostat data, exports
from the Community did indeed decrease over the period considered from around 19 000 tonnes in
2002 to 15 000 tonnes in 2005. However, when compared with the Community market, the overall
importance of the exports market is relatively limited, in fact exports correspond to less than 10 % of
Community consumption throughout the period considered.

(101)

In terms of the indicators where the distinction between Community and export markets cannot be
made, such as production and capacity utilisation, and also investments and employment, their
negative evolution clearly exceeded what could be accounted for by the decrease in export
performance. As such, the negative evolution of those indicators must be seen both as a consequence
of the decrease in sales in the Community market and of the decrease of export sales.

(102) Regarding profitability, cash flow and return on investment, their negative evolution was partly a
result of the Community industry being forced into very low capacity utilisation rates, due to the
negative evolution of the sales volume in both the Community and export markets as mentioned
above. Moreover, the sales prices of the Community industry were under strong pressure from the
dumped imports which also contributed to the negative impact upon those indicators.

(103) Therefore, even if

contributed to the injury suffered,
cannot break the causal
Community industry.

the decreased export performance of

the Community industry might have
the overall effect cannot be considered as significant and
link between the dumped imports and the injury suffered by the

23.

IMPACT OF DECREASED COMMUNITY INDUSTRY PRODUCTION AND ALLEGED DECREASE IN
CONSUMPTION

(104)

It has been argued by one interested party that the poor harvests of 2002 and 2003 and the decrease
in production linked to the lack of raw material, i.e. fresh strawberries, in these years are a major
contributing factor causing injury to Community industry. Indeed, it clear that the poor harvests led
to decreased production. However, this is unlikely to be the main factor responsible for the injury
suffered. The decreased production and sales quantities were accompanied by a fall in prices whereas
usually price increases are the consequence of poor harvests and less supply. In addition, an exam-
ination of the profitability of the Community industry over the period considered demonstrates that
the industry continued to be profitable up to the year 2004 when there was a significant fall in prices
of imports from the PRC.

(105)

It has also been argued that there has been a decrease in consumption of the product concerned on
the Community market and that this decrease rather than the occurrence of dumped imports from
the PRC is the reason behind the injury suffered by Community industry. It is recalled that data on
consumption in this investigation has been derived from production data and that the resulting
consumption figures could be affected by the inclusion of stocks of the product. The possibility
of a minor decrease in consumption in 2004 can therefore not be ruled out. Such a decrease would
have had an effect on the sales volume of the Community industry. However, even if there was a
decrease in consumption during the period considered,
it is recalled that imports from the PRC
increased by 381 % during the period considered at prices which decreased by 38 % during the
period It is therefore considered that any decrease in consumption that might have taken place
cannot be the sole cause of the injury suffered.

18.10.2006

EN

24.

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/21

IMPACT OF ALLEGED STRUCTURAL DEFICIENCIES WITH COMMUNITY PRODUCERS

(106)

the sector

It has also been argued that the problems of the Community industry are linked to structural
problems of
including a production system whose efficiency could be improved.
However, no specific evidence was provided in this respect. Even assuming the industry suffered
from structural deficiencies during the period considered, it is noted that the industry continually
invested in the period considered. The aim of these investments was designed to continue to improve
the efficiency of the industry.

(107) The financial results and the competitiveness of the Community industry were strong up to the
emergence of large import volumes of dumped products originating in the PRC. It is again shown by
the indicators examined that injury became apparent when Chinese frozen strawberries started to be
imported in significant quantities at dumped prices. It is therefore provisionally concluded that any
structural deficiencies that might have existed cannot have been the sole or main cause of the injury
suffered.

25.

IMPACT OF ALLEGATIONS RELATING TO SPECULATIVE BUSINESS DECISIONS BY COMMUNITY
PRODUCERS

(108) Some interested parties claimed that speculation in prices and supply of frozen strawberries onto the
Community market had caused the injury to the Community industry and that the losses suffered
consequently were self-inflicted. It has been alleged that the Polish producers maintained artificially
high prices during the poor harvest of 2003 by reducing supply of frozen strawberries and that this
strategy continued during the season of 2004 thus forcing the user industry to look for alternative
supply in the PRC. The Community industry was then left with a substantial stock that had to be sold
off at below profit prices.

(109) The allegations pertaining to these claims on self-inflicted injury were however not further substan-
tiated. Moreover, an analysis of the sampled Community producers’ sales and stock data as detailed in
sections 18.1.2 and 18.1.3 do not support these allegations. The high prices in 2003 coincided with
high raw material costs due to the poor harvest of this season. Stock levels at the end of this period
were also the lowest recorded during the period considered. In 2004 production recovered to the
levels of 2002 and this increase was accompanied by a decrease in sales prices. Despite the decrease
in sales prices, the Community industry was not able to sell off the produce in this year which
resulted in a significant increase in end-of-year stock for 2004. In the IP, the Community industry
was forced to decrease its sales prices further. This decrease can partly be attributed to the need to
sell off stock built up in the previous year. However, the main trigger for the price reduction was the
need to react to the dumped prices of PRC imports that in this year had decreased by a further 24 %
as compared with 2004.

(110) Even if it was in theory possible for the Community industry to have sold off more of its stock in
2004, this would have been at heavily loss making prices. Therefore it is clear that the Community
industry was in an injurious situation in both 2004 and 2005. The main problem confronting this
industry was the increased volume of dumped imports at low prices levels, undercutting the prices if
the Community industry rather than any management decisions as to the timing of selling off of the
product concerned from stock.

26.

IMPACT OF CURRENCY FLUCTUATIONS

(111) Another factor which was claimed to have caused the injury is the falling currency exchange rate of
the US dollar (to which the Chinese renminbi is linked) against the euro. The dollar depreciation
against the euro was around 34 % in the period concerned.

L 287/22

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(112) As regards the injury margins, the dollar depreciation may have encouraged increased imports to the
Community of the product concerned. However, there is no evidence of a link between the fall in
Chinese import prices to the Community market and the dollar depreciation against the euro. This is
demonstrated by the fact that the fall in Chinese import prices is higher than the dollar depreciation
against the euro and a year-on year comparison shows fluctuations in the currency levels that were
not reflected in the import prices. For instance in the IP the dollar depreciated against the euro by
around 10 % but the fall in Chinese import prices was 24 %.

27. CONCLUSION ON CAUSATION

(113)

It should be recalled that in this case, the decrease of production along with an increase in stock
together with price depression causing reduced profitability are the primary evidence of injury.
the rapidly increasing imports from the PRC undercut substantially the
Bearing in mind that
Community industry prices, there is no indication that the above mentioned other factors could
have been of such significance as to break the causal link between the imports of dumped products
from the PRC and the material injury suffered by the Community industry. No further other factors
have been found in the course of the investigation that could have caused material injury.

(114) Based on the above analysis of the effects of all known factors on the situation of the Community
industry, it is provisionally concluded that there is a causal link between the dumped imports from
the PRC and the material injury suffered by the Community industry.

28. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS

E. COMMUNITY INTEREST

(115)

It has been examined whether compelling reasons exist that could lead to the conclusion that it
would not be in the Community interest to impose anti-dumping duties against imports from the
country concerned. The determination of the Community interest was based on an appreciation of all
the various interests involved, i.e. those of the Community industry, importers processors/users and
suppliers. The Commission sent questionnaires,
in particular, to importers and industrial users of
frozen strawberries.

29.

INTEREST OF THE COMMUNITY INDUSTRY

(116) The Community industry has been suffering from a surge in low-priced imports of frozen straw-
berries from the PRC. It is also recalled that the economic indicators of the Community industry
above showed deteriorating financial results during the period considered. Taking into account the
nature of the injury (i.e. mainly depressed prices and deteriorating profits) and the upward trends in
imports of the product concerned, a further deterioration in the situation of Community industry
would be unavoidable in the absence of measures.

responded to the sampling questionnaire,

(117) The investigation showed that the Community production consists of a large number of producers in
the freezing industry which employs around 2 700 persons for the production and sales of the
for the Community freezing
product concerned. Frozen strawberries are an important product
industry as a whole. For
the product
those that
concerned corresponded to more than 10 % of their entire business turnover. Should measures
not be imposed, prices would continue to decrease and the Community producers would incur
further strong losses. In view of the poor financial situation of the Community producers it can
be expected that already in the short term some Community producers would be forced to cease
production should measures not be imposed. Thus it is likely that those estimated 2 700 jobs would
have to be reduced significantly. Moreover, if measures were not imposed it is highly likely that the
various user industries will suffer a lack of supply in the medium and long term as farmers will no
longer cultivate strawberries destined for the processing industry a result of depressed prices for
strawberries. Effects of loss of workforce would be particularly hard felt in this sector as many of the
Community industry producers are located in rural areas and have substantial importance for the
employment level of the local population. Based on the above, the Community industry would
obviously benefit from the adoption of anti-dumping measures.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/23

(118) Should anti-dumping measures be imposed, the Community producer would likely be able to
increase their selling prices to a level that ensures a reasonable profit margin and to restore fair
competition between Community industry and PRC exporting producers. In addition, the imposition
of measures would also allow the Community industry to continue its restructuring process.

(119)

It is therefore provisionally concluded that anti-dumping measures would be in the interest of the
Community industry.

30.

INTEREST OF UNRELATED IMPORTERS

(120) Four unrelated importers provided answers to the questionnaire. One additional unrelated importer

and three importer associations made their views known through written and oral submissions.

(121) Of the four companies which replied to the questionnaire, only three companies completed the
section relating to the volume of imports. This volume accounts for less then 5 % of the total
imports of the product concerned from the PRC during the IP.

(122) One cooperating importer agreed with the imposition of measures provided that these would be set

for a limited period of time and takes a form that allows effective competition.

(123) Two of the cooperating importers opposed the imposition of measures and stressed that such action
would not be in the interest of the Community as the problem is confined only to Poland, suggesting
the interest of only one Member State’s industry should be weighed against interests of several other
Member States where the importers may suffer economical losses once anti-dumping duties are in
place. It was furthermore held by these cooperating importers that the imposition of measures would
impede their contacts with exporting producers in the PRC as well as assistance provided to these in
the form of training and education.

(124) However, the purpose of the anti-dumping measures is neither to prohibit imports nor to hamper the
activities of the importers in the Community. It should be noted that all cooperating importers also
purchase substantial amounts of frozen strawberries from Polish Community producers and that the
activities of the companies includes the further processing of the product concerned.

(125) Furthermore, the overall effect of the duty on the importers’ performance should be minimal.
Importers typically buy a huge range of different food products. Frozen strawberries usually do
not represent more than 10 % of the total imports of such importers. Therefore the effect of the
duty will likely be diluted.

(126) However, bearing in mind that the importers in this sector trade with both Polish and Chinese
supplies and in view of the moderate duty rate that would be imposed, the market would not be
closed to imports from the PRC, the impact on importers is not expected to be substantial. Alter-
native sources of supply from other third countries without duties are also available (e.g. Morocco).

L 287/24

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

31.

INTEREST OF USERS

31.1. Preliminary remark

(127) Nine user companies, i.e. frozen strawberry processors, submitted questionnaire responses. However,
some of these were of poor quality and lacked essential data on purchases and use of the product
concerned and related costs. Submissions were also made by three associations of processors and one
further processor. All user organisations and processors expressing an interest in the proceedings
opposed to the imposition of measures. In total, the user companies having submitted the relevant
purchase data in the questionnaire reply accounted for an additional (to the 4 % accounted for by the
importers) 12 % of imports to the Community from the country concerned. The user associations
having made submissions to the proceedings represent, according to their own account, through their
members 170 000 tonnes or 80 % of the total frozen strawberry consumption in the Community.

31.2. The use of frozen strawberries

to exceed 20 000 tonnes per year. The main users of

(128) Frozen strawberries are characterised as a semi-finished product primarily destined for further
industry for direct consumption. The
processing although a small portion is sold to the retail
direct consumption of frozen strawberries by the catering industry and households is estimated
not
frozen strawberries are processors
involved in the production of jams, fruit preparations utilised primarily by the dairy industry and
production of fruit drinks. The production of strawberry jam in the Community is relatively stable
and is estimated at 230 000 to 250 000 tonnes per year. The estimated frozen strawberry
consumption for this sector would amount to around 100 000 tonnes per year. Unlike the case
for jam,
jellies and marmalade production, the fruit preparation sector and, particularly, the dairy
industry have seen a steady growth over the same time period. Strawberries are a popular flavour in
the fruit preparation and dairy industry and hold an important part of the overall production in both
of these sectors. It is estimated that some 110 000 tonnes of strawberries are consumed by the fresh
dairy and ice cream industry. Whilst still of importance, strawberry flavour as part of the total
production of fruit-flavoured drinks is far more limited than in the jam and fruit preparation sectors.

(129)

In summary, if we exclude the fruit preparation segment (because they are not end products sold to
consumers) frozen strawberries are used primarily in the jam-making and dairy segments in roughly
equal proportions.

31.3. Shortage of supply and the need for different sources of frozen strawberries

(130) The industry sectors using frozen strawberries have indicated that the sourcing of different varieties
and qualities of frozen strawberries is central to their production as recipes used by the industry
generally consist of a blend of strawberries of varied sources. Different consumer preferences and
demand in the EU are also factors that contribute to the industry’s reliance on a wide range of
sources of raw materials. Similarly, it has been held by the cooperating users that supply from a
number of sources is necessary to ensure all year supply of frozen strawberries in sufficient quantities.
The processing companies cooperating in the investigation have argued that the imposition of
measures would lead to a lack of supply of frozen strawberries for the sector, both in terms of
quantities and in terms of the different qualities needed in the production. In addition, the imposition
of measures would run counter to the substantial investments carried out by the Chinese exporting
producers and supported by users in view of ensuring that all applicable safety standards are met
with the PRC exporting producers.

(131) The production of frozen strawberries in the EU is mainly concentrated in Poland where production
is almost exclusively focused on the freezing of the strawberry variety Senga Sengana. This variety of
strawberry is appreciated by fruit-processing industry as it maintains its qualities in terms of colour
and taste in the freezing process. The large storage capacity of the Polish frozen strawberry producers
allow delivery to be spread all year round even though there is only one crop season for fresh
strawberries each year in Poland. It appears that Polish frozen strawberries together with import
sources that will not be affected by anti-dumping duties (Turkey and Morocco) are able to guarantee
steady supply of all strawberry varieties required by the processing (notably jam) industry.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/25

(132) PRC producers started exporting frozen strawberries in increased quantities only in 2003 (recital 60).
In that year, imports from the PRC increased by 324 %. It appears that all other sources of supply
had provided the Community processors with the varieties and qualities they required to make
according finished products. Exports from the PRC include a number of different varieties and
qualities of frozen strawberries with deliveries starting in June reaching a peak in August.

(133) As detailed above in recital 124, the purpose of anti-dumping measures is neither to prohibit imports
nor to hamper the activities of the food-processing industry in the Community. The purpose of anti-
dumping measures would not be to limit the all year round supply or the accessibility of different
varieties needed by the food-processing industry. On the contrary, the user industry has stressed that
the availability of frozen strawberries from the Community, and in particular Poland, is key to the
production of a wide range of products such as jams, yoghourts and fruit preparation due to the
specific characteristics of the Senga Sengana variety. It must consequently be considered to be in the
interest also for the users to ensure the continuation of the Community production. In turn, the
Community processors seem to be far less reliant on frozen strawberries from the PRC, given their
sourcing patterns before 2002 and the fact that they also import more important quantities from
other sources such as Turkey and Morocco. It can safely be concluded that considering these facts the
risk of any supply shortage due to anti-dumping measures can be ruled out. It is noted in this regard
that one of the main Community jam-makers has not directly imported the product concerned from
the PRC.

31.4. Increased raw material cost and lack of competition

(134) Several of the cooperating users claimed that the imposition of measures would lead to a significant
cost increase, destabilise the prices of raw materials and impede competition on the European market,
leaving processors with Poland as the sole source of supply of frozen strawberries. It was also argued
that the increase in raw material costs for the processing industry with current market structure
cannot be carried over to the retailer level of the distribution chain.

(135) The user industry has demonstrated that the product concerned constitutes a substantial part of the
cost of production of jams (around 30 % to 40 %). Nevertheless it should be recalled that jams,
according to the industry’s own admission generally, would consist of a blend of strawberries of
different sources out of which that of Chinese origin would be limited to around 20 %. An impact
analysis shows that the companies would only have to bear an increase in costs of around 2,5 %. In
addition, none of the processing industries, neither the makers of jam nor those of dairy products,
rely exclusively on products that incorporate frozen strawberries. On the contrary, these products
typically make up merely 10 % of the total turnover of these companies. On the whole, the effect of
measures is therefore only likely to have a marginal effect on the total cost of production and
profitability of users.

(136) Moreover, with the number of operators on the European market and the large volumes of imports
from a range of third countries, there is no risk that competition on the European market would be
impeded even in the event that exports from the PRC would decrease substantially.

31.5. Conclusion on users’ interest

(137) Considering the above, it is unlikely that anti-dumping measures would lead to a shortage of supply
or to a non-competitive situation on the Community market,
in particular, as Chinese frozen
strawberries are likely to retain a substantial market share and there are a number of other third
country exporting producers. As regards the cost impact on the users, it was found that this would
only be marginal and would not materially affect the competitiveness and performance of the food-
processing industry. Moreover, the user industry has pointed out that the Polish frozen strawberry
production is essential to the fruit-processing industry and measures assisting in the upkeep of a
viable Community production would ultimately also benefit the user industry. Therefore, it is provi-
sionally considered that the impact on users would not be substantial.

L 287/26

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

32.

INTEREST OF SUPPLIERS

(138) No individual farmers submitted information as part of this investigation. Information relating to this
sector was therefore obtained from the European Commission’s Directorate-General for Agriculture
and the relevant Polish agricultural authorities as Poland is the main producer in the EU of straw-
berries destined for freezing. Unlike production in other Member States which is focused on the fresh
market, strawberries grown in Poland are almost entirely destined for freezing and further processing.
Indicators show that the sector of strawberry farming is undergoing consolidation leading to fewer
farms of a larger size. It is estimated that the number of commercial producers in Poland decreased
from 153 000 in 1996 to 96 700 in 2002. Although it is expected that the consolidation in recent
years has decreased this number even further, it is nevertheless clear that the farming of strawberries
is an important economic activity for a large number of farms in Poland.

(139) The price of

fresh strawberries destined for the processing industry has traditionally fluctuated
the harvest. From 2004 onwards the prices have
depending on the supply and the size of
however been below the cost of production resulting in losses for the farmers. The increase in
cheap imports from the PRC, resulting in the Community industry having to cut its raw material
costs by offering the farmers progressively lower prices, are claimed to be the main reason for this
development. It is expected that, should the raw material price development continue, there is a
significant risk that some farmers would stop cultivating strawberries and that there will be a
shortage of supply to the processing industry. Should measures be imposed,
the Community
industry would probably be in a position to sell the product concerned at higher prices and
thereby to offer higher prices to the suppliers of strawberries as well.

(140)

It is clear that measures would benefit the supplier sector by allowing them to operate at profitable
levels.

33. CONCLUSION ON COMMUNITY INTEREST

(141) The imposition of measures on imports of frozen strawberries originating in the PRC would clearly
be in the interest of the Community industry. As regards both the importers/traders and the user
industries, any impact on prices of frozen strawberries is expected only to be limited. In contrast, the
losses of market share, price reductions and financial losses suffered by the Community industry
including their raw material suppliers would, in the absence of taking measures, clearly be of greater
magnitude.

(142)

In view of the above,
impose anti-dumping duties on imports frozen strawberries originating in the PRC.

it is provisionally concluded that there are no compelling reasons not to

34.

INJURY ELIMINATION LEVEL

F. PROVISIONAL ANTI-DUMPING MEASURES

(143)

In view of the conclusions reached with regard to dumping, injury and Community interest, measures
should be imposed in order to prevent further injury being caused to the Community industry by the
dumped imports from the PRC.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/27

i.e.

in the absence of dumped imports, on the sales of

(144) The measures should be imposed at a level sufficient to eliminate the injury caused by these imports
without exceeding the dumping margin found. When calculating the amount of duty necessary to
remove the effects of the injurious dumping, it was considered that any measures should allow the
Community industry to cover its costs of production and to obtain overall a profit before tax that
could be reasonably achieved by an industry of this type in the sector under normal conditions of
competition,
in the
Community. The pre-tax profit margin used for this calculation was 6,5 % of turnover based on
average profit levels obtained prior to the existence of dumped imports in 2002. The high profit
levels obtained in 2003 were not taken into account as prices and profit were exceptionally high in
this year. Consequently, on the basis of the information available, it was preliminarily found that a
profit margin of 6,5 % of turnover could be regarded as an appropriate level which the Community
industry could be expected to obtain in the absence of injurious dumping. On this basis, a non-
injurious price was calculated for the Community industry of the like product. The non-injurious
price has been obtained by adding the above mentioned profit margin of 6,5 % to the cost of
production.

the like product

(145) The necessary price increase was then determined on the basis of a comparison of the weighted
average import price with the average non-injurious price. A 15,4 % allowance was added to the
import prices to cover the normal customs duty (14,4 %) and importer handling charges (1 %).

(146) Any difference resulting from this comparison was then expressed as a percentage of the average
import cif value. The investigation showed that the product concerned sold on the Community
market by both exporting producers and Community industry was comparable. This calculation
was therefore made on an average to average basis.

(147) The provisional weighted average injury margins for companies granted either MES or IT status were:

Yantai Yongchang Foodstuff

Dandong Junao Foodstuff

18,1 %

12,6 %

(148)

In order to calculate the country-wide injury elimination level for all other exporters in the PRC, it
should be recalled that the level of cooperation was low. Therefore, a weighted average margin was
calculated on the basis of (a) the injury margin of those cooperating exporters, to which neither MET
nor IT was granted and (b) the injury margin of the highest of the companies not granted MET or IT
to represent the non-cooperators. The country-wide injury elimination level was 34,2 %, being the
weighted average of the abovementioned two elements.

35. PROVISIONAL MEASURES

(149)

In the light of the foregoing, it is considered that in accordance with the Article 7(2) of the basic
Regulation, provisional anti-dumping duties on imports of the product concerned originating in the
PRC should be imposed. The anti-dumping duties should be set at the lower of the dumping and
injury margins, in accordance with the lesser duty rule.

L 287/28

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

18.10.2006

(150) The individual company anti-dumping duty rates specified in this Regulation were established on the
basis of the findings of the present investigation. Therefore, they reflect the situation found during
this investigation with respect to these companies. These duty rates (as opposed to the country-wide
duty applicable to ‘all other companies’) are thus exclusively applicable to imports of products
originating in the country concerned and produced by the companies and thus by the specific
Imported products produced by any other company not specifically
legal entities mentioned.
mentioned in the operative part of this Regulation with its name and address,
including entities
related to those specifically mentioned, cannot benefit from these rates and shall be subject to the
duty rate applicable to ‘all other companies’.

(151) Any claim requesting the application of these individual company anti-dumping duty rates (e.g.
following a change in the name of the entity or following the setting-up of new production or
sales entities) should be addressed to the Commission (1) forthwith with all relevant information, in
particular any modification in the company’s activities linked to production, domestic and export
sales associated with e.g. that name change or that change in the production and sales entities. If
appropriate, the Regulation will accordingly be amended by updating the list of companies benefiting
from individual duty rates.

(152)

In order to ensure a proper enforcement of the anti-dumping duty, the residual duty level should not
only apply to the non-cooperating exporting producers, but also to those producers which did not
have any exports to the Community during the IP.

(153) The proposed provisional anti-dumping duties are the following:

Company

Injury elimination margin

Dumping margin

Proposed anti-dumping
duty

Yantai Yongchang Foodstuff

Dandong Junao Foodstuff

All other companies

18,1 %

12,6 %

34,2 %

0 %

31,1 %

66,9 %

0 %

12,6 %

34,2 %

G. FINAL PROVISION

(154)

In the interest of sound administration, a period should be fixed within which the interested parties
which made themselves known within the time limit specified in the notice of initiation may make
their views known in writing and request a hearing. Furthermore, it should be stated that the findings
concerning the imposition of duties made for the purposes of this Regulation are provisional and
may have to be reconsidered for the purpose of any definitive duty,

(1) European Commission

Directorate-General for Trade
Direction B
Office J-79 5/16
B-1049 Brussels.

18.10.2006

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

L 287/29

HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:

Article 1

A provisional anti-dumping duty is hereby imposed on imports o strawberries, uncooked or cooked
1.
by steaming or boiling in water, frozen, whether or not containing added sugar or other sweeteners,
originating in the People’s Republic of China and falling within CN codes 0811 10 11, 0811 10 19 and
0811 10 90.

The rate of the provisional anti-dumping duty applicable to the net, free-at-Community frontier price,

2.
before duty, of the products described in paragraph 1, shall be as follows:

Manufacturer

Yantai Yongchang Foodstuff

Dandong Junao Foodstuff

All other companies

Anti-dumping duty
%

TARIC additional code

0

12,6

34,2

A779

A780

A999

The release for free circulation in the Community of the product referred to in paragraph 1 shall be

3.
subject to the provision of a security, equivalent to the amount of the provisional duty.

4.

Unless otherwise specified, the provisions in force concerning customs duties shall apply.

Article 2

Without prejudice to Article 20 of Regulation (EC) No 384/96, interested parties may request disclosure of
the essential facts and considerations on the basis of which this Regulation was adopted, make their views
known in writing and apply to be heard orally by the Commission within one month of the date of entry
into force of this Regulation.

Pursuant to Article 21(4) of Regulation (EC) No 384/96, the parties concerned may comment on the
application of this Regulation within one month of the date of its entry into force.

This Regulation shall enter into force on the day following its publication in the Official Journal of the
European Union.

Article 3

Article 1 of this Regulation shall apply for a period of six months.

This Regulation shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in all Member States.

Done at Brussels, 17 October 2006.

For the Commission

Peter MANDELSON
Member of the Commission