European Parliament resolution on the 2004 regular report and the recommendation of the European Commission on Turkey's progress towards accession (COM(2004)0656 — C6-0148/2004 — 2004/2182(INI))
Date: 2004-12-15
Institutions: European Parliament
Subjects: Türkiye, accession criteria, accession negotiations, accession to the European Union, democratisation, economic situation, human rights, judicial reform, political situation

15.9.2005

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 226 E/189

TEXTS ADOPTED

Wednesday 15 December 2004

P6_TA(2004)0096

Turkey's progress towards accession

European Parliament resolution on the 2004 regular report and the recommendation of the Euro-
pean Commission on Turkey's progress towards accession (COM(2004)0656 — C6-0148/2004 —
2004/2182(INI))

The European Parliament,

— having regard to the 2004 regular report and the recommendation of the European Commission on
Turkey's progress towards accession of 6 October 2004 (COM(2004)0656 — C6-0148/2004) (1),

— having regard to its resolution of 1 April 2004 on the 2003 regular report of the Commission on
Turkey's progress towards accession (2) and its previous resolutions on this subject adopted between
18 June 1987 and 1 April 2004,

— having regard to the conclusions of the European Council (Copenhagen, 21 and 22 June 1993, Hel-
sinki, 10 and 11 December 1999, Copenhagen, 12 and 13 December 2002, Thessaloniki, 19 and
20 June 2003, and Brussels, 12 and 13 December 2003),

— having regard to Rule 45 of its Rules of Procedure,

— having regard to the report of the Committee on Foreign Affairs and the opinion of the Committee on

Budgets (A6-0063/2004),

A. whereas the Commission has concluded that Turkey has sufficiently fulfilled the Copenhagen political

criteria and has recommended that accession negotiations be opened,

B.

C.

whereas the European Council decided in 2002 that if Turkey fulfilled the Copenhagen political criteria
the European Union (EU) would open accession negotiations without delay,

whereas there has been substantial legislative and institutional convergence in Turkey towards Euro-
pean standards, in particular since the 2002 elections,

D. whereas the Commission has indicated that Turkey's accession would be different from previous
location,

enlargements because of the combined impact of Turkey's population, size, geographical
economic, security and military potential,

E.

F.

whereas a democratic and economically stable Turkey would substantially benefit the whole of Europe,

having regard to the conclusions of the Helsinki and Copenhagen European Councils, which openly
recognised Turkey's political desire to join the EU and explicitly accorded it the right to the status of a
candidate for full membership,

G. whereas the Commission proposes a strategy for the accession process consisting of three pillars,
respectively on cooperation to reinforce and support the reform process in Turkey, on the specific
conditions for the conduct of accession negotiations within the framework of an Intergovernmental
Conference requiring decision-making by unanimity (benchmarks for the opening and closure of
chapters, the possibility of introducing long transition periods in respect of freedom of movement
for workers, agriculture and the implementation of structural policies (the Cohesion Fund), as well as
introducing specific arrangements and permanent safeguards) and on a substantially strengthened pol-
itical and cultural dialogue bringing together the peoples of the EU Member States and of Turkey,

(1) Not yet published in OJ.
(2) Texts Adopted, P5_TA(2004)0274.

C 226 E/190

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

15.9.2005

Wednesday 15 December 2004

H. whereas the Commission has not proposed a date for opening accession negotiations and has indi-
cated that the negotiation process is an open-ended process the outcome of which cannot be guaran-
teed in advance,

I.

J.

K.

L.

whereas the Commission has stated that the irreversibility of the reform process, and in particular its
implementation with regard to fundamental freedoms, will need to be confirmed over a longer period
of time,

whereas the Commission has stated that, regardless of the outcome of the negotiations or the sub-
sequent ratification process, relations between the EU and Turkey must ensure that Turkey remains
fully anchored in European structures,

whereas the Commission will propose revising the Accession Partnership in spring 2005 and will
present a yearly general review, starting from the end of 2005, of the way in which the political
reforms are consolidated and broadened,

whereas, in line with the Treaty on European Union, in the event of a serious and persistent breach of
the principles of liberty, democracy, respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms and the rule
of law and of the principles of international law, the Commission will recommend the suspension of
negotiations to the Council, which will decide by a qualified majority,

M. whereas the Commission has indicated that the EU will need to define its financial perspective for the

period from 2014 onwards before negotiations can be concluded,

N. whereas the European Council stated in June 2003 that 'The Union's capacity to absorb new members,
while maintaining the momentum of European integration, is also an important consideration in the
general interest of both the Union and the candidate countries',

O. whereas a Commission study on the impact of Turkey's accession has indicated that its accession

renders a substantial reform of many EU policies indispensable,

P.

whereas the Government of Turkey, in cooperation with its parliament, has adopted and implemented
important constitutional and legislative changes over recent years,

Q. whereas the opening of the accession negotiations should imply that the political criteria are fulfilled
and the EU will have the capacity to absorb Turkey while maintaining the momentum of European
integration, and whereas compliance with ‘all’ the Copenhagen criteria has been the basis for accession
to the Union,

R.

S.

T.

whereas the new Penal Code and the Law on Intermediate Courts of Appeal were adopted on 26 Sept-
ember 2004 and the Law on Associations on 4 November 2004, while the decision on the Code of
Criminal Procedure, the legislation establishing the judicial police and the law on execution of punish-
ments and measures are still to be adopted,

whereas in spite of the important changes introduced in two major packages of constitutional reforms
in 2001 and 2004, Turkey has retained a Constitution adopted in 1982,

whereas full parliamentary control over military expenditures and auditing will need to be ensured in
practice on the basis of the adopted reforms,

U. whereas hundreds of cases of torture have been reported to Turkish governmental bodies and human
rights organisations in both 2003 and 2004 and more than 2 000 applications for asylum by Turkish
citizens were accepted by EU Member States in 2003,

V.

whereas the Commission underlines that legislation and implementation measures need to be further
consolidated and broadened, specifically in terms of the zero tolerance policy in the fight against
torture and ill-treatment and the implementation of provisions relating to freedom of expression,
press freedom, freedom of religion, women's rights, children's rights including the prohibition of
child labour and International Labour Organisation (ILO) standards,

15.9.2005

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 226 E/191

Wednesday 15 December 2004

W. whereas, despite the adoption of a major programme of reform, the education and training systems
continue to display certain shortcomings, and whereas it is therefore desirable to improve the edu-
cation on offer in the most disadvantaged regions and to improve school attendance, particularly by
girls,

X.

Y.

Z.

whereas on the reinforcement of religious liberty Turkey should pursue its reform in order to rapidly
guarantee equal treatment for all religious communities and minorities, including in the areas of prop-
erty rights, legal status, schools and internal management, environmental planning rules and the train-
ing of clergy,

whereas the Kurdish people represent an important component of Turkish society and therefore their
rights must be fully recognised,

whereas the Greek Orthodox Halki seminary has not been re-opened despite previous appeals to the
Turkish authorities by the European Parliament,

AA. whereas an integrated strategy to develop the economic, social and cultural needs of the local popu-
lation in the south-east has yet to be adopted and the return of internally displaced persons in the
south-east has been limited and hampered by the village guard system and by a lack of material
support,

BB. whereas Turkey has yet to implement outstanding decisions of the European Court of Human Rights,
including the restoration of the right to property in the Loizidou case and the Court's judgment in the
case of Cyprus v. Turkey,

CC. whereas Leyla Zana and her colleagues have at last been released from unjust imprisonment and are

now working for the better integration of the Kurds into mainstream political life in Turkey,

DD. whereas Turkish and Kurdish political forces, civil society organisations, religious organisations and
prominent personalities in Turkey warmly support the opening of EU accession negotiations, hoping
that the start of these negotiations will deepen and speed up the reform process in Turkey,

EE. whereas the border between Turkey and Armenia has still not been re-opened by the Turkish
authorities, who have thereby missed an opportunity to promote good neighbourly relations with
Armenia,

FF. whereas the Turkish authorities have likewise still not complied with the calls concerning the other

Armenian issues made by Parliament in its resolution of 18 June 1987,

GG. whereas the re-opening to pilgrims of the ruined Armenian churches of Ani, near Kars in Eastern
Anatolia, and the remarkable work carried out by the Turkish historian Halil Berktay on the genocide
and the re-establishment of state relations with the Republic of Armenia represent vital steps forward,
but whereas this process must be taken to its logical conclusion by re-opening the border between
Turkey and Armenia,

HH. whereas in the context of the broader Cyprus issue, the international community remains concerned
about the non-recognition by Turkey of the Republic of Cyprus and the fact that more than 30 000
Turkish troops are stationed in Northern Cyprus,

II.

whereas a continuation of the process of democratisation and the programme of socio-economic
modernisation could lead Turkey to:

— play an important role in connection with a number of transnational
resources, transport, border management, the fight against terrorism);

issues (energy, water

— have a positive influence on the development of secular democratic states in the Islamic world as

a counterweight to religious fundamentalism;

— have a positive impact on the EU's external policy achievements in a number of potentially
unstable neighbouring regions, such as the Mediterranean, the Middle East, the Caucasus and
Central Asia,

C 226 E/192

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

15.9.2005

Wednesday 15 December 2004

1. Welcomes the political reform process in Turkey and the adopted constitutional and legislative changes
that have entered into force, as well as the progress made in implementing those reforms since the European
Parliament adopted its resolution of 5 June 2003 on Turkey's application for membership of the European
Union (1); none the less, is of the opinion that the Turkish authorities still have to adopt and implement
further reforms and put current reforms into practice in order to fully meet the political criteria;

2. Welcomes the impressive efforts of the Turkish authorities to achieve substantial legislative and insti-
tutional convergence in Turkey towards European standards;

3. Welcomes the positive developments in the Turkish economy reflected in particular by the reduction
of macro-economic imbalances and higher growth rates;

4. Welcomes the continuing strong motivation and the political will demonstrated by the Turkish Gov-
ernment and by the great majority of the representatives elected by the Turkish people to grow closer to the
EU; welcomes the significant popular support reflected in poll results;

5.
Notes with satisfaction that over the last few yearsTurkey has fulfilled a number of recommendations
and requirements included in Parliament's resolutions regarding in particular, amongst others: the complete
abolition of the death penalty, the extension of important fundamental rights and freedoms, reduction of
the role of the National Security Council and the lifting of the state of emergency in the south-east; thereby
complying with a number of the recommendations set out in Parliament's resolutions; regrets however the
reservations expressed on the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights as well as the Inter-
national Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights;

Expresses its unconditional support for the civil society organisations and actors operating in Turkey in
6.
defence and promotion of fundamental rights and freedoms; calls on the Council and the Commission to
strengthen cooperation with such organisations in the process of monitoring Turkey's compliance with the
political criteria of Copenhagen;

7.
Acknowledges that the reforms implemented by the Turkish authorities have given non-governmental
organisations greater scope to take action, in particular as regards the promotion of human rights, and calls
on the Turkish Government to step up its efforts to eradicate all forms of intimidation and harassment of
human rights activists and organisations;

8. Welcomes in particular the reform of criminal procedure, strengthening the rights of the defence;
considers however that Article 305 of the new Turkish Penal Code, which sanctions alleged ‘threats to
fundamental national interests’, and the explanatory statement of which targets freedom of expression, in
particular related to the Cyprus and Armenia issues, is incompatible with the 1950 European Convention
for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms; calls therefore for its repeal;

9. Welcomes the release of Leyla Zana and her colleagues from the former Democracy Party (DEP), and
calls for a fair and equitable retrial and for the immediate release of all imprisoned persons sentenced for the
non-violent expression of opinions in Turkey;

10. Welcomes the fact that the Turkish Government has introduced legal changes which enable private
language centres to offer courses in mother tongues other than Turkish (Kurdish, Circassian, Armenian et
al.), to broadcast media programs and to open and operate stations which broadcast in other languages; calls
on the Turkish Government to lift all remaining restrictions in the area of broadcasting and education in
minority languages;

Strongly urges Turkey to actually extend these legal changes and the implementation thereof to edu-

11.
cation and broadcasting for non-Muslim minorities (Greeks, Armenians, Jews, Assyrians);

Invites Turkey to drastically improve its perception of ethnic and religious minorities, for instance by
12.
highlighting their contributions to the cultural heritage of the country; in particular, requests the Turkish
authorities to consider some of these specific contributions such as Hasankeyf, Ani, Zeugma or Aghtamar as
suitable for registration in the World Heritage List of Unesco;

(1) OJ C 68 E, 18.3.2004, p. 592.

15.9.2005

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 226 E/193

Wednesday 15 December 2004

13.
Urges, in this respect, the Turkish government to apply EU environmental and human rights stan-
dards to large-impact projects like the construction of dams in the Munzur Valley and Ilisu, and gold-mining
in Bergama, where historical heritage and unique valuable landscapes are at risk;

Urges the Turkish authorities to fully implement a ‘zero-tolerance’ approach at all levels and in all
14.
aspects to the complete eradication of torture, as cases are still reported to Turkish governmental bodies and
human rights organisations, and as the zero-tolerance approach is put insufficiently into practice;

15.
Suggests to the Turkish Government that, when reforming the criminal procedural law, it should
abrogate the statute of limitations for all criminal cases when proceedings are opened; calls on the Turkish
judicial system, and in particular the prosecutors, to concentrate on cases of alleged torture, given that
currently only few judicial investigations and cases against suspected perpetrators are opened; calls on Tur-
key to increase staffing levels in the public prosecution service in order to achieve results;

Calls on the Turkish authorities,

16.
in that connection, to redouble their efforts to implement that
approach more effectively and, in particular, to take a more resolute approach to the issue of immunity
from prosecution, and emphasises the need to step up educational programmes designed to change the
attitudes of members of the police and armed forces with a view to ensuring strict compliance with the law;

17.
Calls on the Turkish interior ministry to adopt and apply the policy of opening immediately, and as a
matter of principle, administrative and disciplinary investigations against any police officer accused of tor-
ture or mistreatment;

18.
Calls on the Turkish authorities to bring the Law on Associations, the new Penal Code and the Law
on Intermediate Courts of Appeal into force and to adopt the decision on the Code of Criminal Procedure,
the legislation establishing the judicial police and the law on execution of punishments and measures;

Calls on the Turkish authorities to significantly reform the Law on Foundations after consulting —
19.
as should be done in the case of all these Laws — those entities affected by this Law such as relevant NGOs
and the broad spectrum of religious communities;

20.
Calls on the Foreign Affairs Committee and its Subcommittee for Human Rights to follow closely the
human rights situation in Turkey and in particular the implementation on the ground, especially regarding
implementation of the principle of zero tolerance with respect to torture, the return process of displaced
people in coordination with international agencies, the implementation of the campaign and the law to
eradicate violence against women and the issue of protection and promotion of minority rights, freedom
of religion, freedom of expression, press freedom and freedom for trade unions;

21.
Reiterates its call for the electoral system to be reformed by reducing the threshold of 10 %, thereby
ensuring a wider representation of political forces in the Grand National Assembly, including predominantly
Kurdish parties;

22.
Expresses its concern about the DEHAP trial and the danger of dissolution of the party; calls on the
Turkish authorities to respect the right of freedom of expression as well as the right of organisation of
democratic political parties such as DEHAP;

23.
Regards the drafting of a new Constitution as a further and probably necessary reflection of the very
fundamental nature of the changes required for EU membership and notes that a modern Constitution may
form the basis for the modernisation of the Turkish State;

24.
Reiterates the need for continuing efforts to ensure a competent and independent judiciary and calls
on the Turkish authorities to ensure that all legislative changes are rapidly implemented, especially with
respect to the protection of human rights, and translated into a change of conduct at all levels of the
judiciary;

25.
Calls on the Turkish Government to reform current inspection services by allocating the tasks
involved to independent inspection services which should be given sufficient resources to operate effectively
in all regions of Turkey and empowered to investigate any police detention facility at any time while closely
co-operating with independent Turkish human rights NGOs;

C 226 E/194

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

15.9.2005

Wednesday 15 December 2004

Expresses its unconditional support for the civil society organisations and actors operating in Turkey

26.
in defence and promotion of fundamental freedoms;

Calls on the Turkish authorities to energetically pursue their fight against corruption, which still
27.
seriously affects economic, political and social life; welcomes the Turkish authorities' efforts against cor-
ruption, including the ratification of the OECD's Anti-Bribery Convention and the UN Convention against
Corruption, and membership of the Council of Europe's Group of States against corruption (GRECO);

28. Welcomes the reforms which have strengthened the principle of gender equality and draws attention
to the progress on women's rights embodied in the new Penal Code, but reiterates its concern that domestic
violence and other forms of violence against women are still widespread, especially in underdeveloped and
rural parts of the country, and urges the Turkish authorities to provide full legal protection and judicial and
economic aid to victims, as well as shelters and similar facilities, and to support NGOs providing these
shelters and similar facilities; calls on the Commission to support such efforts within the EU assistance
programmes; calls on the Turkish authorities to introduce programmes to eradicate female illiteracy;

29.
Calls on the Turkish authorities to engage in a constant dialogue with the European Parliament on
women's rights in Turkey and to take note in this regard of the resolution on the role of women in Turkey
in social, economic and political life, due to be discussed in 2005 in the European Parliament;

30. Welcomes the fact that the Turkish authorities have made changes to the Penal Code with a view to
repealing all legal provisions which reflect a lenient approach to crimes motivated by honour; nevertheless,
emphasises the need to create conditions under which individuals can report such practices to the auth-
orities in complete safety and confidentiality and to ensure that crimes of honour are properly investigated
and prosecuted;

31.
Urges all parties involved to put an immediate end to the hostilities in the south-east of the country;
invites the Turkish Government to take more active steps to bring about reconciliation with those Kurdish
forces who have chosen to abandon the use of arms;

32.
Calls on the Turkish authorities to step up their efforts to ensure that women whose free access to
primary or secondary education is hindered by difficulties stemming from their family or cultural environ-
ment are able to assert to the full their right to an education;

33.
Stresses that the overall situation in the south-east has improved since 1999, in terms of both secur-
ity and respect for fundamental rights; calls on the Turkish Government to develop plans to enable people
who wish to do so to return to their villages and towns in the south-east and to properly address the
problems currently caused by the village guard system; urges Turkey to disarm the village guards and
disband the village guard system; calls on Turkey to collaborate closely with international bodies, such as
the United Nations, the EU and the Council of Europe, to support and speed up the return of internally
displaced persons, in conformity with the UN Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement, and urges the
authorities to develop an integrated regional development concept to economically develop the south-east as
a region and foster the overall modernisation of society;

Calls on Turkey to lift the geographical reservation to the 1951 Geneva Convention relating to the

34.
Status of Refugees;

Calls on the Turkish authorities to apply the ILO standards for trade union rights and to introduce

35.
further legislation prohibiting the employment of children;

36.
Calls on the Turkish Government to remove all barriers for trade unions to organise themselves and
to promote freedom of association by repealing the clause requiring preliminary authorisation from the
Government for the creation of new organisations and to smooth the path towards the development of a
real social dialogue dimension as one of the pillars of the economic and social model;

Calls on the Turkish Government to limit the political role of the army further through ongoing

37.
reforms;

15.9.2005

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 226 E/195

Wednesday 15 December 2004

38. Welcomes the fact that the principle of the primacy of international law over national law has been
enshrined in the Turkish Constitution as far as the European Convention on Human Rights is concerned
and calls on the Turkish authorities to respect all its provisions and to implement without delay the still
outstanding decisions of the European Court of Human Rights;

39.
Calls on Turkey to promote the process of reconciliation with the Armenian people by acknowledg-
ing the genocide perpetrated against the Armenians as expressed in the European Parliament's earlier resol-
utions with regard to Turkey's candidate status (from 18 June 1987 to 1 April 2004);

40.
Believes that the Governments of Turkey and Armenia have to continue their process of reconcili-
ation, possibly with the assistance of a bilateral committee of independent experts, in order to overcome
explicitly the tragic experience of the past, and requests the Turkish Government to re-open the borders
with Armenia as soon as possible;

41.
Calls on the Commission and the Council to demand that the Turkish authorities formally acknowl-
edge the historic reality of the genocide perpetrated against the Armenians in 1915 and open the border
between Turkey and Armenia at an early date, in accordance with the resolutions adopted by the European
Parliament between 1987 and 2004;

In the context of continuing to improve regional stability and fostering better relations with her
42.
neighbours, asks Turkey to be sensitive to the water requirements of these countries, with particular refer-
ence to the lower Mesopotamian Marshes in Iraq and Iran, where water flows have been significantly
reduced by the construction of the Ataturk Dam; requests that Turkey set up working groups with her
neighbours, including Syria, to ensure the fair and equitable distribution of water from rivers with their
headwaters rising in Turkey;

43.
Reiterates its call to the Turkish authorities to put an immediate end to all activities discriminating
against and creating difficulties for religious minorities and communities, including in the areas of property
legal status, schools and internal management, environmental planning rules and the training of
rights,
clergy, and requests as a first clear sign of implementation the immediate re-opening of the Greek Orthodox
Halki seminary and the public use of the ecclesiastical title of the Ecumenical Patriarchate; calls on Turkey,
bearing in mind the current difficulties, to act in accordance with the relevant case-law of the European
Court of Human Rights; calls for the recognition and protection of the Alevites, including the recognition of
Cem houses as religious centres, and for all religious education to be voluntary and to cover not only Sunni
religion; calls for the protection of the fundamental rights of all Christian minorities and communities in
Turkey (e.g. Greeks of Istanbul, Imvros and Tenedos);

44. Whilst respecting the democratic will of the Greek Cypriot community, regrets that it has not been
able to reach a solution, and calls on the Turkish authorities to maintain their constructive attitude in
finding a settlement of the Cyprus question leading to an equitable solution, to be negotiated on the basis
of the Annan plan and the principles upon which the EU is founded, and to effect an early withdrawal,
pursuant to the relevant UN resolutions, of its forces in accordance with a specific timetable; believes that
such a withdrawal of Turkish forces is a necessary step forward on the way to further easing tension,
resuming dialogue between the parties and preparing for a lasting solution; calls on the Turkish authorities
to recognise the Republic of Cyprus; calls the attention of the Turkish authorities to the fact that the
negotiations concerned are intergovernmental negotiations between Turkey on the one hand and the
25 members of the EU on the other; the Republic of Cyprus is one of those Member States; the opening
of negotiations obviously implies the recognition of Cyprus by Turkey;

45.
Calls on the Council to deliver on promises and to put an end to the isolation of the Turkish Cypriot
community; expects the rapid adoption of the two regulations on economic aid and trade with the northern
part of the island;

46.
Reminds the Turkish authorities of the need to resolve any outstanding disputes with neighbouring
states in accordance with the UN Charter and relevant Treaties; further reminds the Turkish authorities of
the impact on the accession process of good neighbourly relations and abstention from threats and tension-
prone military activities; as stated in the Helsinki European Council Conclusions, failing a settlement, out-
standing delimitation issues should be brought before the International Court of Justice with a view to a
final determination; also invites the Turkish authorities to abolish all existing restrictions applying to ships
flying the Cypriot flag and involved in trade concerning a Member State of the EU;

C 226 E/196

Official Journal of the European Union

EN

15.9.2005

Wednesday 15 December 2004

47.
Calls on the Commission to include all the necessary political reforms in the revised Accession Part-
nership and stresses the need for continued and effective Community assistance based on a revised Acces-
sion Partnership and adapted, as far as possible, to Turkey's needs in terms of compliance with the Copen-
hagen criteria;

48.
Requests the Commission, the Council and the Member States to take all necessary steps in order for
the European Constitution to enter into force so that the EU can fulfil the preconditions for its smooth
functioning and boost its capacity to absorb new Member States;

49. Welcomes the Commission's recommendation to monitor the implementation of the legal reforms,
respect for the principles of liberty, democracy, respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms and the
rule of law, and its commitment to recommend, in line with the Treaty on European Union and the Con-
stitution for Europe, the suspension of the negotiations in the event of a serious and persistent breach of
these principles; urges the Commission and the Council to consult the Parliament hereon;

Recalls the conclusions of the European Council of 21 and 22 June 1993 setting out the Copenhagen
50.
criteria for EU membership and calls on the European Council, in its decision on starting negotiations with
Turkey, to state that the Union's capacity to absorb Turkey as a member, while maintaining the momentum
of European integration, constitutes an important criterion for accession, from the point of view both of the
Union and of candidates for accession;

51.
Encourages the Turkish authorities to continue with the reforms designed to strengthen mechanisms
to safeguard human rights, such as the possibility offered to members of the public to submit a complaint
to an independent body; in that connection, therefore, regards as important the establishment in the near
future of the office of Ombudsman;

52.
Emphasises, in that connection, the importance of exchange and training programmes for judicial
officers and judges and of attendance at the symposiums on Community law which Turkey has started to
organise in cooperation with both the EU and some of its Member States and with the Council of Europe;

53.
Notes with interest the progress made in the context of the economic criteria, and in particular the
compliance of Turkey with the acquis communautaire in the fields of energy, industrial policy, research and
telecommunications; considers, however, that this has been uneven across the various areas, which makes at
least four reforms necessary: an enhanced administrative capacity required to implement and enforce the
acquis, an operationally independent authority to monitor State aid, increased funds for science and research
because Turkey's capacity remains limited owing to the low level of expenditure as a percentage of GDP and
a revised legal framework for the telecommunications sector, with the aim of changing the market structure
which is dominated by large, powerful companies;

54.
Calls on the Commission and the Council to conduct an annual follow-up of the impact study, to
carry out other relevant studies related to the possible accession of Turkey, including the necessary reforms
of EU policies, and to present their conclusions to the European Parliament and the national Parliaments of
the EU Member States;

Highlights that only by demonstrating readiness to embrace EU values through determined imple-
55.
mentation and continued reform will Turkey be able to ensure the irreversibility of the process of reform
and to gather the necessary support amongst the body of EU public opinion; expects the Commission and
the Council to demonstrate on the basis of facts that this has been achieved;

56.
Calls in this context on the Commission and the Council to report annually to the European Parlia-
ment and the national Parliaments of the EU Member States on the progress made by Turkey in fulfilling the
political criteria, and to include in this report all verified cases of torture reported in that year and the
number of Turkish asylum seekers accepted by the EU Member States during that year;

57.
Urges the Commission, once the negotiations on the various chapters have started, to recommend, in
the event of a serious and persistent breach of the principles of liberty, democracy, respect for human rights
and fundamental freedoms and the rule of law, and after consultation of the European Parliament, the
suspension of negotiations, in line with the Treaty on European Union;

15.9.2005

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 226 E/197

Wednesday 15 December 2004

Notes that the negotiations with Turkey can only be concluded following the definition of the EU's

58.
financial perspective for the period from 2014 onwards;

Notes that the budgetary impact of Turkey's accession to the EU can only be fully assessed once the
59.
parameters for the financial negotiations with Turkey have been defined in the context of the financial
perspectives from 2014 onwards;

Stresses that

60.
the Commission's recommendation to negotiate long transition periods, specific
arrangements in areas such as structural policies and agriculture and permanent safeguards for the free
movement of workers in the accession agreement should not have a negative impact on Turkey's efforts to
align with the acquis;

Regards the European Union's capacity to cope with enlargement as a prerequisite, as part of the
61.
Copenhagen criteria, and therefore considers that the European Union, for its part, must be capable of
political and institutional reform;

62.
Underlines the importance of the opinion of the EU citizens about a possible accession agreement;
therefore urges the Turkish Government and the Commission, in the light of the third pillar, to initiate
campaigns to inform citizens of both the EU and Turkey through exchange programmes and public events
that will increase awareness of the integration process and foster mutual understanding; expects from the
Commission concrete proposals for action to give effective support to this process and to promote deeper
political and cultural dialogue between the EU and Turkish society; stresses that the process of the conver-
gence of Turkey to the EU criteria must be conducted in a fair and transparent way;

63.
Stresses that the opening of negotiations will be the starting point for a long-lasting process that by
its very nature is an open-ended process and does not lead ‘a priori’ and automatically to accession; empha-
sises, however, that the objective of the negotiations is Turkish EU membership but that the realisation of
this ambition will depend on the efforts of both sides; accession is thus not the automatic consequence of
the start of the negotiations;

Is of the opinion that in the context of a possible accession it is now up to the Turkish authorities to
64.
prove that they can truly fulfil the Copenhagen political criteria and to confirm over a longer period of time
that the reform process, which will have to be continued and implemented, is fundamental and irreversible;

Calls on the Turkish authorities to encourage frequent visits from and dialogue with the European

65.
Parliament, without restrictions;

Considers that, regardless of whether or not negotiations are successfully concluded, relations

66.
between the EU and Turkey must ensure that Turkey remains fully anchored in European structures;

Considers that the opening of accession negotiations is to be recommended so long as it is agreed

67.
that:

— in the first phase of the negotiations priority is given to the full implementation of the political criteria;
that therefore the agenda of negotiations at ministerial level will start with the assessment of the fulfil-
ment of the political criteria, especially in the area of human rights and full fundamental freedoms in
both theory and practice, in the meantime opening up the opportunity to put other chapters on the
agenda of the negotiations;

— in accordance with the Commission's requirements, six important remaining pieces of legislation are to

be adopted and enforced prior to the beginning of negotiations;

— all mechanisms envisaged by the Commission to ensure close monitoring, intensive political dialogue

and a possible suspension of negotiations, if necessary, are fully effective;

68.
Considering the overall progress outlined in the report of the Commission and taking into account
the above provisions of this resolution, calls upon the European Council to open the negotiations with
Turkey without undue delay;

69.
Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council and the Commission, the Secretary-
General of the Council of Europe, the President of the European Court of Human Rights and the Govern-
ment and Parliament of Turkey.