WRITTEN QUESTION E-3507/02 by Giacomo Santini (PPE-DE) to the Council. Avian influenza epidemic in Italy.
Date: 2002-12-10
Institutions: European Parliament, Provisional data
Subjects: EU control, European Commission, Italy, animal plague, application of EU law, export licence, export restriction, marketing standard, poultry, vaccination

18.9.2003

EN

Official Journal of the European Union

C 222 E/77

(2003/C 222 E/088)

WRITTEN QUESTION E-3507/02

by Giacomo Santini (PPE-DE) to the Council

(10 December 2002)

Subject: Avian influenza epidemic in Italy

The provinces of Verona, Mantua and Brescia are suffering an epidemic of avian influenza caused by a
mildly pathogenic strain of the H7N3 virus. So far the influenza is almost exclusively affecting turkey
farms. In order to stop the disease from spreading, the Italian authorities will ask the EU to approve the
vaccination of the susceptible species in the areas at risk.

However, this approach may mean that poultry produced in the areas where vaccination has been carried
out cannot be exported to other Member States. The three provinces together produce around 80 % of
Italian turkeys and around 20 % of total production is exported.

It is therefore clear that an possible export ban will lead to:

(cid:1) a reduction of around 20 % in turkey production;

(cid:1) the import of poultrymeat from third countries (Brazil and Thailand);

(cid:1) the loss of the German market;

(cid:1) a reduction in the area covered by vaccination with the resulting risk of a perpetuation of the disease
and modification of the virus, so that it becomes highly pathogenic rather than mildly pathogenic.

Can the Council say:

1. whether it is possible to obtain approval for emergency vaccination, whilst maintaining the possibility
of export to other Member States? This was allowed during the previous influenza epidemic in 2000,
when the discriminatory test (DIVA) differentiated between birds testing positive (because vaccinated)
and negative (because infected);

2. whether it is possible to vaccinate on a massive scale using a heterologous vaccine (H7N1) and
continue to export, by ensuring with absolute certainty that the meat of the exported birds definitely
does not carry the virus, in that the birds were healthy before they were slaughtered?

Reply

(5 and 6 May 2003)

The Council always follows with great concern the outbreak and spread of epidemics such as avian
influenza which is currently affecting Italy and to which the Honourable Member is referring.

The Council adopted Directive 92/40/EEC which introduces Community measures for the control of this
disease.

When adopting this Directive, the Council considered that management of such an epidemic should
primarily be the responsibility of the Member States’ veterinary health authorities, which could implement
stricter measures. However, the task of evaluating these measures and, where necessary, adopting specific
implementing measures should be entrusted to the Commission which would submit them to the Standing
Committee on the Food Chain and Animal Health in accordance with Article 21 of the aforementioned
Directive.

The powers of the Commission, which takes the relevant decisions, relate in particular to the evaluation of
vaccines and diagnostic methods and to the relaxation of marketing restrictions, referred to by the
Honourable Member.

It therefore calls on the Honourable Member to address his question directly to the competent authorities.