Report from the Commission to the Council on the implementation of Annex X to the Staff Regulations (Council Regulation 3019/87 of 5.10.1987) 1999
Date: 2000-09-11
Institutions: European Commission
Subjects: European official, employment policy, remuneration of work, servant (EU), third country

COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES

Brussels, 11.09.2000
COM(2000) 553 final

REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE COUNCIL

on the implementation of Annex X to the Staff Regulations
(Council Regulation 3019/87 of 5.10.1987)
1999

REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE COUNCIL

on the implementation of Annex X to the Staff Regulations
(Council Regulation 3019/87 of 5.10.1987)
1999

INTRODUCTION

In accordance with Article 101a of the Staff Regulations, Annex X determines, without
prejudice to the other provisions of the Staff Regulations,
the special and exceptional
provisions applicable to officials of the European Communities serving in non-member
countries.

Article 14 of Annex X requires the Commission to "submit an annual report to the Council on
the application of this Annex and in particular on the fixing of the rate of the allowance for
living conditions as provided for in Article 10".

Since 1 January 1988, the Commission has prepared nine reports. They cover the following
periods: - October 1987-December 1988, 1989, 1990-1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996 and
1997-1998.

Reflecting the wishes of the Council, 1999 brought further staff redeployment and (with the
aim of reducing the cost of establishing weightings) the selection via an invitation to tender of
a well-qualified subcontractor with more competitive charges than EuroCost.

In the wake of the Balkans crisis, 1999 also saw the establishment of the Kosovo
Reconstruction Task Force.

CHAPTER 1: GENERAL PROVISIONS

ARTICLE 1: RECRUITMENT

The number of posts earmarked for the External Service increased in 1999, thanks to the
allocation of four new posts under the 1999 budget and a number of redeployments from
headquarters to the External Service.

Redeployment covered nine posts as part of the devolution (deconcentration) of staff to the
Phare countries, twenty-one posts from the external relations departments at headquarters to
the delegations, and four further posts, including DG XXIV (veterinary checks) and DG IB
(assistance for the Special Envoy to the Middle East Peace Process).

This resulted in a rise in staff numbers in the External Service, bringing the total (including
five floaters) to 693 by 31 December 1999. The flat-rate cut in the External Service's
allocation (the latter was rectified by a transfer to cover a second stage of redeployment
carried out during the year) did however reduce the number of posts funded in 1999 to 644.

2

The Balkans crisis demanded urgent action, and some of the vacant posts earmarked for
opening or boosting numbers at delegations by the Commission Decision of 22 July 1998 had
to be used to increase staffing in the countries surrounding Kosovo - Albania, the Former
Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and Yugoslavia.

As at 31 December 1999, 627 External Service posts were physically filled, and there were
four floaters operating from headquarters.

Three staff were recruited in 1999 from the COM/A/696 reserve list.

ARTICLE 2: MOBILITY

Rotation

The rotation arrangements for 1999 covered 159 officials (compared to 133 in 1998), of
whom

–

–

–

63 moved between delegations (compared to 52 in 1998)

49 moved from a delegation to headquarters (compared to 49 in 1998)

12 left (compared to 8 in 1998)

The principle of alternate postings in delegations and at headquarters continued to be applied:

–

–

49 moved from a delegation to headquarters (compared to 49 in 1998)

56 moved from headquarters to a delegation (compared to 58 in 1998)

In all, then, 180 officials moved under the 1999 rotation exercise (compared to 170 in 1998).

Redeployment

for

(CDSE)),

the External Service

In addition to the redeployments decided on in 1998 and implemented in 1999 (25 posts, 21
of which come from the Relex DGs as a result of an overall decision of the Steering
Committee
including 9 from the devolution
(deconcentration) of Phare, a Commission decision of 22 July 1998 redeployed 13 posts
within the network to bolster EU representation in the countries and regions on which
political priorities were focused. This redeployment exercise will be spread over 1999 (7 posts
- 5A, 1B, 1C), 2000 (5A) and 2001 (1A). The 1999 redeployment drew staff from Antigua
(A), Samoa (A), Senegal (A), Surinam (2A), Togo (A), Paris (B) and Hungary (C). Because
of the Balkan crisis, some of these posts were used to increase the staffing of the delegations
in Albania (3 posts), Yugoslavia (1 post) and the office of the Special Envoy to the Former
Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (3 posts).

ARTICLE 3: RETRAINING

In 1999,
retraining decisions affected 40 External Service officials posted back to
headquarters to one of the RELEX DGs, in accordance with the principle of alternate postings
under the rotation policy.

3

CHAPTER 2: OBLIGATIONS

ARTICLE 4: CARRYING OUT DUTIES AT PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT

Nothing to report.

ARTICLE 5: ACCOMMODATION

In 1999, Relex K continued the policy of providing furnished accommodation for officials
serving outside the Community. References for floor area, number of bedrooms and cost/m²
by country were established.

A few pilot cases were initiated with a view to more extensive application of Article 23 of
Annex X in countries where market conditions and the legal environment permit.

CHAPTER 3: WORKING CONDITIONS

ARTICLES 6, 7 AND 9: ANNUAL LEAVE

1999 was the second year in which the Commission decision of 17.7.1997 reforming the
implementation of leave arrangements for officials serving in third countries had operated.

The new arrangements provided for entitlements to be calculated on the basis of working days
instead of calendar days, and for offices to be closed for a maximum of six days, whatever
their
the delegations and
headquarters, and eliminated any inequalities between officials.

location. This made management and checking easier

for

Moreover, the improvements already produced by closer control over leave planning (to
minimise carryover) were confirmed in 1999.

On the other hand, Article 9(2), which bans rest leave from being combined with annual
leave, was criticised by officials for being restrictive and inflexible.

ARTICLES 8 AND 9(2): EXCEPTIONAL GRANTING OF REST LEAVE

On 17 February 1999, as part of its regular annual decision-making, the Commission decided
to grant rest leave for the year by way of exception only for places of employment where
living conditions were considered "particularly difficult" on the basis of the parameters used
to fix the living-conditions allowance each year.

Strict application of the conditions set out in Article 8 of Annex X resulted in this decision
being taken for 30 places of employment in 1999 (see Annex I), compared to 27 in 1998. The
slight increase between 1998 and 1999 was due to more countries being in crisis in 1998 (13
in 1998, compared to 7 in 1997) following a deterioration in security. The budgetary impact
of this increase was neutralised again this year by making the number of days' entitlement
proportional to the actual duration of the crisis. Short-lived crisis situations in three countries
considered troublespots in 1998 (Indonesia, Lesotho and the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia)
led to their being ineligible for rest leave in 1999.

4

CHAPTER 4: EMOLUMENTS AND SOCIAL ADVANTAGES

SECTION 1: EMOLUMENTS AND FAMILY ALLOWANCES

ARTICLE 10(1): ALLOWANCE FOR LIVING CONDITIONS

On 14 December 1998, the Commission fixed the living-conditions allowance rates for the
year as shown in the table in Annex II.

ARTICLE 10(2): ADDITIONAL ALLOWANCE

Commission Decisions allocated additional allowances in 1999 to officials in the following
posts:

Country

Albania

Algeria
Congo (Brazzaville)
Eritrea

Guinea-Bissau
FRY (Belgrade)

FRY (Pristina)
Sierra Leone

Date of effect

beginning of

March 1997
June 1997
November 1993
February 1999
June 1998
July 1998
June 1998
March 1999
September 1999
July 1999
July 1997
August 1998
December 1998
November 1999

End

crisis level

April 1999

October 1999

October 1999

10 %
5 %
10 %
10 %
10 %
5 %
10 %
10 %
5 %
5 %
10 %
5 %
10 %
5 %

ARTICLES 11 AND 12: ARRANGEMENTS FOR THE PAYMENT OF REMUNERATION

The currency in which officials' remuneration was paid in 1999 breaks down as follows in
percentage terms:

–

–

82% opted to have their salaries paid in Belgian francs under Article 11 of Annex X
to the Staff Regulations;

14% requested payment of part of their remuneration in local currency. Of these,
73% asked for the maximum allowed by the internal directives relating to Article 12
of Annex X (80%) and the remainder opted for percentages varying between 11%
and 76%;

In 1999, a 90% ceiling continued to apply in Japan under the second paragraph of
Article 1 of the internal directives relating to Article 12 of Annex X to the Staff
Regulations;

5

–

lastly, under the second paragraph of Article 12 of Annex X, 4% requested payment
of part of their remuneration in a currency other than that of their place of
employment (Russia, Ukraine and Kazakhstan), on the basis of the necessary
supporting documents.

ARTICLE 13: WEIGHTINGS

On 5 February 1999, the Commission approved Decision 1851 adjusting the weightings
applicable from 1 February, 1 March, 1 April, 1 May and 1 June 1998 to the remuneration of
officials of the European Communities serving in third countries.

On 15 February 1999, the Council adopted Regulation 342/992 laying down the weightings
applicable from 1 July 1998 to the remuneration of officials of the European Communities
serving in third countries.

On 18 August 1999, the Commission approved Decision 7033 adjusting the weightings
applicable from 1 August, 1 September, 1 October, 1 November and 1 December 1998 to the
remuneration of officials of the European Communities serving in third countries.

Previous years' efforts by DG Relex to cut the costs of statistics paid off in the autumn of
1999.

The new procedures adopted halved costs, but maintained quality.

From April 2000, statistical work will be undertaken by Air Inc., a new subcontractor to
Eurostat (replacing EuroCost).

ARTICLE 15: EDUCATION ALLOWANCE

€

A total of

2 750 787 was paid in education allowances in the year 1998/99.

The system of paying advances on education allowances to staff incurring particularly high
costs was retained. All the advances granted for the 98/99 school year were settled within the
prescribed deadlines.

As in previous years, the relatively high exchange rate for the yen prompted the Commission
to allow the annual ceiling for reimbursement to be exceeded for the 98/99 school year in the
case of officials serving in Japan whose children attended an international school there.

ARTICLE 16: INSTALLATION AND RESETTLEMENT ALLOWANCES

Officials posted to a delegation receive an installation allowance. Officials permanently
leaving employment receive a resettlement allowance.

1

2

3

OJ L 60, 9.3.1999, p. 83.
OJ L 43, 17.2.1999, p. 1.
OJ L 277, 28.10.1999, p. 37.

6

In 1998/99, 346 installation-allowance cases and 8 resettlement allowance cases were
processed in Belgian francs (total EUR 3 472 944), and 28 installation-allowance cases and
16 resettlement allowance cases were processed in local currency (total EUR 639 772).

SECTION 2: RULES RELATING TO REIMBURSEMENT OF
EXPENSES

ARTICLE 17: REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES INCURRED IN RESPECT OF REMOVAL OF
FURNITURE AND ACTUAL INSTALLATION ALLOWANCES FOR OFFICIALS NOT IN
FURNISHED ACCOMMODATION PROVIDED BY THE INSTITUTION

There was no need to use this Article in 1999.

ARTICLE 18: TEMPORARY ACCOMMODATION

163 decisions authorising temporary accommodation were taken in 1999 (compared to 166 in
1997 and 187 in 1998).

ARTICLE 19 STAFF CARS/MILEAGE ALLOWANCE

The rules for the use of private cars for the purposes of work and vice versa have applied
since June 1996. The rules were reworded at the end of 1998, and the revised version
distributed at the beginning of 1999. The mileage allowance referred to in Article 19 was
established in accordance with practice in several Member States on the basis of average
running costs. At present it stands at

0.36 for 4 x 4s).

0.26 per km (

€

€

ARTICLE 20: TRAVEL EXPENSES FOR REST LEAVE

Travel expenses for rest leave were reimbursed on the basis of the distance between the place
of employment and the place of leave determined by the Commission. Where the place of rest
leave was disregarded, reimbursement could be claimed up to the same amount. Expenditure
was ECU 221 264 in 1998 and EUR 249 499 in 1999.

ARTICLE 21: REIMBURSEMENT OF THE COST OF TRANSPORTING PERSONAL EFFECTS,

REMOVALS AND STORAGE

There were no problems in connection with this Article.

There were 247 removals in 1997, 266 in 1998 and 237 in 1999.

7

The rules for the removal of personal effects were updated in 1997 and implemented at the
beginning of 1998. An invitation to tender for the insurance of the transport of personal
effects was launched in 1997 and the contract was approved by the ACPC and signed at the
end of February 1998.

ARTICLE

23:

REIMBURSEMENT

OF

RENT

WHERE

THE

OFFICIAL

IS NOT PROVIDED WITH ACCOMMODATION BY THE INSTITUTION

As stated in the comments on Article 5, Article 23 currently applies in six cases. To try and
reconcile efficiency and sound budgetary management, the Commission will look at this
experience to see what conclusions can be drawn on when this Article should apply.

SECTION 3: SOCIAL SECURITY

ARTICLE 24 (THIRD PARAGRAPH): REPATRIATION IN THE EVENT OF A MEDICAL

EMERGENCY OR AN EXTREME MEDICAL EMERGENCY

In 1999, there were 21 medical evacuations, at a cost of around EUR 140 000, including the
standby contract with SOS Ambulance.

ARTICLE 25: ACCIDENT COVER FOR DEPENDANTS

As has already been pointed out, a new contract concluded in 1999 has cut the cost of the
premium, which is split between the Commission and the official.

CHAPTER 6: TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS

ARTICLE 27: TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS RELATING TO REMUNERATION

This article has been obsolete since October 1992.

8

ANNEX 1
DETERMINATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO REST LEAVE
(Article 8 of Annex X)
In force from: 1 January 1996

COUNTRY

Albania
Algeria
Angola
Bangladesh
Bosnia – Herzegovina
Burundi
Cameroon
Central African Republic
Comoros
Republic of the Congo
Dem. Rep. of the Congo
Eritrea
Ethiopia
Georgia
Guinea-Bissau
Guinea
Equatorial Guinea
Kazakhstan
Liberia
Mauritania
Niger
Nigeria (Abuja)
Nigeria (Lagos)
Papua New Guinea
Rwanda
Sierra Leone
Sudan
Chad
Togo
Vietnam

FREQUENCY
3 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
2 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
3 x 5 days
1 x 5 days
1 x 5 days

PLACE

Rome (Italy)
Casablanca (Morocco)
Windhoek (Namibia)
Phuket (Thailand)
Brussels (Belgium)
Mombasa (Kenya)
Libreville (Gabon)
Libreville (Gabon)
Antananarivo (Madagascar)
Libreville (Gabon)
Libreville (Gabon)
Mombasa (Kenya)
Mombasa (Kenya)
Vienna (Austria)
Dakar (Senegal)
Dakar (Senegal)
Libreville (Gabon)
Frankfurt (Germany)
Dakar (Senegal)
Casablanca (Morocco)
Libreville (Gabon)
Libreville (Gabon)
Libreville (Gabon)
Darwin (Australia)
Mombasa (Kenya)
Dakar (Senegal)
Mombasa (Kenya)
Dakar (Senegal)
Libreville (Gabon)
Phuket (Thailand)

9

ANNEX 2

LIST OF POSTS

AND LIVING-CONDITIONS ALLOWANCE RATES

(Article 10 of Annex X)

In force from: 1 January 1999 (1.7.98 for Israel)

0 %

CANADA
CYPRUS
MALTA
NORWAY
SWITZERLAND
USA-NEW YORK
USA-SAN DIEGO
USA-WASHINGTON

20 %

FYROM
BOLIVIA
BULGARIA
FIJI
GABON
JAPAN (NAKA)
MEXICO
ROMANIA
SWAZILAND
THAILAND
VANUATU
YUGOSLAVIA

15 %
SOUTH AFRICA
ANTIGUA &
BARBUDA
BOTSWANA
CHILE
SOUTH KOREA
COSTA RICA
HONG KONG
ISRAEL (TEL AVIV)
JAMAICA
JAPAN (TOKYO)
JORDAN
LEBANON
NEW CALEDONIA
SENEGAL
SYRIA
TURKEY

10 %
NETHERLANDS
ANTILLES
ARGENTINA
AUSTRALIA
BARBADOS
BRAZIL
CROATIA
DOMINICAN
REPUBLIC
ESTONIA
HUNGARY
LATVIA
LITHUANIA
MOROCCO
MAURITIUS
NAMIBIA
POLAND
SLOVAKIA
SLOVENIA
CZECH REPUBLIC
TRINIDAD &
TOBAGO
TUNISIA
URUGUAY
ZIMBABWE

35 %

25 %

BELIZE
BENIN
BOSNIA AND
HERZEGOVINA
CAPE VERDE
CHINA
WEST BANK/GAZA
STRIP
COLOMBIA
COTE D'IVOIRE
EGYPT
ERITREA
THE GAMBIA
GHANA
GUATEMALA
INDIA
INDONESIA
KENYA
LESOTHO
MADAGASCAR
MALAWI
NICARAGUA
PERU
PHILIPPINES
RUSSIA
SOLOMON ISLANDS
SAMOA
SRI LANKA
SURINAME
TONGA
VENEZUELA
ZAMBIA

ALBANIA
ALGERIA
ANGOLA
BANGLADESH
BURKINA FASO
BURUNDI
CAMEROON
CENTRAL AFRICAN
REPUBLIC
COMOROS
REPUBLIC OF THE
CONGO
DEM. REPUBLIC OF
THE CONGO
DJIBOUTI
ETHIOPIA
GEORGIA
GUINEA
GUINEA-BISSAU
EQUAT. GUINEA
GUYANA
HAITI
KAZAKHSTAN
LIBERIA
MALI
MAURITANIA
MOZAMBIQUE
NIGER
NIGERIA (ABUJA)
NIGERIA (LAGOS)
UGANDA
PAKISTAN
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
RWANDA
SÃO TOMÉ AND
PRÍNCIPE
SIERRA LEONE
SUDAN
TANZANIA
CHAD
TOGO
UKRAINE
VIETNAM

10